U.S. patent number 3,783,251 [Application Number 05/093,331] was granted by the patent office on 1974-01-01 for computer assisted radiation therapy machine.
This patent grant is currently assigned to Varian Associates. Invention is credited to John M. Pavkovich.
United States Patent |
3,783,251 |
Pavkovich |
January 1, 1974 |
COMPUTER ASSISTED RADIATION THERAPY MACHINE
Abstract
A computer assisted radiation therapy machine is disclosed. The
machine includes a rotatable gantry having a radiation source
portion which is rotatable about a patient treatment couch.
Geometric and dose parameters of the machine for defining a
prescribed treatment plan of radiation are stored in the memory of
the computer. A readout and display means is provided for
displaying the geometric and dose parameters of the defined
radiation treatment plan. Editing and updating capability are
provided for editing and updating the treatment plan with the
cumulative radiation dose administered to each portal and the total
cumulative dose administered to the patient. Each parameter of a
proposed treatment plan is compared with permissible ranges of
machine parameters stored in a memory to verify that the proposed
treatment is within the permissible range of the machine.
Inventors: |
Pavkovich; John M. (Palo Alto,
CA) |
Assignee: |
Varian Associates (Palo Alto,
CA)
|
Family
ID: |
22238350 |
Appl.
No.: |
05/093,331 |
Filed: |
November 27, 1970 |
Current U.S.
Class: |
600/1; 378/68;
378/97; 378/196; 700/1; 378/65; 378/91; 378/117; 976/DIG.444 |
Current CPC
Class: |
G05B
19/188 (20130101); G05B 19/40935 (20130101); G21K
5/10 (20130101); A61B 6/4476 (20130101); A61B
6/4441 (20130101); A61B 6/102 (20130101); A61N
5/10 (20130101); A61N 5/01 (20130101); A61B
6/10 (20130101); H05G 1/44 (20130101); G05B
2219/42205 (20130101); G05B 2219/42256 (20130101); G05B
2219/35285 (20130101); G05B 2219/36551 (20130101); A61N
5/1048 (20130101); G05B 2219/34376 (20130101); G05B
2219/34242 (20130101); G05B 2219/49143 (20130101); G05B
2219/35307 (20130101); G05B 2219/36087 (20130101); G05B
2219/36153 (20130101); A61N 2005/1074 (20130101); G05B
2219/45169 (20130101) |
Current International
Class: |
A61B
6/10 (20060101); A61B 6/00 (20060101); G21K
5/10 (20060101); A61N 5/01 (20060101); A61N
5/10 (20060101); G05B 19/18 (20060101); G05B
19/4093 (20060101); H05G 1/44 (20060101); H05G
1/00 (20060101); A61n 005/01 () |
Field of
Search: |
;235/151,61.6H,151.3
;250/61.5 |
References Cited
[Referenced By]
U.S. Patent Documents
Foreign Patent Documents
Primary Examiner: Botz; Eugene G.
Attorney, Agent or Firm: Cole; Stanley Z. Herbert; Leon
F.
Claims
What is claimed is:
1. In a radiation therapy apparatus, couch means for supporting a
patient to receive radiation, radiation source means for applying
radiation to the patient, means for supporting and moving said
radiation source means around said couch means, means for storing
information defining geometric and radiation dose parameters of the
radiation machine for defining a prescribed radiation treatment to
be administered to the patient, means for reading out of said
storage means and displaying to an operator the geometric and dose
parameters defining the prescribed plan of radiation treatment,
means for deriving an output representative of the dose of
radiation actually administered to the patient from said source
means in carrying out the defined plan of treatment, means for
automatically editing and updating said storage means with the
derived dose output by adding the derived dose output to the
cumulative total of previously derived dose outputs, if any,
administered to the patient and stored in said storage means, to
obtain an updated cumulative total radiation dose output in said
storage means.
2. The apparatus of claim 1 wherein said means for displaying and
reading out of said storage means the parameters of a prescribed
plan of treatment includes, means for reading out the edited and
updated cumulative total radiation dose output from said edited and
updated storage means.
3. The apparatus of claim 1 wherein said storage means and said
editing and updating means includes, a programmed general purpose
computer.
4. The apparatus of claim 3 wherein said readout and display means
includes, cathode ray tube terminal means interactively coupled to
said general purpose computer means.
5. The apparatus of claim 3 wherein said readout and display means
includes, teletype terminal means interactively coupled to said
programmed general purpose computer means for printing out the
edited and updated treatment plan parameter stored in said storage
means.
6. The apparatus of claim 1 wherein said means for deriving an
output representative of the dose of radiation actually
administered to the patient includes, dosimeter means disposed in
the beam of radiation administered to the patient.
7. The apparatus of claim 1 including, programmed general purpose
computer means having a memory portion, and wherein said storage
means for storing the geometric and dose parameter information
defining a prescribed radiation treatment plan includes said memory
of said computer means, and including second information storage
means for storing geometric and dose parameter information defining
a prescribed radiation treatment plan for a given patient, means
for reading the treatment plan information stored in said second
storage means into said memory portion of said computer means,
means for recording information in said second information storage
means, and said computer means being programmed to read the edited
and updated treatment plan information from said memory portion of
said computer to said recording means for recording the updated
treatment plan information in said second information storage
means.
8. The apparatus of claim 7 wherein said second storage means
includes, an information storage tape medium.
9. The apparatus of claim 1 wherein, said storage means also
includes means for storing information defining permissible ranges
of values of treatment plan parameters for radiation treatment
plans to be administered to the patient, means for comparing a
proposed radiation treatment plan parameter against the respective
parameter of the range of permissible values to derive an interlock
output if the valve of the proposed machine parameter is outside
the respective range of permissible parameter values, and means
responsive to the interlock output to prevent transfer of the
out-of-range proposed machine parameter into the prescribed set of
treatment plan parameters stored in said storage means.
Description
DESCRIPTION OF THE PRIOR ART
Heretofore, the mechanical setup of a radiation therapy machine has
been automated for decreasing the setup time and improving the
accuracy of the mechanical setup for a radiation therapy treatment.
In the prior machine, the desired positional information for the
mechanical setup of the machine was punched into cards according to
a prescribed plan of treatment. A deck of cards representing the
setup for the prescribed plan of treatment was fed into a card
reader. The output of the card reader was fed to control circuits
for sequentially controlling the mechanical motion of the various
movable parts of the machine for geometrically positioning the
machine according to the prescribed plan of treatment. A four digit
visual display was provided for displaying the position of each of
the mechanically movable elements of the radiation therapy
machine.
While the aforecited automated radiation therapy machine
substantially decreased the setup time and improved the accuracy of
the setup, it did not include means for automatically maintaining
an updated reading of cumulative radiation dose delivered to a
patient through a prescribed radiation portal nor did it
automatically maintain a cumulative total of radiation administered
to a given patient.
The prescribed treatment plan for a patient, in the prior machine,
could be edited and updated by punching a new set of punched cards.
However, mistakes could be made by the keypunch operator and these
mistakes would be incorporated into the treatment plan to be
administered to the patient.
It is desired to obtain an improved automated radiation therapy
machine which automatically verifies a proposed plan of treatment
against a range of permissible values to prevent setting up or
editing a treatment plan which is not in conformance with a
predetermined range of permissible values for each parameter of a
treatment plan.
SUMMARY OF THE PRESENT INVENTION
The principal object of the present invention is the provision of
an improved automated radiation therapy machine.
One feature of the present invention is the provision of means for
automatically editing and updating a patient's treatment plan with
the cumulative total of radiation dose, if any, administered to the
certain patient.
Another feature of the present invention is the same as the
preceding feature wherein the means for automatically editing and
updating the patient's treatment plan includes a programmed general
purpose computer.
In another feature of the present invention, cathode ray tube
keyboard terminal or a teletype terminal is interactively coupled
to a general purpose computer for editing, reading out, and
displaying the updated treatment plan.
In another feature of the present invention, information defining a
radiation treatment plan for a given patient is stored in a first
memory means, such as a magnetic tape cassette paper tape or
magnetic disc. This information is transferred into the memory of
the computer and the computer reads the stored information, upon
command, to a readout and display terminal having the capability
for updating the treatment plan information stored in the
computer.
In another feature of the present invention, information is stored
defining permissible ranges of values for a treatment plan of
machine parameters and the corresponding parameters of a proposed
treatment plan are compared against the stored range of permissible
values to derive an interlock output if the value of a proposed
machine parameter is outside the range of permissible values to
derive an interlock output if the value of a proposed machine
parameter is outside the range of permissible values. The interlock
output is employed to prevent transfer of the proposed treatment
parameter into the treatment plan for the patient.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
FIG. 1 is a schematic diagram, partly in block diagram form, of an
automated radiation therapy machine incorporating features of the
present invention,
FIG. 2 is a schematic circuit diagram for deriving signals
determinative of the settings of the respective variable parameters
of the radiation therapy machine, and
FIGS. 3A and 3B shows computer program flow chart for the computer
assisted radiation therapy machine of FIG. 1.
DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
Referring now to FIG. 1, there is shown a computer controlled
radiation therapy machine incorporating features of the present
invention. The radiation machine 1, such as a CLINAC.sup.R
radiation therapy machine model 4 or 35, commercially available
from Varian Associates, or a THERATRON 80 automated cobalt 60
radiation machine made by Atomic Energy of Canada Limited of
Ottawa, Canada, includes a couch 2 having a table portion 3 which
receives the patient to be treated. The couch 2 is rotatable about
a vertical axis 4 by means of a turntable 5 which the couch 2 is
affixed. The couch includes an elevator portion 6 for translating
the couch in the vertical direction Z. In addition, the couch
includes motorized drives for translating the table 3 in the
lateral Y direction and longitudinal X direction. A control pendant
10 is connected to the couch 2 via suitable cable for manual
control of the various portions of the radiation machine 1 and for
allowing automatic control of the radiation machine 1 by the
computer.
A generally C-shaped gantry 8 is rotatable by 359.degree. about a
horizontal axis 9. The gantry 8 is rotatably supported from a stand
11. A source of radiation, such as a linear accelerator producing a
high energy electron beam which is directed against an X-ray
target, produces a beam of X-rays emanating from a collimator head
portion 12. As an alternative, in the case of the cobalt machine,
the cobalt serves as a source of X-ray radiation, and is housed
within the collimator head portion 12. The X-rays are directed out
of the radiating head portion 12 in a beam having an axis 13 which
intersects the gantry axis of rotation 9 at a position identified
as the isocenter 14, which is also intersected by the turntable
axis 4.
The head portion 12 includes two sets of movable beam defining
jaws, as of lead, which are movable to define the length L and
thickness T of the field of the X-ray beam as collimated by the
beam defining jaws. The source 12 is enclosed in a barrel shaped
collimator housing 15. The source housing 15, along with beam
defining jaws, are rotatable about the beam axis 13. The gantry 8
includes a beam stopping portion 16 disposed along the X-ray beam
axis 13 and holding an X-ray absorbing material, such as lead, for
stopping and absorbing the X-ray beam.
A digital computer 18, such as a Varian Data Machine Model 620/i
general purpose digital computer, is coupled to the radiation
therapy machine 1 via the intermediary of a control cable 19 and an
interface 21. The computer 18 includes a core memory portion 22
interconnected to a central processor 23 which includes the address
and arithmetic units. Sixteen channels of analog-to-digital
converters 24 are provided for converting analog output signals
derived from the radiation therapy machine 1 to digital form which
are in turn fed into the central processor 23 for use therein and
for use in the memory 22. Eight channels of digital-to-analog
converters 25 are provided for converting digital output signals
from the central processor 23 into analog signals which in turn are
fed into the radiation therapy machine 1 via the intermediary of
the interface 21. Sensor and control lines 26 are provided for
sensing and controlling functions of the radiation therapy machine
via the interface 21. A machine console 27 is coupled to the
radiation therapy machine 1 and to the computer 18 via the machine
interface 21.
The Varian data machines 620/i computer 18 is a system oriented
digital computer. It has a total memory capacity of 12,388 words of
16 or 18 bits and is plug-in expandable. The memory is magnetic
core with 1.8 microseconds full cycle and 700 nanoseconds access
time. The arithmetic is parallel, binary, fixed points, 2's
complement. It has seven addressing modes and over one hundred
standard instructions. In addition, to the standard equipment which
comes with the Varian 620/i computer, the computer 18 includes, a
620/i expansion chassis, two 620/i memory modules providing an
extra 8,192 words, a 620/i-17 optional package, a 620/i-51 paper
tape reader, an acquisition and control unit, and the 620/i machine
interface 21.
The 620/i-17 optional package contains hardware multiply/divide,
extended addressing, real time clock, power fail/restart, and eight
level priority interrupts. The 620/i-51 accessory is a high speed
paper tape reader which provides for rapid means to load the memory
should a program be lost or scrambled for some reason. It is an
input device only and will not punch. It reads at 300 characters
per second. The acquisition and control unit contains the
following: 7 or 12 bits plus sign programmable sample-and-hold, 16
channels or multiplexed analog-to-digital conversion 24, and the
eight channels of 9 bit plus sign digital- to- analog converters 25
plus 16 sense and eight control lines 26. In addition, the
acquisition and control unit contains the BCD registers and
controller for the BCD information available from the radiation
machine 1.
A digital cassette tape unit 28, such as a model 100 COMPUCORDER
available from Datatronics, Inc. of Rochester, New York, is coupled
by suitable cables to the central processor 23 for reading digital
data, stored in the patient's individual cassette, into the central
processor 23 and memory 22. In addition, outputs from the processor
23 are recorded back into the patient's cassette via the tape unit
28. A cathode ray tube/keyboard terminal 29, such as a model ALPHA
103A CRT/keyboard terminal, commercially available from Beehive
Medical Electronics, Inc. of Salt Lake City, is coupled to the
central processor 23 via cable 31 for displaying data read from the
memory 22 through the central processor 23 and for controlling
certain operations of the radiation therapy machine 1 via the
computer 18.
The CRT terminal 29 forms the major input-output device for the
computer 18 and includes an alpha numeric display. It has a
standard typewriter keyboard and four way cursor control. In
addition, it has an 11 inch CRT screen with 20 lines and 40
characters per line. The CRT terminal 29 has type-over capability
using the cursor as well as line-erase and screen-clear. It has its
own internal character generator with 64 characters ASC II set. A
remote slave cathode ray tube (CRT) 32 is provided for remote data
observation. A standard ASR 33 teletype unit is coupled to the
central processor 23 via suitable cables to provide a hard copy
printout and to serve as a backup input for the CRT/keyboard
terminal 29 and for the paper tape reader accessory of the computer
18.
Referring now to FIG. 2 there is shown one of the circuits for
generating an analog positional signal determinative of the
position of one of the variable parameters of the radiation machine
1, such as: gantry angle G; housing angle, H; couch position in the
X, Y and Z directions, etc. The positional signal circuit of FIG. 2
includes a potentiometer 34, as of 10 k ohms, attached to the drive
shaft 35 via mechanical coupling 36. Drive shaft 34 generates the
motion of the parameter being controlled, such that a full-scale
motion of the parameter being varied or controlled results in
generating a full scale +10 volts to -10 volts analog output
derived from the pickoff 37 of the potentiometer 34. -15 volts and
+15 volts, respectively, are applied to opposite ends of the
potentiometer 34 through trimming potentiometers 38 and 39 provided
at the ends of the potentiometer 34. The trimming potentiometers 38
and 39 provide for calibration of the range and the end points for
each positional output readout. One turn 0.25 percent linearity,
0.095 percent resolution potentiometers 34 are utilized on the beam
collimator jaws, and position indicators. Ten turn 0.1 percent
linearity, 0.019 percent resolution potentiometers 34 are provided
for each of the other analog positional readouts.
Each of the motorized control motions of the radiation machine 1 is
driven by a shunt-wound dc motor 40 operated by an SCR controller
41. With exception of the gantry rotation controller, each
controller is open-loop providing full output in response to a
6-volt dc signal, decreasing to 0 output at 0.5 volts dc (.+-.0.5
dead band volts). The gantry speed control is closed loop, speed
regulated, full speed output in response to a 12-volt dc input,
against with .+-.0.5 dead band volts. The turntable drive is
equipped with a brake which is engaged when the input voltage of
the motor controller is zero. The couch longitudinal and lateral
motions have switch actuated electric clutches engaging their
respective drives.
Control of each motion of the radiation therapy machine 1 is
obtained by direct digital control. Positions of each of the eight
analog motions are sampled, by sampling the output of each
potentiometer 34, every 50 milliseconds, 10 microseconds required
for each sample. Sampling is controlled by the central processor 23
and is effected through the interface 21 to the positional control
circuits of FIG. 2 coupled to the drive 35 for each of the driven
elements of the radiation therapy machine 1. The driven motions are
sufficiently fast so as to alter their feedback from zero to full
scale in 15 seconds. Assuming a 12-bit plus sign analog-to-digital
converter output will vary a maximum of one least-significant bit
in 3.6 milliseconds, allowing observation of at most four
least-significant bit changes at every reading.
Each patient has in his file a digital tape cassette. For treatment
of a patient, his cassette is loaded into the tape unit 28 and a
command from the keyboard terminal 29 causes the tape to be read
into the central processor 23 and stored in the memory 22 of the
computer 18. The information transferred from the cassette to the
memory 22 of the computer 18 includes the patients identification
number, his name, the diagnosis of his condition, the portal
definition of eight separate radiation treatment portals, each
including an identification number 1-8 and a definition of the
quantities, G, S, X, Y, Z, H, L, T, and dose for each of the
defined portals, whether the individual treatment will involve arc
therapy, and if so the start and stop gantry angles G, and the rads
per degree, and information as to which, if any wedge is to be
employed and whether blocks are to be employed. Wedges serve to
shape the intensity of the radiation beam, and blocks serve to
protect certain portions of the patient being treated for radiation
emanating from the beam. In addition, information stored in the
memory 22 from the patient's cassette, includes a sequence of how
the portal definitions are to be administered, i.e., the treatment
plan, the monitored cumulative dose per portal, and the total
cumulative dose for the patient.
Once this information has been stored in the computer 18, the
keyboard terminal 29 is actuated for displaying desired information
from the memory 22 on the display of the keyboard terminal 29. On a
proper command from the keyboard terminal 29, the central processor
23 causes to be displayed, from the memory 22, on the cathode ray
tube display 29, the next treatment to be given. For example, a
certain radiation portal is defined on the visual alphanumeric CRT
display, with the prescribed set points for the quantities of
G,S,X,Y,Z,H,L,T, etc. Opposite the prescribed values for the
aforementioned quantities, which define the treatment to be given,
is displayed the corresponding present position of each of the
settings of the radiation therapy machine 1. Positional values are
obtained from the output of the positional circuits of the type
shown in FIG. 2 as converted to digital form via the
analog-to-digital converters 24 and as sent to the display tube of
the keyboard terminal 29, from the central processor 23. Upon
depressing the proper command button on the machine control pendant
10, the central processor 23 causes the actual positional signal to
be monitored and to be compared with the prescribed positional
signal to derive error signals which are fed to the controllers for
causing the radiation therapy machine 1 to take the positions
defined by the treatment plan being executed.
An anti-collision program is stored in the memory 22 and the
central processor, in conformance with the program, continually
checks for the possiblity of a collision between the gantry 8 and
the couch 2. If imminent collision is determined, an anti-collision
sub-routine is executed to avert the collision. The radiation
machine is positioned in accordance with the predetermined
prescribed plan. The geometric set points can be achieved in less
than 30 seconds because all of the geometric motions of the
radiation machine are obtained simultaneously.
As each of the geometric parameters achieves its set point, the set
point value is displayed on the cathode ray tube opposite the
corresponding prescribed value for the treatment plan being
executed. Thus, all the set point values for the quantities G, S,
X, Y, Z, H, L and T are achieved automatically and presented
automatically. The planned values for dose,time, rads per degree,
stop angle, wedge and blocks are displayed but these adjustments
are made manually from the machine console 27. Each of the manual
adjustments from the machine console 27 has a BCD positional output
signal generator of conventional design coupled thereto in the
conventional manner. As the manually adjustable parameters are set,
the corresponding positional value is fed into the computer 18 and
presented on the display adjacent the planned value. Each wedge and
block is separately coded with electrical connections and
electrical connections are made to these coded connections for
feeding an input signal to the computer 18 corresponding to the
particular wedge or block employed. Thus wedge and block
information is also fed to the computer and presented on the
display 29.
The computer 18 is programmed to compare the prescribed value for
all of the aforementioned geometric and other machine parameters
against the set point values achieved for each of the adjustable
parameters. If all of the prescribed values do not conform to the
set point values, the computer 18 generates an interlock output
signal which is fed via the machine interface 21 to actuate a relay
45 which opens a circuit in the machine console 27 and prevents
energization of the radiation "ON" button 46 in the machine console
27 such that the beam of radiation cannot be turned onto the
patient until all of the actual set points values for the variable
parameters of the radiation machine conform to the prescribed
values. This greatly reduces the probability of the operator making
a mistake and delivering a dose of radiation to the patient which
is not called for by the prescribed treatment plan. Tolerances in
the mechanical settings can be built into the system to compensate
for uncertainties in patient positioning on the treatment couch
2.
The radiation head portion 12 of the radiation therapy machine 1
includes a dosimeter 20 for monitoring the dose of radiation
actually administered to the patient. The output from the dosimeter
is continually monitored by the computer 18 throughout the
treatment. The measured radiation dose per treatment is stored in
the memory 22 of the computer and displayed on the CRT/terminal
display 29. In addition, the computer updates the patient treatment
plan status information stored in the memory 22 by updating the
portal status portion of the treatment plan to include the
cumulative total of radiation dose administered through the
particular portal just administered and the total dose administered
to the patient. The status information is also updated to include
which treatments in the sequence of treatments has been
administered and which numbered treatment is to be administered
next.
The treatment plan portion of the patient's treatment plan
information stored in the memory 22 is also updated by the computer
by entering a mark such as an asterisk under the number of the
portal definition just administered in the sequence of portal
numbers which defines the treatment plan sequence.
After the treatment is terminated an interlock signal goes to the
computer 18 from the radiation machine 1. This interlock signal
prevents the computer from performing any functions other than
printing out the updated portal definition information for the
portal just administered. The print out is on the teletype 33. The
print out includes the complete portal definition of prescribed and
present positions of the elements, etc., together with present
date, time, cumulative dose for this portal and the grand total of
dose administered to the patient.
After the print out, the operator types the command END at the
keyboard terminal which commands the computer 18 to readout all the
updated treatment plan information, portal definition information,
etc., relating to this patient from the memory 22 back into the
individual patient's tape cassette via the tape deck unit 28.
Any detail of the prescribed overall radiation treatment plan or
any one of the prescribed parameters of an individual portal
descriptions can be easily changed during the course of treatments.
The operator pushes an EDIT button on the CRT keyboard terminal 29
and types in the appropriate change at the keyboard. Two levels of
edit capability are incorporated. Certain major changes, such as
overall treatment plan, can only be initiated by supervisory
personnel with a special access key which serves to complete an
interlock circuit in an interface between the CRT/keyboard terminal
29 and the central processor 23. If the therapist desires periodic
examination before certain treatments can be administered to the
patient, he can require that some one of supervisory rank be
present at a given treatment by typing in an appropriate legend in
the overall treatment plan.
Any proposed new machine parameter for a change in a treatment plan
or portal definition is compared by the computer 18 against the
respective permissible ranges for that parameter stored in the
memory 22. If the proposed value of the parameter is within the
permissible range the change is entered and the treatment plan or
portal definition stored in the memory 22 is thus edited.
If the proposed change in parameter is not within the permissible
range of values, an error message is displayed on the CRT display
29 and the proposed parameter change is not entered.
The computer assisted radiation machine 1 also includes a simulator
mode of operation. In the simulator mode the radiation therapy
machine is manually controlled by the operator from the pendant 10
to position the geometric machine parameters for a certain
treatment to be administered. The final settings of the machine are
monitored by the respective positional output signals and define
portions of a complete portal definition. Upon a command the
operator causes the computer 18 to transfer the manually set
machine parameters into the memory 22 to establish a portal
definition in a treatment plan of information stored for that
patient in the memory 22. Subsequently this portal definition is
completed by the operator and becomes a part of the patient
treatment plan to be transferred to his cassette in the manner as
previously described above. A computer program flow chart the
aforedescribed computer program is shown in FIG. 3.
Since many changes could be made in the above construction and many
apparently widely different embodiments of this invention could be
made without departing from the scope thereof, it is intended that
all matter contained in the above description or shown in the
accompanying drawings shall be interpreted as illustrative and not
in a limiting sense.
RELATED CASES
The simultaneous motion and anti-collision program are described
and claimed in copending U.S. application Ser. No. 93,327 filed
Nov. 27, 1970, now U.S. Pat. No. 3,720,817. The feature of
verifying the prescribed treatment plan against the actual settings
of the radiation machine is disclosed and claimed in copending U.S.
application Ser. No. 93,332 filed Nov. 27, 1970, both applications
are assigned to the same assignee as the present invention.
* * * * *