U.S. patent number 3,854,735 [Application Number 05/300,074] was granted by the patent office on 1974-12-17 for static face seal.
This patent grant is currently assigned to Exxon Production Research Company. Invention is credited to Everett H. Lock, William C. Maurer.
United States Patent |
3,854,735 |
Maurer , et al. |
December 17, 1974 |
STATIC FACE SEAL
Abstract
A static face seal for sealing the clearance gap between a pair
of radial surfaces including an elastomeric seal ring, a plastic
backup ring, and a soft metal anti-extrusion ring. The
anti-extrusion ring includes a first portion defining an axially
extending surface and a second portion defining an outwardly
sloping surface. The anti-extrusion ring is adapted to fit snugly
into a groove having an outer surface complementary to the axially
extending and sloping surfaces of the anti-extrusion ring.
Inventors: |
Maurer; William C. (Houston,
TX), Lock; Everett H. (Houston, TX) |
Assignee: |
Exxon Production Research
Company (Houston, TX)
|
Family
ID: |
23157587 |
Appl.
No.: |
05/300,074 |
Filed: |
October 24, 1972 |
Current U.S.
Class: |
277/638; 277/644;
277/650; 285/357 |
Current CPC
Class: |
F16J
15/166 (20130101); F16J 15/121 (20130101) |
Current International
Class: |
F16J
15/12 (20060101); F16J 15/16 (20060101); F16j
015/06 () |
Field of
Search: |
;285/356,357,363-368
;220/46R ;277/180-190,237,166,235,236,151,168,170,144 |
References Cited
[Referenced By]
U.S. Patent Documents
Primary Examiner: Rothberg; Samuel B.
Assistant Examiner: Smith; Robert I.
Attorney, Agent or Firm: Graham; Robert L. Reilly; James
A.
Claims
We claim:
1. A static face seal assembly for sealing the junction of a pair
of radially extending surfaces, one of said surfaces having a
groove formed therein, said groove being defined in part by an
outer axially extending wall having a beveled edge, said static
face seal assembly comprising a seal ring disposed in said groove
for sealing the clearance gap between said pair of radially
extending surfaces; a soft-metal anti-extrusion ring having a first
portion which defines an axially extending surface sized to fit in
close conformity with said axially extending wall of said groove,
and a second portion which defines an outwardly sloping shoulder
adapted to engage said beveled edge in said one of said surfaces
and the other of said surfaces to prevent extrusion of said seal
ring.
2. An anti-extrusion ring as defined in claim 1 wherein said
anti-extrusion ring is composed of a metal having a Brinnel
hardness less than about 100.
3. An anti-extrusion ring as defined in claim 2 wherein said first
portion is sized to provide interference fit with said axially
extending wall.
4. An anti-extrusion ring as defined in claim 2 wherein the
allowance between said axially extending surface of said first
portion and the axially extending wall of said groove is between 0
and a negative 0.004 inches.
5. An anti-extrusion ring as defined in claim 2 wherein the sloping
shoulder of said second portion defines an angle of between about
50.degree. and about 30.degree. with the axis of said
anti-extrusion ring.
6. An anti-extrusion ring as defined in claim 2 wherein the radial
dimension of said first portion is at least 0.030 inches.
7. An anti-extrusion ring as defined in claim 2 wherein said
anti-extrusion ring has an axial dimension slightly greater than
the depth of said groove.
8. An anti-extrusion ring as defined in claim 7 wherein the axial
dimension of said anti-extrusion ring is from 0.001 to 0.006
greater than the depth of said groove.
9. A static face seal assembly for use in sealing the clearance gap
between a pair of radially extending surfaces, one of said surfaces
having a groove formed therein, said groove being defined in part
by an outer axially extending wall having a beveled edge, said
static face seal assembly comprising an elastomeric seal ring
disposed in said groove, a soft metal anti-extrusion ring having a
first portion which defines an axially extending surface sized to
fit in close conformity with said axially extending wall of said
groove, and a second portion which defines an outwardly sloping
shoulder adapted to engage said beveled edge; and a plastic backup
ring interposed between said elastomeric seal ring and said
anti-extrusion ring.
10. A static face seal assembly as defined in claim 9 wherein said
anti-extrusion ring is composed of a metal having a Brinnel
hardness less than about 100.
11. A static face seal assembly as defined in claim 10 wherein said
anti-extrusion ring has an axial dimension slightly greater than
the depth of said groove.
12. A static face seal assembly as defined in claim 10 wherein said
elastomeric seal ring, said plastic backup ring, and said
anti-extrusion ring are arranged concentrically within said groove,
each ring being sized to protrude axially beyond said groove and
adapted to engage the other of said surfaces.
13. A static face seal assembly as defined in claim 12 wherein said
elastomeric seal ring is an O-ring.
14. A static face seal assembly as defined in claim 13 wherein said
plastic backup ring substantially covers the inner wall of said
anti-extrusion ring and is composed of a fluoroplastic.
Description
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
1. Field of the Invention
This invention relates to static face seals. In one aspect it
relates to a three ring seal assembly. In another aspect, it
relates to an improved anti-extrusion ring for static face
seals.
2. Description of the Prior Art
The function of a static seal is to separate pressurized fluids at
the joint of two non-moving members. The seal normally comprises a
sealing element such as an O-ring mounted in a gland defined by the
joined members. When the seal is employed at the interface of a
pair of planar, radially extending surfaces, it is normally
referred to as a face seal. Such seals are frequently used in the
assemblage of members that must be disconnected from time to time
to permit repair or replacement of parts or to provide access to
the interior of the assembly. Typically, face seals are used in a
variety of fittings such as flange fittings, plug fittings, cap
fittings, and the like. Face seals also are used between components
of pumps, swivels, valves, and other fluid handling devices.
A serious problem associated with static seals, particularly those
employing elastomeric O-rings, is that of extrusion. High pressures
tend to force the members being joined apart causing the O-ring to
extrude through the the clearance gap with the result that the
O-ring is damaged or the seal is blown out. Extrusion is
particularly serious under cyclic loading such as that encountered
in reciprocating pumps.
A commonly applied remedy for O-ring extrusion involves the use of
anti-extrusion rings. These rings are normally thin annularly
shaped members composed of much harder material than the O-ring and
are mounted in the gland so as to provide zero clearance at the
interface of the joined members. A particularly useful
anti-extrusion ring for high pressure service is the wedge shaped
ring frequently referred to as a delta ring. This ring has a
triangular cross-section and has an outer beveled surface. The
beveled surface is adapted to mate with a complementary shaped
surface formed in a wall portion of the mounting groove. Under
hydraulic loading, the O-ring bears against the delta ring wedging
it into the clearance gap separating the members being joined. The
delta ring in effect provides a metal-to-metal contact across the
clearance gap. Experience with these rings however has shown that
the rings are difficult to retain in the groove during
installation. The delta rings, because of the beveled surface, tend
to become dislodged from their mounting grooves when the member in
which the ring is installed is tilted downwardly. Although
adhesives can be used to retain the delta rings in place, this
procedure is time consuming and cumbersome and is not recommended
in applications such as pump packing where it is desired to replace
the packing and return the pump to operation as quickly as
possible.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
The present invention provides an improved face seal assembly
comprising an elastomeric seal ring, a plastic backup ring, and a
soft metal anti-extrusion ring. A novel feature of the invention
resides in the configuration of the anti-extrusion ring. This ring
and the groove containing it have complementary shaped portions
which permit the ring to be frictionally retained within the groove
thereby facilitating installation. The anti-extrusion ring includes
outwardly tapering portion which provides a metal-to-metal contact
which under loaded conditions provides the wedging action at the
joint of the members being joined. The contact pressure increases
in response to internal fluid pressure much in the same manner as
delta rings.
The three rings comprising the face seal are adapted to be
concentrically positioned in an axially opening groove formed in
one of the gland members. The elastomeric ring is the inner ring in
the concentric arrangement and provides the initial seal for
internal pressure. The plastic ring is intermediate the other two
rings and provides a secondary seal for the assembly. It also
serves to transmit hydraulic forces uniformly to the anti-extrusion
ring and to plug minute openings between the anti-extrusion ring
and the gland members confining it. The anti-extrusion ring is the
outer ring of the assembly and serves to close the clearance gap
between the members being joined and thereby prevents the extrusion
of the other rings. In a preferred embodiment, the anti-extrusion
ring is confined within the mounting gland under compression and
thus itself functions as a sealing element.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
FIG. 1 is a longitudinal sectional view of a portion of a plunger
pump provided with the static face seal assembly of the present
invention.
FIG. 2 is an enlarged sectional view of the static face seal
assembly shown in FIG. 1.
FIG. 3 is an enlarged sectional view of another embodiment of the
static face seal assembly.
DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
The present invention will be described in connection with a static
face seal for a plunger pump packing cartridge. It will be
appreciated by those skilled in the art, however, that the improved
seal assembly and improved anti-extrusion ring can be used in other
high pressure applications.
With reference to FIG. 1, a packing cartridge 10 containing packing
11 is shown threadedly connected to the fluid end body 12 of a
plunger pump. The packing 11 contained in the packing cartridge 10
surrounds a plunger 13 and provides a dynamic seal therefor. The
cartridge 11 is a hollow cylindrical member having a flat forward
end 14 and a generally cylindrical outer surface 15. The cartridge
10 is sized to fit into a recess formed in an endportion of body 12
and terminating in a radially extending end wall 16.
A face seal assembly 17 provides a static seal between mated
surfaces 14 and 16. The term "face seal" as used herein refers to a
seal employed at the interface of two radially extending planar
surfaces. In high pressure service, a face seal is preferred over
other types of seals such as a bushing seal because it can be
preloaded thereby creating a high pressure seal zone. Such seals,
however, are difficult to maintain because high pressure,
particularly a fluctuating pressure, tends to force the mated
surfaces apart.
The improved face seal assembly constructed according to the
present invention and illustrated in FIG. 2 comprises an
elastomeric seal ring 18, a plastic ring 19, and a soft metal
anti-extrusion ring 20. The three ring assembly is adapted to be
mounted in a specially configured groove 21 formed in the face 14
of cartridge 10. The groove 21 is of generally annular
configuration having an inner, axially extending wall 22, a flat
bottom 23, and an outer wall 24 shaped to cooperate with the
anti-extrusion ring 20.
The elastomeric seal ring preferably is a conventional O-ring. Such
rings are inexpensive and available in a variety of sizes. The
O-ring can be composed of natural rubber, polyisoprene,
polybutadiene, ethylene-propylene rubber, neoprene,
acrylonitrile-butadiene, and the like.
The plastic backup ring can be of rectangular cross-sectional
configuration as illustrated in FIG. 2. Although a variety of
plastics are useable as a backup for the O-ring, preferred material
is a fluoroplastic such as polytetrafluoroethylene (teflon). As
described in detail below, the teflon ring under high stress tends
to cold flow and seal minute clearance gaps between the
anti-extrusion ring and its contact surfaces.
As mentioned earlier, the anti-extrusion ring 20 is composed of a
soft metal. Suitable metals including bearing metals having a
tensile strength less than about 40,000 psi and a Brinnel hardness
number less than about 100. Examples of such metals include bronze,
bronze alloys, and copper alloys. These metals are strong enough to
withstand the compressive forces imposed thereon and yet are
capable of deforming to close the clearance gap between the members
being joined. The anti-extrusion ring 20 includes a first portion
25 defining an axially extending outer surface 26 and a second
portion 27 defining an outwardly sloping shoulder 28. The outer
wall 24 defining groove 21 is configurated complementary to
surfaces 26 and 28 so that the ring 20 fits snugly on the outer
wall 24. The first portion 25 terminates in a flat radial surface
29 which in one embodiment is adapted to engage the bottom 23 of
groove 21. The outside diameter of the first portion 25 defined by
surface 26 is sized in relation to the groove 21 so that the
anti-extrusion ring 20 is retained within the groove by the
frictional engagement of surface 26 on the outer wall 24. The fit
between the two surfaces should preferably be between a zero
allowance and a 0.004 negative allowance. Preferably, this fit will
be between 0.001 and 0.003 negative allowance.
The forward end of the anti-extrusion ring 20 terminates in a flat
annular surface 30 which is adapted to sealingly engage surface 16
of member 12. The axial dimension of the ring 20 as measured
between surfaces 29 and 30 is preferably slightly greater than the
depth of groove 21. Thus when the members 10 and 12 are joined
together, the anti-extrusion ring 20 is retained under compression.
The axial dimension of the ring 20 in the unstressed condition
preferably should be between about 0.001 inches and 0.006 inches
greater than the depth of the groove 21. The radial dimension of
the portion 25 should be sufficient to withstand the compressive
forces exerted on the ring 20. Thicknesses will vary depending upon
the size of the ring but will normally be between about 0.060
inches and 0.030 inches.
The slant angle, indicated as A in FIG. 2, between the surface 28
and the axis of the ring 20 should be selected to provide the
wedging action necessary to prevent extrusion of the plastic ring
19. This angle should be between about 50.degree. and about
30.degree. with 45.degree. being preferred. The inner surface 31 of
ring 20 is preferably circular and is adapted to mate with the
outer surface of the plastic backup ring 19.
The radial dimension of groove 21 as measured between its inner
wall 22 and the axial extending portion of its outer wall 24 is
sized in relation to the three ring assembly. As indicated above,
the anti-extrusion ring 20 provides an interference fit with wall
24. The outer diameter of plastic ring 19 and the inner surface 31
of anti-extrusion ring 20 are sized to provide zero clearance
between the two mating surfaces. The O-ring 18 is sized to fit
snugly between the inner wall of plastic ring 19 and the wall 22 of
groove 21. The three ring assembly is thus snugly maintained in the
groove 21 permitting the cartridge to be mounted on the pump
without fear of the assembly or any component thereof dislodging
from the groove 21. The radial dimension of plastic ring 19
preferably is about the same as that of the axial extending portion
25 of ring 20 whereas the cross-sectional diameter of the O-ring 18
is slightly larger than the radial dimension separating wall 22 and
the inner wall of plastic ring 19. The O-ring 18 protrudes a short
distance above the other two rings in the unstressed condition.
When the cartridge 10 is mounted on the pump body 12, and the
mating surfaces 14 and 16 are drawn together as the cartridge is
screwed into the pump body 12, the O-ring 18 is deformed slightly
and compressed into the space separating plastic ring 19 and wall
22. This provides the initial seal for the assembly. As the
surfaces 14 and 16 are brought closer together, the plastic ring 19
and anti-extrusion ring 20 are also compressed slightly creating
high contact pressures between surface 30 and surface 16. This
contact pressure in combination with the plastic backup ring 19
prevents the O-ring 18 from extruding through the clearance gap
between the mated surfaces. Fluid pressure applied to the O-ring 18
deforms the O-ring forcing it against the plastic ring 19. At
extremely high pressures the plastic ring behaves much in the
manner of the viscoelastic fluid transmitting forces uniformly
along the inner surface 31 of the anti-extrusion ring 20. These
radially acting forces cause the tapered portion 27 of ring 20 to
move upwardly along the beveled edge of the outer wall 24 further
increasing the contact pressure of surface 30 on the pump body
12.
An alternate form of the anti-extrusion ring 20 is illustrated in
FIG. 3. In this embodiment the seal assembly 17 is identical to
that illustrated in FIGS. 1 and 2 except axial portion 25 is
truncated so that bottom surface 29 does not contact the bottom of
groove 21. In this arrangement, the plastic ring 19 seals the
interface between wall 24 of groove 21 and surface 26 of the
anti-extrusion ring 20.
The above tests demonstrate that the face seal of the present
invention provides a highly reliable seal and, because of its
unique construction, provides a convenient assembly which enables
the parts to be assembled with ease.
It should be emphasized that the anti-extrusion ring 20 in either
the embodiment of FIG. 2 or FIG. 3 can be used in combination with
the plastic ring 19 and O-ring 18 as illustrated above or in
combination with other types of sealing elements.
The dimensions, configurations, and choice of material, of the
three ring assembly described above can vary within relatively wide
limits depending upon the operating conditions. One example of a
specific design of the assembly that has performed extremely well
in providing static face seals for a plunger pump packing cartridge
is described below (numerals are with reference to FIG. 2):
Groove (21) ______________________________________ Diameter of wall
(22), inches 4.712 Diameter of wall (24), inches 5.500 Depth,
inches .237 Slope of beveled edge, degrees 45 O-ring (18)
______________________________________ Material Nitrile, 90
Durometer Rubber Nominal size, inches 51/4 .times. 43/4 .times. 1/4
Plastic Ring (19) ______________________________________ Material
Teflon Outside Diameter, inches 5.375 Inside Diameter, inches 5.250
Height, inches .237 Thickness, inches .062 Anti-Extrusion Ring (20)
______________________________________ Material SAE 660 Bronze
Diameter - Surface (31), inches 5.375 Height - Surface (31), inches
.243 Diameter - Surface (26), inches 5.501 Height - Surface (26),
inches .112 Angle (A), degrees 45
The cartridge 10 containing the three ring face seal 17 was
installed on a reciprocating pump having a 31/2 inch (diameter)
plunger. The plunger pump was employed to pump drilling fluid at a
pressure ranging between about 9,000 and 10,000 psi at an average
temperature of about 150.degree. F. The plastic ring 19 was first
positioned within the anti-extrusion ring 20 and this assembly was
then forced into the groove 21 of cartridge 10. The interference
fit between the ring 20 and groove wall 24 required the application
of a slight amount of force but readily lodged in the groove by
hand manipulation. (Negative allowance greater than about 0.003
inch may require tamping the ring 20 into place.) The O-ring 18
then was forced into the groove 21. The three ring assembly
retained in position by interference between adjacent surfaces
permitted the manipulation of the cartridge 10 without danger of
the rings falling out. This insured that the rings remained
properly positioned as the cartridge was screwed into the pump body
12.
A similar test was performed using a face seal illustrated in FIG.
3. The only difference between this seal and those previously
tested was the anti-extrusion ring 20. The ring 20 was of the same
material and dimensions as above except the height of surfaces 31
and 26 were 0.180 and 0.049 respectively. The pump was operated for
25 hours without failure to the face seal.
* * * * *