U.S. patent number 3,861,551 [Application Number 05/233,599] was granted by the patent office on 1975-01-21 for threaded bottle cap with vertical external scores.
Invention is credited to Charles N. Hannon.
United States Patent |
3,861,551 |
Hannon |
January 21, 1975 |
THREADED BOTTLE CAP WITH VERTICAL EXTERNAL SCORES
Abstract
A threaded bottle cap with a pilfer-proof skirt externally
vertically scored and of sufficient length to be locked under a
shoulder on the neck of a container to provide rounded, relatively
smooth edges when the scores are ruptured as the cap is removed
from the container.
Inventors: |
Hannon; Charles N. (Scarsdale,
NY) |
Family
ID: |
26815370 |
Appl.
No.: |
05/233,599 |
Filed: |
March 10, 1972 |
Related U.S. Patent Documents
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Application
Number |
Filing Date |
Patent Number |
Issue Date |
|
|
117512 |
Feb 22, 1971 |
|
|
|
|
Current U.S.
Class: |
215/252 |
Current CPC
Class: |
B21D
51/50 (20130101); B65D 41/348 (20130101); B65D
2401/35 (20200501) |
Current International
Class: |
B21D
51/50 (20060101); B21D 51/38 (20060101); B65D
41/34 (20060101); B65d 041/34 () |
Field of
Search: |
;215/42,252 |
References Cited
[Referenced By]
U.S. Patent Documents
Foreign Patent Documents
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
604,758 |
|
Sep 1960 |
|
CA |
|
457,170 |
|
Jul 1968 |
|
CH |
|
170,649 |
|
Mar 1960 |
|
SW |
|
1,021,712 |
|
Mar 1966 |
|
GB |
|
Primary Examiner: Norton; Donald F.
Attorney, Agent or Firm: Gillette; Donald P.
Parent Case Text
This is a continuation-in-part of my copending application Ser. No.
117,512 filed Feb. 22, 1971, now abandoned.
Claims
What is claimed is:
1. A closure for a container having a threaded section at the end
of its neck and a ridge that extends outwardly from the neck below
the threaded section, said closure comprising:
A. a closed end;
B. a skirt extending from the perimeter of said end and
comprising:
1. a pilfer-proof section at the edge of said skirt remote from
said closed end,
2. a cylindrical section between said closed end and said
pilfer-proof section to engage said threaded section of said
container,
3. an outwardly bulged section between said cylindrical section and
said pilfer-proof section, and
4. a plurality of substantially evenly spaced slots encircling said
skirt in said bulged section, said slots being defined by bridges
of the material of said bulged section and by tongues of material
of said bulged section pivoted inwardly, the total distance that
each of said tongues extends inwardly being less than the radially
outward extension of said bulged section, whereby the innermost end
of said tongues do not reach said container; and
C. a plurality of scores extending from the edge of said skirt most
remote from said closed end toward said closed end and inwardly
from the outer surface of said skirt, and parallel to the axis, the
depth of said scores being less than the thickness of said
pilfer-proof section, said scores being equal in number to the
number of said bridges and being angularly spaced apart by the same
angle as said bridges so that all of said scores have substantially
the same angular orientation with respect to a corresponding one of
said bridges.
2. The closure of claim 1 in which said pilfer-proof section is
initially flared out approximately 6.degree..
3. The closure of claim 1 in which there are eight of said
scores.
4. The closure of claim 1 in which said scores extend from the edge
of said skirt to a point below said bulged section.
5. The closure of claim 4 in which each of said scores is in line
substantially with the center of a corresponding one of said
bridges.
6. The closure of claim 5 in which each of said scores extends
across the central portion of a corresponding one of said
bridges.
7. The closure of claim 1 in which said scores extend from the edge
of said pilfer-proof section remote from said closed end toward,
but not into, each of said slots.
8. The closure of claim 1 in which each of said scores extends
toward, but not into, the center of a respective one of said
tongues.
9. The closure of claim 1 comprising, in addition: a plurality of
lines extending across said scores whereby the breaking of said
scores interrupts said lines.
10. The closure of claim 1 in which said closure is scored to a
depth of at least approximately 70 percent of the thickness of the
material of said closure.
Description
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
1. Field of the Invention
This invention relates to a cap, or closure, attached to the open
end of a container by threaded engagement with the neck of the
container and having a pilfer-proof skirt turned under a locking
shoulder below the threaded portion on the neck of the container.
In particular, the invention relates to a closure of this type
having external vertical scores in the skirt.
2. Description of the Prior Art
Threaded bottle closures with pilfer-proof skirts have become quite
common in the past few years for use on containers of beverages and
other liquids that used to be sold in containers capped by means of
crowns. A crown, once removed, cannot be easily replaced on a
container since the removal normally involves visibly deforming the
crown. However, it is possible for a closure that makes threaded
engagement with the neck of the container to be removed by
unscrewing it and then replaced without indication that the
container has been opened. It is desirable for the consumer to be
able to do this but undesirable for it to be done prior to reaching
the consumer, especially in the case of containers used to dispense
beverages because of the possibility of contamination of the
product. It would even be undesirable in the case of products not
intended for human consumption because it would also make such
products subject to possible contamination or pilferage.
In order to lock a threaded, metal closure in place, it has become
common in recent years to provide, at the lower edge of the
cylindrical part of the closure, a skirt to be deformed by a roller
during the capping process so as to turn the skirt under the
locking shoulder normally provided on such containers. This skirt
is referred to as a pilfer-proof skirt and is initially formed as
an integral part of the closure. These closures are made of ductile
sheet metal, such as aluminum. During the manufacture, the
cylindrical part of the closure is lanced by blades perpendicular
to the axis of the closure and spaced a slight distance apart to
leave several spaced bridges, which are relatively narrow sections
of the ductile material. The lancing weakens the skirt so that when
the closure is unscrewed the bridges are forced to rupture, thus
allowing the pilfer-proof section to remain upon the neck of the
container when the main part of the closure is removed. The main
part can later be reapplied to the container, but it will be
evident to anyone who later picks up the container that it has
already been opened. Thus any potential consumer will be aware that
there is a possibility of contamination or pilferage of the
product.
Such containers have been almost invariably of the type to be used
only once and are frequently referred to as "no return" bottles.
One reason for this type of use is that the pilfer-proof ring is
somewhat difficult to remove from the container and it is easier to
sell the container for only a single use. In the case of beer and
other alcoholic beverages sold in such containers, there is the
added legal requirement that they not be used a second time.
However, with the advent of widespread public interest in
environmental protection, it has been found to be advantageous to
make the pilfer-proof section easily removable from the neck of the
container so that the container can be used again if it is legally
permissible to do so. In addition, the lancing leaves a relatively
sharp edge on the main part of the closure, and the small sections
of the ridges increase the possibility that a person attempting to
remove or replace such a closure may be cut. Moreover, it is not
uncommon for some of the bridges to fail to break when an attempt
is made to unscrew the closure. When this happens the threaded part
of the closure is twisted askew on the threads of the container and
thus becomes locked in place. Under such circumstances, it may be
almost impossible to remove the closure without the aid of a
suitable tool. In my U.S. Pat. No. 3,645,062 I proposed to make the
closures easier to break by scoring across the bridges in a
direction perpendicular to the axis of the container and in line
with the long dimension of the lanced slots.
The present invention is directed to a different scoring technique
that permits the pilfer-proof section to be bent out of the way
easily so that the entire cap, including this section, can be
removed from the neck of the container without causing the threads
on the closure to become twisted askew with respect to the threads
on the container. The bending of the pilfer-proof section that
results from unscrewing such a closure from the container on which
it is placed is sufficient evidence that the closure has been
tampered with, but it may be desirable, in addition, to provide a
visible pattern, such as a series of horizontal lines, on the
pilfer-proof section to indicate that the scoring marks have been
broken through by removing the closure from the neck of the
container.
One type of closure that has been proposed as a means of attaching
the pilfer-proof skirt to the main part of the closure is described
in U.S. Pat. No. 3,601,273. In that patent, the lancing is done in
such a way that alternate bridges are relatively wide and the
remaining bridges are relatively narrow. The pilfer-proof skirt is
vertically scored from the inside with fewer scores than the number
of bridges and with no attempt to align the scores in any
particular position relative to the bridges. When such a closure is
removed from the neck of a container, it is expected that the
vertical scores will rupture allowing the sectors of the
pilfer-proof skirt to be cammed outwardly by the shoulder of the
container. However, as shown in FIG. 4 of that patent, an extremely
dangerous rupture of certain of the bridges may take place causing
sharp pointed sections of the pilfer-proof skirt to project
outwardly to a position where anyone attempting either to loosen or
tighten the closure may be severely cut. The pilfer-proof skirt is
most likely to break out this way when the scores happen to be
aligned with the narrow bridges. The dangers of such a structure
are readily apparent to consumers. In addition, there is a growing
tendency for agencies of the government having to do with product
safety to become concerned about items such as this.
It is one of the objects of the present invention to provide a
closure member having a pilfer-proof section that can be easily
separated into relatively small sectors having no sharp edges and
attached to the remainder of the closure in such a way as to be
easily bent back far enough to allow the closure to be easily
removed from the container and reapplied thereto in case the
product in the container has been only partially consumed.
A further difficulty encountered with some attempts at providing a
screw-type closure with a pilfer-proof section that is removed from
the container with the rest of the closure is the tendency of some
of the scores to remain closed, thereby providing an unbalanced
resistance to removal of the closure. This may cause the threaded
part of the closure to be shifted askew, which greatly increases
the torque required to remove the closure from the container. This
is similar to the case of closures having unscored pilfer-proof
rings attached by bridges that fail to break.
It is, therefore, a further object of the present invention to
provide a screw-type closure with a pilfer-proof section that
remains attached to the main part of the closure and has scores so
arranged that the pilfer-proof section is uniformly divided into
the desired individual sectors, thereby permitting easy removal of
the closure from the container and easy replacement of the closure
on the container.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
The bottle cap in accordance with the present invention includes
bridges that are wider than the normal bridges in closures used
heretofore. The metal of the pilfer-proof section below the bridges
is scored externally and in a direction parallel to the axis of the
container and in a region specifically related to the location of
the bridges. When such closures are removed, the pilfer-proof
section breaks through at the scored locations and twists the
relatively narrow metal of the bridges to allow the pilfer-proof
section to ride up over the threaded part as the closure is removed
from the neck of the container. I have even found it possible,
although less desirable, to omit the lateral slots that are lanced
through between the threaded portion and the pilfer-proof skirt of
the closure. As another alternative, I have found that the
pilfer-proof section may be scored directly below each of the
lateral slots instead of directly in line with the center of each
of the bridges.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
FIG. 1 is a side view of a closure scored in accordance with the
present invention and fitted on the neck of a bottle.
FIG. 2 is a cross-sectional view along the line 2--2 of the bottle
and closure in FIG. 1.
FIG. 3 shows a modified scoring arrangement for a second embodiment
of a closure in accordance with the present invention.
FIG. 4 shows still another embodiment of the present invention.
FIG. 5 is a developed view of the lower edge of a closure scored in
accordance with still another modification of the invention.
FIG. 6 is a side elevational view of the closure in FIG. 1 prior to
the time it is applied to a container and has threads formed in
it.
FIG. 7 is a perspective view of a lancing and scoring tool for use
in the manufacture of the closure in FIG. 6.
FIG. 8 is a plan view of a lancing and scoring blade for use in the
tool in FIG. 7.
FIG. 9 is a cross-sectional view of the lancing and scoring tool in
FIGS. 7 and 8 at one point of contact with a closure.
FIG. 10 is a fragmentary cross-sectional view corresponding to FIG.
9 but illustrating a different point of contact between the closure
and the scoring blade.
FIG. 11 is a simplified top elevational view of a machine for
knurling, scoring and lancing the closure of FIG. 6.
FIG. 12 is a fragmentary cross-sectional view of the closure in
FIG. 1 illustrating the clearance between the closure and the
container onto which it is threaded.
FIG. 13 is a fragmentary view of the pilfer-proof section of the
closure in FIG. 1.
FIG. 14 is a fragmentary view corresponding to FIG. 13 but
illustrating the way that the score ruptures when the closure is
removed from the container.
FIG. 15 is a bottom view of the closure according to the present
invention illustrating the deflection of the pifler-proof section
caused by removal of the closure from a container.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
FIG. 1 shows a bottle closure 11 having a flat top 12 and a
generally cylindrical skirt extending downwardly from the perimeter
of the top. This closure is preferably made of ductile material,
such as a deformable aluminum base alloy having a thickness of
about 0.010 to 0.011 inch. At the upper end of the skirt is a
knurled band 13 that provides better frictional engagement with the
closure so that the latter can be more easily unscrewed from a
container 14. Below the knurled band 13 the skirt has been deformed
into a threaded section 16 and at the lower end of the threaded
section is an outwardly extending bulge 17 formed by pressing the
sheet metal material of the skirt outwardly by a predetermined
amount. The extent of the outward bulge will be described in
greater detail hereinafter. The bulge may include, at its upper
side, a second knurled band 18. Between the upper and lower limits
of the bulge 17 are several lateral slots 19, each formed by
lancing a short tongue of the skirt material inwardly, preferably
pivoting each of the tongues about the lower edge thereof. The
section of the skirt that remains between the slots 19 are bridges
21 that join the upper part of the closure 11 to a pilfer-proof
section 22 that forms the lowermost part of the skirt.
In accordance with this invention, a plurality of vertical scores
23 are formed in the pilfer-proof section 22, and in this
embodiment each of the scores 23 is directly in line with and below
the center of each of the bridges 21. The lowermost end of the
skirt is tucked under a shoulder (not shown) on the neck of the
container 14, and, if desired, a plurality of stripes 24 may be
printed on the pilfer-proof section to assist in visually
indicating when the scores 23 have been broken in removing the
closure from the container.
As will be described in greater detail hereinafter, when the
closure 11 is unscrewed from the container 14, each of the scores
23 ruptures so that the pilfer-proof section breaks into small
sectors. Each of the bridges 21 forms a hinge for the ends of the
pilfer-proof sectors 22 below that bridge.
FIG. 2 shows a cross-sectional view to illustrate the arrangement
of the bridges 21 and indicate that there are eight of such
bridges. It is possible to use other numbers of bridges, but I have
found that the use of eight bridges allows the closure to be
removed without having to deform the pilfer-proof section as much
as would be necessary if there were a smaller number of bridges. At
the same time, it is easier to provide eight bridges than to try to
fit nine or more around the closure 11.
FIG. 3 shows a modified closure 26 in which each of the external
scores 27 has been extended up through the respective bridge 21
with which it is aligned. This would appear to increase the
flexibility of the hinges formed by the two sections of each bridge
on each side of the respective scores 27, but under certain
circumstances it may be desirable not to increase the flexibility
to this extent. Further, this embodiment is not as amenable to
having a bulge 17 since the scores would have to extend into the
bulge and would be difficult to produce.
FIG. 4 shows still another form of closure 28 in which there are
scores 29 of approximately the same length as the scores 23 in the
embodiment in FIG. 1, but there are no transverse slots and,
therefore, no bridges to be aligned with these scores. Since the
closure in any of the foregoing embodiments comes off of the
container as a unitary structure and does not leave a pilfer-proof
ring behind as in the case of closures previously used, it would
appear that the slots that result in forming the bridges 21 of the
embodiments of FIGS. 1-3 are not necessary, and, indeed, it has
been found possible to do without them as is shown in the
embodiment in FIG. 4. However, this means that the entire length of
metal from one of the scores 29 to the next forms a hinge, whereas
in the embodiments in FIGS. 1-3 only the thin strips of metal of
the bridges 21 form the hinges. The segments of the pilfer-proof
section 22 in FIG. 43 are stiffer and make it more difficult to
remove the closure 28 from the container 14. If this is desirable,
then the slots can be omitted as in the case of this embodiment.
Furthermore, the external scores 29 may be increased somewhat in
depth to make it easier for them to be ruptured when the closure is
removed from the container.
FIG. 5 shows a fragmentary side view of still another modification
of the invention with the scores 31 midway between the bridges 21
instead of in line with them. The bridges 21 are formed when
tongues 32 are lanced out of the closure material and pressed
inwardly to form the slots 19. Each of the scores 31 extends from
the lowermost edge of the pilfer-proof section 22 to a point just
below the lowermost edge of the respective tongue 32. In this case,
the stiffness of the pilfer-proof section 22 that resists bending
when the cap is removed from the bottle is less than that in the
embodiment of FIG. 4 but greater than that in the embodiment of
FIG. 1.
FIG. 6 shows the closure 11 of FIG. 1 prior to the time it is
placed on a container. Thus, the threads 16 of FIG. 1, which are
formed during the process of sealing the container, have not yet
been incorporated. However, the knurled band 13 and, particularly,
the bulge 17, the knurled band 18, the slots 19, and the bridges 21
are shown somewhat more clearly in FIG. 6 than in FIG. 1. The slots
19 are formed in such a way that the metal is bent inwardly from
the top edge of the slots rather than from the bottom as in FIG. 1.
In addition, the pilfer-proof section 22 is shown as being slightly
conical with an included angle of approximately 6.degree. to
facilitate placing the closure on a container to be sealed. The
scores 23 have also been formed by the time the closure 11 reaches
the stage of manufacture shown in FIG. 6.
FIG. 7 shows a device 33 constructed to lance and score caps in
accordance with the present invention. The device 33 is mounted on
a shaft 34 and comprises a plurality of lancing blades 36 that form
the slots 19 in FIG. 1. Simultaneously, with the lancing the device
33 scores the vertical marks by means of vertical scoring blades
37. Since these scoring blades are fixedly positioned with respect
to the lancing blades 36, the location of the scores relative to
the bridges 21 in the closure 11 in FIG. 1 is fixed. This device 33
can be used to provide the scores 21 and the slots 19 as shown in
the closure 11 in FIG. 1. If the scoring blades 37 are made longer
so that they extend up between the lancing blades 36, the device 33
may also be used to lance and score the closure 26 shown in FIG. 3.
By omitting the lancing blades 36, the device 33 may be used to
form the scores 29 in the closure 28 of FIG. 4.
The lancing and scoring blades and the mechanism are shown in more
detail in FIGS. 8-10. FIG. 8 shows one form of the lancing and
scoring blade adapted for use in certain capping machines. Only
about half of the perimeter of the lancing blade 38 is provided
with lancing edges 39. For the sake of convenience, the structure
shown in FIG. 8 is actually made up as a tool pack and individual
scoring blades 41 are fitted in slots centered between pairs of the
lancing edges 39. The tool pack is formed as an annular structure
with a central aperture 42 to fit on a support in a capping
machine. The tool pack also is provided with apertures 40 that
allow the tool pack to be assembled with a specific relationship
between the lancing edges 39 and the scoring blades 41.
FIG. 9 shows a closure 43 supported on a rotating member 44 in a
forming machine. The member 44 has a knurling ring 46, a
cylindrical section 47, a pair of discs 48 and 49 that produce the
outward bulge 17 in the closure 43 and also cooperate to produce
the knurled band 18 and the slots 19. Below the disc 49 is a
tapered section which may comprise two discs 51 and 52 to form the
slightly conically tapered pilfer-proof section 22 of the closure
43. Below the disc 52 is a limit ring 53 that prevents the closure
material from being squeezed too much while the closure 43 is being
formed.
Cooperating with the member 44 to form the closure 43 is a group of
discs, including a knurling ring 54 that cooperates with the ring
46 to form the upper knurled band 13. Below the ring 54 is another
cylindrical ring 56, the lower side of which is machined away to
cooperate with the disc 48 in forming the bulge 17 and the knurled
band 18. Below this is the lancing blade 38, one of the edges 39 of
which is shown pressing a tongue 32 into the bulge 17. Below the
lancing blade 38 is a section that holds the scoring blades 37 and
below that is a disc 57 that presses against the ring 53 when the
closure 43 is being formed. As shown, each of the scoring blades is
at an angle that corresponds to the taper in the disc 52.
FIG. 10 shows a different cross-sectional view of the closure
forming apparatus and particularly illustrates the way that one of
the scoring blades 37 presses into the pilfer-proof section 22 of
the skirt of the closure 43. The blade 37 may be set so that it
presses approximately 0.006 inch into the 0.010 inch thickness of
the closure metal.
Another type of closure forming machine is shown in FIG. 11. In
this machine, unformed closures 58 enter the machine along the
direction of the arrow 59 up a ramp 61. Each of the closures 58 has
its open end facing upwardly and it is picked up by an arbor 62,
which may be generally similar to the member 44 in FIG. 9. This
arbor 62 rotates as shown by the arrows 63 and moves in a circle as
indicated by the arrow 64 to push the closure 58 along a circular
shelf 66. A raised central disc 67 has several forming stations set
into it. The first of these stations is indicated by reference
numeral 68 and forms one of knurling bands, for example the
knurling 13 shown in the closure in FIG. 9. In order to form this
knurling band, the arbor 62 revolves the closure 58 against the
knurling surface of the station 68. Subsequently, the closure 58
reaches a second station 69, which has a configuration suitable for
forming the bulge 17 and the second knurling band 18 as shown in
FIG. 9. Thereafter, the closure 58 is brought around to the third
station, which includes a lancing blade 71 with lancing edges 72.
Scoring blades 73 are fixedly located with respect to the lancing
edges 72 to place the scores as desired and preferably centered
with respect to the bridges formed by the gaps between adjacent
scoring edges 72. Thereafter, the closure 58, which is then in the
same configuration as the closure 11 in FIG. 6, leaves the shelf 66
by way of a downwardly sloping ramp 74.
FIG. 12 is a fragmentary cross-sectional view showing the closure
11 of FIG. 1 applied to a glass bottle 14. As may be seen, the
bottle has a shoulder 76 and the pilfer-proof section 22 of the
closure 11 is folded under this shoulder. Above the pilfer-proof
section 22 is shown one of the tongues 32 formed by the lancing
blade in the apparatus just described. It is important to note that
the bulge 17 in the closure 11 extends far enough out so that the
inwardly directed tongue 32 does not come into contact with the
wall of the container 14 above the shoulder 76. Thus when the
closure 11 is removed from the container and replaced on the
container, the tongues 32 do not scrape on the container surface.
One effect of such scraping would be to leave an undesired metallic
deposit which, in the case of certain chemicals frequently found in
beverages, could lead to an unsightly dark band. Another adverse
effect of such contact between the tongues 32 and the container 14
is an increase in the torque required to remove the closure from
the container. Thus, the bulge 17 must extend outwardly farther
than the tongues 32 extend inwardly.
FIG. 13 is an enlarged view showing precisely how the pilfer-proof
section 22 is scored in the closure 11 of FIG. 1. As may be seen,
the scoring mark 23 ends just below the bottom of the bridge 21 and
below the bulge 17. The region of the bridge 21 just above the end
of the scores 23 and to the left and right of the end of the scores
acts as a hinge, or more precisely one part of a hinge, for the two
segments of the pilfer-proof section 22 on each side of the scores
23.
When the closure is removed from the bottle by being unscrewed,
each of the scores 23 breaks, as shown in FIG. 14, and divides to
form a V-shaped notch 23a. The two segments of the pilfer-proof
section 22 on the sides of the notch 23a spread apart enough to
allow them to pass over the glass collar on the neck of the bottle
and to allow the entire closure, including the pilfer-proof section
22, to be removed as a unit. This is contrary to the practice of
present, unscored pilfer-proof sections, which normally break at
the bridges. However, by virtue of the present embodiment, the
bridges 21 are made stronger than such bridges have been made
heretofore, and they do not break when the closure is removed. For
example, previously bridges have had a width of approximately 0.030
inch; but in accordance with the present invention, they should
preferably be somewhat broader, although it is not essential that
they be. I have found that by making the bridges with a width of
about 0.090 inch in the direction transverse to the axis of the
cap, they provide an optimum bending characteristic.
When the closure is unscrewed, each of the segments of the
pilfer-proof section 22 twists the half section of the bridge 21 at
each of its ends just enough to allow the inwardly directed lower
edge of the pilfer-proof section 22 to slide past the shoulder and
threads on the bottle. But due to the fact that there are
preferably about eight such segments in the complete pilfer-proof
section 22, none of the segments has to pivot outwardly very far.
On the other hand, one of the disadvantages of providing too many
scoring marks is that some of them may not rupture. This would
cause the aforementioned, undesired twisting of the closure to a
skewed position. Therefore, the corners of each segment adjacent
each of the notches 23a are still nearly in line with each other
and there are no outwardly extending sharp edges to cut the person
removing the closure from the bottle. Furthermore, by scoring the
pilfer-proof section 22 from the outside, the edges of the notches
are quite round and safe, as shown in FIG. 15. If there were only
four such segments, for example, each one would have to turn
considerably farther out and the points at the edges of each of the
notches 23a would be a real danger to anyone trying to remove such
a closure.
* * * * *