U.S. patent number 3,847,773 [Application Number 05/369,016] was granted by the patent office on 1974-11-12 for method and apparatus for curtain electrophoresis.
This patent grant is currently assigned to Technicon Instruments Corporation. Invention is credited to Lloyd R. Snyder.
United States Patent |
3,847,773 |
Snyder |
November 12, 1974 |
METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR CURTAIN ELECTROPHORESIS
Abstract
A method and apparatus for curtain electrophoresis in which
ionic species of a sample are separated by differential migration
under the influence of an electric field gradient extending
horizontally across a sheathed vertical curtain of a liquid medium.
The sample enters the curtain, which includes buffer solution,
adjacent the top of the curtain, and the sample fractions leave the
curtain adjacent the bottom of the latter at different lateral
locations with reference to the vertical center line of the
curtain. The adverse effect of horizontal sample flow inequality on
sample separation resolution, which inequality results in
horizontal band broadening or spreading, is significantly reduced
or eliminated. Such reduction is achieved by pulsing the electric
field on and off in synchronization with the sample flow: the field
is deenergized while the sample is entering the curtain and again
while the sample is leaving the curtain.
Inventors: |
Snyder; Lloyd R. (Yorktown
Heights, NY) |
Assignee: |
Technicon Instruments
Corporation (Tarryton, NY)
|
Family
ID: |
23453706 |
Appl.
No.: |
05/369,016 |
Filed: |
June 11, 1973 |
Current U.S.
Class: |
204/550;
204/547 |
Current CPC
Class: |
G01N
27/44782 (20130101); G01N 27/44769 (20130101); G01N
27/44756 (20130101) |
Current International
Class: |
G01N
27/447 (20060101); B01k 005/00 () |
Field of
Search: |
;204/18R,18G,299 |
References Cited
[Referenced By]
U.S. Patent Documents
Primary Examiner: Mack; John H.
Assistant Examiner: Prescott; A. C.
Attorney, Agent or Firm: Tedesco; S. P. Rockwell; Stephen
E.
Claims
What is claimed is:
1. In a method of curtain electrophoresis, wherein a sample is
introduced into a sheathed curtain of buffer solution in an
electric field for separation of at least one sample constituent by
differential migration, which constituent forms a sample band
laterally displaced with reference to the remainder of the sample
when exiting from the curtain; the improvement of deenergizing the
electric field during the interval that the sample is introduced
into the curtain and again during the interval that the sample band
exits from the curtain.
2. A method as defined in claim 1, further including collecting
said sample constituent as it exits from said curtain.
3. A method as defined in claim 1, wherein: a series of samples are
sequentially introduced into said curtain and said electric field
is pulsed in phase with the sample flow to deenergize said field
during the interval that each sample is introduced into the curtain
and again during the interval that the sample exits from the
curtain.
4. A method as defined in claim 3, wherein: each sample is
separated in said curtain into a plurality of constituents forming
sample bands laterally displaced with reference to one another, and
collecting said sample constituents as they exit from the curtain.
Description
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
1. Field of the Invention
The invention relates to electrophoresis and relates more
particularly to electrophoresis of the sheathed curtain type.
2. Prior Art
Band broadening of a sample species in the direction of separation
of species, i.e., in the direction of the electric field gradient
and at right angles to the direction of the curtain flow, has had a
known adverse effect on sample separation resolution in curtain
electrophoresis. The relative performance of a given
electrophoresis system, that is, the degree of separation per time
unit, is determined both by the extent of differential migration of
adjacent sample species and by band broadening or spreading of each
species. Optimum separation requires, among other parameters,
minimum band spreading.
Factors which are known to contribute to band broadening in
electrophoresis include, among others, molecular diffusion, thermal
diffusion and convection, electroosmosis and inequality of sample
flow apart from electroosmosis. The molecular diffusion factor is
unavoidable. However, certain factors which contribute to band
broadening, such as thermal diffusion and convection for example,
may be lessened when circumstances indicate that the factor is
significant. For example, if circumstances indicate that it would
be desirable to raise the field voltage, the electrophoresis system
may be cooled to avoid intolerable thermal conditions resulting
from such voltage increase, and/or the thickness of the sheath from
front to back may be reduced, with concomitant reduction in the
thickness of the flowing medium in the sheath.
I contemplate a method and apparatus for curtain electrophoresis
wherein the electric field gradient is pulsed in synchronization
with flow of the sample to reduce or eliminate the contribution to
band broadening of sample flow inequality, apart from
electroosmosis, in circumstances indicating that such band
broadening factor is significant.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
One object of the invention is to provide an improved method and
apparatus for curtain electrophoresis for the above-stated
purpose.
It is further contemplated to provide such method and apparatus in
which ionic species of a sample are separated by differential
migration under the influence of an electric field gradient
extending horizontally across a sheathed vertical curtain of a
liquid medium. The sample enters the curtain, which includes a
buffer solution adjacent the top of the curtain, and the sample
factions leave the curtain adjacent the bottom of the latter at
different lateral locations with reference to the vertical center
line of the curtain. The adverse effect of horizontal sample flow
inequality on sample separation resolution, which inequality
results in horizontal band broadening or spreading, is
significantly reduced or eliminated. Such reduction is achieved by
pulsing the electric field on and off in synchronization with the
sample flows: the field is deenergized while the sample is entering
the curtain and again while the sample is leaving the curtain.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
In the drawings:
FIG. 1 is a diagrammatic view illustrating horizontal band
broadening in curtain electrophoresis according to the prior
art;
FIG. 2 is a similar view illustrating horizontal band width
controlled in accordance with the invention;
FIG. 3 is a somewhat schematic, fragmentary view in perspective of
curtain electrophoresis apparatus embodying the invention;
FIG. 4 is an enlarged sectional view taken on line 4--4 of FIG. 3;
and
FIG. 5 is a diagrammatic view of controls for the sample flow and
the electric field in accordance with the invention.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENT
In FIG. 1 illustrating band broadening of a cylindrical jet of a
single sample species with reference to a curtain in accordance
with prior art electrophoresis, the outline of a vertically
arranged oblong curtain is indicated generally at 10. The flow of
the curtain which is a liquid medium is represented by the arrow U.
While in practice the sample is introduced into the upper portion
of the curtain in the vertically central plane of the curtain and
equidistant from the pair of usual non-illustrated electrodes at
zero field gradient, for ease of illustration the sample is shown
as introduced in the upper right corner of the curtain. In
consequence, the illustrated portion of the electric field gradient
is in the direction of the arrow E and may be assumed to be a
negative gradient increasing in strength to the left and effecting
leftward displacement of the sample species by pressure of the
field thereon. Hence, the sample species is subject to velocity
profiles in the vertical and horizontal directions as in
practice.
The sample 12 is shown in FIG. 1 moving progressively within the
curtain after its introduction thereinto, and the illustrated
representation of its movement and broadening is intended to show
typical band broadening in accordance with prior art
electrophoresis apparatus only with reference to horizontal sample
flow inequality, apart from electroomosis. As the sample has a
finite depth in the curtain and the curtain is conventionally
sheathed by a non-illustrated wall structure including closely
spaced plates opposing one another, the laminar sample flow in the
center of the curtain is at a far greater velocity than the
velocity of the sample flow along the wall structure, and this
results in the aforementioned inequality of sample flow. Such
inequality of flow occasions band broadening in the direction of
separation of species, which is the horizontal direction, and has
an adverse effect on separation resolution as previously
indicated.
Such adverse effect on separation resolution is observable at the
bottom of the curtain when the band leaves the curtain for typical
analysis at that location, as by collection in a tube for later
use. As indicated in FIG. 1, the leading edge of the sample leaves
the curtain at point X1 while the trailing sample edge leaves at
point X2. The sample band width on leaving the curtain is X2-X1.
The curve 13 below the curtain represents the concentration profile
of the sample band leaving the curtain 10. Band broadening
obviously interferes with the separation and/or collection of many
bands of species, e.g., up to and in excess of fifteen bands in a
single curtain.
With reference to FIG. 1 sample flow conditions in the curtain in
additional detail, it is to be noted that the sample introduction
to the curtain is of finite duration, the leading edge of the
sample band being indicated at 14 and the trailing portion at 16.
The sample has finite width at the time it leaves the
non-illustrated sample injection tube, and subsequently the sample
band is broadened by the aforementioned factors which are time
dependent. It will be observed in FIG. 1 that migration of the
sample species under the influence of the electric field occurs
while the sample is introduced into the curtain, and that this
migration effects leftward displacement and horizontal broadening
of the sample band. Similarly, as the sample band leaves the
curtain, the trailing portion of the band continues under the
influence of the field to migrate leftward. Under such continuing
influence, the band is broadened further as shown.
FIG. 2 illustrates the same sample species in the same curtain and
shows how deenergizing the electric field, both on introduction of
the sample to the curtain and again as the sample leaves the
curtain, controls band broadening in accordance with the invention.
The entire sample band 12, with leading edge 14 and trailing
portion 16, is admitted to the curtain while the field is
deenergized. Of course, during such sample introduction there is
inequality of vertical sample flow resulting in vertical band
broadening but this does not adversely effect sample separation
resolution. When the entire sample is in the curtain, the field is
reenergized and the sample species band then commences lateral
migration under the influence of the field. Such migration
continues until the species band is about to commence leaving the
curtain. At such time the field is again deenergized until the
entire band has left the curtain. The band 18 below the curtain
represents the flow of the sample species from the curtain, and it
can be seen that the last-mentioned band is very much narrower,
indicating much better separation resultion, than the base of the
curve 13 of FIG. 1. To compensate for lost sample mirgration time
during deenergization as aforesaid of the electric field, the field
voltage may be increased.
Turning now to the structure of the electrophoresis system shown
FIGS. 3-5, a pair of plate parts 20, 22 of dielectric material are
vertically arranged in slightly spaced apart and opposing relation
to another. The space between the plate parts is vertically
partitioned conventionally by a pair of dialysis membranes 24, and
the plate parts are provided with two side edge seals 26
therebetween. This construction and arrangement provides two side
compartments 28 housing suitably mounted vertically arranged
electodes 30, respectively. Between the compartments 28, there is a
compartment 32 which provides a conventional sheath for the
electrophoresis curtain. The usual buffer solution is supplied to
the interior of the sheath and to the electrode compartments 28 as
by a spill-over trough, for example. The trough, which is arranged
horizontally, has a vertical back wall 34, a shorter front wall 36
over which the solution spills along its horizontal extent, end
walls and a bottom wall. Liquid buffer solution, which forms a salt
bridge between the electrodes 30 through the membranes 24, may be
supplied to the trough through an inlet tube 38.
The bottoms of the compartments 28, 32 may be open for drainage
therefrom. As shown in FIG. 3, a sample inlet 40 is formed in plate
part 20 opening into the upper central portion of the compartment
32. In the illustrated form of the invention, the sample fractions
separated from one another by differential migration in the field
gradient between the electrodes 30 are not analyzed by being
scanned with a spectrometer as they leave the curtain, but are
collected for later use in numerous tubes, only four such tubes
being shown and indicated at 42. Each tube 42 has the inlet end
thereof extending upwardly between the respective lower edges of
the plate parts 20, 22 in the compartment 32. If desired, the tubes
42 may convey the separated sample species therein for delivery to
respective ones of analysis manifolds, not shown, in a
continuous-flow type of automated analyzer.
In FIG. 5 illustrating the controls for pulsing the electric field
on and off in synchronization with the sample flow, a
solenoid-operated three-way valve is indicated generally at 44. The
valve has a buffer solution inlet arm 46, a sample inlet arm 48 and
an outlet arm 50. The outlet arm 50 is connected to the inlet 40
(FIG. 3) in the plate 20. The arm 46 is supplied with the usual
buffer solution under pressure, and the arm 48 is supplied with
sample under pressure. The valve 44 is controlled by a timer 52
through lead 54. The energization and deenergization of the
electrodes 30 is also controlled by the timer. The electrodes 30
may be electrically connected in series and for this purpose one of
the electrodes is shown connected to the timer by a lead 56, the
electrodes being interconnected by a lead 58.
In operation, the valve 44 is actuated by the timer 52 to the valve
position shown in FIG. 4 to admit sample to the electrophoresis
curtain while simultaneously deenergizing the electrodes 30. The
timer 52 next simultaneously actuates the valve 44 to shut off the
sample supply to the curtain and admit buffer solution through the
arm 46 to pass into the electrophoresis curtain through the valve,
while energizing the electrodes 30. The sample in the curtain moves
progressively therethrough in the electric field and species of the
sample are separated into respective bands by differential
migration in the field. As the bands of species commence leaving
the curtain at different times depending on the lateral
displacement of the bands, it is necessary to deenergize the field
before the first band commences to leave the curtain and to
maintain the field deenergized until the last band has left the
curtain. The timer 52 deenergizes the electrodes during this
period. The timer may then initiate the next cycle of operation by
placing the valve 44 in the condition of FIG. 4. In this manner a
series of samples may be sequentially separated into sample
components.
While only one form of the invention has been illustrated and
described, it will be apparent, especially to those versed in the
art, that the method and apparatus for curtain electrophoresis may
take other forms, and are susceptible of various changes in details
without departing from the principles of the invention.
* * * * *