U.S. patent number 3,722,793 [Application Number 04/834,283] was granted by the patent office on 1973-03-27 for voting system.
Invention is credited to Samuel Aronoff.
United States Patent |
3,722,793 |
Aronoff |
March 27, 1973 |
VOTING SYSTEM
Abstract
A voting system embodying a registration machine operable by the
voter through a voter's identification card and controllable by the
precinct officer for voters use; upon registration said
registration machine electrically releases a voter's selection
panel for voting; a multiplicity of voting panels are electrically
coupled to a single totalizer which sequentially totalizes the vote
from each panel for every voting choice on respective specialized
counters from which a single card record is instantly obtainable
that is suitable for quick totalization of vote from a given area;
an electrically interconnected recorder automatically records the
exact vote of each anonymous voter.
Inventors: |
Aronoff; Samuel (Los Angeles,
CA) |
Family
ID: |
25266568 |
Appl.
No.: |
04/834,283 |
Filed: |
June 18, 1969 |
Current U.S.
Class: |
235/50A;
235/54F |
Current CPC
Class: |
G07C
13/00 (20130101) |
Current International
Class: |
G07C
13/00 (20060101); G07c 013/00 () |
Field of
Search: |
;235/54,54F,55,5A,54A,54D,51 ;40/2.2 |
References Cited
[Referenced By]
U.S. Patent Documents
Primary Examiner: Tomsky; Stephen J.
Assistant Examiner: Wal; Stanley A.
Claims
What is claimed is:
1. An integrated voting system machine comprising: a voter's
registration machine module having means for sensing a voter's
identification card, and means including a recording tape for
imprinting the voter's identification, the said registration tape
being retained; means for concealing the mode of registration with
respect to the actual voter; a voting apparatus module embodying
the setting of all candidacies, candidate and issue areas, and
including mechanisms for selecting the vote, selection indication
means, and individual write-in modules for each candidacy;
totalizing module means coupled to said voting apparatus module to
receive total votes therefrom, said voting apparatus module further
including vote switch means to transfer the total vote to the
totalizing module means; control console means coupled to control
the use of the registration machine and vote selection panel; said
totalizing module means further including means generating a total
registration record for total vote, and recorder means for the
individual unidentified vote to serve as a simple record and for
possible recount.
2. An integrated machine as a voting system having interrelated and
interconnected modules comprising:
at least one voter's registration machine module, operable in
conjunction with a voter's identification card, electrically
interconnected with a remote control console and a voting selection
panel;
at least one voter's identification card for voter's registration
of identification into and as a link permitting proper operation of
the voter's registration machine;
single control module means coupled for remote electrical control
of each voter's registration machine module by an authorized
officer, whose release of said voter's registration machine enables
the voter to proceed with the vote;
at least voting panel apparatus module for the voter's selection of
his vote from the entire slate, said module being electrically
interconnected with the voter's registration module and totalizing
and recording modules;
at least one range extending module, which extends the range of
listings of the number of available candidates for a specific
office beyond that provided in the specific candidate section of
the vote selection module, is appended and electrically
interconnected with the specific candidacy section of the vote
selection module, thus allowing the voter to make his voting choice
from all available registered candidates for the particular
office;
a single vote totalizing machine module that is electrically
interconnected with the plurality of voting panels in one or
plurality of voting stations, and that sequentially and
simultaneously totalizes the sum vote selection from each voting
panel for each vote selection on respective specialized counters,
from which counters a single card record of the totalized vote from
all coupled voting panels is instantly obtainable at any time, said
totalizing module being further electrically interconnected with
the voter's registration machine for the latters restoration to
open position when the vote is totalized;
a single record card of the totalized vote obtainable instantly at
will from the totalizing machine module, said card being usable for
automatic totalization of the vote for each and every candidate and
proposition from a major voting area; and
a recorder machine module that is electrically interconnected with
the totalizer machine module, which said recorder module records
the complete selected vote of each anonymous voter on the
chart.
3. The method in an integrated voting system comprising the use by
the voter of a unique voter identification card that certifies the
voter's eligibility to vote in a given area, the recording and
imprinting on tape of such identification card by means of a
registration module suitable to accept such voter identification
card, such recording of the identification card to serve as a means
of registration of voter, accepting, tabulating and totalizing the
votes from a number of voting stations wherein voters have
registered their respective individual vote selection, each voter
having an aforesaid unique voter identification card and having
recorded same in aforesaid registration module, the voting method
comprising the steps of releasing a voting station for use by
voter, selecting the vote choice and retaining the selection made
by the individual voter until complete, scanning the selections
voted when complete, totalizing the scanned selections and
simultaneously recording the individual voter's selection, finally
locking the voting registration station against further voting
until further release, and obtaining an instantaneous record of the
totalized vote of a plurality of voting stations at a given
location, the record being suitable for machine totalization for a
larger area of votes.
Description
This invention relates to a system for voting in national, state or
local elections for election of officers or on any pertinent issue.
The system is equally applicable to periodic polling of public
opinion by any private or public agency on matters of public
concern.
The system embodies the complete voting process beginning with the
registration and identification of the eligible voter thru the
ultimate count of the complete vote. As such, it embodies and
envisions new and novel techniques and procedures in which the
combination of a number of new and novel devices and mechanisms are
utilized.
A number of voting systems currently in use attempt to apply
certain improvements or partial mechanization to a certain phase of
the voting process, - as for example, the actual registration of
the vote. Some attempt to use centralized computing machines which
require that the recorded vote be conveyed to a computing center
for a count of the vote. This involves the use of specialized
record cards that require special registration apparatus, the cards
being adequately designed to be accepted by the computing
equipment. Other systems resort to the use of various types of
voting sheets, - various ways of using specialized computers, -
various forms of voting panel design, etc.
None of these existing systems have attacked the complete voting
process. None have resolved the problems of cost, speed, accuracy,
security, voter identification and registration. In spite of the
various minor compromise remedies a tally of the vote is still a
long, drawn-out process; - costs are still unreasonably high that
include service personnel in booths, - cost of records, - cost of
transfer to centers for computation, - costs of computation, -
costs of identification. Potentiality of error, - and of potential
fraud in identification, or the problem of write-in votes is still
a major factor.
The average precinct voting station still requires four to five
attendants whose duties are, to obtain the signature of the voter,
to check the name with the available record for the precinct
registration, to check off the name on the total registration
sheet, issue voting ballot, receive the ballot after voting, tear
off number and deposit ballot in voting box, and guide the voter in
proper manner for voting. In general, the average urban precinct
voting station maintains four or five voting booths. The vote count
proceeds after closing hours of the voting precinct, and may
continue into the long hours of the following day to
completion.
Accordingly, the objectives of this invention are to provide
for:
1. Quick, authorized, and registered means for voter personal
identification that will simultaneously exclude the possibility of
fraudulent voter representation.
2. Quick and automatic registration of voter in the polling booth
that will also prevent the possibility of repeat registration.
3. Automatic permission to vote following adequate voter
registration.
4. Automatic permission to vote in only one specified precinct in
which the voter is registered.
5. Complete secrecy and security of voter with automatic
non-correlation of voter with his actual vote.
6. Means for write-in votes - where permissible - and integration
of this vote to other candidates in the same category.
7. Automatically governing voter selection of his vote so that he
will not exceed the number of choices permissible for eligible
vote.
8. A minimum number of service personnel - (only one envisioned
instead of the current four or five persons.)
9. Automatic servicing (or use) of maximum number of voting booths.
(The present limit of four or five booths may be extended to 12 to
20 booths, thus accommodating several precincts in one voting
station.)
10. Automatic instantaneous, continuous and accurate count of vote
for entire voting station for all booths.
11. Ability to instantly obtain record of voting count at any time
period by automatic means.
12. Ability to instantly obtain a record of total vote for each
candidate and issue at close of voting time.
13. Automatic untamperable accuracy of total vote count.
14. Elimination of need to transfer records of individual votes to
central point for count - or computer processing.
15. Absolute elimination of massive records - and reduce necessary
records to absolute minimum and in simple form.
16. Possibility - when desired - for recount of vote with absolute
minimum of paper (no need for individual cards or computers), at
high speed at absolute accuracy.
17. Possibility of using the same equipment for opinion polling of
specific surveys with adequate means for obtaining the requisite
data in such surveys, - this use will likewise result in reduced
costs of such surveys, - greater representative numbers to obtain
better indicative results, - high speed of results, - high
accuracy, and quick analysis of results.
18. Simplicity in voter use, simplicity in system use, and general
reliability of system.
19. Reduction in the number of records to be summarized in final
count by a factor equal to the number of voters divided by the
number of voting stations; this factor may have an envisioned range
of 1,000 to 5,000.
The manner in which the outlined objectives are achieved, - the
functioning of the system in this invention, - and the individual
major components that implement and are embodied in this invention
and the functions thereof are further delineated in the following
specifications.
The new and novel features which are believed to be characteristic
of this invention, both as to organization and method of operation,
together with further objectives and advantages thereof will be
better understood from the following descriptions considered in
conjunction with the accompanying drawings in which a presently
prefered embodiment of the invention and its components is
illustrated by way of example. It is expressly understood, however,
that the drawings are for the purpose of illustration and
description only, and are not intended as a definition of the
limits of the invention including any and all of its
components.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
FIG. 1 is a front view of a resident citizens identification card
used in accordance with the present invention;
FIG. 1A is a rear view of the card of FIG. 1;
FIG. 2 is a front view of a voters identification and registration
card embodying the card of FIG. 1;
FIG. 2A is a rear view of the arrangement of FIG. 2;
FIG. 3 is a perspective view of a voters registration module used
in conjunction with the card of FIG. 2;
FIG. 4 is a layout of a representative voting panel module, shown
in the vertical plane;
FIG. 5 is an external perspective view of a totalizing module in
accordance with the invention;
FIG. 6 is a representative front view layout of the registering
face components embodied in FIG. 5;
FIG. 7 is a perspective view of a paper chart recorder module
registering individual voter selections;
FIG. 8 is a perspective view of a form of polling attendant's
control module;
FIG. 9 is a perspective view of a composite arrangement embodying
the voting module of FIG. 4 and the voter registration module of
FIG. 3;
FIG. 10 is a perspective view of one example of the disposition and
interconnection between a number of modules shown in FIG. 9 and the
control module of FIG. 8 as well as voters totalizing module of
FIG. 5 and individual voter recording module of FIG. 7;
FIG. 11 is a perspective view of a voting booth containing the
voting arrangement of FIG. 9;
FIG. 12 is a schematic wiring diagram indicating the electrical
interconnection between various modules and their principal
components;
FIG. 13 is an arrangement of vote selecting button mechanisms in
combination with the write-in mechanism;
FIG. 13A is a cross-sectional view of the voting buttons of FIG.
13, illustrating the manner in which all voting buttons are
simultaneously released on completion of totalization of votes;
FIG. 14 is a cross-sectional view of the voting buttons wherein the
voter may select more than one candidate but less than the total
number of candidates;
FIG. 14A is a plan view of the hold and release mechanism of the
voting buttons of FIG. 14;
FIG. 15 is a diagram of the mechanism for selection by the voter of
either a "Yes" or "No" vote for an issue or proposition;
FIG. 15A is a cross-section of the voting panel module of FIG.
15;
FIG. 16 is a diagram of the mechanism of the vote button;
FIG. 17 is a schematic diagram of the interconnection of the vote
holding relays in preparation for the totalizer;
FIG. 18 is a perspective view of the totalizing drum;
FIG. 18A is a plan view of the drum of FIG. 18;
FIG. 19 is a sectional view of the disposition of the voting
counters in the totalizing module and their relative
interconnections;
FIG. 20 is a further detail of FIGS. 5 and 6 indicating the
disposition of the voting counters of FIG. 19;
FIG. 20A is a further detail of FIG. 20 indicating the manner of
obtaining a card record of the totalized figures on the
counters;
FIG. 21 is a diagram of a printed paper to be placed over a section
of the voting module of FIG. 4 to identify the respective offices
and candidates for offices;
FIG. 22 is a diagram of a printed paper to be overlaid on the
entire voting panel module of FIG. 4 identifying all offices,
candidates for offices and issues or propositions;
FIG. 23 is a diagram of a combination voting button incorporating
an indicating light on the voting panel module of the corresponding
selection of the voter;
FIG. 24A is a schematic front view of the voters' selection panel
indicating the voters selection buttons, number of candidates
selected, light indicator and final voting button;
FIG. 24B is a fragmentary schematic view of the metering mechanism
permitting only the maximum allowable candidate selection;
FIG. 24C is a fragmentary schematic view of the holding and release
mechanisms;
FIG. 24D is a detailed view of the voting button;
FIG. 24E is a detailed view of the final vote button when selection
is completed;
FIG. 24F is a detailed view of the mechanism showing the number of
candidates selected;
FIG. 24 G is a fragmentary schematic view of the blocking plate for
preventing selection of candidates above the allowable number;
FIG. 25 is a front view of a light indicating panel in connection
with FIGS. 24A-24G showing the exact candidates selected from the
large number of candidates;
FIG. 26 is a perspective view of the detail of the selector
mechanism of FIGS. 24A-24G;
FIG. 26A is a schematic view of the upper detail of FIG. 26 showing
the mechanism for the selection pin;
FIG. 27 is a diagram of the electrical balancing circuit that
exactly positions the candidate pin of FIG. 26;
FIG. 28 is a representation of a relay panel for the condition of
FIGS. 24A-24G that finally activates the corresponding counters in
the corresponding totalizer module;
FIG. 29 is a simplified schematic and diagrammatic representation
of a counter assembly for the condition of FIGS. 24A-24G;
FIG. 30 is a schematic diagram showing interconnecting wiring
correlating FIGS. 24A-24G, 25, 26, 27, 28 and 29;
FIG. 31 is a perspective view of a module for use by a voter
combining FIGS. 24A-30 inclusive;
FIG. 32A is a perspective view illustrating the numerals and binary
code indices embossed on the individual drums of a typical counter
in accordance with the invention;
FIG. 32B is a layout of the pattern on a drum of FIG. 32A;
FIG. 33A is a perspective view of another form of numeral and code
representation on a typical counter drum;
FIG. 33B is a layout of the pattern on the drum of FIG. 33A;
FIG. 34 is a layout of a sub-card on which the totalized figure is
obtained from the totalizer;
FIG. 34A is a further layout of FIG. 34 showing the name of the
candidate or issue for additional identification;
FIG. 35 is a diagram of a total registration card embodying the
subcards of FIGS. 34 or 34A; and
FIG. 36 is a representation of a normally available adding computer
machine which totalizes the vote of all corresponding sub-cards
from the various areas.
The present invention consists of an electrically interconnected
system embodying the various major elements cited above, and
described hereinafter, which allows a voter to adequately identify
himself and then proceed to exercise his vote, - the results of
this vote being automatically totalized and/or recorded to
instantly obtain the status of the total vote.
FIGS. 1 and 1A - show a U. S. citizen identification card as
currently obtainable by all U.S. citizens. This identification card
is a certification by the respective agencies of the United States
Government that the bearer is in fact a citizen of the United
States. Whenever it may be found desirable that the form or
specific content of this identification may be modified, this will
in no way affect the basic principle of its use as an original
element for certification of citizenship and eligibility to
vote.
FIGS. 2 and 2A represent a composite voter's Identification Card
which is provided by the subordinate political entity (state,
county, etc.) to the voter at the time of registration. This card
is intended to replace the present voter's registration
certificate. This Voter Identification Card utilizes the original
U. S. Citizen identification card, 1, and is enclosed and sealed in
a suitable transparent, preferably plastic, frame 2, which also
contains additional information 3 relating to the State, County and
Precinct Number in which the voter resides as well as the voter's
name and address, and his registration number. The latter data, 3,
may be on a separate card or made as part of Card 1 and inserted
into the frame 2; alternatively this data 3 may be made inscribed
on the frame 2 proper. The name, address and registration number of
the voter must be provided in such manner, preferably but not
exclusively by raised letters on the plastic so that printing
thereof may be possible.
Besides the written reference material, the frame 2 is provided
with indexed mounting holes 4, and suitable notches 5 around its
periphery; - the matrix combination of mounting holes and notches
being made to identify a specific precinct in which the voter
resides and where the voter will exercise his vote. In the form
shown the approximate overall dimensions of the frame are made to
be suitable for wallet use, but are not exclusive to these. The
indicated notches and mounting holes are shown as examples and may
vary as to location, number, and character to suit given
conditions.
For convenience and further quick identification of the state in
which the voter is registered, the card - or portion of the card or
frame on which the state information is supplied, - may be made in
various colors or combination of colors.
Thus, the Voter's Identification Card - FIG. 2 - is a complete
identification as to citizenship - use of photo, - residence, -
voter registration, - and precinct in which the voter resides and
may vote. The voter uses this card when he appears to vote.
The nature of this Identification Card is such that the voter can
be identified easily and, hence, the possibility of fraudulent
representation is reduced to a minimum.
It may be noted that in certain introductory stages compromises may
be devised as to content and form of the Voter Identification Card.
This, however, in no way contravenes or departs from the basic
concept of the use of an adequate identification card for the
voter.
When a voter presents himself at the voting poll, he identifies
himself to the poll attendant by presenting his Voter
Identification Card - FIG. 2. At this point only one poll attendant
is required (instead of the current use of four or five
attendants). Thus, an immediate economy is affected.
The poll attendant - who has a list of the voters in this precinct
provided to him by the voter registrar office - simply checks off -
as a convenience - the voter's name - and directs the voter to a
specific booth. The attendant presses a button on his Booth
Selector - FIG. 8 - (the details of which will be described
hereinafter) - which allows the voter to enter the booth, register,
and vote.
Upon entry into the voting booth, the voter places his Voter
Identification Card - (FIG. 2) - on the Voter Registration Machine
shown - FIG. 3 - in a manner described thereinafter. A particular
form of the Voter Registration Machine is shown in FIG. 3. Various
other forms and designs may be made to fulfill the requisite and
described functions. These variations, however, in no way
contravene or depart from the basic concept of the invention.
The Voter Registration Machine - FIG. 3 - is equipped with suitable
pins 6 and 6A whose disposition form a pattern that corresponds to
the pattern of indexing in FIG. 2; the particular pattern of pins
being made exclusive for a specific precinct.
The Voter Identification Card - FIG. 2 - is placed on the Voter
Registration Machine - FIG. 3 - over the pins 6 and 6A. In doing
so, the acceptance of the card - FIG. 2 - by the machine is an
additional confirmation of the voter's right to vote in the
specific precinct. In the given position, the portion of the card -
FIG. 2 - that contains the voter's name and address (and possibly
voter's number) automatically locates itself in the window 7
beneath which is located a paper 8 that is released from roll 9, at
a programmed point, by means of motor 10; the paper is taken up
onto roll 11.
When the poll attendant depresses the selector button on the booth
selector machine - (the selector button being represented by the
switch 12 in FIG. 3) - the electromagnet 13 - FIG. 3 - is energized
which activates armature 14 and causes pawl 15 to disengage from
armature 16. Armature 14 is integral with pawl 15 and operates
about pivot 17. Engagement between pawl 15 and armature 16 is
maintained by spring 18.
Armature 16 is integral with platten 19 which is provided with a
suitable handle as part of 19. A suitable pad 20 is affixed to
platen 19. The platen assembly pivots about a shaft 21.
As the voter places the Voter Identification Card (FIG. 2) on the
Voter Registration Machine (FIG. 3) as described above, and when
the armature 16 is released from pawl 15, the voter depresses the
platen assembly by means of the platen handle 19 to the operating
position as shown in dotted form.
In the operating position platen 19 is engaged behind pawl 22 and
is held in place. In this position the pad 20 depresses the Voter
Identification Card (FIG. 2) at the area of the voter's name,
address and serial number, and imprints this data on the paper 8.
Simultaneously, the platen depresses plunger 27 operating against
spring 28 and guided in slot 29. The depression of plunger 27
closes the contact 30 and 30 A.
As will be shown hereinafter in the composite circuit diagram, -
FIG. 12, - contact 30 permits the voter to register his vote upon
selection of his voting choice. Thus, registration of the voter is
automatically assured by the voter's proper registration of
identification and a record of identification is secured. This
record is completely independent of the voter's selection of his
vote, - and no interrelation between the vote and identification of
voter exists. This assures security and secrecy of voter's choice
of ballot.
At this point the final and complete functioning of the Voter's
Identification Machine - FIG. 3 - can be detailed while deferring a
description of its programmed interconnected function in the system
in connection with the outline of the composite circuit diagram
FIG. 12.
Simultaneously with contact 30, contact 30A is also closed; - the
latter provides a signal to the poll attendant that the booth is in
operation and occupied.
Upon completion of the vote by the voter, and its automatic
registration, - as will be subsequently described, - the circuit
programming is such that the totalizing machine - FIG. 18 - which
is detailed hereinafter - energizes the electromagnet 25 through
closing of the contact 26; - this activates the armature 23 which
is integral with the pawl 22 and pivoted about the shaft 24, - the
pawl-armature assembly being normally held in locked-in position
against the platen 19 by means of spring 31. Activation of the
armature 23 releases the platen 19 from engagement with the pawl 22
and platen 19 returns to its original position by means of spring
32 - or optionally it may be returned by hand - until it is
re-engaged with pawl 15. As the platen is released from engagement
with pawl 22, the contact 30 is broken - thus, no further
registration can be made - and motor 10 carries through the paper 8
so that the imprinted voter's name and address is removed from the
open window and a new clear paper area is prepared for the next
voter.
The paper 8 has perforated holes 33, - on either or both sides, -
by means of which a sprocket wheel 34 is driven which in turn moves
an electrical wiper 35 around a circular contact 36. The wiper 35
and sprocket wheel 34 are coaxially and rigidly mounted on a shaft
37. The function of the sprocket-contact assembly is to meter the
amount of paper to be moved for the following registration. The
length of paper can be ascertained by the movement of the arm 35
for (360-X) degrees - the X quantity being a "dead" or disconnected
area.
The movement of the paper is reasonably controlled by a
clutch-brake device 38 mounted on the motor frame coaxially with
the motor shaft. Thus, when the motor 10 and clutch-solenoid 38 are
activated by contact 39 - the latter closing when armature assembly
22-23 is activated - and further held activated by contact 35-36 -
the clutch engages the driving shaft 40 and continues to drive the
paper.
When, however, the contact 39 is broken and subsequently contact at
35-36 is also broken, the clutch-brake is released from the motor
and instantly provides a brake on the shaft to thus holding it in
place and allowing the motor 10 to coast to a standstill.
The voter then removes his Voter Identification Card and
departs.
FIG. 8 represents the attendant's booth selector device. In its
simplest form it comprises a suitable box 41 onto which is mounted
a panel 42, the latter carrying a series of buttons 43 each of
which activates a contact 12 - (this contact also shown in FIG. 3).
Corresponding to each button-switch assembly is a signal light 44
that indicates occupancy of a booth when contact 30A is closed as
described above for FIG. 3. The number of buttons-switch-light
combinations on each panel corresponds to the number of booths
available at each polling place.
Thus, the poll attendant can control the assignment of a booth, -
the use of the booth, - and the prevention of illicit repeat
voting.
FIG. 4 is an illustration of a Voting Panel. The actual
disposition, - number of voting conditions, and proportions of the
panel may vary under different circumstances without circumventing
or departing from the basic concepts of this invention.
In its general form the voting panel provides for;
a. the selection of candidates for office - where two candidates
are automatically elected representing a certain political party.
For example, president and vice president, - or governor and
lieutenant governor for a given political party. These are
indicated in positions 1 and 2 on the panel (FIG. 4).
b. the selection of a candidate for a single office where a number
of candidates may be competing for the same office; - for example -
a senator, a member of state assembly, - etc. The candidates for
this office are represented by positions 4 to 12 to n - (any
number) on the panel (FIG. 4).
c. the selection of several (2 or more) candidates for several open
offices for which a greater number of candidates compete than there
are open offices; - for example - city supervisors, - certain
commissions, - etc. The selections for these offices are
exemplified by positions 21 to 27 to n (any number) on the panel
(FIG. 4).
d. the approval or disapproval of presented issues on which the
voter may express his will by voting "Yes" or "No." Such issues may
be of national, state, or local importance. These may include for
example, - certain bond issues, - issues relating to salaries of
officials, - school, hospital or general maintenance issues, etc.
These are represented by positions 51-52 - - - n, - 62-63 - - - n,
- 71-73 - - - n - - - , on voting panel (FIG. 4).
e. the approval of a single presented candidate for a single office
where no other candidates are available and hence no choice
presented to a voter. This frequently occurs in the case of
judgeships or similar offices. These offices are represented in
positions 31 to 34 to n (any number of offices), where each
position is for an independent and singular office and only one
candidate shown for this office.
The above presentations are presented as examples of possible
categories and are not exclusive thereto. Various categories for
voting may be presented to the voter in various ways, and the panel
arrangement may be made in any convenient form to specific desired
conditions without circumvening or departing from the scope and the
intent of invention. The specific advantageous features relating to
the voting panel are discussed hereinafter.
Position 3 on the Voting Panel (FIG. 4) - represents a means for
optional "write-in" vote for candidates. A form of this device and
method is detailed hereinafter in FIG. 13.
Item 45 (shown in FIG. 4) indicates a form of "vote-selector"
device which is placed opposite each candidate, and which the voter
uses for his vote for any candidate he selects. In its simplest
form, but not exclusively, the "vote-selector" device is a typical
electrical push button contact in combination with (or in separate
form) a signal light indicating the voter's selection. Item 45 is
made typical for any number of such positions as may be found
necessary in a given situation. The "vote-selector" device is
further detailed in FIG. 23, and described hereinafter.
Item 46, - (Shown in FIG. 4), - indicates a form of "vote-selector"
device which is placed opposite each issue, and by means of which
the voter exercises his selection as to a "YES" or "NO" vote on the
specific issue. In its simplest form, but not exclusively, the
"vote-selector" device (Item 46) is a typical electrical
two-position switch in combination with (or in separate form) a
signal light indicating the voter choice. Item 46 is made typical
for any number of such positions of issues as may be found
necessary in a given situation. This "vote-selector" device is
further detailed in FIG. 15 and described hereinafter.
Item 47 - (schematically shown in FIG. 4) - is the final "vote"
device that the voter uses to register his vote. In essence item 42
is a form of electrical self-resetting contact whose details are
described hereinafter in FIG. 16, and whose position in the system
is indicated in the composite schematic wiring diagram - FIG.
12.
Item 48 - (schematically shown in FIG. 4) - represents an
interconnect between positions 1, 2, and 3 - the interconnecting
mechanism intended to be behind the panel and not available to the
voter's view. A form of such basic mechanism is shown in FIG. 13
and description thereof included hereinafter. The intent of this
interlocking mechanism is to prevent invalidation of the voter's
vote. In the given case the voter is given only one choice, out of,
say, three, - i.e., either of the two (as indicated) political
parties or a "write-in" vote. Should the voter, for example, press
the button for position 1, and then, either thru error or intent,
press button for position 2 then the button 1 will disconnect to
original position and its signal light will extinguish. Similarly,
should the voter, for example, press the button for position 2 and
then open the cover in position 3 for a "write-in" (in accordance
with the manner hereinafter described) then the button 2 will
disconnect and retain the original position and its signal light
will extinguish.
Item 50 - (schematically shown in FIG. 4) - represents an
interlocking device which permits the voter to select one candidate
out of a larger group of competing candidates and where a
"write-in" mechanism may or may not be provided. As in the previous
case, the intent is to permit the voter to make his singular choice
while at the same time preventing the invalidation of his vote.
This device is similar to that shown in FIG. 13.
Item 49 - (schematically shown in FIG. 4) - represents an
interlocking device which permits the voter to make a selection of
two (or more) candidates - as stipulated - from a larger number of
available candidates. A form of such basic mechanism is shown in
FIG. 14 and pertinent description thereof included accordingly.
Assuming, - for example, - that in the given category three
candidates are to be selected out of a group of seven contending
candidates. When the voter selects three or less candidates his
vote is valid and he can proceed with his vote. If, however, the
voter selects three candidates - i.e., he depresses three buttons,
- and then, - either by accident or design, - he depresses a fourth
button, the last action will then automatically reject the first
three buttons to the original position extinguishing simultaneously
the corresponding signal lights, and the voter can then resume
making his voting selection. The voter is also presented with the
option of being able to withdraw any one of his previously set
group of buttons if he finds that such setting may be an error of
judgement or the preference for another candidate.
Thus, it is evident, that in each of the above cases the voter is
given ample freedom to properly make his selection, to correct any
error he may have made, to correct for any preference he may have,
and to see and examine precisely the complete "ballot" that
satisfies his wish, - without invalidating his vote, - before he
presses the "vote" button item 47. The actual vote is completely
secret, and the panel settings are completely automatically cleared
before the voter accepts his card.
The voting procedure thus established for the voter in this
invention is simple, - devoid of unnecessary paper, - fool proof as
regards to accuracy, - devoid of possibility of an invalid vote, -
it is quick, - and the voter is completely unaware of the automatic
mechanisms that are used for totaling and/or recording of the vote,
or the sequences that clear the voting mechanisms for the following
voter. A clear analysis of the voting procedure will accompany the
detail for FIG. 9, discussed later.
Forms of implementation of the various positions that have been
schematically indicated in FIG. 4 are presented in the following.
It must be indicated that these forms are pertinent in the
functions they perform in the system; - they may vary however in
the detail of final mechanical formulation. Thus, they are
presented as examples in an overall functioning system.
FIG. 13 is a detail of a functioning device represented
schematically as items 45 and 48 in FIG. 4. This device shows the
vote selector units in combination with an interlocking mechanism
and a write-in system. The interlocking mechanism is such that it
permits only one voting choice out of several possibilities; - in
the example shown - two direct presented possibilities and one
write-in possibility; - only one of the three being acceptable for
a vote.
In FIG. 13, - item 45 is the voting selector button - typical for
the various positions - and is the same as represented in FIG. 4.
Item 52 is the typical signal lamp for each voting position which
is covered by a suitable lens 53. Positions 1, 2, and 3 in FIG. 13
correspond to positions 1, 2, and 3 shown in FIG. 4. The voting
buttons 45, the lamps 52 and lenses 53 as well as the associated
mechanisms are all supported on the voting panel 54 (also shown in
FIG. 4).
Each button 45 is affixed to one end of a stem 55, the other
extreme of which is attached to a tapered tip 56. The button
assembly is retained to a fixed outer position by means of a collar
57 and spring 58. In this position the lamp 52 is extinguished.
When one, for example, of the button assemblies is first depressed
- at the voter's option - the tapered portion 56 enters a hole of a
split plate 59-60 (shown in greater detail in FIG. 13A). One half
of the split plate 59 is held rigidly in the housing 61 and serves
the purpose of a back-up guide for the entering tapers; block 61 is
also supported on the panel 54. The other half of the split plate
60 is free to move linearly in grooves 62 in the housing 61. The
movement of plate 60 is restrained by means of a spring 63. Thus,
when the first button assembly is fully depressed plate 60 is moved
linearly to allow the taper 56 to pass thru fully, - and when
passed the spring 63 causes the plate 60 to return to the original
position thus holding the button in the depressed position by means
of interference on the back of the taper. In this depressed
position the tip of 56 causes the electrical contacts 64 and 65 to
close (normally these contacts are open). In the depressed position
of the button assembly contact 64 energizes the corresponding
signal lamp 52, while contact 65 closes a necessary circuit on the
vote totalizing and/or recording circuit as will be more evident in
connection with the wiring diagram shown in FIG. 12.
If, however, either by design or accident the voter depresses a
second button - (say position 2) - the latter will fully perform as
in the first instance; however, in doing so it opens the split hole
on the first button disengaging plate 60 from the first button
assembly and causing spring 58 on the first button assembly to
return it to the open position.
Thus, only one of the several indicated positions can be made valid
and effective in the selected vote.
In the schematic representation item 48 FIG. 4 is shown as being
interconnected with position 3 - FIG. 4, the latter being described
as a provision for a "write-in" position. Position 3 in FIG. 13
describes a form of this "write-in" implementation.
As the button assembly of position 3 - FIG. 13 - is depressed it
performs all the functions, and subject to the same response, as
the button assemblies of positions 1 and 2. In addition, however,
button assembly in position 3 is mechanically engaged with the
write-in mechanism as follows.
As the voter button assembly in position 3 is depressed it
additionally moves a link 64A which is attached to a pin 65A that
is guided in a suitable hole 66 in a fixed block. The link 64A is
advanced by means of the collar 57 on the button assembly in
position 3. When the button assembly is in the fully depressed
position - (i.e., vote position) - pin 65A is disengaged from pin
67, - the latter being rigidly attached to the shaft 68 which is
rigidly locked to a door 69. Door 69 covers an opening 70 in panel
54 and the door 69 is held in the cover position by means of spring
71.
In the normal non-voting position the button assembly is in the
outer position and hence pin 65A is locked behind pin 67 thus
disallowing door 69 to open. However, in the depressed button
assembly position the engagement between the pins 65A and 67 is
removed thus allowing the door 69 to open making the opening 70
open to the voter thru which he can "write-in" his choice on the
paper 72, one or both sides of which are perforated 73 to drive a
suitable sprocket metering wheel 74 - which determines the length
of paper to be moved so as to clear the recorded vote from the
opening and make the clear paper available to the next voter.
During the write-in period the voter holds the door 69 open by
hand; - as he completes his write-in he releases the door and the
door closes.
The drive mechanism for the paper is similar to that described in
connection with FIG. 3. The paper passes unidirectionally between
two drums - 81 and 82 - one of which is a supply roll while the
other is a take up roll. Drum 82 is coupled coaxially on shaft 80
to clutch-brake 78 and motor 79 and is driven by them.
The metering sprocket wheel 74 is coupled to an electrical wiper 76
thru shaft 75; the wiper 76 traverses in electrical contact over a
sector 77 which is arranged to cover an angle of (360-x).degree. -
the segment x constituting an electrically disconnected area. The
motor, clutch-brake, and circular contact are electrically
interconnected thru a switch 83 to the power source. When the
switch 83 is temporarily closed the clutch and motor are energized
and drive the paper as well as the sprocket wheel. At some point
the contact 76-77 takes over as the switch 83 is released - the
motor thus continuing to advance the paper until the wiper 76 comes
into the dead area of contact 77 thus power on the motor and clutch
are interrupted - the clutch release then acts as a brake on the
drum 82 stopping the advance of the paper instantly while allowing
the motor to coast to a halt.
The location of switch 83 is also shown in FIG. 13A and its
function is therefore tied to completion of the totalizing process
of the vote as will be seen in the wiring diagram FIG. 12.
Attached to the plate 60 is the core 84 of a solenoid consisting of
shell 88 and coil 87. When the coil is energized the core 84
"lifts" the plate 60 thus releasing all buttons. Simultaneously
core 84 exerts a force on the contacts 83 and 86 thru the medium of
stem 85. Under this action contact 83 is closed and contact 86
closes one side and opens the other. The function of contact 83 is
described above while that of 86 is interconnected in the system as
shown in the wiring diagram FIG. 12 and serves as an element in the
totalizing process. As the coil 87 is energized the solenoid opens
plate 60 and thus the vote and totalization thereof is completed
and the button assemblies are restored to the original
position.
The schematic interconnection shown in FIG. 4 as item 50 indicates
an interlock between positions 4 thru 12 to n positions. In this
case it is intended to secure the selection of a single candidate
out of potential multiple candidates where "write-in" is not
presupposed. Essentially this may be achieved with the same
mechanism as shown in FIG. 13 - the mechanism being provided for
the available number of candidates - without the use - however - of
the write-in mechanism. Various modifications and arrangements of
the mechanism may be made or substituted without departing from the
essence of the invention that provides for a suitable interlock
that will prevent invalidating a vote.
The schematic interconnection 49 shown in FIG. 4 indicates an
interlock for positions 21 to 27 to N where two or more individual
candidates are to be selected for a given post. Let us assume the
total number of candidates for the given positions to be N from
which n number (2 or more) are to be selected in the vote.
Correspondingly these are N number of button assemblies.
One form of implementation of this condition is shown in FIG. 14
and 14A. In this Figure the following items are similar to those
shown in FIG. 13. Panel 54, - button 45, - spring 58, - signal lamp
52, - lens 53, - stem 55, - and collar 57. FIG. 14A is a projection
of the sub-panel assembly discussed hereafter.
Attached to stem 55 is a cylinder 89 that operates in a hole 90 of
sub-panel 91, which is suitably affixed also to the basic panel
54.
Sub-panel 91 carries a number of pawls 92 that are pivoted on 93.
Springs 94 are attached to the pawls 92 and to the sub-panel and
hold the pawls in a given position with reference to the sliding
member 96 by means of pins 95 that are rigidly attached to 96. An
oval slot 98 is provided in the sliding member, 96, thru which a
close pin 97 is projected; the pin 97 being rigidly attached to the
sub-plate 91. The sliding member 96 is further guided in its motion
by means of guides 103 that are fixed to the sub-plate. The motion
of the sliding member 96 is limited by the long length of the
oblong hole 98.
Attached to one end of the sliding member is a pin 99 over which is
loosely fitted an arm 101 which is pivoted on a pivot 100 that is
affixed to the sub-panel 91. A spring 102 is attached to the arm
101 and to the sub-panel. Thus, the spring 102 holds the sliding
arm at one end of the oblong hole 98 and in such manner that when
the button assembly is in the out position the pawl 92 is in
contact with the surface of the cylinder 89; - further when the
button assembly is fully depressed pawl 92 engages with the back
side of the cylinder 89 and holds the button assembly in the
depressed - hence vote - position.
A solenoid core 104 as well as a pin 108 are attached to the
opposite end of the sliding member 96. The core 104 is movable in
the solenoid frame 105 and coil assemblies 106 and 107 - all of
which make up the solenoid. The core will pull on the sliding
member when either or both coils 106 and 107 are energized. During
this motion pin 108 will activate the SPDT switch 109 so that one
contact closes while the other opens.
A measuring circuit is made as an accessory element to the
mechanism. This measuring circuit consists of N number of
resistors, 113, each of which has a value of r - each resistor
operating in conjunction with a given button assembly (vote point).
All of the N resistors are connected in series, and further in
series with coil 106 and the entire circuit is connected to a power
source whose voltage is E.
Each button assembly activates three SPST switches 110, 111, 112 in
such manner that when the button assembly is fully depressed the
three switches will be closed - (contacts made).
Switch 110 is connected across a corresponding resistor r - and
when closed it shorts out this resistor.
Switch 111 is connected in the totalizing circuit and is directed
to the totalizing function as will be further evident in FIG.
12.
Switch 112 when closed energizes the signal light.
As each button assembly is depressed - (in the vote position) the
total resistance of the measuring circuit is reduced by a value r
correspondingly increasing the circuit current I.
The operating conditions of the circuit and mechanism can therefore
be established as follows:
Let:
N = total number of position resistors - corresponding to the total
number of candidates.
n = the maximum number of available positions to which candidates
may be elected - i.e., less than
N; - hence correspondingly maximum number of allowable vote
selections - or maximum number of button assemblies that can be
depressed.
R = resistance of coil 106.
r = resistance of each section resistor.
Hence the normal steady current "I" - when all button assemblies
are in the "out" positions is
I = E/Nr+R
The maximum allowable current prior to activating the core 104
is
I.sub.A = E/(N-n)r+R
The minimum current that will activate the core 104 (i. e., one
position above the allowable n positions) is
I.sub.T =E/[(N-n)r+R] -r
and the circuit conditions are adjusted to meet this
requirement.
Thus, for example, if there are 7 candidates from which any two may
be selected by the voter as his choice, - a valid vote will be
obtained. If, however, by design or accident the voter presses a
third button, then the coil 106 will activate the core and release
all previous choices. The voter can then proceed to make his final
selection.
Coil 107 will activate the core when the vote is complete and thus
restore all buttons to the original position. This is accomplished
thru the overall totalizing and operating circuit as well as switch
109, as will be further shown in FIG. 12.
The schematic positions 31 to 34 to N in FIG. 4 do not require
interlocking. Each position can be voted upon independently.
In this case the implementation shown in FIGS. 14 and 14A minus the
measuring system would apply. Specifically, the following items
would be deleted from FIGS. 14 and 14A for this condition - contact
110, - resistors 113, - coil 106. Thus, this condition for voting
would be satisfied.
Item 46 in FIG. 4 indicates the special case of a mode of voting on
issues where a "Yes" or "no" vote is required. These are indicated
in positions 51-52-N, or 62-63-N, or 71-72-73-N.
The implementation of this requirement is illustrated by examplary
mechanism in FIGS. 15 and 15A.
In FIGS. 15 and 15A, - four normally open SPST switches 115, 116,
117, 118 are activated by the arm 119 which is attached to shaft
120, - the actuation occuring when the arm 119 is deflected by
means of the knob 145 which is in front of the voting panel 54. The
knob 145 is the means that is available to the voter for his vote
selection.
In FIGS. 15 and 15A the following items are similar or the same as
indicated in FIGS. 13 and 14: Panel 54; - signal lights 52; -
lenses 53.
In FIGS. 15 and 15A the arm 119 and knob 145 and eccentric 121 are
all rigidly attached to the shaft 120. Normally (in non-voting)
position the assembly is held in neutral position by means of the
spring members 122 to which are attached suitable tips 123. In the
neutral position all of the switches 115, 116, 117, and 118 are
open and the signal lights are extinguished, while the operating
knob 145 is midway between the "YES" and "NO" positions on the
panel 54.
Two pawls 124 and 126 are pivoted freely about their respective
pivots 125 and 127 which are supported on a sub-base panel 114, the
latter being supported to the rear of the voting panel 54. A spring
145A joins the two pawls 124 and 126 and thus the pawl tips are in
constant contact with the eccentric 121.
At the opposite ends of the pawl members 124 and 126 are oblong
slots 130 and 131 respectively thru which protrude the pins 128 and
129 respectively, the latter being rigidly attached to the reset
arms 132 and 133 which are pivoted freely about pivots 134 and 135
respectively, the pivots being rigidly affixed to the sub-plate
114. The opposite ends of the reset arms are freely pivoted about
the pivots 137 and 136 respectively, both of which are rigidly
attached to the actuating arm 138 which in itself, is freely
pivoted about the pivot 139 - the latter being rigidly attached to
the sub-panel 114.
A solenoid core 141 is freely attached to the actuating arm 138 by
means of a pin 140. A spring 144 is attached to the actuating arm
138 and to the base panel 141, - thus holding the reset arms and
core in neutral position normally. Besides the core 141 the
solenoid is composed of a housing 142 and exciting coil 143. When
the actuating arm is deflected it operates the SPDT switch 151
opening one contact and closing the other.
A means is provided to the voter for correcting his choice in case
of accidental or inconsiderate choice. This accomplished by means
of a twist of reset arm 148 which in turn causes pawl 146 to
depress the reset arm 138 thru the member 152 which is guided in
guides 150. The pawl 146 and the arm 148 as well as spring 149 are
attached to the shaft 147, - the spring being held taut by
attachment to the sub-panel 114. The spring thus assures the return
and positioning of the reset arm 148 and its assembly to the
neutral position.
When a voter selects his preference on any issue he turns the knob
145 to either the "YES" or "NO" position as his choice may be. This
automatically will close a pair of contacts - either 116 and 118 or
115 and 117. In doing so the corresponding pawls 124 or 126 will
retain this vote selection in position until the vote is completed.
In this condition one of the switches (either 115 or 116) will
illuminate one of the signal lights - indicating the voter's
choice. The other switches (either 117 or 118) will close a circuit
on the totalizer which will register the voter's choice.
The solenoid coil 143 as well as the switch 151 are connected into
the general performance circuit which register the vote and clears
the panel, - the general circuit being shown in FIG. 12. As the
solenoid coil 143 is energized the pawls 124 and 126 release the
eccentric 121 and the assembly returns to the normal position. The
solenoid is then deenergized thru the operating circuitry in which
switch 151 is interconnected.
Item 47 in FIG. 4 shows schematically a button entitled "VOTE". The
voter presses this button after he makes the complete selection of
his choices and is satisfied therewith. When this button is pressed
to its full position the circuit FIG. 12 automatically completes
the voter's count and/or voter's record and automatically resets
the entire voting panel and voter's registration to normal.
A form of implementation of this button is shown in FIG. 16. In
this Figure a number of items are similar or equal to the
components shown in FIGS. 13, 14 and 15 and perform similar
functions. They are therefore numbered to the same numbers as
previously used. These common parts are as follows: Button 45, -
stem 55, - collar 57, - cylinder 89, - spring 58, - voters panel
54, - signal light 52, - lens 53, -
The cylinder 89 is guided in a hole in sub-panel 153 which is
supported on back of panel 54. A pawl 154Ais freely pivoted about a
pivot 155A- the latter being affixed to the sub-panel 153. A spring
156 is attached to the pawl 154Aand to the sub-panel 153 and thus
assures the contact between the pawl 154Aand the cylinder 89. A
link 163A joins the pawl 154Ato the solenoid core 157. The solenoid
is composed of the core 157, - housing 158 and energizing coil 159.
By means of the link 160, - which is attached to the core 157, when
the coil is energized the core actuates the two normally open SPST
switches 161 and 162. Both of these switches, as well as the
solenoid are connected into the operating circuit FIG. 12.
When the button 45 is depressed it automatically activates the
switches 154 and 155 thru the stem 163. One of the switches - 155 -
is connected in the operating circuit which provides the power to
the circuit and initiates the entire process of vote totalizing
and/or recording, and subsequent clearing of the voting panel and
voter's registration mechanism. The other switch - 154 - energizes
the corresponding signal light that is illuminated during the
period of the functioning of the operating circuit FIG. 12.
At an appropriate time point in the operating circuit the coil 159
is energized causing the core 157 to pull on the pawl 154 thus
releasing the entire button assembly to normal position at which
time the circuit to the solenoid is likewise interrupted and the
entire system restored to normal. The vote now being complete.
The precinct totalizing system consists of four sections, all of
which may be incorporated into one unit exemplified by FIG. 5 -
Totalizing Machine. The sections include:
a. Vote accumulating and selector panel FIG. 17
b. Selector totalizing drum FIG. 18
c. Vote totalizing panel-counters FIG. 19
d. Counter printing mechanism FIG. 20.
The vote accumulating and selector panel - FIG. 17 - consists of a
mounting panel 164 on which are mounted groups of relays typified
by coil 165 and SPST contact 166. Each relay represents a candidate
or issue.
The relays are mounted on the panel in groups. Each group
represents X-number of candidates and issues derived from a given
voting booth. For convenience - though not essential - the number
of potential votes is placed horizontally - representing a group.
All groups are placed vertically - so that the same vote selection
in each group is directly above each other vertically - to Y number
of groups - i.e., from Y number of booths.
This arrangement - though not exclusive - provides an easy method
for interconnecting the relays between groups.
The number of relays required for the panel is therefore equal to
XY.
As can be seen all votes from the different booths for the same
candidate or the same issue are interconnected. Therefore, the
number of wires directed from the selector panel to the totalizing
drum FIG. 18 equals the number of candidates and issues that are
presented. The drum merely selects each group successively and
causes the totalizer counters to add the corresponding votes.
The interconnection and direction of the wiring is indicated in
FIG. 17. The contacts 166 close for each relay for which a vote is
selected by the voter.
A form of selector totalizing drum is delineated in FIGS. 18 and
18A.
The totalizing drum consists of an insulating cylinder 167 around
the circumference of which are conducting bands 168, each of which
is connected to corresponding conducting segments 169 and 170. Each
band and segment combination represents a given voting booth.
Hence, the drum contains as many band and segment combinations as
there are voting booths whose total vote it is desired to
totalize.
The two segments connected to each band are displaced from each
other by an angle t.sub.1.
Each segment 169 is displaced from the corresponding segment on the
next band by an angle t.sub.2.
The angular displacements t.sub.1 and t.sub.2 are determined by the
conditions and constants of the drum and circuitry.
In addition to the booth bands (168) - one additional conducting
band 171 with appended segments 172 is placed around the drum. The
number of segments 172 is equal to the number of booth bands 168
that are available on the drum. The displacement of the segments
172 between each other is equal to t.sub.2 ; and the segments 172
are aligned with the segments 169.
The drum is mounted on a shaft 173 that is supported in bearings
174. Attached to the shaft is a suitable motor 175 that drives the
drum continuously and unidirectionally, the motor being supplied
from a suitable source of power.
In contact with each booth band is a stationary brush 177. Adjacent
to this brush are placed two additional brushes 176 and 178 that
contact the segments 169 and 170 respectively as the drum is
rotated in the direction as shown. Obviously as the drum rotates
brush 176 contacts segment 169 first; at a time interval t.sub.1
brush 178 contacts segment 170. The corresponding contacts on the
next band are made after the preceding contacts have been
broken.
The band 171 is contacted continuously by the stationary brush 179.
Adjacent to it is the brush 180 which successively contacts and
breaks contact with each segment 172 as the drum rotates as
shown.
Brush 177 is connected to the booth battery - minus. Brush 176 is
directed to the relays in the particular group and makes possible
for the selected relays (selected by the voter's choice) to pass an
operating signal to the respective counters adding each vote as the
drum passes the segment-brush contact.
Brush 178 is directed to the vote button solenoid and thru the
circuitry is held until the vote is totalized and/or recorded, then
the panel is cleared.
It is evident from FIGS. 18 and 18A, and the descriptions relating
thereto that
a. brush 176 closes the relay circuits for the totalizing counters
and are held pending release as follows.
b. After a time element of t.sub.2 - t.sub.1, at the indicated
direction of rotation, brush 178 being directed to the vote button
solenoid and energizes the solenoid so that the vote button and the
voting panel can be released. Thus brush 178 holds the solenoid for
the duration of contact, the entire panel is restored to normal
status when the circuit is interrupted as the drum advances
further.
The connection of brush 178 to the vote button solenoid 158 is
indicated in FIG. 12.
Brushes 179 and 180 are used in the circuit to assure consecutive
operation of the totalizing process as the vote is accumulated from
a number of booths.
FIG. 18 is an isometric view of the drum with its associated
components and the brushes and motor elements.
FIG. 18A is a development of the drum for clarity.
In both cases, the relative disposition of the bands and segments
is indicated. Only a few bands are shown. These can be extended to
X number of bands corresponding to a corresponding number of
booths.
The mode of vote totalizing is illustrated in FIG. 19. A suitable
panel 181 supports all of the digital electromechanical counters
required for the number of candidates and issues in question. Each
counter represents a given candidate for a specific office, or a
given direction for an issue.
The typical counter 182 is mounted on the panel in such manner that
the numerals project beyond the surface of the panel in order to
make these adequate for printing. Each counter is equipped with its
respective operating solenoid 183 that advances the counter one
digit for each impulse received. The solenoids are connected as
shown and as such are incorporated into the system.
FIG. 19 shows a partial number of potential counters that may be
used. Their disposition on the panel is optional and may be
arranged to any convenient consideration in the given
situation.
A front view of the partial panel of FIG. 19 together with
associated counters that complete the desired information is
further shown in FIG. 6.
FIG. 20 and 20A show a form (though not exclusive) for recording
the registrations of the totalizing counters. Numerous
modifications and designs may be made available for this recording,
- these in no way can be considered as contravening the intent and
scope of this invention in obtaining instantaneous, accurate,
secret, and tamperproof totals of the obtained vote.
In FIGS. 20 and 20A the counter panel 181 and the typical counters
182 are the same as shown in FIG. 19 - and hence the same item
numbers represent them.
The panel 181 with its counters is located in a suitable box 184
and the total box assembly placed in a suitable box-like housing
185, and suitably retained therein.
Placed in front of the counter panel - and a very small distance
away from it to allow for insertion of a suitable card - is a
platten consisting of a solid plate 187 and a resilient pad 188.
The platten is free to move in a forward and reverse direction and
is guided by the guides 186.
In back of the solid plate 187, a suitable cylinder 190 is
eccentrically rigidly mounted on a shaft 189 which is supported in
the frame 185. On the exterior of the frame 185 the shaft 189 is
projected to receive a handle 191 which is made rigid with the
shaft.
Normally, the cylinder 190 is located so that its minor radius
contacts the plate 187. Continuous contact between the cylinder 190
and the plate 187 is made possible by the compression springs 194.
In the normal position of the cylinder 190 and platten - 187, 188 -
a gap is available between the pad 188 and the counter
numerals.
A record of the registration of the totalizing counters is obtained
by inserting a suitable card 193 with a carbon 192 into the gap
between the counters and the pad 188. By turning the handle 191 in
a direction so that the eccentric cylinder 190 pushes on the
platten 187 until a carbon impression is obtained of the digital
numbers of the counters. As the handle 191 is either released or
returned to normal the springs 194 push the platten back to normal
position. The card and carbon can then be removed with a complete
record obtained of the vote registration. Each counter and its
position on the recorded card being suitably identified for each
candidate or issue.
The construction of the recording mechanism shown in FIG. 20 and
20A, is made in a manner as to prevent possibility of tampering
with the digital counters. Accessibility to the counter faces is
made impossible because of the narrow gap and because the platten
is not removable from the assembly.
Many design forms of the total precinct registration vote are
feasible that will achieve the same result.
One alternative may provide for a horizontally mounted digital
panel - - - in which the roller 190 rolls over the card and carbon
191-192.
The essential direction of this invention is that a simultaneous
record is obtained of the totalized precinct vote at any time - and
especially at the close of the voting time. This record being made
by a machine which is tamper-proof, accurate, secret, and not
related to the particular voter.
The panel 181 includes other counters besides the totalizing
counters 182 described above - although all counters are identical
in design.
A more comprehensive view of the data presented on the card when
the vote totals are obtained is shown in FIG. 6.
In FIG. 6 a partial number of totalizing counters 182 are shown on
panel 181 and are identified to the exact position as shown on the
voting panel FIG. 4. Each identified counter, therefore, represents
the total vote for any candidate or issue preference obtainable at
any moment as accumulated over any voting time (or at the end of
the voting period).
Additional necessary information is obtained by the following
counters shown as mounted on the basic panel 181.
Precinct No. - counter 195. This counter is preset and fixed.
Machine No. - Counter 196. This refers to the totalizing machine.
The number is preset and fixed.
Date - counter 197. This refers to the date of voting. The date is
preset and fixed.
Time of Day - counter 198. This counter is driven by a preferred
time mechanism installed on back of panel.
Total Vote - counter 199. This counter totalizes the total vote in
the precinct up to any voting period and total at the end of the
voting period.
Certification. This is a space reserved for signature of the
personnel obtaining the card record.
Although the major subassemblies used in the totalizing process
have been separately described as to implementation and function,
it may be desirable, as a matter of convenience, though not
essential in relation to the basic intent and scope of this
invention, to combine these in one assembly. Thus, FIG. 5
identifies one form, though not exclusive, of such affirmation.
In FIG. 5 - a suitable box 201 contains within it the counter panel
- indicated as 181.
The vote accumulating and selector panel - FIG. 17, - the selector
totalizing drum - FIG. 18, - the vote totalizing panel - FIG. 19
and FIG. 6, - are all contained internally within the box 201. The
card record mechanism FIG. 20 is visible. Also the card for
recording - (Items 192-193 FIG. 20A) is likewise visible.
All of the wiring is made internally, and a connector 202 with an
appropriate cable 203 containing the necessary wires is provided
for interconnection to the rest of the system.
Similarly, the voting panel and all its individual accessories have
been separately described as to implementation and function. It may
also be found desirable, as a matter of convenience, though not
essential in relation to the intent and scope of this invention, to
combine all of these in one assembly. Thus, FIG. 9 offers one mode,
- though not exclusive, - for such combination.
In FIG. 9 the voting panel with all its accessory implementation is
mounted onto a special cabinet 204 which also contains the voter's
registration device.
The accessories mounted on back of the voting panel include:
a. Vote selector and interlocking mechanisms FIGS. 13, 14, and 15
with all signal lights and buttons.
b. The vote button - FIG. 16 -
The cabinet 204 is equipped with a suitable connector 205 and a
cable 206 with adequate number of wires, - to enable it to be
interconnected into the general totalizing and recording
system.
To meet the demand for an actual individual voters record without
identifying the actual vote with the voter, a simplified recorder
is shown in FIG. 7.
This recorder utilizes a roll of paper for the individual voter's
record on which are either perforated or marked the total vote of
the voter in a relatively narrow space across the width of the
paper. Thus, a comparatively narrow roll of paper of proper texture
may replace the stacks and volumes of individual cards that require
special processing on specialized equipment.
FIG. 7 describes a mode of a paper type recorder which will record
automatically each and every selection of the voter - and
categorize these as for an unidentified voter.
In FIG. 7, an appropriate arm 207 pivoted about pivot 208 is held
in position against a limit block 212 by means of a tension spring
209. At the end of the arm 207 is placed a cutting blade 210,
which, when moved under the energized influence of solenoid 211,
will pierce a hole in the paper 215 in a predetermined line. Each
such hammer assembly represents a specific candidate for office or
issue choice and each such hammer corresponds to and works in
conjunction with the corresponding totalizing counter.
The paper 215 is obtained from a roll which is mounted on a
cylinder 214 which in turn is supported on a shaft 216. Mounted on
the shaft 216 is a clutch-brake device 217 that is actuated by a
solenoid 218 when it is energized. Normally, the shaft 216 is held
in position by the brake. The clutch-brake is coaxially supported
by the motor 219; - the motor is allowed to run continuously - as
an alternative - and is supplied by any source of electrical
energy.
Thus, when the Coil 218 is energized the paper advances a
predetermined distance which determines an individual's vote. In
the stationary interval of the paper the individual hammers, under
the influence of the pulses received by the respective voter's
choices, will record the voter's choice on the paper. Thus, a width
"W" defines a single voter while the respective choices of the
voter - identified to the corresponding voters panel as shown in
213 - recorded across the paper provides a complete record of
voters' choice.
The recorded end of the paper is taken up on roll 220 supported on
shaft 221 and held in tension by means of an electrical or
mechanical torque device 222. The entire mechanism, supported on a
suitable panel 223 may be enclosed in a suitable cabinet 224.
The interconnection of its components in the general schematic is
indicated.
It may be noted that a vote check may be made in a similar device
where the hammers 210 can be replaced with an electrical contact
operating thru the holes 223A onto a common plate. The contact will
then be connected to the individual totalizing solenoids (as in
FIG. 19), and as the roll is advanced the totalizing counters will
totalize the number of votes for each candidate and for every issue
choice. Thus, the same mechanism extends its utility in a simple
way.
The perforations 223A caused by the hammers 210 may be replaced by
using a suitable marker (instead of the cutter 210) which will
place a suitable print on the paper (instead of the perforation).
This in no way however departs from or circumvents the intent and
scope of this invention.
In the case where imprints are used, a vote check may be used by
picking up the individual markers thru photocell means for each
vote selector position, and the output of the photocells amplified
and fed to the counter solenoids (FIG. 19) for totalizing the vote.
In this case also the totalizing counters extend their utility in a
simplified manner.
In all cases the recorder may be used optionally.
The general disposition of the major components in this voting
system is indicated in FIG. 10.
It will be noted that the major equipments of the system are
electrically interconnected. These include:
a. The voting and registration unit - FIG. 9
b. The booth selector unit - FIG. 8
c. The totalizing unit - FIG. 5 and
d. The recorder unit - FIG. 7 - used optionally.
It will be noted that for any number of voting booths used in a
precinct - only one totalizing unit - and only one recorder unit
(used optionally) are required.
It will be noted also that the total count for any number of voting
booths in any precinct is obtainable instantly at the end of the
voting period and the information relayed to the central point for
total accumulation.
The general position of the voting and registration unit as placed
in a booth is shown in FIG. 11. This elemental equipment is the
only item visible to the voter which he has to use for registering
and voting.
The general composite wiring diagram is shown in FIG. 12. The
drawing identifies the various basic components that have been
previously discussed as to implementation and function in this
invention.
FIG. 12 shows one form of a complete circuit of operation as
typical for all of the various candidates and issues shown on the
voting panel (FIG. 4) - with all major common elements in the
circuit.
Thus, as the poll attendant presses contact 12 (FIG. 3) - the
registration platten is released and the voter depresses it into
voting position thus registering himself. In so doing he closes
contact 30 (shown in FIG. 12 and referred to in FIG. 3), which
closes the negative circuit to the battery and is thus prepared for
the final vote.
As the voter selects his candidate he presses a typical vote button
which closes, as for example, contacts 110, 111, and 112 (shown in
FIG. 12 and referred to in FIG. 14). In doing so contact 111
prepares the circuit for the vote totalization when the vote button
(FIG. 16) will be depressed.
As the vote button (FIG. 16) is depressed a circuit is closed from
plus (+) - thru contact 155 - thru contact 111, thru relay coil 165
- energizing the relay. When the drum (FIG. 18) comes into position
and closes the circuit thru 176-169-168-177.
As the relay 165 is energized contact 166 is closed energizing the
counter (FIG. 19) coil 183 causing one digit advance of the
counter; - at the same time the recorder pen (or hammer) 207 is
caused to make a corresponding record on the paper through
activating coil 211.
As the drum advances in the direction shown, the contact between
176 and 177 is broken thus restoring the counter and recorder.
Thus, the vote is totalized.
In the subsequent motion of the drum contact is established between
177 and 178 thru the band 168 and contact 170. This causes the
solenoid on the voting button (FIG. 16) 158 to be energized and at
once releasing the hold on the contacts 154 and 155 causing a
temporary hold on 158 until coil 106 is energized which releases
and opens contact 111, 110, and 112 to normal. Meanwhile, contact
26 (FIG. 3) is energized releasing the registration platten.
As the drum further advances contact between 177 and 178 is broken
and the system restored to the original position.
In the process the vote is totalized and recorded. As the drum
proceeds it follows the same process for the next booth.
The circuit shown is a typical vote for one candidate. All
candidate votes are parallelled and the entire voters selection is
recorded.
It should be noted that while the demonstrated circuitry and the
sequence of operation is indicated as shown by way of example,
numerous modifications in sequence of operation and, hence, in
continuity of circuit can be made to effect the same or similar
result.
Also the sequence of operation may be made not only thru the
interconnection as shown, but thru an individual electromechanical
intermittent programmer which will achieve the same result.
Neither or both of the above alternatives in any way circumvent or
depart from the scope and intent of the invention, - namely (a)
that the vote is made possible when the voter registers properly,
(b) that the voter makes his complete selection of the vote prior
to totalizing, (c) when so made to the satisfaction of the voter he
votes - by pressing the vote button, (d) when so voted the
totalizing selecting machine then totalizes and records the vote,
(e) upon completion of the addition and record of the vote, (f) the
voting panel is cleared, and (g) the registration machine is
released and restored - thus (h) notifying the attendant thru a
signal light. With the exception of registering and vote selection,
the entire process is automatic and does not require any dexterity
or acquaintance on the part of the voter in the mechanization
process.
Thus, the actual vote and totalizing process within the precinct
polling place is complete.
Practical application of the voting panel to different localities
may direct specific formulation considerations depending on the
number of potential offices for which candidates may apply, - the
number of candidates that may apply for any given office, - and the
limitation of the acceptable size of the voting panel that will
make its use convenient. In each case the manner in which the
voting buttons may be identified with respect to the candidate and
office becomes a factor. These considerations lead to some novel
methods and devices which become applicable to and part of this
invention.
Consider first the voting panel layout presented in FIG. 4. (This
layout is again reflected in FIGS. 9, 10). As may be seen the
voting button is identified by an adjacent label (which may or may
not be framed) identifying the candidate with appropriate
designations. The issues are similarly identified. In addition a
pilot light is placed adjacent to the button indicating the
selected candidate or direction of issue.
It may be felt that attachment to the panel of individual labels -
or insertion of individual labels into individual frames - may be
unnecessarily time consuming on a voting panel which adequately
accommodates the required candidates or issues together with the
individual identifications as shown.
The consideration of this time element leads to two potential
alternatives that mitigate the condition.
Thus, complete sections of identifying candidates or issues can be
printed on suitable paper that can be attached to the voter panel
that will identify each position in the given section. An example
of such section is shown in FIG. 21 for section A in FIG. 4.
A further means is available wherein a template of the complete
panel printed on suitable paper may be attached to the panel by any
suitable means, - the attachment being made in such manner that the
identifications will be properly aligned with the voting buttons.
An example of such a printed identification template as applying to
FIG. 4 is shown in FIG. 22.
Further, space and design considerations may lead to a desirability
to make the pilot light as part of the voting button. This
requirement is indicated in FIG. 23.
FIG. 23 shows a voting panel 225 into which is inserted a voting
button which consists of a tube 226 - the front of which contains a
plastic transluscent button (or plate) 227 which is held in place
rigidly by a suitable ring 228. Attached to the tube is a ring 229
which limits the outward motion of the tube when the ring becomes
in contact with the panel 225.
The tube 226 has two prong projections 232 which are formed by
cutting two slots across the tube. Attached to the prongs is the
cone 56 shown in FIG. 13 that operates in panels 59-60 of FIG. 13
as described in connection with FIG. 13.
A bracket 230, - which is placed in the tube slots, - is attached
to the panel 225 by any suitable means. The bracket 230 carries a
lamp base 233 into which is inserted a lamp 234.
A compression spring 231 is placed between the collar 229 and the
bracket 230 in such manner that when the panels 59-60 release the
cone 56 the tube 226 moves forward from the front of the panel
until it is stopped by means of the collar 229.
When the tube is depressed - as described in connection with FIG.
13 - the lamp illuminates and its illumination is shown thru the
plate 227.
In all other respects the button assembly functions as described
for FIG. 13.
Occasion arises for extraordinary voting requirements in specific
districts where a very large number of candidates are seeking
election to several vacant positions, - for example - in cases
where more than one hundred candidates are eligible for perhaps
five vacancies.
While the outlined system - in principle - is capable of providing
the facility for vote selection and vote, yet practical
considerations that will require 100 to 200 vote buttons may become
too cumbersome to provide in one panel - the voting panel may
become too large - and the vote selection may be too bewildering to
the voter.
A modified form of the basic vote-selector and voting arrangement
is therefore provided as part of this invention which will relieve
this problem where applicable. The method is shown in the following
illustrations and description.
FIG. 24A is a front view - (the view to the voter) - of a panel for
selection of a limited number of candidates - say five or 10 from
an available number of candidates that are eligible and who are
placed on ballot - say 25 or more - (the panel provides up to 999
candidates - although in practice 200 seems to be an upper
limit).
FIGS. 24B, C, D, E, F, G are component mechanisms located behind
the panel that form part of the implementation.
In FIG. 24, - the voting panel is shown in FIG. 24A. The voting
panel is indicated as 235, on which are mounted the various
subassembly components. It will be noted that the various basic
button assemblies are the same or similar to those shown in FIG.
14, - the principal detail parts of which are 45, 55, 57, 58, 89,
96. Similarly the release mechanism is also similar to that shown
in FIG. 14 and is represented by items 92, 93, 94, 95, 96, 97, 98,
99, 100, 101, 102, 104, 105, 106. Also the balancing circuit is
likewise similar to that in FIG. 14 and is represented by item
113.
Assume that a voter wishes to select on his first step a candidate
to whom No. 143 was assigned. He thus depresses the buttons to show
143.
Of these the first digit (i.e. 1, in column A,) actually selects
the vote translating mechanism FIG. 26, i.e., the particular
mechanism that will operate the 100 series.
The buttons 43 (columns B and C) cause the horizontal and vertical
selection of the translator mechanism to a point where they
intersect and stop and cause a corresponding relay to be energized
on the relay panel FIG. 28. (No. 143).
As the No. 143 relay is energized, it in turn energizes a
corresponding counter (No. 143) on the counter panel (FIG. 29)
making the counter ready for totalizing when the totalizing drum
selects that booth as described for FIG. 18. Simultaneously the No.
143 will be illuminated on the pilot light panel FIG. 25 and the
drum indicator mechanism FIG. 24F will indicate selection No.
1.
All of the buttons in column A select the 100 series in any number
selected. While all 10 buttons are shown (which make the capacity
of the unit to 999), as a practical matter it is hardly likely that
more than two buttons will be required (for a total capacity of
199).
The button assembly in column A is shown in FIG. 24D. In this
assembly the basic button assembly is used to activate a switch
assembly 236 whose function it is to energize the proper circuit
FIG. 27 that will actuate the specific translating mechanism FIG.
26, and provide the first digit in the circuitry that will
determine the complete number for the selected candidate - hence,
select the proper subsequent relay.
The button assemblies in columns B and C are equal in design and
construction and are detailed in FIG. 24B. As shown, a major
portion of these assemblies is duplicated from FIG. 14 and the
respective components identified by the same numers as in FIG.
14.
In essence FIG. 24B utilizes the basic button assembly of FIG. 14,
mounted on panel 235. Attached to the cylinder 89 is an electrical
wiper type contact 237 that is used to connect a respective point
on the resistance 113 to the bar 238. The terminations of the
resistor and the bar being connected to the bridge circuit shown in
FIG. 27. Thus, it is evident, that as a given button is depressed a
corresponding section of the resistance 113 becomes effective. As
will be seen in the circuit FIG. 27, this change in resistance
unbalances the bridge circuit - FIG. 27 - causing a corresponding
resistance to seek the balance point - which establish the criteria
for the values in columns B and C of FIG. 24A. The release
mechanism in FIG. 24C is identical to the release mechanism in FIG.
14 and performs an identical function. It should be noted that this
release mechanism is repeated in all columns A, B and C, and is
operated by the one solenoid identified as 104, 105, and 106.
An added feature for three columns A, B, C is the introduction of a
blocking device 240 - FIG. 24G - which is activated by a solenoid
239. The function of this blocking plate is to prevent a vote for
more than the allowable selection for which only that number of
vacancies is available. Thus, for example, if only five vacancies
are available - i.e., select no more than five candidates out of a
total available number of candidates say 143 - then at the
completion of the fifth selection by the voter the plate 240 will
be pulled automatically into place engaging the narrow slot with
the stem 55 - thus preventing further selections. It is obvious
that a registration of more than the allowable five selections will
invalidate the vote.
It is to be noted that the release mechanism FIG. 24B and 24C is
operated after each selection is registered in, thus permitting the
selection buttons to be used for the next candidate selection until
the full allowable complement of selections is completed.
FIG. 24F shows a drum 241 and the operating mechanism for it. The
drum carries successive numbers which indicate the number of
candidates that have already been selected by the voter for the
particular vacancies. The figures on the drum are shown exposed on
the panel 235. - FIG. 24A.
The drum 241 is mounted on a shaft 242 which also rigidly supports
a tooths wheel 243 and a spring 245. The shaft assembly is
supported by and operates in bearings 246. A pin 244 is mounted on
wheel 243 at a point determined by the maximum number of candidates
to be selected. At the limit of the selection, when the total
selections are registered in, the pin 244 actuates the moving blade
of contact 247 closing the contact and thru the circuitry causes
the drum to be reset - as will be shown later. The moving contact
of 247 is restrained to an open position by the spring 248.
The pawl 249 which is loosely pivoted to arm 250 at the point 251
causes a one digit indication on the drum 241 when the solenoid 254
is energized. The solenoid 254 is coupled loosely thru its core to
the arm at the point 255. The arm 250 is pivoted on the base plate
253 - which supports the entire subassembly - at the point 252. The
pawl 249 is held normally against the tooth wheel by means of
spring 257.
From the above the implementation of the advancing mechanism for
the indicating drum 241 is evident.
The resetting of the drum is achieved thru the contact 247 and
associated circuitry. This is a limiting condition for the
allowable number of candidates to be selected.
If, however, the voter does not select the complete number of
allowable candidates - whether by intent or oversight - and he
registered the final "Vote" - then the resetting of the advance
mechanism is accomplished by energizing the solenoid 255 thru the
circuitry. The core of the solenoid 255 carries a hook 256 which
engages the pawl 249 and thus releases the drum shaft assembly to
be reset to the original position. Upon completion the solenoid 255
is subsequently deenergized and the system restored for the next
voter.
FIG. 24E indicates the assembly of the button that may be
designated as the "select" button. In essence it is a duplicate of
the button assembly described in FIG. 24D except that in FIG. 24E
the button activates a switch 258 whose purpose it is to close the
battery supply circuit on the working mechanisms when all
conditions of selection have been set up.
Mounted on the panel 235 is a pilot light 259 whose function is to
indicate that the limiting number of candidates has been
established. This pilot light with its accessories is of the same
elements as shown in the previous figures.
In order to assure that only one digit in each of the columns A, B
and C, have been depressed, - i.e., in order to avoid an ambiguous
condition of having more than one button depressed, an interlock -
similar to that shown in FIG. 13 - (or FIG. 14) - is provided in
each column of buttons. (The interlock is not shown in FIG. 24 and
is understood to be included).
After each selection of the candidate and registration in the
totalizing circuit to the respective counters, a corresponding
pilot light 260, FIG. 25, illuminates and indicates in the
corresponding window 261 the number assigned to the specific
candidate as the voter's selection. The indicating lights are
suitably grouped on panels 262 - each panel representing a group of
99 candidates. Thus, before the final "Vote" button is depressed,
the voter can see exactly the candidates he selected for the
particular office.
It is understood, of course, that, as a matter of convenience, the
indicating panels FIG. 25 are conveniently located in the near
vicinity of the selector panel FIG. 24 so as to be in view of the
voter.
FIG. 26 shows a translating mechanism whose function it is that in
response to the digit selections of columns B and C it provides the
proper contact representing these two digits, and, in combination
with the contact obtained in FIG. 24D, energizes the proper relay
representing the whole 3-digit number and can thus activate the
proper corresponding counter to totalize the vote for the given
candidate.
In FIG. 26A, a carriage 263 is caused to ride vertically - up and
down - on a screw 264 as the screw is driven by a suitable motor
265 and clutch-brake device 266 thru the gear train 267-268, - gear
268 being mounted rigidly on the screw shaft 269; the shaft being
supported by an upper bearing 270 and by a lower bearing 271, - the
latter being at the center of a supporting gear 272. As shown, the
supporting gear 272 is simultaneously a platform for the following
mechanism, although specified design consideration may provide a
combination of platform and gear in separately identifiable details
and rigidly joined.
The platform-gear 272 is in turn driven by a suitable motor 273 and
clutch-brake mechanism 274 thru a gear 275 which is in mesh with
the platform gear 272. As will be noted the platform gear 272
operates in a forward and reverse direction in the horizontal plane
- (as distinguished from the vertical plane in which the carriage
263 operates).
Mounted on the platform 272 are two posts 276 and 277 which by
means of tongues as part of 276 and 277 guide the carriage 263 thru
two grooves that are part of the carriage. Thus the carriage is
prevented from any side motion and allows motion only in a vertical
plane.
The carriage, further detailed in FIG. 26 - carries within the
forward tip a pin 278 which is rigidly connected to a vertical pin
279, - the latter protruding thru the oblong hole 280 in the
carriage. The pin 279 further engages freely with a sliding plate
282 thru the hole 281. The sliding plate 282 provides an oblong
hole 283 which surrounds with ample clearance the screw 264 thus
allowing the slider 282 to move freely without interference with
the screw. Two pins 285 and 286 are rigidly attached to the
carriage 263, - and another pin 284 is rigidly attached to the
slider 282. A spring 287 is so placed between the pins 285, 286 and
284 that the pin 278 is normally on an inward position with
reference to the carriage 263. The slider 282 is guided in a slot
288 incorporated in the carriage 263. Thus, as the slider is pushed
forward the pin 278 is pushed forward - and conversely the pin is
retracted as the slider is retracted under the action of the spring
287.
Mounted on the platform 272 is also a hammer-platten 289 which
extends the full height of the vertical travel of the carriage 263.
The hammer-platten 289 operates radially about a fulcrum 292 and
pivoted in a bearing 290 above and in a bearing hole 291 in the
platform 272. The platten 289 is held in normal position against a
pin 293 by means of a spring 294 which is retained against the body
of the platform.
An arm 295 and a tip 297 are extended from the platten at a
convenient point near the surface of the platform 272. As a
solenoid 296 - placed near 295 is energized the platten deflects in
a direction that its hammer strikes the slider 282 and drives the
pin 278 forward. Simultaneously the tip 297 activates a switch 298
(which is normally open) whose function will be evident in the
overall circuit. As the carriage 263 descends to the null position
near the platform it activates a switch 299 (which is normally open
when the carriage releases it). The function of the latter will be
evident in the general circuit.
A circular panel - FIG. 26A - is so located about the carriage that
the axis of the panel circle coincides with the axis of the screw.
The panel is indicated as 300 in FIG. 26A, - and is shown in
developed form in FIG. 26A. Located in the panel 300 are 100 holes
301; - of these 10 holes are equally spaced vertically and 10 rows
of these vertical lines are horizontally - thus making up the 100
holes. Behind these holes are contact switches 302 (normally open)
- so placed that when the tip 278 penetrates these holes (as the
solenoid 296 operates the platten 289) the tip closes the switch
302. Hence the carriage must be adequately located so that the pin
278 will close the proper contact 302 corresponding to the voter's
selected candidate choice.
The horizontal and vertical positioning of the carriage 263 is
accomplished independently thru a bridge balancing circuit shown in
FIG. 27.
FIG. 26 shows the portions of the bridge that are connected with
the movement of the carriage. Thus, a resistor 303 is supported in
the block 277 vertically. The resistor is divided into 10 sections
corresponding to the 10 position points. A wiper 304 is attached to
the carriage 263. The wiper traverses the resistor. The carriage
will travel until a balance is obtained in the bridge circuit FIG.
27.
Similarly an electrical wiper 305 is attached to the moving
platform 272. The wiper traverses the resistor 306. The platform
will rotate until a balance of the bridge FIG. 27 is obtained.
Thus, the exact point - selected by the voter - will be established
to secure the proper total for the voter's candidate.
When the proper point on the panel 300 is established - and the pin
278 activates the switch 302, - the combination of the switch 302
which determines the digits in columns B and C together with the
switch in column A will activate a relay that will cause the proper
counter to totalize the vote for the proper candidate.
The slider 282 is allowed to return instantly as soon as pin 278
closes contact 302. This is accomplished by the following
mechanism. A subslider bar 307 - (sliding part way underneath the
slider 282) - contains a shaft internally 308 which carries rigidly
a tip 310, a spring 309 and an outside arm 311. The spring 309
maintains the tip 310 in a vertical position and at the same time
the arm 311 so inclined that as the subslider 307 moves forward,
the arm 311 impinges against the block 277 in such a manner that
the shaft 308 turns in a direction to move the tip 310 radially
thus releasing the forward force on the slider 282 and hence the
slider 282 together with its pin 278 are forced to return to the
original position under the action of the spring 287.
Hence, the platten hammer 289 actually advances the slide 282 thru
the intermediary mechanism above described, so that while the
platten hammer 289 may still press on the subslider 307, - the
slide 282 will be released and the subsequent operations can
continue without interference of the pin 278 within the hole
301.
As the platten is released thru the subsequent circuitry, the
subslider returns to normal position again engaging the slider and
thus be ready for the next operation.
FIG. 27 shows the circuit used in obtaining the roper operation of
the driving motor in order to establish the exact setting for the
operation of the requires switch 302 in FIG. 26, - and hence for
the proper totalizing of the vote for the selected candidate. This
circuit represents the requirement for each motor necessary for
each axis.
In the diagram, the items 113 and 238 are the same shown in FIG.
24. These represent one digit columns. Similarly items 303 (or 306)
and 304 (or 305) are the same items as shown in FIG. 26. Further,
items 289, 295, 296, 266 (or 274) and 265 (or 273) are the same
items shown in FIG. 26.
Additionally, the resistors 312 and 313 are equal resistors that
complete the bridge network. The bridge detector is, for
convenience, a polarized relay identified as 314, in which the
detecting coil is 315, - the common movable contact 316, - and the
two fixed contacts 317 and 318. The common contact 316 will deflect
in either direction to make contact with either 317 or 318
depending on the direction of unbalance of the bridge network. The
bridge network is energized by a suitable source of voltage -
represented as a battery 319.
Each of the contacts 317 and 318 are connected to a corresponding
relay coil 320 and 321 respectively. Relay coil 320 operating
switches 322 and 323, - while relay coil 321 operates switches 324
and 325; the normal position of these switches is as shown. The
interconnection between the motor 265, - clutch-brake 266, - the
solenoid 296, - the hammer platten 289-295, and the relays and
bridge circuit is as shown. When the function of the platten 289 is
complete the excitation on the solenoid 296 is subsequently
interrupted thru the overall circuitry.
From the diagram FIG. 27 it can be seen that as the bridge network
is unbalanced in such direction that the motor drives the carriage
(or platform) in one direction - (say positive direction) - then as
the bridge network is unbalanced in the opposite direction - (say
negative direction) - the alternate relay is energized and the
motor drives in the direction opposite to the positive.
Furthermore, when balance of the bridge network is obtained - both
relays 320 and 321 are deenergized - and in this condition the
motor is stopped - the clutch-brake mechanism places a brake on the
operating shaft and holds it and the platten causes the pin slider
263-278 to close contact 302. (FIG. 26A)
A balance condition of the bridge network is obtained at (a) when
the precise contact position for totalization of vote is obtained,
and (b) when the carriage and platform are in the neutral
(originally normal) position.
FIG. 28 is an intermediary relay panel similar to that shown in
FIG. 17.
Each of the positions consists of a relay 326 with two SPST
contacts 327, each relay representing a specific candidate. One of
these contacts is used to activate the corresponding counter for
totalizing - similar to that of FIG. 17, - and the operating system
is brought into simultaneous function with FIG. 17 thru the
totalizer.
The other contact is used to initiate the activation of the relay
thru the contact 302 and to then hold the activation in parallel
with the relays shown in FIG. 17.
Thus, the totalization is achieved with the activation of "Vote"
button and simultaneously with the totalization of the vote for all
candidates on the voting panel.
FIG. 28 shows two panels, - 328 and 329, - one for relays numbered
from 0 to 99, - while the other is from 100 to 199. The selection
of the requisite panel is achieved by the digit selected in column
A - FIG. 24, - while the selection of the specific relay is
achieved thru the mechanism shown in FIG. 26, - one such mechanism
for each panel.
The relays are released - and totalization is completed thru the
totalizer FIG. 18.
FIG. 29 are the panels containing the counters for the respective
candidates.
These panels correspond to the two panels in FIG. 28 - the counters
being activated thru the action of the relays on panel 28.
The assembly of the counter panels as well as the interconnection
of the counter solenoids is the same as that shown for FIG. 19, -
and the totalization of these counters is accomplished
simultaneously with those of FIG. 19.
Finally, the record obtained from these counters - of FIG. 29 - is
the same as that obtained in FIG. 20A. And the obtaining of this
record may be made concurrent with those obtained for FIG. 19.
The overall interconnecting circuit for the special condition of
selection of a relatively small number of candidates from a very
large number of available applicants is indicated in FIG. 30.
All of the components previously described are identified in FIG.
30. The circuit diagram is presented for one circuit for purpose of
analysis, - all other circuits being similarly treated.
The sequence of events can be summarized as follows - in this
special case of a large number of candidates for one office:
a. As digit button in column A FIG. 24 is depressed, an exciting
circuit is established for the proper bridge network that operates
the corresponding 100 series.
b. As the digits in column B and C FIG. 24 are depressed they
complete the corresponding bridge networks and set the bridge
networks for the exact positioning of the carriage to activate the
contact 302.
c. As the proper counter relay is activated thru contact 302, the
digit buttons columns A, B and C are released with the return of
the carriage, and ready for the next candidate selection;
simultaneously the drum 241 is advanced to show the number of
candidates chosen, - and also a light 260 is illuminated on panels
FIG. 25 to show the candidate selected.
d. Multiple button depressions are prevented by the blocking
mechanism.
e. When the vote is completed and totalized, the drum is released
to return to zero - all the pilot lights are extinguished and the
system returned to normal condition.
The system operates simultaneously with all other candidate
selections and from the same "Vote" button.
The large multiplicity of candidates that may be eligible for
particular offices - as well as the possible large number of
vacancies to be filled in a given election leads to a possibility
of a requirement for a very large and perhaps cumbersome voting
panel.
FIG. 31 shows a form of voting unit that makes possible a rather
small and compact voting unit, that will accommodate a large number
of candidates and a multiplicity of office vacancies, while at the
same time bringing to easy view and understanding to the voter of
the eligible candidates and issues to be voted upon.
In FIG. 31, the vertical panel 330 shows a replaceable printed list
of all candidates for the various offices to which the candidates
aspire, as well as all issues. These sheets are printed in advance
and apended to the basic panel.
Each office is cited, - each issue identified, - and the names of
all candidates for the specific offices are listed. Alongside each
candidate is a number showing the button or combination of buttons
to be depressed to vote for a particular candidate. As an added
advantage, the various office areas can be shown in different color
areas - or color stripes; similarly the buttons can be arranged in
corresponding area groupings with the same color arrangements.
The vote selection buttons for each candidate are shown in the
horizontally inclined panel 331. The designations on the buttons
correspond to the designations for the candidates shown on the
printed sheet. The designations may be a number, - or a combination
of number and letter, - or both in combination with color etc. The
button areas may also have the same color as the areas on the
candidate list.
Thus, a voter can find his preferred candidate on the printed
sheet, and using the designation shown he presses the corresponding
button. At the conclusion of his selection of all candidates and
issues, he presses the vote button and his function is complete.
All other functions are automatic and are performed without the
control or knowledge of the voter.
The horizontal vote selection panel also contains the registration
device as above described.
The entire voting unit can thus be made compact, intelligent, and
simple to manipulate. Decisive advantages are thus achieved in the
voting process.
It will be noted that the process of automatically totalizing the
votes at the precinct level presents enormous advantages in
obtaining expeditiously, accurately and economically a final vote
count. It presents a potential of reducing the count of the vote by
a possible factor of 1,000 or greater. Assuming a precinct to be
assigned a potential voting population of 1,000 then the obtainable
final precinct count and record instantly would be 1.
This factor is particularly significant in populated areas where
the number of items to be counted - whether automatically or
otherwise - would be 1,000 per 1,000,000 - instead of
1,000,000.
In less populated areas the results obtained at the precinct stage
may be adequate to obtain a final count, since the final count from
the limited number of precincts can be reasonably quickly added
either with or without further mechanization.
However, in more densely populated areas, where the results of
thousands of precincts complicated by a large candidate population,
the problem of the final count of all of these precincts may become
a factor to be contended with.
The following implementation of this invention provides an
automatic means for quickly obtaining a final vote count from all
precincts and for each candidate.
FIG. 6 described above shows a form of a general panel layout for
the candidate and issue counters - as well as the counters for the
additional pertinent data.
For the purpose of a final automatic count of all precincts a
special design of the digital drums in each counter provides the
essential simple element of this implementation. This design is
shown in FIG. 32.
FIG. 32A shows typical digital drums that are provided for the
purpose. In this figure, item 332 is the basic drum on the central
facial circumference of which are projected the digital numbers 0
to 9 inclusive at 36.degree. angles. The face of the drum 333 is
divided into four convenient circumferential sections, each of
which sections being made available for a suitable tip 334, the
combination of which for the four sections will define the given
number in binary code form; - the tips 334 being placed
conveniently alongside the given number, - the number of such tips
and their disposition in the four circumferential sectors will
signify the binary presentation for the particular number.
Both the number and the binary tips are projected beyond the face
of the panel - as shown in FIG. 32B - so that a record of both may
be obtained simultaneously.
The manner in which the digital numbers are to be recorded on a
suitable card has been described above in FIGS. 6 and 20.
The binary tips representing each of the digits are provided in a
form suitable for adaptation in subsequent corresponding
summarizing and printing computers.
Thus, the binary tips may be made in the form of small magnets. At
the same time the card on which the data will be printed will be
provided with a suitable magnetic material along one of the
surfaces. Hence, while the printed record is obtained of the
digital number, the corresponding binary tips will magnetize
corelated areas of the magnetic surface. In this manner both the
digital number and the corresponding binary magnetic record will be
obtained simultaneously.
In this case the available final card record from the precinct will
be prepared automatically for the final totalization and printed
record thereof in a programmatic computer which is designed to
perform with magnetic pick-offs.
The binary tips may be made in the form of small piercing mandrels
- such that when the digital number is recorded the mandrels will
automatically pierce suitable holes in the card that will represent
the binary representation for the given digit.
In the latter case, the final precinct card will be prepared
automatically for adaptation to a programmatic computer which is
designed to perform either with electromechanical contacts that
will operate thru the pierced holes or with appropriate
photoelectric and amplifying circuits that will serve as pick-offs.
The programmatic computer will totalize the results of all
precincts for each candidate and issue and provide a printed record
thereof.
The binary tips may still have another form. They may be designed
to provide a suitable printed dot that will be printed
simultaneously with and in the same manner as the digital
number.
In this case, the pick-off for the computer programmer will be a
form of photoelectric device with an adequate amplifier.
Another form of matrix for the digits is shown in FIGS. 33A and
33B. As shown the face of the digital drum 335 is divided into 10
circumferential bands 336, and a distinguishing tip 338 is placed
in successive bands opposite the digits 337. Thus, the
distinguishing feature in this case is not binary but displacement
of the tip in a horizontal direction.
As in the binary case the tips 338 may take different forms
depending on their adaptation to a given computer.
Thus, the fundamental approach on this invention is the basic
affirmation of the digital drums of the counter so that both the
digital number as well as its corelated matrix code will be
recorded instantly simultaneously on a suitable card in the
precinct directly from the booths totalizing machine. In this
manner the card will be automatically prepared and available for
complete automatic totalization of the vote for each candidate and
issue by means of a corresponding programmatic computer or the
equivalent.
Any manner of affirmation of the matrix tips lies within the scope
of, and does not circumvent, the intent of this invention.
Likewise, any affirmation of the drums - whether in cylindrical
form or in flat circular dial form - or any other form, - lies
within the scope of this invention and none circumvent or depart
from the intent of this invention.
Each section representing each counter on the counter totalizing
panel will then present both the totalized vote for a given
candidate or issue as well as the assigned number to this category
that will correspond to that shown on the voting panel, - as
illustrated in FIG. 34. For convenience the matrix code shown in
FIG. 34 is binary.
An added feature of this area is the provision of cutting mandrels
on the counter panel that will pierce predetermined coded areas 339
in the card. The code will identify a candidate or issue and is
intended to facilitate the final totalization process when the
respective card sections of the various precincts are separated
from the general card and placed together for final processing in
the computer either by automatic feed or hand feed.
The respective sections in the general card will appear as shown in
FIG. 35.
It is to be noted that the system outlined in this invention is
equally adaptable to general public opinion polling.
In this case the various designations required in a poll for
analysis can be designated by the various numbered positions. These
may include the specific public issues on which a poll is taken,
and various characteristics of the voters involved in the poll.
Among such characteristics may be affiliation with political
parties, color, national origin, age groups, educational status,
earning status, religious inclinations, and such other factors that
may be of interest at a particular poll.
The extent to which the various equipments may be used will depend
a great deal on the extent to which the polling station may be set
up for a contemplated voting population as well as the extent of
information required for the poll.
Should personal identification not be required, the registration
device may be shunted and thus made inapplicable. Alternatively a
blank card may be used with a minimum of reference data, - as for
example citizen or foreigner, or other designations.
A mode of obtaining the final count from all precincts
automatically is indicated schematically in FIG. 36.
In FIG. 36, - item 340 represents a stack of cards from all
precincts, - as in FIG. 34, that show the precinct totals for a
given candidate or issue. Item 341 represents an advancing
mechanism that advances one card at a time to an accounting
position 342 at which point a suitable system of pick-offs
represented by 344 are located. When the card is in position a
particular pick-off in each column is energized which in turn
energizes a corresponding solenoid 346 in a corresponding digital
column of an adding machine 345 that has digital columns
corresponding to that shown on the card. The adding machine 345
will then register the total precinct number of votes by means of
the registering mechanism 347 and will indicate the total in the
total area 348 as well as record the card total number on the tape
349. At the end of the stack of cards - or at any convenient point
- the totalized number of all votes for the various precincts can
be registered on the tape - either manually - or automatically. The
precinct cards are advanced automatically by the succeeding card
and at each advance the registration of the machine is made
automatically.
All of the components shown in FIG. 36, - except the card 342, -
are generally known and standard in the trade and are therefore not
detailed herein.
The FIG. 36 serves to show the adaptation of the card of FIG. 34 to
the mode for total count of the vote.
To summarize, this invention provides a complete automatic
expeditious system for voting beginning with the identification and
registration of the voter at the time of vote thru the complete
count of the vote.
The implementation of the system involves the application of new
and novel devices and approaches, as well as the combination of
well-known apparatus, that make possible the automatization of the
various stages of operation. This automatization reduces to an
absolute minimum the demands upon the voter, and simplifies the
actual mode of voting. At the same time the subsequent processes, -
namely, - individual recording of the vote, - totalization of the
overall precinct vote, - the record of the total precinct vote and
the production of this record in a form suitable for obtaining the
total vote by means of adequate computers, - and all functions
associated therewith, - are obtained instantly, economically, with
an absolute minimum of paper requirement. These functions are
completely beyond the control and knowledge of the voter.
Among the unique and novel elements used and incorporated in the
implementation of this invention are the following:
1. The use of a citizens identification card in the voting
process.
2. The provision of a voters identification card that;
a. utilizes the citizens identification card (1 - above),
b. provides for identification as to locale (state - address -
precinct),
c. provides a matrix for automatic corelation to the specific
precinct registration machines,
d. is designed to permit the printing of the voter's pertinent data
(name - address, etc.) on a paper at the time of registration for
voting.
3. The remote control box which permits the precinct attending
personnel to assign a booth to the voter for voting, and the
control by the attending personnel of the registration mechanism to
permit the voter to proceed with vote, and to prevent repetitive
voting.
4. A unique and novel voters registration machine that;
a. allows the voter to register only when so released by attending
personnel,
b. permits the voter to vote only upon proper registration with the
voters identification card - interconnected thru the circuitry,
c. prints the voters identification on paper,
d. automatically releases the voter identification card when vote
is completed and totalized,
e. advances the paper automatically when vote is completed,
f. registrants vote is not visible, kept secret, and unrelated to
actual vote.
5. A unique, new and novel voting panel - used either in
horizontally inclined position or in vertical position that
embodies;
a. voting buttons and/or switches of the push and/or rotary type in
combination with - where required - suitable interlocking
mechanisms by means of which the voter can select his choice of
candidates to the maximum permissible of all available candidates
without invalidating his vote.
b. interlocking mechanisms that provide the selection of one
candidate out of a group - or a number of candidates out of a
larger group,
c. the ability to change a selected candidate - when an error is
detected by the voter - without destroying his complete
"ballot",
d. the ability to actually view the entire slate of selected
candidates and issues - thru the use of the pilot lights - before
actually registering the vote - i.e., depressing the vote
button,
e. the ability to record a large number of candidates for any
office from which a relatively small number are to be selected, -
the mechanism for same being compact and unique,
f. the provision for a write-in vote, the mechanism of which is
interlocked with the apparent registered candidates,
g. the automatic removal of the registered write-in vote so that it
is not evident to the subsequent voter,
h. the complete elimination of a paper or card or similar
ballot,
i. the provision for the listing of candidates or issues on the
voting panel next to the selection button - or the posting of the
complete slate of candidates and issues with identifying numbers
and color schemes on a suitable paper or card which is placed in
the vicinity of the voting panel while the voting buttons show the
numbers and color corresponding to those shown on the complete
ballot,
j. the ability of the complete voting panel clearing itself
automatically after the vote and registration thereof is
completed.
6. A unique, new and novel recording unit which automatically
provides a simple record of the actual voting selection of each
voter on a roll of paper. The vote is not related to - and can not
be identified with the actual voter, - and is hence secret and
secure. Where required by law, this provides a simple inexpensive,
non-voluminous method of having a voter record which can be used
subsequently for recheck or recount if desired. The use of this
recorder does not exclude the use - if desired - of an IBM type
card punching equipment - and IBM punch card.
7. A unique and novel totalizing mechanism which instantly and
accurately totalizes the vote for all booths in a precinct, for the
each candidate and issue. One such mechanism serving all booths in
the precinct and in combination with the recording and totalizing
machines.
8. A unique and novel totalizing machine consisting of a series of
digital counters corresponding to the numbers of the candidates and
issues from which a complete record of the vote may be
automatically instantly obtained at any time - and at the end of
the voting time - of the status of the vote in relation to time and
place.
9. Unique and novel digital drums in the counters that contain a
matrix of the digit as well as the digit from which a suitable
record of the totalized vote can be obtained on a suitable card
both in digital printed form as well as in adequate matrix suitable
for totalization of the entire vote from all precincts.
10. A unique, new and novel precinct totalized record for each
candidate or issue on a card - automatically obtained - that is
suitable for subsequent use in a suitable computer to obtain the
total vote from all precincts. The card embodies:
a. A printed total digital record for each candidate or issue.
b. A printed record of the number corresponding to the candidate or
issue.
c. A suitable matrix of the corresponding digital record that is
used for a final total vote registration.
d. A suitable matrix of the corresponding number identifying the
candidate or issue.
e. A peripheral perforated matrix identifying the candidate or
issue that will facilitate final totalization and prevent
errors.
11. A unique candidate selector system used in conjunction with the
special selecting section for the special condition where a large
number of candidates are registered for a limited number of
offices. This system embodies a unique digital selecting controller
to obtain the exact position that identifies the candidate.
12. A novel unit for a combination registering and voting cabinet,
that is portable, simple to operate, and easily installed in a
booth.
Each and all of the above, and in suitable combination and
interconnection with each other, are claimed as new and novel as
individual elements and as components of a voting system which
encompasses the entire process of voting and/or polling. The system
involves voter identification, voter registration, - ballot
presentation, - voting method, - vote totalization and final vote
count. In short the implementation of the entire and complete
voting process is new and novel in a complete voting system.
This invention of the voting system and its implementation with the
new and novel components results in great voting economy - in
expedient (almost instantaneous) delivery of vote count, - in
secrecy of ballot, - in security of vote, - in elimination of
unnecessary stacks of paper and card records, - of ease of use - of
ease of installation, storage, and transport - and of quick and
easy interchangeability of component elements.
Although this invention is described with a certain degree of
particularity, it is understood that the present disclosure has
been made by way of example and that numerous changes in the
details of construction, in general arrangement, or in sequence of
circuitry may be resorted to without departing from the spirit, the
essence and the scope of the invention as hereinafter claimed. No
claim is made to the particularity of standard commercially
available parts, components and materials except as they may be
particularly interrelated in the fulfillment of the intent and
function of this invention.
* * * * *