U.S. patent number 3,734,169 [Application Number 05/221,316] was granted by the patent office on 1973-05-22 for spray refrigeration system for low temperature-sensitive product.
This patent grant is currently assigned to Union Carbide Corporation. Invention is credited to Henry Joseph Falk.
United States Patent |
3,734,169 |
Falk |
May 22, 1973 |
SPRAY REFRIGERATION SYSTEM FOR LOW TEMPERATURE-SENSITIVE
PRODUCT
Abstract
A system for spray refrigeration of low temperature-sensitive
products at optimized slightly above freezing temperature, but
avoiding freeze damage at sub-freezing ambient temperatures, by
introducing external heat in response to sensing of the ambient
temperature.
Inventors: |
Falk; Henry Joseph (Grand
Island, NY) |
Assignee: |
Union Carbide Corporation (New
York, NY)
|
Family
ID: |
22827297 |
Appl.
No.: |
05/221,316 |
Filed: |
January 27, 1972 |
Current U.S.
Class: |
165/257; 62/64;
99/470; 62/51.1; 62/243 |
Current CPC
Class: |
F25D
3/105 (20130101); F25D 2700/14 (20130101) |
Current International
Class: |
F25D
3/10 (20060101); F25b 029/00 () |
Field of
Search: |
;62/62,514
;165/28,30 |
References Cited
[Referenced By]
U.S. Patent Documents
Primary Examiner: Perlin; Meyer
Assistant Examiner: Capossela; Ronald C.
Claims
What is claimed is:
1. In a method for the intransit refrigeration of freeze-sensitive
products supported on a metal base in a thermally insulated
closeable storage chamber by over head spraying a cryogenic fluid
having a boiling point at atmospheric pressure below about
-20.degree. F. in response to gas temperature monitoring within the
storage chamber so as to maintain the storage chamber gas
temperature below a chamber temperature predetermined upper limit,
the improvement comprising: sensing the ambient temperature outside
said storage chamber and commencing the introduction of heat into
said storage chamber through said metal base in response to such
ambient temperature sensing when said ambient temperature is within
5.degree.F. of said chamber gas temperature upper limit and at
average density of 1-15 watts per square foot of metal base area
and at rate higher than the rate at which heat flows through the
chamber walls to the ambient air so as to maintain the chamber
inner wall at temperature not substantially colder than the sensed
chamber gas temperature, and transferring part of such heat to the
sprayed cryogenic fluid.
2. A method according to claim 1 wherein heat is introduced into
said storage chamber in at least two increments with the first heat
increment introduced when said ambient temperature is within
5.degree.F of said chamber gas temperature upper limit and a second
heat increment introduced when said ambient temperature is more
than 5.degree.F below said chamber temperature upper limit.
3. A method according to claim 1 wherein heat is introduced to said
storage chamber when the ambient temperature is slightly above the
chamber temperature upper limit.
4. A method according to claim 1 for the intransit refrigeration of
fresh meat, wherein the chamber temperature upper limit is
32.degree.F. and heat is introduced to said storage chamber when
the ambient temperature is below 30.degree. F.
5. A method according to claim 1 for the intransit refrigeration of
leaf vegetables, wherein the chamber temperature upper limit is
38.degree.F. and heat is introduced to said storage chamber when
the ambient temperature is below 33.degree.F.
6. A method according to claim 1 for the intransit refrigeration of
bananas, wherein the chamber temperature upper limit is
56.degree.F. and heat is introduced to said storage chamber when
the ambient temperature is below 54.degree.F.
7. Apparatus for the intransit refrigeration of freeze-sensitive
products comprising in combination:
a. a closeable storage chamber for said products surrounded by
thermal insulation sufficient to reduce heat transfer below 0.1
Btu/hr .times. ft.sup.2 .times. .degree. F.;
b. a thermally insulated container associated with the storage
chamber for storing pressurized liquefied gas having a boiling
point at atmospheric pressure below about -20.degree. F.;
c. spray conduit means positioned within the upper portion of said
storage chamber for discharging a multiplicity of discrete cold
fluid streams into the storage chamber;
d. liquefied gas flow control means comprising a gas temperature
sensing element positioned within said storage chamber, a fluid
discharge conduit between the liquefied gas container (b) and spray
conduit means (c), a flow control valve in said fluid discharge
conduit, and signal transmitting means from said gas temperature
sensing element to said control valve for controllably releasing
liquefied gas from said container through said spray conduit means
into said storage chamber when the sensed temperature is in a
predetermined range with a refrigeration release temperature upper
limit;
e. a metal base in the floor of said storage chamber extending
substantially the entire length and width thereof for supporting
the product;
f. a multiplicity of electrical resistance heating elements
positioned in spaced relationship beneath said metal base (e) in
heat transfer relation therewith each extending the entire length
of said metal base;
g. power source means for said electrical resistance heating
elements;
h. an ambient air temperature sensing element outside said storage
chamber and signal transmitting means from said element to said
power source for activating at least some of said electrical
resistance heating elements when said ambient air temperature drops
to within 5.degree.F. of said refrigeration release
temperature.
8. Apparatus according to claim 7 with a multiplicity of ambient
air temperature sensing elements, a multiplicity of ambient air
temperature sensing elements, a multiplicity of signal transmitting
means each joined to a different temperature sensing element and
arranged with electrical resistance heating elements such that a
first set of heating elements are activated when the sensed ambient
air drops to a first temperature and a second set of heating
elements are activated when the sensed ambient air drops to a
second temperature below said first temperature.
9. Apparatus according to claim 8 with three ambient air
temperature sensing elements and three set of heating elements
connected such that the first set of heating elements is activated
when the sensed ambient air drops to 30.degree.F., the second set
of heating elements is additionally activated when the ambient air
temperature drops to 15.degree.F., and the third set of heating
elements is still additionally activated when the ambient air
temperature drops to -5.degree.F.
10. Apparatus according to claim 7 wherein the electric power
source is three phase and the electrical resistance heating
elements are connected in a delta arrangement.
11. Apparatus according to claim 7 wherein the electric power
source is three phase, with a multiple of three electrical
resistance heating elements.
12. Apparatus according to claim 7 wherein said metal base is
supported above the inner wall of the storage chamber by a
multiplicity of transversely spaced metal members extending the
entire length of said chamber, and said electrical resistance
heating elements are located between some adjacent pairs of
longitudinal members in contiguous relation therewith.
13. Apparatus according to claim 12 wherein a multiplicity of
longitudinally aligned aluminum extrusions comprise said metal base
and transversely spaced metal members, each extrusion having an
upper panel section with adjacent panel edges longitudinally bonded
to each other, and also having longitudinally extending lower
sections of inverted T- cross-section and bottom end attached to
the inner wall of said storage chamber.
Description
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
This invention relates to a method of and apparatus for improved
intransit spray refrigeration of low temperature-sensitive
perishable foods such as fresh meat, leaf vegetables and bananas,
using cryogenic fluid.
In the low temperature shipment of fresh perishable food products,
temperature controls are usually set at points comfortably above
freezing, for example at 40.degree.F. An ample
margin-above-freezing allows for nonuniform temperatures throughout
all zones of the chamber storage space and takes into account
cyclic fluctuations of temperature below the set point (temperature
upper limit) provided by the refrigeration system controls. An
ample margin also provides a degree of protection against freeze
damage due to a reversal of heat flow direction, e.g., against loss
of heat through the walls of the storage chamber in the event the
ambient air temperature drops below the freezing point of the
perishable product.
The ability to control temperature of freeze-sensitive products
dependably at or near 40.degree.F. is a relatively recent
accomplishment and represents a vast improvement over earlier
practice which often permitted temperature excursions to much
warmer levels with consequent loss of valuable products. The closer
control of shipping temperatures at near 40.degree.F. is an
achievement of systems which spray liquefied gas refrigeration
directly into the cold product storage chamber. The direct
admission of a refrigerant such as liquid nitrogen into the chamber
is controlled in response to thermostatic devices sensitive to the
chamber temperature as disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 3,287,935 to J.
J. Kane et al. The use of atmosphere-circulating fans in the
chamber, and the use of indirect refrigeration applied to the
chamber floor are additional improvements aimed at achieving
uniform distribution of refrigeration and more uniform temperature
throughout the space within the chamber. A further important
advance achieved by the direct spray refrigeration, liquefied gas
systems is the fast recovery of low temperatures following
operation (opening and closing) of the chamber doors. The loss of
refrigeration which occurs when the chamber doors are opened can be
minimized and localized by the use of load dividing partitions to
suppress convection.
Despite the foregoing advances, the use of control settings
significantly below 35.degree.-40.degree.F. for low
temperature-sensitive products has not been found practical for
year-round commercial operation. The exposure of trucks and
trailers to severe winter conditions often reduces chamber
temperatures well below levels imposed by the on-board
refrigeration system and therefore introduces the risk of
freeze-damage and loss of product. It should be understood that the
temperature level maintained during shipment is heavily influenced
by the level to which products are prechilled before shipment. In
effect, the product acts as a huge thermal ballast. Despite this
ballast effect, exposure of the chamber to severe winter conditions
can extract sufficient heat through the chamber walls to reduce the
temperature of portions of the contents adjacent the inner walls
several degrees below the prechilled level. Such occurrences
persist even though thermal insulations for trucks and trailers
have been improved significantly in recent years. Therefore, a
trailer loaded with prechilled product in a warm region for
shipment to markets in a cold region must be maintained during
shipment at a temperature level reflecting ample
margin-of-protection against freeze damage.
Heating devices are sometimes used on-board trucks and trailers to
prevent freeze-damage of product. The heaters are high-capacity
systems and thermostatically controlled by chamber temperature such
that they operate cyclically or intermittently. The refrigeration
system is also high capacity, at least with respect to
refrigeration requirements prevailing when ambient temperature is
near freezing. It is evident that if the two, opposed high-capacity
systems become operative simultaneously, then the refrigeration and
heat would be expended one against the other in a wasteful manner.
The rate of introduction of refrigeration and heat would bear no
relationship to the heat leakage between the storage space and its
environment. If refrigeration were supplied by liquefied gas and
heat were supplied by a combustible fuel, then the on-board
supplies of both refrigerant and fuel would be quickly and
needlessly consumed. For this reason, it has been usual practice to
set the heater control to be activated at a temperature well below
that of the refrigeration system so that no overlap of their
operative temperature ranges could occur. The temperature span
between the set points of the two systems being necessarily
substantial, the combined systems are therefore incapable of
maintaining close temperature control of the storage space.
More specifically, according to the prior art the operative
temperature range of each system (heating and cooling) is usually
fixed by an associated thermostatic device each responsive to
chamber temperature and amounts to at least several (e.g., 2-3)
degrees. Thus, the refrigeration system may be activated at, say
42.degree.F. and deactivated at 39.degree.F. The heater system may
be activated at 32.degree.F. and deactivated at 35.degree.F.,
thereby leaving 4.degree.F. margin (35.degree. to 39.degree.F.)
separating the operating ranges of the two systems. Therefore, the
combined systems permit a temperature variation in the storage
chamber from 32.degree. to 42.degree.F., or 10.degree.F.
change.
Another shortcoming of prior art heating systems for spray
refrigerated trailers is their slow response time. When the heater
is controlled by storage chamber temperature, then the entire
trailer wall structure must first become deeply chilled before the
heater is activated. The system must now introduce heat at a high
rate sufficient not only to counterbalance the continuing loss of
heat through the walls but also to re-warm the walls several
degrees to a temperature level to which the produce can remain
safely exposed. It is evident that the heater must possess a high
capacity in order to temperature-cycle the mass of the walls. It is
also evident that the introduction of large doses of heat poses a
heat distribution problem and increases the risk of local
overheating of product near the zone of heat introduction.
Still another disadvantage of prior art combustion heaters is that
they usually employ the product chamber atmosphere as their oxygen
source. After extended operation the oxygen of the product
atmosphere may be consumed down to the combustion limit and the
combustion reaction will be extinguished. This situation is
particularly acute when an inert liquefied gas refrigerant system
is employed such as liquid nitrogen; simultaneous operation of such
heating and refrigeration systems is essentIally impossible. It has
been normal practice to manually deactivate the liquefied gas
refrigeration system before manually activating a combustion heater
systems.
An object of this invention is to provide an improved method of and
apparatus for spray refrigeration of freeze sensitive product.
Another object is to provide such method and apparatus in which the
product is maintained at significantly closer to optimum
temperature than heretofore possible and yet without freeze
damage.
Still another object is to provide such method and apparatus that
avoids local overheating and damage of perishable product.
Other objects and advantages of this invention will be apparent
from the ensuing disclosure and appended claims.
SUMMARY
In the method aspect of this invention, temperature-sensitive
product is supported on a metal base in a thermally insulated
closeable storage chamber and refrigerated by overhead spraying a
cryogenic fluid having a boiling point at atmospheric pressure
below about -20.degree.F. in response to gas temperature monitoring
within the storage chamber so as to maintain the storage chamber
gas temperature below a predetermined upper limit. In the practice
of this invention, the actual upper limit is determined on the
basis of the product to be stored, and is preferably about
32.degree.F. for fresh meat, about 38.degree.F. for leaf vegetables
such as lettuce and about 56.degree.F. for bananas.
In this method, the ambient temperature outside the storage chamber
is sensed and heat introduction is commenced to the storage chamber
through the metal base in responSe to such ambient temperature
sensing when the ambient temperature drops to within 5.degree.F. of
the chamber gas temperature upper limit. Moreover, the heat is
introduced at average density of 1-15 watts per square foot of
metal base area -- a very low rate as compared to prior art heating
systems for intransit refrigeration of freeze-sensitive products.
The heat is however introduced at rate higher than the rate at
which heat flows through the chamber walls to the ambient air so as
to maintain the chamber inner wall at temperature not substantially
colder than the sensed chamber gas temperature. Part of this heat
is transferred to the sprayed cryogenic fluid. The heat input
average density should be at least 1 watt per square foot of metal
base area to achieve the desired temperature control in the storage
chamber, and less than 15 watts to avoid product loss due to
excessive warming and inordinate consumption of refrigeration. In a
preferred embodiment, heat is introduced into the storage chamber
in at least two increments with the first increment introduced when
the ambient temperature is within 5.degree.F. of said chamber gas
temperature upper limit and a second heat increment is introduced
when the ambient temperature is more than 5.degree.F. below the
chamber temperature upper limit.
In the apparatus aspect of the invention, a closeable storage
chamber for the products is surrounded by thermal insulation
sufficient to reduce heat transfer below 0.1 Btu/hr .times.
ft.sup.2 .times. .degree.F., and a thermally insulated container is
associated with the storage chamber for storing pressurized
liquefied gas having a boiling point at atmospheric pressure below
about -20.degree.F., as for example pure nitrogen or nitrogen mixed
with oxygen. Spray conduit means are positioned within the upper
portion of the storage chamber for discharging a multiplicity of
discrete cold fluid streams into the storage chamber to refrigerate
the product. Liquefied gas flow control means comprise a gas
temperature sensing element positioned within the storage chamber,
a fluid discharge conduit between the liquefied gas container and
the spray conduit means, a flow control valve in the fluid
discharge conduit, and signal transmitting means from the gas
temperature sensing element to the control valve for controllably
releasing liquefied gas from the container through the spray
conduit means into the storage chamber when the sensed temperature
is in a predetermined temperature range having a refrigeration
release temperature upper limit.
The apparatus also includes a metal base in the floor of the
storage chamber extending substantially the entire length and width
thereof for supporting the product. A multiplicity of electrical
resistance heating elements are positioned in spaced relationship
beneath the metal base in heat transfer relation therewith, each
extending substantially the entire length of the metal base. Power
source means are provided for the electrical resistance heating
elements. An ambient air temperature sensing element is positioned
outside the storage chamber, and signal transmitting means join the
element and the power source for activating at least some of the
electrical resistance heating elements when the ambient air
temperature drops to within .+-. 5.degree.F. of the refrigeration
release temperature upper limit.
It should be understood that the activation temperature of the
electrical resistance heating elements is based on the particular
requirements of the perishable products to be refrigerated, and may
be above or below the refrigeration release temperature upper
limit, but in any event within 5.degree.F. of same. The temperature
difference must be small in order to minimized the temperature
variation in the storage chamber and closely approximate the
optimum refrigeration temperature for product to be transported.
For example, if fresh beef is to be shipped the storage chamber
temperature must in any event be kept above 27.degree.F., the beef
freezing point. A preferred refrigeration release temperature upper
limit for the refrigerant spray into the storage chamber is
31.degree.F., and the heating element activation temperature is
preferably above this temperature but not more than 36.degree.F.
and preferably about 32.degree.F. This means that a "thermal
overlap" occurs, i.e. heat introduction is commenced when the
ambient air is still slightly warmer than the refrigeration release
temperature control setting, and this heat is absorbed by the
sprayed refrigerant. However, the thermal overlap usually exists
for a short time period. The "extra" refrigerant consumed during
this period is a minor consideration compared to the improved
quality of the beef at destination, relative to the prior art
shipment at warmer, less precise temperature level controls. A few
degrees of thermal overlap helps to insure positive, close control
of chamber temperature with a low rate of heat addition, because it
permits the heater control to anticipate a drop in ambient
temperature to a level below the refrigeration release temperature
control setting. By commencing heat addition slightly in advance of
an actual need for heat, a "control lag" is avoided because the
metal base will be prewarmed in ample time to prevent an
uncontrolled decline in chamber temperature.
As another example, fresh lettuce begins to freeze at about
31.7.degree.F. and a preferred refrigeration release temperature
upper limit is 38.degree.F. Experience has shown that storage below
this limit but above freezing results in best quality and long
shelf life of the delivered product. In this system it is preferred
to fix the heating element activation temperature at a lower level
for conservation of refrigeration, e.g. 33.degree.F. This heater
activation temperature permits a relatively wide margin between the
product freezing temperature and the upper limit for storage of
such product according to the present invention, e.g. 38.degree.F.
In contrast to the fresh beef product embodiment, there may be no
thermal overlap because the heating element is only activated when
the ambient air temperature drops several degrees below the
refrigeration release temperature upper limit. It should be
understood that although 38.degree.F. is the preferred upper limit
for practicing this invention for leafy vegetables the
refrigeration release control may be set at a temperature lower
than 38.degree.F. at the discretion of the operator, provided that
the on-off range of the control does not extend down to the
freezing point of the product. The refrigeration system of this
invention is a high rate system capable of overriding the warming
effect of the heater system; hence the heater system cannot protect
the product if the refrigeration system should operate down to an
excessively low temperature.
As a further illustration, bananas are preferably maintained at a
significantly higher temperature so that if the refrigeration
release temperature upper limit is 56.degree.F. an appropriate
heating element activation temperature is 54.degree.F. Thermal
overlap is preferred for close control but is not essential.
An especially important aspect of the invention is that the heating
is controlled in response to ambient temperature rather than to the
temperature of the product storage chamber. If the inside
temperature were used for heater control, the chamber thermal
insulation would necessarily become deeply chilled before
activating the heaters. Under these circumstances the heaters would
require sufficient heating capacity to not only replenish heat as
rapidly as it escapes through the chamber outer walls but also to
rewarm the chamber inner walls and the thermal insulation
contiguous thereto. The resultant large dosage of heat would
necessarily be quickly and uniformly distributed to avoid warming
the product above the desired level. Even more importantly, it
would be necessary to terminate the rapid and massive heat
introduction at a temperature below the operating range of the
spray refrigeration system, else such heat would drastically
increase the rate of refrigerant consumption. Because the warming
range of a high-capacity heater and the cooling range of the spray
refrigeration system could not overlap but must be spaced apart in
actual practice, the gross range of temperature control would be
too wide for optimum quality and shelf life of many perishable
products.
The heater system of this invention senses ambient air temperature
and in effect anticipates an increase in temperature difference
across the walls of the thermally insulated product storage chamber
which would be sufficient to chill the inner wall and insulation to
an undesirably low temperature. The heater than adds heat at only a
slow rate of 1-15 watts per square foot of metal base area --
needed to sustain the inner wall temperature despite a higher
temperature gradient across the wall. The chamber inner walls are
maintained at temperature not substantially colder than the sensed
chamber gas temperature as fixed by the spray refrigeration system,
and the need for a massive influx of heat to rewarm the walls is
eliminated.
As previously indicated, the heat is introduced at rate higher than
the rate at which heat flows through the chamber walls to the
ambient air, with part of the heat absorbed by the sprayed
cryogenic fluid. Moreover, the chamber floor assembly has
substantial heat storage capacity and continues to dissipate heat
to the chamber environment even after the heating may have been
terminated by a rise in ambient temperatures. Most of this stored
heat is also transferred to the refrigerant. The heat may be
transferred by solid conduction through the metal base and by
convection to gas circulating to the chamber. For example, lettuce
may be refrigerated in the system with a chamber gas temperature
upper limit of 38.degree.F. and a heater activation temperature of
33.degree.F. If during storage the ambient air drops to
33.degree.F. the heaters are activated and the heater floor
assembly is warmed and causes continued cycling of the
refrigeration system. Even through the ambient air rises above
perhaps 36.degree.F. so that the heaters are deactivated, the floor
assembly will have absorbed sufficient heat to warm the chamber gas
to 38.degree.F., thereby activating the cryogenic spray
refrigeration system. This relationship exists because of the small
5.degree.F. temperature span between the refrigeration release
temperature upper limit and the heater activation temperature,
which is necessary to maintain the product within the desired close
temperature limits only slightly above the low temperature product
damage point.
One important advance of this invention is the type of ambient air
temperature sensing element employed. Since the inner wall
temperature is fixed and held constant by the spray refrigeration
system, it is not necessary to sense the temperature difference
between the product chamber and the ambient air. This is fortunate
because temperature difference sensors and controllers are
expensive and not sufficiently rugged and durable for truck and
trailer service. The heater control of this invention may be a
simple, rugged ambient temperature sensor as for example a
fluid-filled bulb or bimetallic actnator.
Another advantage of the invention is that the use of a
low-capacity low-density heating system prevents damage to
heat-sensitive materials in the immediate vicinity of the heaters.
As will be described below in greater detail, the electric heaters
are preferably positioned within closed longitudinal channels
beneath the metal base. If heat was rapidly introduced per unit
metal base area the temperature within the channels could readily
rise to levels which damage both thermal and electrical insulation
adjacent to one associated with the heater elements.
Fresh beef may be shipped without freeze damage in the system of
this invention using a storage chamber nitrogen spray refrigeration
release temperature upper limit of 31.degree.F. when the ambient
air is subfreezing. This temperature closely approximates the
optimum for storage of fresh beef, and represents a substantial
improvement over the 40.degree.F. upper limit of prior art
intransit spray refrigeration systems.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
FIG. 1 is a schematic cross-sectional view taken in elevation, of a
tractor-trailer assembly incorporating one embodiment of the
invention.
FIG. 2 is a schematic flowsheet showing the fluid and electric
interconnections of a refrigerant spray-electric heating system
suitable for use in the FIG. 1 assembly.
FIG. 3 shows the three-phase delta electric circuit preferred for
the activation of the electric resistance heating elements.
FIG. 4 is a cross-section transverse view taken in elevation on an
enlarged scale, of part of a preferred floor assembly of a product
storage chamber.
FIG. 5 is an isometric view looking downwardly on an aluminum
extrusion with a positioned electric resistance heating element
suitable for fabrication of the FIG. 4 floor assembly, and
FIG. 6 is a schematic flowsheet of the fluid and electric
interconnections for deactivation of the electric heating system in
the event of an inoperative refrigerant spray system.
DESCRIPTION OF PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
Referring now to the drawings, FIG. 1 shows trailer 11 attached to
tractor 12 and supporting perishable product storage chamber 13
composed of multiple compartments 13a, 13b, 13c and 13d. These
compartments are separated from each other by transverse load
dividing partitions 14a-b, 14b-c and 14c-d which are retractable as
for example by rolling up to the ceiling. Each compartment may be
provided with a separate refrigeration system independently
controlled by the temperature within the specific compartment. It
should be recognized however that the transverse partitions and the
separate refrigeration systems are not essential to the practice of
the invention; only one compartment and one refrigeration system is
needed.
Product chamber 13 may be constructed with an outer casing 15 of
material such as corrugated steel or aluminum, rear doors 15a and
metal heat conductive base 16. Inner walls 17 may be formed of
sheet metal fiber reinforced plastic or plyboard, and thermal
insulation 18 between outer casing 15 and inner wall 17 is a
suitable low thermal conductive material such as foamed plastic or
glass fiber.
As previously indicated, the thermal insulation 18 should be
sufficient to reduce heat transfer below 0.1 Btu/hr .times.
ft.sup.2 .times. .degree.F. For example, about 3 inches of
polyurethane insulation of 0.0195 Btu/hr .times. ft.sup.2 .times.
.degree.F/ft avg. thermal conductivity is suitable for a
temperature difference, ambient to chamber, of 80.degree.F. or
lower. It will be recognized by one skilled in the art that the
aforementioned heat transfer upper limit may be achieved by
employing a relatively thin layer of highly efficient insulation or
a relatively thick layer of less efficient (and less costly)
thermal insulation. Thermal insulation effectiveness is an
important aspect of this invention because it directly affects the
heating requirements to obtain the aforestated objects. If the
thermal insulation were 100 percent effective, heating would not be
required and on the other hand if the insulation were extremely
inefficient the spray refrigeration system would not perform its
function at warm ambient and the heating requirements would be
prohibitively high at low ambient temperature. The thermal
insulation effectiveness of below 0.1 Btu/hr .times. ft.sup.2
.times. .degree.F. represents an appropriate balance between these
considerations and facilitates the improved performance of the
present system as compared to prior art spray refrigeration
systems.
The refrigeration system includes one or more liquefied gas
containers 19, control boxes 20 and 21 mounted on the storage
chamber 13 at convenient locations, and overhead spray conduit
means 22, for example a multiple orifice nozzle. At least one such
spray conduit 22a, 22b, 22c and 22d is provided in the upper
portion of each respective compartment 13a, 13b, 13c and 13d. These
spray conduits are operated in response to associated gas
temperature sensing elements 23a, 23b, 23c and 23d in the
compartments.
The heating system includes a multiplicity of electrical resistance
elements 24 mounted beneath the metal base 16 in heat transfer
relation therewith and preferably extending substantially the
length of the base. Electric generator 25 in the tractor 12 is
joined to elements 24 by electrical supply conductors 26
terminating in receptacle 27 mounted on the front of chamber 13.
Preferably an alternative power source (not illustrated) is
provided for use when the trailer 11 is not adjacent tractor 12, as
for example at the loading dock, and second receptacle 28 is
attached to the rear of product chamber 13 for connection to a
dockside electrical supply system. It will be understood that FIG.
1 merely shows the layout of the major components of the system;
interconnections are illustrated in the ensuing figures.
Referring now to FIG. 2, the interconnection of the refrigerant
spray and electric heating components and their function is
illustrated and will be described in detail. The liquefied gas
container 19 is filled from a suitable source of such refrigerant
through connection 20 and preferably sealed at saturated condition
and at temperatures corresponding to a vapor pressure above 10
psig. with the entire liquid and vapor substantially in
equilibrium, e.g. 20 psig. and -298 .degree.F for a 84 percent
N.sub.2 - 16 % O.sub.2 by volume mixture. Under these conditions,
the vapor pressure is sufficient to dispense the entire contents of
the container 19 without external heat. Alternatively the cryogenic
liquid may be stored in container 19 under non-saturated
conditions, i.e. in the subcooled state. Under these conditions, it
would be normal practice to provide means for building sufficient
internal pressure on demand to discharge the liquid. Those skilled
in the art will appreciate that this heat may be introduced
externally, using the well-known pressure building coil. The latter
includes a liquid discharge conduit, an atmospheric heat vaporizer
and a conduit for returning the resulting vapor to the container
gas space (not illustrated).
When refrigeration is demanded in any given compartment of the
storage chamber 13, liquid is withdrawn from container 19 through
discharge manifold 29 and thereafter through the appropriate branch
conduit, e.g. 30a communicating with compartment 13a. The function
and operation of each refrigeration supply system for compartments
13a, 13b, 13c and 13d is essentially identical and in the interest
of simplicity only one such system will be described. Assuming that
the temperature in storage compartment 13a rises to the
predetermined refrigeration release temperature as sensed by
element 23a, e.g. a fluid filled bulb, an electrical or pneumatic
signal representative of such condition is transmitted through
conductor 31a to pneumatic relay 32a. The latter receives gas at
the pressure of container 19 through an instrument supply system
including vaporizer 33 in an instrument supply conduit 34, and
branch conduit 35a. The refrigeration deficient signal through
conductor 31a causes relay 32a to release instrument gas pressure
from instrument supply branch conduit 35a into instrument gas
control conduit 36a connected to pneumatically controlled valve 37a
in refrigeration supply branch conduit 30a. This opens valve 37a
and allows refrigerant to flow through conduit 30a and spray header
22a for example mounted on the ceiling of refrigerant-deficient
compartment 13a.
Pure liquid nitrogen is a suitable refrigerant for use with many
perishable products. If one compartment of chamber 13 is to be
entered while another is maintained under automatic control of its
refrigerant system as heretofore described, then the preferred
refrigerant is a mixture of oxygen and liquid nitrogen of such
composition as to produce a breathable atmosphere in the
refrigerated compartment. In the latter case the oxygen content of
the liquid is preferably at least 15 percent by volume but not in
excess of about 18 percent. In general, liquid refrigerant of
higher oxygen concentration within the foregoing range will require
more effective thermal insulation systems for refrigerant storage
container 19 in order to avoid oxygen enrichment of the stored
refrigerant to level substantially higher than 21 percent. The use
of oxygen-nitrogen mixtures as the refrigerant is further
contingent upon compatability of such mixtures with the product
which is stored in the compartment. Whereas the preservation of
some products such as fresh beef is enhanced by relatively high
oxygen atmospheres as for example 12 percent oxygen by volume,
other products such as leafy vegetables are best stored in an
atmosphere produced with a pure nitrogen refrigerant. Regardless of
the refrigerant employed, the refrigeration system for a product
storage compartment should be deactivated before the compartment is
entered. This can be accomplished by closing the instrument gas
supply valve 34a in conduit 35a.
As previously indicated, the heating system includes a multiplicity
of electrical resistance heating elements positioned in heat
transfer relation with the metal base 16 of the product storage
chamber. As illustrated in FIG. 2, the electrical supply for the
heaters is three-phase power supplied from the tractor generator 25
or from a dockside electrical system through one of the receptacles
27 and 28. The heaters are connected in a delta arrangement. For
purposes of illustration only one resistance element and one switch
is shown per phase but in actual practice each phase may contain a
plurality of resistance elements and each switch may contain three
contacts permitting one or more elements to be energized
simultaneously in each phase of the circuit. In such an
arrangement, operation of any switch will maintain a balanced load
on the three-phase power supply. A preferred multiple resistance
arrangement for the heaters will be described hereinafter in
connection with FIG. 3, but for purposes of understanding FIG. 2 it
is sufficient to recognize that the heaters are arranged in three
separate sets with the heaters of a particular set being equally
distributed among the three phases. Each set of heaters is
controlled by a separate thermostatic switch 38a, 38 b or 38c.
Whereas the switches are illustrated as single-pole devices, it
should be understood that each is a three-phase switch so that each
switch comprises three independent contacts, one for each phase of
the circuit. Each of the switches is independently actuated by an
ambient air temperature sensing element 40a, 40 b or 40c outside
the storage chamber. The actuation system comprises relays 41a, 41b
and 41c joined to ambient air temperature sensing bulbs 40a, 40b
and 40 c respectively by signal receiving means 42a, 42b and 42c,
and joined to switches 38a, 38b and 38c respectively by switch
actuating means 43a, 43b and 43c.
Each of switches 38a, 38b and 38c is preset to close at a different
minimum temperature sensed by its corresponding element, e.g. fluid
filled bulbs or bimetal switch actuators 40a, 40b or 40c exposed to
ambient temperature. For example, switch 38a may be set to close
when the ambient air temperature drops to a first level of
30.degree.F. Electric power will be thereby supplied to activate a
first set of resistance heaters 44 in the chamber floor. Switch 38b
is set to close when the temperature sensed by bulb 40b falls to a
second lower level as for example 15.degree.F. and the power is
furnished to a second set of heaters 45. Similarly, switch 38c
close when the temperature sensed by bulb 40c falls to a third
level below the second temperature for example -5.degree.F. thereby
supply power to a third set of heaters 46 in the trailer floor.
This stepwise control of heater addition to the storage chamber 13
achieves maximum simplicity in the instrumentation and electrical
components, yet introduces heat incrementally in accordance with
the temperature difference prevailing between the product storage
space and the colder ambient atmosphere. The operation of the
heaters is continuous once the power supply switch in a given
circuit has been closed In other words, operation is not modulated
or cycled in response to the temperature variations within the
trailer.
Since each switch remains closed at all temperatures below its
operating point, it is evident that a set of resistance elements
which is activated at a relatively high temperature level will
remain in operation when a set is activated at a lower temperature
level. Thus, the total heat supply by the heater system will be the
sum of the heater ratings of all heater sets which have been
activated at and above the prevailing temperature. For example, at
14.degree.F. in the aforementioned illustration, both the heater
sets 44 and 45 controlled by switches 40a and 40b will be
operative.
The precise number of heaters and their individual wattage is
subject to choice. It is preferred that no fewer than three heaters
be in operation together in order that the heat input will be
reasonably well-distributed over the chamber metal base. When
three-phase power is used, the number of heaters should preferably
also be a multiple of three so that the heating load can be
balanced. The total wattage supplied by the heating system will be
dependent upon the severity of winter conditions to be encountered,
upon the effectiveness of the storage chamber insulation system,
and upon the margin between the temperature level maintained by the
refrigeration system and the minimum permissible level which avoids
damage to the product. The total heat load to be provided in a
conventionally-sized trailer about 45 feet long, 8 feet wide and 8
feet high may be on the order of 3,000 watts with all sets of
resistance elements in operation. A suitable arrangement of heaters
for such a trailer may comprise three elements in set 44 and six
elements each in sets 45 and 45. Thus, the fifteen elements may
each be rated at 200 watts. If the elements extend substantially
the full length of a 45 foot long trailer, then heater elements
providing 5 watts per foot of element length are suitable. Such
elements of each set are spaced at equal distances in the
transverse direction across the chamber metal base, e.g. the three
elements of set 44 may be for example at about 30 inch intervals
and the five elements of sets 45 and 46 are each at approximately
17 1/2 inch intervals.
The preferred method for connecting the heater elements in the
three-phase, delta scheme is shown in FIG. 3. The first set 44 of
heaters consists of three resistance elements 44, 44b and 44c, one
of which is connected in each phase of the delta circuit. It is
also seen that each element 44a, 44b and 44c is connected
respectively in series with one of contacts 48a, 48b and 48c, all
contained in switch 38a of FIG. 2.
The second set 45 of resistance elements consists of six elements
45a- f, two of which are provided in each phase of the delta
connection in a similar manner to first set 44. Two heater elements
in each phase are wired in parallel and are connected in series
with one of contacts 49a, 49b, and 49c contained in switch 38b. The
third set 46 of heaters also consists of six resistance elements
46a-f which are interconnected into the delta circuit in the same
manner as second set 45. Resistance elements 46a-f are paired, one
pair to each phase, and are controlled by contacts 50a, 50 b and
50c in switch 38c. By distributing the resistance elements
comprising a set equally among the three phases of the power
supply, the load on the supply will be balanced at all times.
The first set 44 of heaters which are controlled by switch 38a are
placed in operation at the warmest temperature level sensed by
elements 40a, 40 b and 40c. Because the temperature difference
across the storage chamber walls has the least value when first
heater set 44 is activated, loss of heat from the storage chamber
which must be overcome by these heaters is at a comparatively slow
rate. For this reason, only three heater elements are provided in
first set 44. In the other heater sets 45 and 46 which are
activated at substantially lower ambient temperatures, the heat
loss which they must replace is relatively greater and six elements
are provided in each of these sets.
The product 59a is supported on or in low conductive members as for
example wood pallets 59b, which in turn are positioned on the upper
surface of metal base 16. Alternatively and if a convenient form as
for example beef quarters, the product 59a may be suspended in the
chamber gas space. In any event the product should not be placed
directly against heat conductive metal base 16 so as to avoid
excessive warming of the bottom layer. Heat introduced to the
chamber by the electrical resistance elements is transferred to gas
continuously circulating in contact with metal base 16 and the
warmed gas transfers the heat to the product by contact therewith.
The chamber gas flow may be natural circulation supplemented by the
refrigeration spray pressure driving force (when the refrigeration
system is operating), or a fan may be positioned at the upper end
of the chamber, e.g. the front of the FIG. 1 trailer-chamber, to
insure the desired flow pattern.
FIG. 4 illustrates a preferred floor assembly supported on
transverse beams 52 which are attached to the frame or chassis of
the trailer 11 and are usually steel structural members. Outer
casing 15 of the product storage chamber 13 rests on these beams
with spaced inner wall 17 and a suitable thermal insulating
material 18 therebetween. Metal heat conductive base 16 is
positioned on inner wall 17 and comprises a multiplicity of panel
elements 53, 54 and 55 which for example may be produced a aluminum
extrusions extending the entire length of the trailer and welded to
each other as at 56. The extrusion includes longitudinal inverted
T- sections 57 having lower ends attached to the bottom side of
metal base 16 to achieve maximum strength and rigidity with minimum
weight and utilization of material. Adjacent inverted T- sections
57 form open channels 58 extending the entire length of the metal
base 16, and the electrical resistance heater elements 24 are
preferably positioned within such channels. By way of example and
using 15 elements as previously described, 54 channels may be
provided in the floor assembly and elements 24 may be transversely
spaced between every fourth pair of adjacent channels as
illustrated, thereby providing uniform distribution of heating
elements over the area of the metal base. The fifteen electrical
resistance elements may also be grouped electrically as illustrated
in FIG. 2 with three elements in first set 44, six elements in
second set 45 and six elements in third set 46.
FIG. 5 illustrates the assembly of an electrical resistance heater
package which may comprise the unit 24 placed between adjacent
longitudinal channels as described in connection with fIG. 4.
Aluminum extrusion 59 is slightly narrower than the space between
the webs of the FIG. 4 T- sections 57 and upwardly bent thin flange
members 60 are an integral part of the extrusion 59. Heater strip
61 comprises a plastic sheet with metal wire embedded therein and
leads 62 extending from opposite ends. Strip 61 is installed within
extrusion 59 underneath flange members 60, after which the latter
are bent downward (as shown by arrows and broken line) to hold the
heater strip 61 intact within the channel and to protect the strip
against mechanical damage. After assembly the extrusion is inserted
within an appropriate channel and the leads 62 are connected into
the circuit as for example illustrated in FIG. 3. The heater strip
is of any suitable form available in a low heat rating per unit
length, preferably in the range of 1-15 watts per foot length. For
example, in the FIG. 3 embodiment constantan wire embedded in a
fiber-reinforced silicone plastic sheet was used and provides an
average rating of 5 watts per foot length.
While three-phase power has been described in detail, it will be
understood that single-phase current could be employed. A single
feeder wire would be provided and would supply several branch
circuits, one circuit for each set of electrical resistance
elements installed in the chamber floor. Each branch circuit would
be controlled by one of the thermostatic switches 38a-c shown in
FIG. 2. Similarly, the voltage of the power supply is subject to
choice, it being necessary to choose the heaters to suit the
voltage. For example, 120 volts D.C. would be suitable. One
advantage of a three-phase, 220-volt supply is that line protective
devices (breakers or fuses) have low amperage ratings and are
readily available at low cost.
Another modification of the invention is shown in FIG. 6 which
duplicates in part the components of FIG. 2 -- a full
representation of all components being unnecessary to an
understanding of the modification. In FIG. 6, a fluid pressure
conductor 63 is branched from the control instrument fluid supply
conduit 34 downstream of valve 64 and upstream of the manifold 65
serving the individual relays, e.g. 35a. The fluid pressure
conductor 63 leads to relay 66 joined by actuator means 67 to
electrical switch 68 located in the electrical feeder wire 69a to
the heater circuits. Relay 66 is set to open switch 68 in the event
the pressure of the instrument control fluid from the refrigeration
system drops to an intolerably low level. In such event, the
effectiveness of the refrigeration system would be impaired or lost
and the heater system would be deactivated to prevent continued
warming of the product. Loss of pressure of the control fluid could
be due to inadvertent closure of, or failure to open valve 64.
Alternatively, it could signal a loss of pressure in refrigerant
storage container 19, due to inadvertent venting of vapor
therefrom, or to failure of an associated pressure-building system,
or to depletion of refrigerant. If desired, an additional set of
contacts in relay 66 can be furnished to actuate an audible or
visual warning device to alert a person in attendance.
A series of tests using an externally heated nitrogen spray
refrigeration system similar to that previously described and
illustrated in FIGS. 1, 2, 4 and 5 demonstrated the remarkably
close-to-optimum temperature achievable by this invention. The
floor was formed of extruded aluminum sections about 1.25 inch
wide. The spray refrigeration control components were set for a
34.degree.F. chamber gas temperature upper limit, and all
electrical resistance heating elements were activated to furnish
3,000 watts at an average heat density of about 8.3 watts per
square foot of extruded aluminum metal base to a 45 ft. long
.times. 8 ft. wide .times. 8 ft. high chamber trailer with about 3
1/2 inches (average) of polyurethane thermal insulation to reduce
heat transfer below about 0.07 Btu/hr .times. ft.sup.2 .times.
.degree.F.
Two temperature measurements were made of the aluminum base top
surface, one directly over an electrical resistance heating element
and another measurement midway between adjacent heating elements in
the transverse direction of the base. Another temperature
measurement was made in the chamber gas space three inches above
the aluminum base top surface, and the fourth measurement was six
inches below the chamber ceiling. With all three sets of heating
elements activated, the metal base temperature rose to 66.degree.F.
above the heater element and to 61.degree.F. midway between heater
locations. It was thus apparent that the base temperature was quite
uniform, demonstrating the excellent transverse distribution of
heat obtained through the highly conductive aluminum panels. After
steady-state conditions were obtained in the chamber, the gas
temperature near the ceiling varied with time only about
1.degree.F. from the refrigeration temperature upper limit control
point, i.e. between 34.degree.F. and 35.degree.F. The temperature
three inches above the aluminum base was found to be only about
1.degree. higher than the near-to-ceiling temperature at the
corresponding time. Stated otherwise, the 30.degree. temperature
rise of the metal base top surface was virtually undetectable a
distance of three inches above the floor. This means that with the
product supported in pallets or carts and not in direct contact
with the floor, the product temperature will not be significantly
affected by the relatively high temperature of the metal base, even
at maximum heat input. This heat will instead by uniformly
distributed to the product by gas circulating in contact with the
heated floor.
Although preferred embodiments have been described in detail, it
will be appreciated that other embodiments are contemplated along
with modifications of the disclosed features, as being within the
scope of the invention.
* * * * *