U.S. patent number 3,812,646 [Application Number 05/237,858] was granted by the patent office on 1974-05-28 for supporting a thin walled bottle during capping.
This patent grant is currently assigned to Monsanto Company. Invention is credited to Eugene P. Baldyga, John E. Griesing.
United States Patent |
3,812,646 |
Baldyga , et al. |
May 28, 1974 |
SUPPORTING A THIN WALLED BOTTLE DURING CAPPING
Abstract
In capping a bottle containing a carbonated beverage capable of
generating a pressure of from about 15 to 150 psig depending on
temperature conditions, wherein a top load is applied to force a
closure into sealing engagement with an end section of the bottle,
the improvement of circumferentially enveloping a curved, stress
minimizing transition zone in the bottle between the side and
bottom walls with a restraining member during application of the
top load to prevent outward deflection of the transition zone, the
bottle being formed of a high barrier, flexible, thermoplastic
material having a wall thickness in the area of the transition zone
of between 10 to 35 mils. The apparatus comprises a shallow support
member for the lower portion of the bottle to resist outward
deflection of the thermoplastic during capping.
Inventors: |
Baldyga; Eugene P.
(Springfield, MA), Griesing; John E. (Granby, CT) |
Assignee: |
Monsanto Company (St. Louis,
MO)
|
Family
ID: |
22895519 |
Appl.
No.: |
05/237,858 |
Filed: |
March 24, 1972 |
Current U.S.
Class: |
53/488;
53/329 |
Current CPC
Class: |
B67B
3/18 (20130101) |
Current International
Class: |
B67B
3/00 (20060101); B67B 3/18 (20060101); B65b
007/28 () |
Field of
Search: |
;53/42,329,331 |
References Cited
[Referenced By]
U.S. Patent Documents
|
|
|
1993650 |
March 1935 |
Darling et al. |
2174745 |
October 1939 |
Hoffman et al. |
2312288 |
February 1943 |
Schmutzer et al. |
2824584 |
February 1958 |
Breeback |
3714755 |
February 1973 |
Phalin et al. |
|
Primary Examiner: McGehee; Travis S.
Attorney, Agent or Firm: Murphy; Michael J.
Claims
We claim:
1. In the method of capping a bottle containing a beverage capable
of generating a temperature-dependent pressure of from 15 to 150
psig by applying a top load to the bottle to force a closure into
sealing engagement with cooperating surfaces on an end section of
the bottle, the improvement which comprises circumferentially
enveloping a curved, stress-minimizing transition zone only in the
body of the bottle between the side and bottom walls with a
restraining member and resisting outward deflection of said
transition zone with said restraining member during application of
said top load to avoid damaging said bottle, said bottle being
formed of a high barrier, flexible, thermoplastic material having a
wall thickness in the area of said transition zone of between 10 to
35 mils.
2. The method of claim 1 wherein the thermoplastic at least in the
area of the transition zone is molecularly oriented.
3. In the method of capping a bottle containing a beverage capable
of generating a pressure due to carbonation of from 15 to 150 psig
at temperatures within the range of from 45.degree. to
120.degree.F. which comprises placing a closure loosely on an outer
end section of the bottle such that a flattened region of the
closure overlies the bottle mouth and a depending skirt surrounds a
threaded portion on the outer surface of the bottle neck, while
said beverage is at a temperature on the order of 32.degree. to
40.degree. F., then bringing a capping head and the bottle with the
closure thereon together under an axial pressure of from 200 to
1,000 pounds to seal an annular band of the flattened section of
the closure against the end face of the bottle neck and thereafter
deforming the closure sidewall inwardly about the threaded portion
of the bottle neck to sealingly engage the threaded portion and
closure sidewall against said carbonation pressure after release of
said axial pressure and increase of the beverage temperature to
within said range, the improvement which comprises moving a support
member having a cavity formed therein contoured to match the outer
surface of a curved transition zone in the lower portion of said
bottle relative to said bottle prior to application of said axial
pressure so as to support said transition zone against outward
deflection during application of said axial pressure, said bottle
being formed of a high barrier, flexible molecularly oriented
thermoplastic material having a wall thickness in the area of said
transition zone of between 10 to 35 mils.
4. The method of claim 3 wherein the thermoplastic comprises a
polymer, the major portion of which has been polymerized from a
monomer having at least one nitrile group in its molecular
structure.
5. The method of claim 4 wherein the thermoplastic has been
stretched axially and circumferentially to develop said molecular
orientation.
Description
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
This invention is directed toward filling and capping bottles and
more particularly toward capping bottles containing a beverage
capable of generating a pressure due to carbonation of from 15 to
150 psig at the extremes of the temperature conditions to which it
might be exposed prior to consumption.
Bottled carbonated beverages such as soft drinks and beer have been
traditionally marketed in glass containers having relatively thick
walls on the order of 1/8 - 1/4 inch. These thicknesses are
provided basically in order that the containers be capable of
withstanding miscellaneous impact forces without breaking, such as
those encountered e.g., during handling, filling and capping. More
specifically, the procedure for bottling beverages in such
containers customarily involves drawing a beverage portion from a
reservoir at a very high rate into the container and then
transferring the thus filled container, usually automatically, to a
capping machine where a closure is then sealed by various automated
techniques to the bottle, such seal being adequate to retain the
pressure of the contents until the bottle is opened. The
temperature of the beverage during filling and capping is usually
quite low, e.g., about 32.degree.-40.degree. F., and consequently
the internal pressure from carbonation immediately after capping is
also quite low, but eventually the temperature could rise to as
high as 120.degree. F. before the bottle is opened by a consumer
and at this temperature the internal pressure could reach 150 psig
at a level of 5.0 volumes of CO.sub.2 within the container, whereas
at the other end of the scale, i.e., at 45.degree. F. and a
relatively low carbonation level of 2.6 volumes of CO.sub.2, the
pressure of the contents might be as low as 15 psig. Such packages
are generally considered to require special pressure resistant
closures in contrast to non-pressurized packages where the internal
pressure is essentially atmospheric.
Equipment for applying the caps to the bottles usually includes a
type of pressure block which is moved axially relative to the
closure bearing surface of the bottle at a substantial force, e.g.,
on the order of 200-1,000 pounds, depending on the equipment, in
order to establish a seal of the closure with the upper surface of
the bottle finish. As mentioned, because of the relatively thick
walls, the base sections of prior art glass bottles readily
withstood such top loads without breaking or buckling.
Recently, thermoplastic materials have been developed which have
been found especially suitable for pressurized packaging
applications primarily because of their attractive carbon dioxide
and oxygen barrier properties. Typical of such materials are
polymers based on acrylonitrile or methacrylonitrile; vinyl
chloride and certain polyesters. Using the prior glass container
art as a guide, bottles made from these materials and used in these
applications were initially made with rather thick walls, and,
accordingly, when we passed such containers through filling and
capping equipment of the type just described, the base area to
which the relatively high top loads were transmitted was
sufficiently heavy to readily withstand the load.
Other considerations however dictate that a more sophisticated
approach is necessary to provide a commercially successful
carbonated beverage bottle made from these materials. For example,
though such thermoplastic bottles have advantages, e.g., in terms
of a substantial reduction in weight over glass or metal, if they
are to be competitive they must obviously be produced at costs
approaching those of the latter. Thus, it is desirable to reduce
the wall thickness in order to decrease the amount of the
relatively expensive-to-synthesize thermoplastic therein. Also,
though these special thermoplastics possess desirable barrier
properties, they tend to be somewhat brittle, and especially is
this so with polymers wherein the major constituent has been
polymerized from a monomer containing at least one nitrile group in
its molecular structure. Therefore, the wall thickness cannot be
greatly reduced if a high degree of sturdiness is necessary. To
compensate for brittleness, it has been suggested that an impact
modifier be incorporated into the bottle forming polymer and/or
that the polymer be stretched in order to preferentially orient the
molecules thereof in the direction of stretch, each of these
approaches being for the purpose of improving impact strength. In
addition, since the area of maximum stress from internal pressure
occurs in the lower portion of an elongated container in the area
of the confluence of the sidewall with the base, it has been
necessary to very carefully redesign this area versus that
previously employed in the less critical, heavy walled containers
in order to take maximum advantage of bottle contour in minimizing
high stress areas without having to preferentially thicken the wall
in such areas. This has involved a rather critical choice between
maximum curvature in the area of the lower portion of the bottle
and bottle stability or the ability of the container to support
itself in an upright position on a flat surface without requiring
an auxiliary support. When all of these process and container
design changes are made, however, though the strength properties
are substantially improved and manufacturing economics
competitively approach those of containers made from other
materials, we have found that problems occur in the ability of the
otherwise desirable thin walled, impact resistant, strong
thermoplastic bottles to withstand conventional filling and capping
top loads.
One solution to this dilemma is to incorporate means into the
capping machine and bottle to prevent the lower end from ever being
exposed to the otherwise necessary capping top loads, for example
by supporting each bottle at a circumferential ring on its neck
below the finish. However, this appears to require that separate
means be incorporated into existing or new capping machines which
means must be used with thin walled lightweight plastic bottles but
which are not required when the bottles are made of other
relatively thick walled materials such as glass. In addition, any
separate support ring on the bottle would have to be below the
finish in order not to interfere with the latter and would,
accordingly, detract from the aesthetic appearance of the
container.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
Now, however, there has been developed a novel technique for
accommodating thin walled, flexible, barrier thermoplastic bottles
in carbonated beverage filling and capping machines.
Accordingly, it is a principal object of this invention to provide
novel method and means for supporting a thin walled, flexible
bottle containing a beverage capable of generating pressures on the
order of 15-150 psig at temperatures of from 45.degree. to
120.degree.F., as a cap for resisting such pressures is being
applied to the bottle.
An additional object of this invention is to provide method and
means for supporting such a container against substantial top loads
other than at the neck area thereof.
A further object of this invention is to provide method and means
for supporting such a container which has a generously rounded
stress minimizing wall portion joining the side and base walls
which tends to collapse on itself when axially loaded with forces
generated by conventional carbonated beverage filling and capping
machine heads.
A specific object of this invention is to provide method and means
for supporting such a container which does not require that any
revisions at all be made to already existent commercial capping
heads.
Yet another object of this invention is to cap such a bottle by
application of top loads on the order of 200-1000 pounds without
rupturing or in any way permanently deforming the bottle after
dissipation of such capping loads.
Other objects of this invention will in part be obvious and will in
part appear hereinafter.
These and other objects are accomplished in the method of capping a
bottle containing a beverage capable of generating a
temperature-dependent pressure of from 15 to 150 psig through
imposition of a top load to the bottle to force a closure into
sealing engagement with cooperating surfaces on an end section
thereof, by providng the improvement which comprises
circumferentially enveloping a curved, stress minimizing transition
zone in the bottle between the side and bottom walls with a
restraining member during application of said top load to prevent
outward deflection of said transition zone, said bottle being
formed of a high barrier, flexible, thermoplastic material having a
wall thickness in the area of said transition zone of between 10 to
35 mils.
The apparatus includes a shallow support member for the lower
portion of the bottle to resist outward deflection of the flexible
thermoplastic during application of capping forces, the support
member preferably having a cavity formed therein which is contoured
to match the outer surface of the lower portion of the bottle.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
In describing the overall invention, reference will be made to the
accompanying drawings wherein:
FIG. 1 is an elevational view of a bottle and closure useable in
the method of the present invention;
FIG. 2 is a vertical sectional schematic view illustrating in solid
lines the bottle of FIG. 1 supported according to the present
invention just prior to imposition of a top load;
FIG. 3 is a partial, schematic view of the lower end of the bottle
of FIGS. 1 and 2 during imposition of a capping top load which is
not supported according to the invention;
FIG. 4 is a view similar to FIG. 3 after release of the top
load;
FIGS. 5 and 6 are vertical, sectional, schematic views of
alternative forms of bottle support according to the present
invention; and
FIG. 7 is an enlarged, sectional, schematic view of the upper end
of the bottle of FIGS. 1 and 2 during capping;
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE ILLUSTRATED EMBODIMENTS
Referring now to the drawings, there is illustrated in FIG. 1, a
one piece bottle 10 for containing a carbonated beverage which is
formed of a high barrier, flexible, thermoplastic material, such as
a polymer comprising from 60 to 80 weight percent polymerized
acrylonitrile monomer and 40 to 20 weight percent of another
monomer, such as styrene, copolymerized therewith. it should be
understood, however, that this composition represents a preferred
embodiment and that alternative yet highly selective types of
thermoplastics are useable in packaging the carbonated beverages,
such as soft drinks and beer, toward which the present invention is
directed. To accomplish this, it is necessary that the
thermoplastic exhibit high barrier properties toward oxygen and
carbon dioxide, materials having permeabilities of less than 20
(O.sub.2) and 30 (CO.sub.2) cc./day/100 sq.in./mil./atm. at
73.degree.F. being considered herein as qualifying for this
application.
Bottle 10 comprises sidewall 12, the upper portion of which
converges inwardly to eventually form central opening 14 through
which the contents is discharged, the inwardly tapered end section
16, in the illustrated embodiment, having a finish constituting
threads 18 integrally formed on its outer surface. Alternative
types of finishes, however, may be provided on bottle 10 for
accommodating different types of closures, e.g., crown, rip cap, or
crown-twist off. Bottle 10 includes a rounded transition zone 20 at
the lower end thereof which smoothly connects sidewall 20 with base
22. Base portion 22 includes a raised inwardly convex central area
24 and a relatively flat annular seating ring portion 26 for
supporting bottle 10 in an upright position on a flat surface
without requiring an auxiliary coaster-like support member.
Transition zone 20 is rather critical in the design of bottle 10 in
that this is the area of the bottle in which maximum stresses are
developed due to the pressure of the beverage contents 28, when the
bottle is capped and the contents are increased in temperature,
e.g., to the temperature of the particular surroundings to which
the filled and capped bottle is exposed during handling, storing,
etc., which temperature is considered to lie anywhere within the
range of from about 45.degree. to 200.degree.F., with the
corresponding internal pressure, depending on the carbonation
level, being within the range of 15 to 150 psig. Of course the
beverage temperature, because of consumer preference, most likely
will have been reduced again to around 32.degree. F. at the time of
consumption.
Bottle 10 in the area of transition zone 20 has a relatively thin
wall of between 10 to 35 mils as shown at 78 in FIG. 1, which has
been molecularly oriented during molding by stretching the plastic
forming transition zone 20 both axially in the direction of axis 62
and either subsequently or simultaneously in the radial direction
perpendicular to axis 62. For the high nitrile plastic of bottle 10
of the illustrated embodiment, stretching should be carried out
above the glass transition temperature of the polymer and
preferably within the temperature range of from 250.degree. to
325.degree. F. Though bottle 10 (with cap 32 sealed thereon) can
successfully contain contents 28 without being molecularly
oriented, the ability of the bottle to withstand impact is greatly
improved by orienting the plastic of transition zone 20 in the
sense that the plastic tends to yield when exposed to a critical
yield stress such as an impact force, whereas the bottle is prone
to fail at transition zone 20 under exposure to similar force
conditions with an unoriented plastic.
Closure 32 is provided for bottle 10 and comprises flattened end
wall 34 and skirt 36 depending from the periphery of wall 34. In
the illustrated embodiment, closure 34 is made of thin walled
deformable aluminum metal having a liner 56 (FIG. 7) therein which
is inert to contents 28, though obviously closure 32 could be
formed of other materials such as plastic.
Contents 28 in the illustrated embodiment comprises a cola beverage
to which 3.75 volumes of carbon dioxide has been added, but which
is at a temperature sufficiently low, e.g., on the order of
32.degree. F. to avoid generation of the pressures otherwise
encountered due to carbonation on subsequent increase of the
temperature. By a volume of CO.sub.2 gas under these circumstances
is meant one volume of CO.sub.2 gas measured under standard
conditions for gases dissolved in one volume of the liquid. Though
bottling the beverage at low temperature is preferred since the
pressures encountered are lower, it should be realized that the
beverage temperature during bottling can be higher, e.g.,
70.degree. F., and such may be desirable to reduce refrigeration
requirements. Contents 28 has been added to bottle 10 by
conventional filling equipment preferably while supported within
support member 30, (FIG. 2) the significance of which will be
described hereafter.
As indicated in FIG. 2, in capping bottle 10, cylindrical closure
32 is placed, either automatically or manually, loosely on the neck
of bottle 10 such that end wall 34 overlies opening 14 and
depending skirt 36 surrounds the threads 18 on the outer surface of
neck 16. According to the present invention, at some time prior to
application of the top load, as indicated by the dotted line
position of head 48 in FIG. 2, bottle 10 is placed within shallow
support member 30, or alternatively, support member 30 may be
brought up around the bottom portion of bottle 10 while the latter
is held in fixed position by a suitable means (not shown). This
latter placement could be accomplished, for example as illustrated
in FIG. 6, by means of piston rod 38 reciprocable in conventional
fluid actuated cylinder 40 which has at its outer end, carrier
platform 42 with a continuous side portion 43 extending upwardly
from its periphery, as illustrated in FIG. 6. In the preferred
embodiment of FIG. 1, support member 30 has an upwardly facing
cavity 44 formed therein, the sidewall 46 of which is contoured to
exactly match the outer surface configuration of transition zone 20
of bottle 10, i.e., wall 46 is curved at a radius or radii
equivalent to that of R of the bottle (FIG. 1). For good thin
walled, flexible thermoplastic pressurized container design, R
should be maintained at between 0.125 to 0.7 inch.
As illustrated in FIG. 2, conventional capping head 48 is supported
above the cap-bearing bottle 10, and includes a pressure block 52,
having a bottle facing cavity formed in its lower end which
includes a vertical surface 54, the diameter of which is equivalent
to that of the outside diameter of bottle neck 16 plus the
thickness of sidewall 36 of closure 32 as well as that of liner 56,
should the latter extend partially down along wall 36. Roller 58,
resiliently supported by means such as springs 60 is positioned
beneath head 48 and beside closure 34 and bottle neck 16.
Next, capping head 48 and the closure-containing bottle are brought
together under an axial pressure of from 200 to 1,000 pounds in
order to swage or bend the metal (and optionally the liner) of the
closure around the outer upper corner of the bottle wall around the
periphery of opening 14 so as to frictionally engage and seal the
closure to the bottle. These rather substantial top loads are
necessary for such deformation to occur. Thus, an annular band 64
of the flattened section 34 of closure 32 is sealed against end
face 50 of the bottle neck and with the upper end of the sidewall
forming a corner with surface 50, except that in the illustrated
embodiment where closure 32 has a liner therein, the seal on the
top surface is formed between face 50 and an annular surface
portion of liner 56. This loaded position is depicted in the
outline form of head 48 in FIG. 2 and in detail in FIG. 7. While
this axial pressure is maintained by suitable means either pushing
upwardly on support member 30 or downwardly on pressure block 52,
resiliently supported rollers such as that shown at 58 are moved
radially inwardly against the thin wall 36 of closure 32 so as to
deform it inwardly around and against the threaded finish 18 so as
to sealingly frictionally engage the opposing surfaces of the
threads and sidewall against internal carbonation pressure after
release of the axial pressure and subsequent increase of the
beverage temperature. During deformation of sidewall 36, either
bottle 10 or rollers 58 are rotated circumferentially to cause the
sidewall to engage the threads on the neck. It is preferable also
that this action of the roller(s) crimp end portion 65 of the
closure sidewall under ledge 66 at the base of neck 16 so as to
provide the sealed container with a tamper proof feature, though a
separate roller can be provided to accomplish this.
As can be appreciated from FIG. 2, the relatively thin, molecularly
oriented deformable wall 78 (FIG. 1) of transition zone 20 is
circumferentially enveloped by member 30 and therefore supported
against outward deflection during application of the axial sealing
pressure. The wall thickness of the bottle in the region of the
neck finish and upper portion of sidewall 12 is shown as somewhat
thicker than that of transition zone 20 in the illustrated
embodiments of FIGS. 1 and 7, but this increased thickness tends to
be somewhat of a limitation of the blow molding manner of forming
the bottle and need not necessarily exist. After the closure
sidewall has been deformingly engaged with the bottle neck finish,
the pressure block and supported bottle are separated from each
other and the thus tightly capped container extricated from support
member 30.
FIG. 3 illustrates the appearance of the transition zone with
respect to the remainder of the lower portion of a bottle 10 under
an axial capping load as just described when the transition zone is
not supported against outward deflection, the bottle merely resting
on flat surface 74. As illustrated, portion 68 has been rather
dramatically deformed outwardly primarily because of the generous
curvature of transition zone 20. In the illustrated embodiment,
this effect is accentuated because of the differences in diameter
in the cylindrical bottle from that at 70 versus that at transition
zone 20. This creates sort of a hinge effect at 72 causing the wall
to collapse downwardly on itself when loaded. If the container as
illustrated in FIG. 3 does not rupture under the imposition of
capping forces as is the case more often than not, it can retain a
permanent set after dissipation of such force which resembles its
deformed shape under load, such shape being illustrated at ridge 76
in FIG. 4. Ridge 76 acts as an area of high stress concentration,
and also tends to detract from the aesthetic appearance of the
lower portion of the bottle.
Support member 30 of the present invention may alternatively be
provided in two or more complementary pieces such as 78a and 78b in
FIG. 5, which are moved toward each other in the direction of 82
preferably until they abut the surface of the lower portion of the
bottle. Each portion 78 is preferably, though not necessarily,
contoured as at 84 to match the outer contour of transition zone 86
in bottle 80.
The above description and particularly the drawings are set forth
for purposes of illustration only and are not to be taken in a
limited sense.
Various modifications and alterations will be readily suggested to
persons skilled in the art. It is intended, therefore, that the
foregoing be considered as exemplary only and that the scope of the
invention be ascertained from the following claims.
* * * * *