U.S. patent number 3,797,259 [Application Number 05/207,144] was granted by the patent office on 1974-03-19 for method for insitu anchoring piling.
This patent grant is currently assigned to Baker Oil Tools, Inc.. Invention is credited to Archer W. Kammerer, Jr..
United States Patent |
3,797,259 |
Kammerer, Jr. |
March 19, 1974 |
**Please see images for:
( Certificate of Correction ) ** |
METHOD FOR INSITU ANCHORING PILING
Abstract
Method for securing tubular piling or pile casing in the ground
which comprises inserting tubular piling into the ground,
preferably heavy piling adapted to be driven into the ground,
inserting an expandable mechanism, e.g., an expandable
hydraulically actuated mandrel, into the tubular piling at one or
more spaced intervals or positions longitudinally along the piling,
expanding the mechanism at each such position to expand the piling
outwardly to form one or more protrusions spaced longitudinally
along the piling, and retracting the expandable mechanism at each
such position.
Inventors: |
Kammerer, Jr.; Archer W.
(Fullerton, CA) |
Assignee: |
Baker Oil Tools, Inc. (Los
Angeles, CA)
|
Family
ID: |
22769379 |
Appl.
No.: |
05/207,144 |
Filed: |
December 13, 1971 |
Current U.S.
Class: |
405/244; 29/523;
72/462 |
Current CPC
Class: |
E02D
5/54 (20130101); E02D 5/28 (20130101); Y10T
29/4994 (20150115) |
Current International
Class: |
E02D
5/28 (20060101); E02D 5/24 (20060101); E02D
5/22 (20060101); E02D 5/54 (20060101); E02d
005/28 (); B21d 039/00 () |
Field of
Search: |
;61/53.6,53.68,53.5,56,53,53.52,53.64 ;29/523,521 |
References Cited
[Referenced By]
U.S. Patent Documents
Foreign Patent Documents
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
599,786 |
|
Jul 1934 |
|
DD |
|
1,034,128 |
|
Jun 1966 |
|
GB |
|
431,069 |
|
Jul 1935 |
|
GB |
|
Primary Examiner: Shapiro; Jacob
Attorney, Agent or Firm: Kriegel; Bernard
Claims
I claim:
1. The method of securing tubular piling in the ground, which
comprises inserting tubular piling into the ground having straight
longitudinal walls and a wall thickness ranging from about
three-sixteenths inch to about 11/4 inches, inserting an expandable
means into said piling, expanding said means against the interior
of said piling at intervals along the lengths of said piling to
form a plurality of external annular protrusions spaced from each
other about 2 to about 30 times the lateral extent of each
protrusion beyond the outer surface of said piling and without
increasing the internal diameter of the piling between said
protrusions, to thereby secure said piling against the soil of the
adjacent ground formation, and retracting said expandable means
after expansion thereof to enable said means to be moved
longitudinally within said piling; said means being expanded
against the interior of said piling to form said protrusions
extending laterally outwardly beyond the outer surface of said
piling an amount ranging from about one-fourth inch to about 3
inches, the piling inserted into the ground having an outside
diameter to wall thickness ranging from about 25 to about 75, in
which protrusions formed by said expanding means are spaced from
each other by a distance such that the angle of shear of the soil
surrounding said piling and its protrusions is of a magnitude so
that said soil is in shear solely with itself substantially along
the entire length of said piling between the uppermost and
lowermost protrusions on said piling.
2. The method as defined in claim 1; in which said piling is
inserted into ground having a high shear strength relative to its
coefficient of friction against the external piling surface.
3. The method as defined in claim 1; in which said piling is
inserted into ground comprising sand by driving the piling into
said ground to a desired depth.
Description
This invention relates to a method for securing tubular piling in
the ground, and is particularly concerned with procedure for
inserting tubular piling, preferably formed of thick wall heavy
pipe, in the ground, as by driving same, and after being inserted
to a predetermined depth in the ground, forming protrusions at
spaced intervals on the piling to securely anchor the piling in the
ground.
The load-bearing capacity of longitudinally flat or straight
tubular piling is dependent chiefly upon a combination of
load-bearing capacity of the soil or ground at the lower end or tip
of the piling, and the coefficient of friction between the ground
or soil and the piling skin along the length thereof. Where the
piling is made of metal such as steel, such coefficient of friction
may be relatively low and hence a major portion of the load-bearing
capacity is dependent upon the load-bearing capacity at the lower
end of the piling. Under these conditions, the cross-sectional area
of the piling must be increased, resulting in increased cost of the
piling and also of its insertion into the ground.
Continuously corrugated piling, that is pile casing having
corrugations which extend over the full length of the casing, as
illustrated in FIG. 1 of U.S. Pat. No. 3,375,670, similarly
utilizes friction between the ground and the continuously
corrugated skin of the piling, and end bearing loading capacity, to
permit loading when inserted into the ground. Additionally, the
soil trapped between such continuous corrugations is to some extent
mobilized into resistance against itself, but this additional
resistance to movement of the pile casing under loading is often
insufficient to securely anchor the piling, particularly under
heavy loading or when subjected to extreme vibration or shock
loading.
In the above-noted Pat. No. 3,375,670, continuously corrugated
light metallic tubular casing is inserted into a predrilled hole in
soft soil, after which an expanding mechanism is used to expand the
casing to substantially remove the corrugations and to render the
walls substantially straight longitudinally. Although this
operation increases the total volume of the casing and radial
pressure is exerted by the casing against the surrounding soil as a
result of this operation, to thereby aid in anchoring the piling,
the flattening out of the corrugations according to this process to
render the pile casing again longitudinally flat or straight,
removes the load-bearing resistance of the soil initially trapped
between the corrugations, and the resulting pile casing again
depends for load-bearing capacity in large measure only upon the
coefficient of friction between the soil and the piling skin.
The above patent states that if desired, the tubular pile casing
previously rendered flat or straight by the initial expanding
operation, can be further expanded by the formation of further
corrugations in the wall of the casing after the original
corrugations have been substantially removed. The resulting
"re-corrugation" produces a continuously corrugated piling as
illustrated in FIG. 4 of the patent. Although the resulting
re-corrugations are annular in shape rather than helical, the
re-corrugated pile casing is again essentially a continuously
corrugated piling which in many instances, even with the compaction
of the surrounding soil produced by the initial expansion and the
resistance of the soil trapped in the small areas between the
annular re-corrugations, has a load-bearing capacity which often is
insufficient to securely anchor the piling, particularly against
heavy or shock loading or vigorous vibration.
Also, as previously noted, the above patent is directed to securing
light tubular casing in the ground, and which is usually inserted
into a predrilled hole. Such light casing cannot ordinarily be
driven into the ground, except by the use of a mandrel to support
it as it is driven, as noted in the patent. Moreover, such light
tubular piling cannot be employed in many applications for
supporting heavy structures and requiring high loading capacity,
and is usually filled with concrete to finish the pile.
It is accordingly the object of the present invention to afford a
method of inserting and securing tubular piling, particularly thick
heavy wall tubular piling, in the ground, and to anchor same in the
surrounding soil against vertical movement therein as result of the
application of high static loading, shock loading or high
vibrational forces.
There is provided according to the present invention a method of
securing tubular piling, preferably formed of thick wall heavy
pipe, in the ground, which comprises inserting tubular piling
having straight longitudinal walls into the ground, e.g. by driving
same, inserting an expandable means into the tubular piling at one
or a plurality of spaced predetermined positions longitudinally
along the piling, expanding such means at each such position to
expand the piling outwardly a predetermined extent to form one or a
plurality of protrusions or corrugations extending outwardly at
spaced intervals longitudinally along the piling, and retracting
the expandable means at each such position after expansion thereof,
to thereby secure the piling against the soil of the adjacent
ground formation.
The resulting piling with appropriately spaced protrusions or
corrugations extending outwardly to a significant extent, as
pointed out in greater detail hereinafter, effectively mobilizes
the resistance of the adjacent soil, particularly the soil trapped
between adjacent protrusions, against itself over virtually the
entire length of the tubular piling with high effectiveness, so
that the soil adjacent the tubular piling effectively is in shear
against itself throughout substantially the length of the piling,
rather than being in shear against the side of the piling. The
distance between the protrusions or corrugations, accordingly, is
maintained particularly so that the above-noted condition prevails,
that is, so that the angle of shear of the soil adjacent the casing
is of a magnitude such that the soil is in shear solely with itself
substantially along the entire length of the piling between the
uppermost and lowermost protrusions on the piling.
According to another feature of the invention, in order to provide
maximum effectiveness of the protrusions formed insitu on the
piling according to the invention, it has been found that the ratio
of the outside diameter of the piling to the wall thickness of the
piling be within certain limits, as noted hereinafter.
Generally, the protrusions or corrugations formed at spaced
intervals insitu on the piling wall have substantially the same
configuration and extend outwardly substantially the same amount
from the piling wall, although these conditions can vary as
desired, for example the extent of protrusion of the corrugations
can vary, since it is often difficult when expanding the piling
wall by the expandable means described more fully below, to have
each corrugation or protrusion extend outwardly from the piling
wall the same amount. Also, the distance between adjacent
corrugations or protrusions formed on the piling wall can be
substantially the same or can be varied as desired depending upon
the soil conditions encountered.
Also, where formations of different types are encountered along the
length of the tubular piling, for example stratas of sand and clay,
only a portion of the longitudinal length of the tubular piling can
be corrugated insitu according to the invention, e.g., where the
adjacent formation is of a sandy nature, the remainder of the
tubular piling wall remaining longitudinally straight.
The tubular piling is generally formed of metals or metal alloys
such as iron, steel, copper, and the like. Any suitable material of
construction can be utilized which is sufficiently ductile to be
expanded to form the spaced corrugations or protrusions thereon
according to the invention.
In preferred practice, the tubular piling is inserted into ground
having a high shear strength value relative to its coefficient of
friction against the pile surface. Hence the insitu corrugated
piling according to the invention has high effectiveness in soils
having a sandy content, such as sand itself, and particularly in
shale. The resistance to axial forces of the insitu corrugated
piling of the invention is generally in proportion to the
difference between the insitu properties of a particular soil in
shear versus friction against the piling skin. As an illustration,
in sand, the insitu piling produced according to the invention
successfully resists pullout forces of about twice the level of
longitudinally straight or flat piling, and substantially higher
then that of continuously corrugated pile casing of the type
illustrated in FIGS. 1 and 4 of above Pat. No. 3,375,670. In shale,
the relative difference in pullout forces between the insitu
corrugated piling of the invention and the straight or continuously
corrugated piling noted above increases dramatically in favor of
the piling having the spaced corrugations formed insitu according
to the invention, e.g., to the extent of say as much as 10 times
the pullout resistance of longitudinally straight piling.
Any suitable expandable means or mechanism can be employed for
insertion into the tubular piling after it is placed in the ground,
for expanding the tubular piling at one or more predetermined
positions along the piling to provide the insitu corrugations or
protrusions on the piling wall. Thus for example a tool having a
hydraulically inflatable mandrel comprising a short rubber-like
packing element can be employed to bulge the piling outwardly to
form the corrugations and the packing retracted by relieving the
pressure. Alternatively, suitable mechanical, explosive or
vibrating type tools can be employed for this purpose.
The invention will be more fully understood from a detailed
description of certain embodiments thereof taken in connection with
the accompanying drawing wherein:
FIG. 1 is a longitudinal and partial sectional view of tubular
piling in position in the ground prior to expansion or deformation
of certain portions thereof according to the invention;
FIG. 2 is a longitudinal and partial sectional view of the tubular
piling in the ground following expansion of the circumference of
the casing to form the protrusions or corrugations thereon;
FIG. 3 is a longitudinal view partly in cross section of a
hydraulically actuated tool for insertion into the tubular piling
of FIG. 1, to expand the piling and form the protrusions at
predetermined spaced intervals as shown in FIG. 2;
FIG. 4 is a longitudinal view of continuously corrugated tubular
casing positioned in the ground, not in accordance with the
invention, but for comparison purposes;
FIG. 5 illustrates practice of the invention wherein tubular piling
is expanded only in certain locations along the length of the
piling;
FIG. 6 is a longitudinal view partly in section of insitu
corrugated piling in the ground and illustrating a modification of
the invention wherein the distance between adjacent protrusions or
corrugations varies and also the extent of bulging of the
respective protrusions varies; and
FIG. 7 is a longitudinal view partly in section of step taper
tubular piling having protrusions or corrugations formed insitu
thereon after the piling is inserted in the ground.
Referring to FIG. 1 of the drawing, tubular steel piling 10 having
a longitudinally straight wall 12 is driven into the ground 14 by
any suitable means. The invention is particularly directed to the
use of thick wall heavy tubular piling which can be driven into the
ground without predrilling a hole therein, and without use of
special means such as a supporting mandrel as is required for
driving light tubular casing. Thus, the wall thickness of the
tubular piling employed according to the invention can range from
about three-sixteenths to about 11/4 inch. However, tubular piling
of smaller or larger wall thickness can be employed, and if
desired, a hole can be predrilled in the ground and the tubular
piling dropped therein, or a combination of these procedures can be
employed, that is the tubular piling can be driven into a
predrilled hole of somewhat smaller diameter, or alternatively,
vibrating or circulating techniques can be employed to insert the
piling in the ground.
The outside diameter of tubular piling employed according to the
invention can vary, and can range, e.g. from about 6 inches to
about 48 inches. The invention principles are particularly
applicable for tubular piling wherein the ratio of outside diameter
of the piling to the wall thickness ranges from about 25 to about
75.
Generally, and as illustrated in FIG. 1, the tubular piling is
closed by an end bearing 16 at the lower end of the piling, but it
will be understood that alternatively the tubular piling can be
open at both ends and after insertion into the ground, soil or sand
trapped within the piling can be removed by any suitable means.
A hydraulically actuated expander mechanism illustrated in FIG. 3
is lowered into the hollow tubular piling 10 of FIG. 1 to a
predetermined position therein. The mechanism illustrated in FIG. 3
comprises a hollow casing 18 carrying a short resilient and
inflatable, e.g., rubber-like, packing element 20 around its outer
surface. The resilient packing element is in contact with a
plurality of circumferentially spaced plates 23, each carrying an
arcuate segment 22, and such plates carrying the segments 22 are
adapted to be movable radially outward on the tubular casing 18.
The tubular element 18 is closed at its lower end by a plug 24.
When the expander is lowered into the tubular piling 10 illustrated
in FIG. 1, the packing element 20 is in normal retracted position
around the tubular element 18, and the plates 23 and segments 22
are in the positions shown in full lines in FIG. 3. Upon passage of
a hydraulic fluid under pressure into the tubular element 18 and
via a passage 26 in the casing and into the tubular packer 20, the
packer is expanded radially and simultaneously expanding the plates
23 and segments 22 to their position shown in phantom in FIG. 3,
and into compressive contact with the inner surface of the tubular
piling 10, and bulging or expanding the adjacent circumference of
the piling wall 12 to form the protrusion or corrugation indicated
at 28 in FIG. 2. It will be understood that the hydraulically
actuated cylindrical expander illustrated in FIG. 3 is simply
illustrative of any suitable expandable means for expanding the
tubular piling to form corrugations or protrusions therein
according to the invention, and hence such expander mechanism forms
no part of the present invention.
Following expansion of the expander mechanism to produce the
protrusion or corrugation indicated at 28 in FIG. 2, the hydraulic
pressure in the expansion mechanism is relieved, causing the
expandable packer 20 and segments 22 carried thereon to retract to
the full line position shown in FIG. 3. The expansion mechanism can
then be moved to another predetermined position within the tubular
piling and the operation repeated to form another corrugation or
protrusion indicated at 28a in FIG. 2. This operation can then be
repeated to form any desired additional number of spaced
protrusions indicated at 28b in FIG. 2.
The spaced apart protrusions or corrugations as illustrated at 28,
28a and 28b in FIG. 2, can have a bulge or outward extension
generally of at least 1/4 inch and usually not more than about 3
inches beyond the outer surface of the tubular piling wall 12, the
extent of bulge or expansion depending on the outside diameter of
the piling. Preferably it is desired to obtain the greatest extent
of outward bulging of the corrugations or protrusions as possible,
dependent on the ability of the tubular piling to be deformed
without rupturing. The greater the outer extent of the protrusion,
the more effectively is the soil mobilized against itself between
the adjacent corrugations.
The shape of the corrugations indicated at 28, 28a and 28b is of
generally rounded contour as result of expansion of the outer skin
of the tubular piling by the expandable tool in the manner
described above. In the embodiment illustrated in FIG. 2, the
amount of outer radial extension of the respective corrugations is
approximately equal, and the distance between adjacent
corrugations, e.g., between 28 and 28a, between 28a and 28b and
between the other successive corrugations, is substantially equal,
making for a substantially symmetrical arrangement of the
corrugations formed insitu on the tubular piling wall. This
arrangement is preferably employed where the soil conditions are
substantially the same throughout the length of the corrugated
portion of the tubular piling.
As a specific example, but not in limitation of the invention, the
straight sided tubular piling 10 has an outside diameter of 14
inches, a wall thickness of 3/8 32 inch, and is corrugated
according to the invention as illustrated in FIG. 2, to an outside
diameter of 16 inches, that is the corrugations form an outward
bulge of 1 inch from the outer wall of the casing, the corrugations
being spaced 13 inches apart along the length of the tubular
casing, starting 18 inches from the lower end or tip 16 of the
piling. In a test carried out on tubular piling of this type in
sandy soil, with spaced apart corrugations formed thereon as noted
above according to the invention, the straight sided piling
indicated in FIG. 1, initially driven into sand, moved upon the
imposition of a test pull of 47,000 lb. net, whereas the insitu
corrugated piling illustrated in FIG. 2 and produced according to
the invention moved upon application of a test pull of 64,000 lb.
net.
As previously noted, the spacing between corrugations, say between
the adjacent corrugations 28b in FIG. 2, is designed so that the
shear angle of the soil, e.g., sand, at the ends of the respective
protrusions or corrugations, and illustrated at A in FIG. 2, is
such that the soil is in shear against itself throughout the entire
length of the space between corrugations 28b and is not in shear
against the side of the tubular piling. This condition is satisfied
by spacing the corrugations so that the shear line 30 of the shear
angle A extends from the outer end 31 of one corrugation, e.g.,
28b, to the inner end 33 of the adjacent corrugation 28b. In
addition, the other angle of shear of the soil, illustrated at B,
adjacent the corrugations 28b is such that stress is applied along
the shear line 32 to a substantially large volume of adjacent soil
14. It is thus seen that the soil trapped between the adjacent
corrugations or protrusions of the tubular piling in FIG. 2 and the
adjacent volume of soil effectively mobilizes the resistance of the
soil against itself over virtually the entire length of the piling,
to effectively aid in anchoring the piling securely in the
formation. It has been found that the distance between adjacent
protrusions preferably is about 2 to about 30 times the extent of
such protrusion beyond the outer surface of the piling.
On the other hand, in the case of conventional continuous
corrugated piling illustrated at 34 in FIG. 4, the small amounts of
soil indicated at 36 and trapped between the adjacent corrugations
38, although mobilized into resistance against itself, such
resistance is substantially reduced due to the small amount of such
compacted soil between such corrugations and the overlapping of the
cones of soil-shear angle from one corrugation to the next, as
indicated at 40.
It will be understood that the soil shear angles indicated at A and
B are illustrative and that such shear angles will vary with
varying soils. Also it will be understood that the invention is not
intended to be limited as to the above-described theory whereby the
invention piling is securely anchored.
Referring to FIG. 5 of the drawing, there are illustrated
embodiments in which (1) the tubular piling 10a, of a structure
substantially the same as tubular piling 10, has formed insitu
thereon according to the invention principles, only a single
protrusion or corrugation 28 adjacent the lower end of the tubular
piling, (2) a tubular piling 10b again similar to that of tubular
piling 10, with four protrusions or corrugations 28 spaced apart
and located adjacent the lower end of the piling, and (3) tubular
piling 10c, similar to piling 10, having six corrugations or
protrusions 28 formed insitu at the lower end of the piling,
illustrating insitu corrugation of only a portion of the tubular
piling where the soil conditions at 14 adjacent the insitu formed
corrugations, e.g., comprising sand, may be different from the soil
conditions of the soil 14a adjacent the upper end of the
uncorrugated portion of the respective pilings, e.g., the soil 14a
for example being clay. In clay, which does not freely flow and
reconsolidate, as contrasted to sand, and which does not have high
shear strength values relative to its coefficient of friction
against the tubular skin of the piling, the insitu formed
corrugations according to the invention are not as effective as in
the case of said which has a high shear strength value relative to
its coefficient of friction against the piling skin.
Referring to FIG. 6, there is illustrated an unsymmetrical
arrangement of corrugations or protrusions on the insitu corrugated
piling according to the invention, wherein the distance between
adjacent corrugations 28c and 28d is different from the distance
between the adjacent pair of corrugatios 28d and 28e. This
embodiment is applicable where the soil conditions are different
along the various longitudinal locations of the piling. Also, in
the embodiment of FIG. 6, it is seen that the extent of bulge or
outward projection of the corrugations varies, for example,
corrugations 28c, is smaller than the extent of bulge or outward
projection of other corrugations such as 28d and 28e. To a large
extent this can be due to the difficulty in expanding each of the
spaced apart corrugations the same amount, by the expandable means
employed.
In FIG. 7 there is shown another modification of the invention
employing step taper tubular piling 41 and in which one or more
protrusions or corrugations 28f are formed insitu on one or more of
the respective step portions 42, 44 and 46 of varying diameter,
after insertion of the piling in the ground.
It will be understood that instead of employing an expandable
mechanism which forms only one corrugation or protrusion at a time,
a mechanism can be employed having multiple expansion elements,
e.g., multiple packers of the type illustrated at 20 in FIG. 3, and
multiple sets of cooperating plates 23 and segments 22 to form a
plurality of spaced apart protrusions or corrugations at the same
time. However, the use of a tool of the type illustrated in FIG. 3
which forms but a single protrusion at a time is preferable, since
it permits greater flexibility in adjusting and varying the
distance between adjacent insitu corrugations on the tubular
piling.
If desired, following formation of the protrusions or corrugations
on the tubular piling, e.g. in the embodiments of FIGS. 2, 5, 6 and
7, the tubular piling can be filled with concrete, but it will be
understood that this is not necessary.
The invention procedure can be employed for anchoring tubular
pilings for suport particularly of heavy structures such as
buildings, offshore oil drilling platforms, dams, and for tying
down bridge abutments of suspension type bridges.
From the foregoing, it is seen that the invention provides a novel
procedure for inserting and anchoring tubular piling in the ground,
particularly where thick heavy wall piling is required. In effect
the result of the invention procedure which produces insitu spaced
apart corrugations longitudinally along the tubular piling is to
substitute the shear strength of the formation itself, e.g. sand,
for the shear value as between the formation and the piling skin.
This results in substantially increasing the vertical resistance to
movement of the insitu corrugated piling of the invention as
compared to smooth or uncorrugated piling or as compared to
continuously corrugated piling.
* * * * *