U.S. patent number 3,714,004 [Application Number 05/094,353] was granted by the patent office on 1973-01-30 for method and apparatus for cathodic protection.
This patent grant is currently assigned to Continental Oil Company. Invention is credited to David W. Barnett, Olen L. Riggs, Jr..
United States Patent |
3,714,004 |
Riggs, Jr. , et al. |
January 30, 1973 |
METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR CATHODIC PROTECTION
Abstract
An improved apparatus and method for cathodically protecting
surfaces exposed to a corrosive environment utilizing a
predetermined number of anodes, each anode being connected to a
power source adapted to supply a predetermined polarizing current
thereto, and each anode being connected to a current controller
adapted to supply an adjustingly, controlled polarizing current
thereto. The polarizing current supplied by the current controller
to any one anode is adjustingly controlled in response to the anode
potential of that one anode with respect to the protected surface,
the cathodic protection system being adapted to sequentially
provide electrical continuity between each anode and the current
controller and between the remaining anodes and the power source in
such a manner that polarization of the system is obtained and
maintained utilizing a minimum overall power consumption and in a
manner maintaining a predetermined polarization over substantially
the entire area of the protected surface.
Inventors: |
Riggs, Jr.; Olen L. (Houston,
TX), Barnett; David W. (Chute, TX) |
Assignee: |
Continental Oil Company (Ponca
City, OK)
|
Family
ID: |
22244662 |
Appl.
No.: |
05/094,353 |
Filed: |
December 2, 1970 |
Current U.S.
Class: |
205/727;
204/196.03 |
Current CPC
Class: |
C23F
13/04 (20130101) |
Current International
Class: |
C23F
13/04 (20060101); C23F 13/00 (20060101); C23f
013/00 () |
Field of
Search: |
;204/147,196 |
References Cited
[Referenced By]
U.S. Patent Documents
Primary Examiner: Tung; T.
Claims
What is claimed is:
1. A cathodic protection apparatus for obtaining and maintaining
polarization of a protected surface in a corrosive environment, the
protected surface being maintained cathodic, comprising:
a plurality of anode means, each anode means being disposed at a
predetermined position with respect to the protected surface;
a current controller means adapted to selectively provide an
adjustingly controlled, polarizing current to one of said anode
means;
a power supply means adapted to selectively provide a predetermined
polarizing current to the remaining of said anode means;
a reference electrode means mounted in the vicinity of each of said
anode means and generating an electrical control signal
corresponding to the passivation condition of said protected
surface, said current controller means being adapted to receive
said electrical control signal and to adjustingly control the
polarizing current provided by the current controller in response
thereto; and
a switch means in electrical communication with said plurality of
anode means, said power supply means, said current controller means
and said reference electrode means, whereby said switch means is
adapted to selectively and sequentially provide electrical
continuity between said remaining anode means and said power supply
means and to provide electrical continuity between said one anode
means, said reference electrode means in the vicinity of said one
anode means and said current controller means.
2. A system of claim 1 in which the reference electrode means is
located within the area of the throwing power of its corresponding
anode means for which the passivation condition is being
measured.
3. A system of claim 1 in which the plurality of anode means,
controller means and switch means are placed and cooperate such
that the passivation condition encompasses substantially the entire
area of the surface being protected in the corrosive
environment.
4. A system of claim 1 in which the controller means and switching
means are adapted to operate in a cyclic manner with the period of
time for each step in the cycle being adjusted according to a
predetermined program.
5. A system of claim 1 in which the controller means and switching
means are adapted to operate in a cyclic manner with the period of
time for each step in the cycle and the overall cycle being
adjusted in response to a control signal indicative of parameters
of the passivation system.
6. The apparatus of claim 1 which is adapted to maintain a minimum
overall power consumption and passivation condition for a large
complex surface in a corrosive environment.
7. A method of protecting a surface by obtaining and maintaining
polarization of the surface in a corrosive environment to maintain
the surface cathodic with a minimum overall power consumption and
passivation condition comprising:
disposing a plurality of anode means at a predetermined position
with respect to the protected surface;
adapting a current controller means to selectively and adjustingly
provide and control a polarizing current to one of said anode
means;
adapting a power supply means to selectively provide a
predetermined polarizing current to the remaining of said anode
means;
mounting a reference electrode means in the vicinity of each of
said anode means and generating an electrical control signal
corresponding to the passivation condition of said protected
surface;
adapting said current controller means to receive said electrical
control signal and to adjustingly control the polarizing current
provided by the current controller means in response thereto;
and
connecting by a switch means said plurality of anode means, said
power supply means, said current controller means and said
reference electrode means, whereby said switch means selectively
and sequentially provides electrical continuity between said
remaining anode means and said power supply means and provides
electrical continuity between said one anode means, said reference
electrode means in the vicinity of said one anode means and said
current controller means.
Description
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
1. Field of the Invention
This invention relates generally to improvements in cathodic
protection systems and, more particularly, but not by way of
limitation, to a cathodic protection apparatus utilizing a
predetermined number of anodes wherein the polarizing current is
supplied to each anode sequentially by a power source and a current
controller.
2. Description of the Prior Art
In the past, cathodic protection apparatus has been proposed
wherein the current or power supply to the power electrode or, in
other words, the anode, was controlled to some extent via a
reference half-cell, control circuitry. In some of the systems of a
nature mentioned above, the power supply to the anode was placed or
switched to an "on" or an "off" position as a function of
information supplied via the reference half-cell. In some other
systems of this general nature, the polarizing current was adjusted
to some degree and in some manner as a function of the information
supplied via the reference electrode.
In the past, the above mentioned systems have provided adequate
solutions to various problems in the art of cathodic protection,
however, it has been found that when attempting to protect
particularly large or geometrically complex structures, most of
these systems have been proven inadequate from an overall
protection, control apparatus investment, and operating cost
viewpoint. The cathodic protection systems proposed in the past
have generally been found to utilize or consume a large total
amount of power to obtain and maintain a particular polarization,
and in some other instances these cathodic protection systems have
been found inadequate to provide a desired protection over the
entire area of the surface being protected.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
The present invention contemplates a cathodic protection apparatus
for obtaining and maintaining a predetermined polarization of a
protected surface in a corrosive environment, having a
predetermined number of anodes adapted to cooperate with the
protected surface which is maintained cathodic, in such a manner
that the predetermined polarization is obtained and maintained
utilizing a minimum total power consumption and such that a
predetermined polarization is established and maintained over
substantially the entire area of the protected surface. Each anode
is disposed at a predetermined position with respect to the
protected surface, and each anode is adapted to cooperatingly
establish an anode potential between each anode and the protected
surface. A power supply is connected to each anode and is adapted
to provide a predetermined polarizing current to the anodes
connected thereto. The cathodic protection apparatus includes a
potential control which is adapted to selectively indicate the
anode potential of each anode, and to provide an output control
signal proportional to one of the anode potentials compared to a
predetermined set potential. A current controller is connected to
each anode and is adapted to provide an adjustingly, controlled
polarizing current to each anode connected thereto. The current
controller is also connected to a portion of the potential control,
and is adapted to receive the output control signal from the
potential control. The current controller adjustingly controls the
polarizing current provided by the current controller in response
to the output signal of the potential control. A switching control
is interposed between each anode and the power supply and between
each anode and the current controller. The switching control is
adapted to selectively and sequentially provide electrical
continuity between one of the anodes and the current controller and
electrical continuity between the remaining of the anodes and the
power supply, such that sequentially, the current controller
provides controlled polarizing current to one of the anodes and the
power supply provides polarizing current to the remaining
anodes.
An object of the invention is to provide a cathodic protection
apparatus for protecting a surface exposed to a corrosive
environment utilizing a minimum total power consumption.
Another object of the invention is to provide a cathodic protection
apparatus for protecting surfaces exposed to a corrosive
environment wherein a predetermined polarization is controllingly
maintained over substantially the entire area of the protected
surface.
One other object of the invention is to provide a cathodic
protection apparatus for protecting surfaces exposed to a corrosive
environment which utilizes a minimum number of protection
units.
A further object of the invention is to provide a cathodic
protection apparatus for protecting relatively large surface areas
exposed to a corrosive environment.
A still further object of the invention is to provide a cathodic
protection apparatus for protecting surfaces exposed to a corrosive
environment wherein the protected surface has a relatively complex
geometrical shape.
One other object of the invention is to provide a cathodic
protection apparatus for protecting surfaces exposed to a corrosive
environment which is economical in construction and operation.
Other objects and advantages of the invention will be evident from
the following detailed description when read in conjunction with
the accompanying drawings which illustrate various embodiments of
the invention.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
FIG. 1 is a schematic-diagrammatical view of a cathodic protection
apparatus constructed in accordance with the invention.
FIG. 2 is a schematic-diagrammatical view of a modified cathodic
protection apparatus, similar to the cathodic protection apparatus
of FIG. 1.
FIG. 3 is a graph showing Current Density (MA/CM.sup.2) versus Time
(minutes) relating to a particular test specimen cathodically
protected in accordance with the present invention.
DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
Referring to the drawings in general and to FIG. 1 in particular,
shown schematically and diagrammatically therein is a cathodic
protection apparatus or system 10 adapted to cathodically protect a
surface, designated in FIG. 1 by the general reference 12, and
referred to below as the protected surface 12. An electro-chemical
type of cathodic protection basically relates to a system whereby
an electric current is supplied to an anode emersed in an
electrolyte and to a surface which is to be protected, wherein the
protected surface potential is maintained cathodic, thereby
reducing the corrosive effect of the electrolyte on the protected
surface. Cathodic protection of this general type is well known in
the art, and a detailed description thereof is not necessary
herein.
More particularly, the cathodic protection apparatus 10 is adapted
to obtain and maintain polarization within a predetermined range
over substantially the entire area of the protected surface 12 in
contact with a corrosive fluid or environment, referred to
sometimes below as an electrolyte and designated in FIG. 1 by the
general reference 14.
The term polarization is known in the art generally as a condition
wherein corrosion is controlled by use of an electric current to
oppose the electrolytic tendency of a metal to corrode (replace
lost electrons).
It should be particularly noted that the protected surface 12 has
been shown diagrammatically in FIG. 1 as having a circular shape
merely for illustrative purposes, and for the purpose of clarity of
description. It should therefore, be noted that the cathodic
protection apparatus 10 of the present invention is particularly
useful for cathodically protecting large surface areas, surfaces
having an irregular geometrical configuration or, in general,
surfaces wherein the anode potential required to maintain a
predetermined current density varies with respect to different
positions on the protected surface 12, as will be made apparent
below.
The cathodic protection apparatus 10 includes a predetermined
number of power electrodes and, more particularly, as shown in FIG.
1, two power electrodes 16 and 18, referred to below as the anodes
16 and 18, are disposed in the electrolyte 14. It should be noted,
that in a particular application utilizing the cathodic protection
system of the present invention, more anodes may be required, and
the two anodes 16 and 18 are shown in FIG. 1 merely for
illustrative purposes. The factors considered in determining the
precise number of anodes to be utilized in a particular application
will be described more fully below.
The anodes 16 and 18 are spaced a predetermined distance apart or,
more particularly, the anodes 16 and 18 are disposed at
predetermined positions with respect to the protected surface 12.
The spacing of the anodes 16 and 18 over the protected surface 12
and the number of anodes utilized in a particular cathodic
protection system will depend on such considerations as, for
example, the material to be protected, that is the composition of
the protected surface 12, the "throwing power" of the anodes, the
geometry or geometrical configuration of the protected surface, the
corrosivity of the particular electrolyte 14 and the temperature of
the electrolyte 14.
It is well known in the art that an anode operating in a particular
cathodic protection system has a determinable "throwing power" with
respect to the particular cathodic protection system. The term
"throwing power" is generally used in the art to indicate the
ability of a given electrode or anode to cover or to maintain and
hold polarized a given surface area in contact with a particular
electrolyte or corrosive environment.
In the cathodic protection apparatus 10, the anodes 16 and 18 are
disposed with respect to the protected surface 12 such that the
throwing power of each anode 16 and 18 cooperates to establish and
maintain a predetermined polarization over substantially the entire
area of the protected surface 12. For example, the anodes 16 and 18
may be disposed such that the throwing power of the anode 16
slightly overlaps the throwing power of the anode 18, and thus the
two anodes 16 and 18 cooperate to protect the entire area of the
protected surface 12 in contact with the electrolyte 14.
In most instances, sufficient empirical data is available to
determine the spacing or placement of the anodes over the protected
surface. In other instances, however, it may be necessary to
establish the empirical data with respect to a particular cathodic
protection system in order to determine the spacing in accordance
with the above described cooperation. The determination of the
number of anodes and the determination of the spacing of the anodes
in a particular application, as described above, will be made more
apparent below.
The cathodic protection apparatus 10, as shown in FIG. 1, also
includes a predetermined number of reference electrodes, each
reference electrode being disposed in the electrolyte 14, and one
of the reference electrodes being disposed and adapted to cooperate
with one of the anodes 16 or 18 in the operation of the cathodic
protection apparatus 10. The reference electrodes are constructed
of a material which is located in the e.m.f. table at a lower or
more noble position than the material of the protected surface 12,
and may be, for example, a calomel electrode when cooperating or
being utilized in a system wherein the protected surface 12 is a
stainless steel.
More particularly, as shown in FIG. 1, two reference electrodes 20
and 22 are disposed in the electrolyte 14. The reference electrode
20 is disposed with respect to the protected surface 12 and with
respect to the anode 16 to indicate the anode potential of the
anode 16 with respect to the protected surface 12, and to cooperate
to control the polarizing current being provided to the anode 16
during one portion of the operation of the cathodic protection
apparatus 10, as will be described in more detail below. The
reference electrode 22, as shown in FIG. 1, is disposed with
respect to the protected surface 12 and with respect to the anode
18 to indicate the potential of the anode 18 with respect to the
protected surface 12, and to cooperate in the cathodic protection
apparatus 10 to control the polarizing current being provided to
the anode 18 during one portion of the operation of the cathodic
protection apparatus 10, as will be described in more detail
below.
Each anode 16 and 18 is electrically connected to the positive side
of a power source or, more particularly as shown in FIG. 1, a
central power supply 24 via a two-position switch 26. The positions
of the switch 26 are designated in FIG. 1 as A and B and, as shown
in FIG. 1, the switch 26 has been positioned in the A position
thereof.
The anode 16 is connected to the B-position of the switch 26 via a
conductor 28, and the anode 18 is connected to the A-position of
the switch 26 via a conductor 30. The switch 26 is connected to the
positive side of the central power supply 24 via a conductor
32.
In the A-position of the switch 26, as shown in FIG. 1, the switch
26 functions to provide electrical continuity between the anode 18
and the positive output side of the central power supply 24 via the
conductors 30 and 32. In this position of the switch 26, there is
no electrical continuity between the anode 16 and the central power
supply 24, for reasons to be made more apparent below.
It is apparent from FIG. 1, that when the switch 26 is moved or
positioned in the B-position thereof, the switch 26 will establish
electrical continuity between the positive side of the central
power supply 24 and the anode 16 via the conductors 28 and 32, and
the anode 18 will not be in electrical communication with the
central power supply 24, for reasons which will be made apparent
below. The central power supply 24, is adapted to provide a
predetermined amount of polarizing current to the anode 16 or 18
connected thereto or, in other words, in electrical continuity
therewith. It is apparent from the above, that the power supply 24
will more particularly provide polarizing current to the anode 16
or 18, depending upon the position of the switch 26. Power supplies
of this general nature are well known in the art and no further
description is required herein.
Each anode 16 and 18 is also electrically connected to the positive
output side of an automatic current controller 34 via a
two-position switch 36. The two positions of the switch 36 are
designated in FIG. 1 as A and B and, as shown in FIG. 1, the switch
36 has been moved or switched to the A-position thereof. As shown
in FIG. 1, the anode 16 is electrically connected to the A-position
of the switch 36 via a conductor 38, and the anode 18 is
electrically connected to the B-position of the switch 36 via a
conductor 40. The switch 36 is electrically connected to the
positive output side of the automatic current controller 34 via a
conductor 42.
It is apparent from FIG. 1, that in the A-position of the switch
36, as shown in FIG. 1, the switch 36 functions to provide
electrical continuity between the anode 16 and the positive output
side of the automatic current controller 34 via the conductors 38
and 42. In this position of the switch 36, the anode 18 is not in
electrical communication with the automatic current controller
34.
It is also apparent from FIG. 1, that when the switch 36 has been
moved to the B-position thereof, the switch 36 will function to
provide electrical continuity between the anode 18 and the
automatic current controller 34 via the conductors 40 and 42. In
the B-position of the switch 36, the anode 16 will not be in
electrical communication with automatic current controller 34, for
reasons which will be made more apparent below.
The automatic current controller 34 is adapted to provide an
adjustingly, controlled polarizing current to the anode connected
thereto or, in other words, to the anode 16 or 18 in electrical
continuity therewith. More particularly, the polarizing current
provided by the automatic current controller 34 is adjustingly
controlled in response to a control signal received by the
automatic current controller 34, in a manner to be more fully
described below. Current controllers adapted to provide an
adjustingly controlled current output in response to a control
signal are well known in the art and therefore a detailed
description is not required herein.
As shown in FIG. 1, the negative side of the automatic current
controller 34 is electrically connected to the protected surface 12
via a conductor 43, and the negative side of the central power
supply 24 is also electrically connected to the protected surface
12 via a conductor 45 which is connected to the conductor 43. The
central power supply 24 and the automatic current controller 34 are
thus connected to the protected surface 12 in such a manner as to
maintain the protected surface 12 cathodic.
As shown in FIG. 1, each reference electrode 20 and 22 is in
electrical communication with a comparator 47 via a two-positioned
switch 44. The two positions of the switch 44 are designated in
FIG. 1 as A and B and, as shown in FIG. 1, the switch 44 is in the
A-position thereof.
The reference electrode 20 is electrically connected to the
A-position of the switch 44 via a conductor 46 and the reference
electrode 22 is electrically connected to the B-position of the
switch 44 via a conductor 48. The switch 44 is electrically
connected to the comparator 47 via a conductor 50.
It is apparent from the foregoing in FIG. 1, that in the A-position
of the switch 44, as shown in FIG. 1, the switch 44 functions to
provide electrical continuity between the reference electrode 20
and the comparator 47 via the conductors 46 and 50. In this
position of the switch 44, the reference electrode 22 is not in
electrical communication with the comparator 47.
It is also apparent from FIG. 1, that in the B-position of the
switch 44, the switch 44 functions to provide electrical continuity
between the reference electrode 22 and the comparator 47 via the
conductors 48 and 50. In the B-position of the switch 44, the
reference electrode 20 is not in electrical communication with the
comparator 47, for reasons which will become apparent below.
As mentioned before, the reference electrodes 20 and 22 are each
adapted and positioned to indicate the anode potential of one of
the anodes 16 or 18, more particularly, the reference electrodes 20
and 22 are adapted and positioned such that the potential of each
reference electrode 20 and 22 with respect to the protected surface
12 is indicative of the potential of the anode 16 or 18 with
respect to the protected surface 12. The comparator 47 is thus
adapted to compare the potential of one of the reference electrodes
20 or 22, depending upon the position of the switch 44 with a
predetermined set potential, and to produce an output control
signal 52 which is proportional to such comparison or, in other
words, indicative of such comparison.
The automatic current controller 34 is adapted to receive the
output control signal 52 from the comparator 47, as indicated in
FIG. 1, and to adjustingly control the polarizing current provided
by the automatic current controller 34 in response to the output
control signal 52.
In actual practice, the comparator 47 and the automatic current
controller 34 may, in some instances, comprise a unitary current
control unit which is commonly referred to in the art as a
"potentiastat." Potentiastats adapted to automatically adjust the
current output therefrom in response to a particular reference or
control signal supplied thereto are well known in the art and
further detailed description is not required herein.
As diagrammatically indicated in FIG. 1, the switches 25, 36 and 44
are interconnected or ganged in such a manner that the switches 26,
36 and 44 are each simultaneously positioned in the respective
A-position or in the respective B-position thereof. Also as shown
in FIG. 1, the switches 26, 36 and 44, in a preferred form,
comprise a unitary switching control unit, indicated in FIG. 1 by
the general reference 56. From the foregoing, it is apparent that
the switching control unit 56 is interposed between each anode 16
and 18 and the power supply 24, between each anode 16 and 18 and
the automatic current controller 34, and between each reference
electrode 20 and 22 and the comparator 47. The switching control
unit 56 is particularly adapted to selectively and sequentially
provide, for a predetermined period of time, electrical continuity
between selected ones of the anodes and the automatic current
controller 34 and electrical continuity between the remaining
anodes and the power supply 24, such that sequentially the
automatic current controller 34 provides controlled polarizing
current to some of the anodes and the power supply 24 provides
polarizing current to the remaining anodes, as will be described
more fully below. In other words and in a preferred form, the
switching control unit 56 is adapted to sequentially switch or move
each switch 26, 36 and 44 to the respective A-position or
B-position thereof at predetermined time intervals, for reasons
which will become more apparent below.
The switching control unit 56 may, for example, be adapted to
maintain the switches 26, 36 and 44 in the A-position for a
preselected period of two minutes and at the end of that time move
the switches 26, 36, and 44 to the B-position thereof. The
switching control unit 56, for example, might then hold the
switches 26, 36 and 44 in the B-positions thereof for a period of 2
minutes and at the end of that time move the switches 26, 36 and 44
back to the A-positions thereof. The particular time interval or
switching period established for the switching control unit 56 with
respect to a particular cathodic protection apparatus 10 will
depend to some extent on the size of the surface area being
protected by the cathodic protection apparatus 10, the required
polarization, the number of anodes utilized in the particular
cathodic protection system, and the composition and other
parameters of the electrolyte 14. In view of the detailed
description of the cathodic protection apparatus 10 contained
herein, the determination of the switching period for a particular
application will be apparent to those skilled in the art.
It should be specifically noted that the switches 26, 36 and 44
have been diagrammatically shown in FIG. 1 as being mechanically
operated merely for the purpose of clarity of description and, in a
preferred form, the switches 26, 36 and 44 would be adapted such
that they would be electrically or electronically operated.
Electrical or electronic switching units adapted to function in a
manner as generally described above and as will be more
particularly described below are well known in the art and further
detailed description is not required herein.
It should also be noted that there are various systems and
apparatus available which are adapted to indicate the anode
potential of a particular anode in a cathodic protection system,
and to subsequently provide an output signal proportional to a
comparison of that anode potential with a predetermined set
potential. The utilization of the reference electrodes 20 and 22
and the comparator 47, as shown in FIG. 1, is indicative of a
preferred form. Therefore, the comparator 47 and the reference
electrodes 20 and 22 are sometimes referred to below as a potential
control.
OPERATION OF FIG. 1
As mentioned before, the cathodic protection apparatus 10, as shown
in FIG. 1, is adapted to cathodically protect the surface 12
utilizing a minimum total power consumption, and in a manner
maintaining polarization within a predetermined range over
substantially the entire area of the protected surface 12.
During the initial start-up of the cathodic protection apparatus
10, shown in FIG. 1, the switching control unit 56 is in, what may
be referred to as an initial switching position, wherein the
switches 26, 36 and 44 are in the A-position. In this position, the
anode 18 is receiving polarizing current from the central power
supply 24 via the switch 26.
The power supply 24 is particularly adapted to supply a minimum
polarizing current to any particular electrode and, more
particularly, as shown in FIG. 1, to provide a minimum polarizing
current to the anode 18 in the A-position of the switches 26, 36
and 44. The polarizing current provided by the power supply 24
should be sufficient to maintain the potential of the anode 18
within a predetermined minimum-polarization range for a particular
application such that the automatic current controller 34 can
provide sufficient polarizing current to the anode 18 to bring the
overall potential of the anode 18 up to a predetermined potential
during the time period when the switches 26, 36 and 44 are moved to
the B-position.
During the initial start-up and in the A-position of the switching
control unit 56, the anode 16 is being provided polarizing current
by the automatic current controller 34 via the switch 36, and the
reference electrode 20 is in electrical communication with the
comparator 47. In this position, the reference electrode 20 will of
course be registering or measuring a minimum or, more particularly,
a "zero" potential. Thus, in this position, the output control
signal 52 of the comparator 47 will indicate to the automatic
current controller 34 that a maximum polarizing current is to be
supplied to the anode 16 via the switch 36.
It should be noted that the initial current to establish
polarization in the cathodic protection system 10 is generally
higher than the polarizing current required to maintain
polarization. Therefore, the polarizing current output of the
automatic current controller 34 to the anode 16 will be at a
maximum during the initial start-up of the cathodic protection
apparatus 10. It should also be noted that the reference electrode
20 is continuously providing the anode potential indication to the
comparator 47 and the control signal output 52 of the comparator 47
will thus vary in response thereto, thereby varying the polarizing
current output of the automatic current controller 34 in accordance
therewith.
After a predetermined period of time, the switching control unit 56
will move the switches 26, 36 and 44 to the B-position thereof. In
the B-position of the switches 26, 36 and 44, the central power
supply 24 will be providing polarizing current to the anode 16 via
the switch 26 and the automatic current controller 34 will be
providing polarizing current to anode 18 via the switch 36. The
polarizing current being provided by the automatic current
controller 34 to the anode 18 will be adjustingly, controlled in
response to output of control signal 52 of the comparator 47
cooperating with the reference electrode 22, in a manner similar to
that described before with respect to the anode 16 and the
reference electrode 20.
After the predetermined polarization of the cathodic protection
apparatus 10 has been established, the power supply 24 and the
automatic current controller 34 will cooperate to maintain the
cathodic protection apparatus 10 within a predetermined
polarization range, or in other words to cathodically protect the
surface 12, in a manner similar to that described above with
respect to the start-up operation of the cathodic protection
apparatus 10. Thus, during the operation of the cathodic protection
apparatus 10, when the switches 26, 36 and 44 are in the
A-position, the power supply 24 will be providing a minimum
polarizing current to the anode 18 and the automatic current
controller 34 will be providing an adjustingly, controlled
polarizing current to the anode 16, that is adjustingly controlled
with reference to the output control signal 52 of the comparator 47
cooperating with the reference electrode 20. In the B-position of
the switches 26, 36 and 44 of the switching control unit 56, the
power supply 24 will be providing a minimum polarizing current to
the anode 16 and the automatic current controller 34 will be
providing an adjustingly, controlled polarizing current to the
anode 18, that is adjustingly controlled with reference to the
output control signal 52 of the comparator 47 cooperating with the
reference electrode 22.
It is apparent from the foregoing and from FIG. 1, that the
reference electrode 20 functions to provide a reference anode
potential measurement to the comparator 47 when the switches 26, 36
and 44 are in the A-position thereof, and the reference electrode
22 functions to provide a reference anode potential measurement to
the comparator 47 when the switches 26, 36 and 44 are in the
B-position thereof. Thus the switch 44 sequentially and selectively
provides electrical continuity between the comparator 47 and the
reference electrode 20 or 22.
It has been found that in cathodic protection systems utilizing
only one power anode and one reference electrode, that the power
anode may consume substantially more total power output than
necessary to maintain the particular desired, polarization. It has
also been found that, in some instances, utilizing a single power
anode and a single reference electrode that the predetermined
potential at which the power anode is maintained may be
insufficient to provide the cathodic protection required by the
system or, in other words, to maintain the particular cathodic
protection system within a predetermined polarization. This of
course results in an overall increased operating cost and, in some
instances, an increased corrosion rate with respect to particular
areas of the protected surface.
The utilization of a predetermined number of power electrodes or
anodes and a predetermined number of cooperating reference
electrodes, in a manner as described above, permits the entire
cathodic protection system to be maintained within a predetermined
range utilizing less total power consumption and assures that all
areas of the protected surface are maintained within that
polarization range, thereby effectively reducing and controlling
corrosion.
The above is particularly important when considering the
utilization of a cathodic protection apparatus to protect tanks,
having a relatively large surface area in contact with a corrosive
fluid, wherein the various parameters of the corrosive fluid in the
tank may significantly vary throughout the tank due to the large
volumetric area occupied by the corrosive fluid. Thus, it is
apparent from the foregoing that in such a tank, for example, the
temperature of the corrosive fluid or the corrosive environment
could vary considerably from one portion of the tank with respect
to another portion of the tank, thus requiring more polarizing
current to be provided at one area and less polarizing current to
be provided at another area.
The cathodic protection apparatus 10 of the present invention thus
establishes and maintains a predetermined polarization over the
entire area protected surface 12 in such a manner that the
polarizing current to each predetermined area of the protected
surface 12 is maintained at a minimum and yet is sufficient to
cathodically protect that portion of the protected surface 12. It
should be particularly noted that the term "total power
consumption" of the cathodic protection apparatus refers more
specifically to the power consumed by the central power supply 24
and the automatic current controller 34 in establishing and
maintaining the predetermined polarization.
It should also be noted that the utilization of a predetermined
number of power anodes and predetermined number of associated
reference electrodes cooperating therewith, in a manner as
described above, becomes important in attempting to cathodically
protect surfaces having an irregular or relatively complex
geometrical shape. The various parameters of the corrosive fluid,
in such an instance, and the polarizing current required to
establish and maintain particular areas of the surface within a
predetermined polarization range may vary considerably.
The graph shown in FIG. 3 is a plot of current density, measured in
milliamps per centimeter squared, versus time, measured in minutes,
for a particular experimental utilization of the cathodic
protection apparatus 10, as described before. In this particular
experiment, the test specimen was annealed 1020 carbon steel with a
surface area of 22 square centimeters. The electrolyte utilized was
a merchant grade H.sub.3 PO.sub.4 (75 percent by weight) at a
temperature of 24.degree. centigrade. The reference electrode was a
saturated calomel cell (SCE). The time interval or time period for
the switching control unit 56 was set to sequentially switch the
switches 26, 36, and 44 between the A-position and the B-position
at 2-minute time intervals.
It is apparent from FIG. 3 that the current density required to
maintain polarization within a predetermined range decreased over a
period of time, the larger amount of polarization current being
required to initially establish polarization. More particular, and
as shown in FIG. 3, in approximately 120 minutes the current
density required to maintain the test specimen (the carbon steel)
cathodically protected was approximately 0.1 milliamps per square
centimeter, whereas the current density required to establish
polarization varied from approximately 2.0 to 0.15 milliamps per
square centimeter in approximately 60 minutes. In this example, the
corrosion rate was determined to be approximately 1.2 mpg, whereas
normally the corrosion for unprotected steel is between 500 and 600
mpg.
From the foregoing it is apparent that the total polarizing
current, that is the current provided by the central power supply
24 and the automatic current controller 34, to maintain a
predetermined polarization decreased over a period of time. Thus,
in this example, the total power consumed by the cathodic
protection system 10 was substantially reduced over a period of
time, since the current density required to maintain the
predetermined polarization decreased during that period of
time.
It should also be noted that the switching control unit 56
cooperates with the central power supply 24 and the automatic
current controller 34, as described above, in a manner such that a
large number of anodes are effectively and efficiently controlled
by the single unit combination. Thus, the cathode protection
apparatus 10 is also adapted to control a large number of anodes
utilizing a reduced number of protection units.
DESCRIPTION OF FIG. 2
The cathodic protection apparatus 10a, shown in FIG. 2, is
constructed similar to the cathodic protection apparatus 10,
described before. One of the differences between the cathodic
protection apparatus 10a and the cathodic protection apparatus 10
is that each switch 26a, 36a, and 44a of the switching control unit
56a is a three-positioned switch, having a third position
designated in FIG. 2 by the letter or switch position C.
As shown in FIG. 2, when the switching control unit 56a has been
actuated to move the switches 26a, 36a, and 44a to the C-position
thereof, the central power supply 24 and the automatic current
controller 34 are not in electrical communication with either the
anode 16 nor the anode 18. In other words, the C-position of the
switching control unit 56a represents a switch position wherein
polarizing current is not being provided via the central power
supply 24 nor the automatic current controller 34.
As shown in FIG. 2, a programmer 70 is disposed between the
switching control unit 56a and the protected surface 12. More
particularly, and as illustrated in FIG. 2, the programmer 70 is
adapted to sense various parameters relating to the protected
surface 12 or the electrolyte 14 via a sensing conductor 72 and to
provide an actuating control signal 74 to the switching control
unit 56a. The control signal 74 is responsive to the particular
sensing control signal 72 being supplied to the programmer 70, as
will be made more apparent below.
As diagrammatically indicated in FIG. 2 and in a preferred form,
the programmer 70 is adapted to control the switching sequence of
the switching control unit 56a. More particularly, the programmer
is adapted to control the cycle time or period of the switching
control unit 56a, that is the particular period of time in which
the switching control unit 56a will maintain the switches 26a, 36a,
and 44a in the A-position, the B-position or the C-position
thereof.
Since the particular amount of polarizing current required to be
provided to a particular anode at a given time and in a particular
cathodic protection system to maintain the system polarized depends
upon such parameters as, for example, the temperature of the
electrolyte 14, as mentioned before. The programmer 70, in that
instance, can be more particularly adapted such that the sensing
signal 72 is responsive to the temperature of the electrolyte 14.
The output control signal 74 of the programmer 70, in that example,
would set the cycle time or switching period of the switching
control unit 56a in accordance with the measured temperature of the
electrolyte 14.
As shown in FIG. 2, the C-position of the switches 26a, 36a, and
44a essentially represents an "off" position, the sensing signal 72
might be adapted to sense the presence of the electrolyte within
the protected surface 12 and the programmer 70 might then be
adapted to cooperate with the switching control unit 56a to move
the switches 26a, 36a, and 44a therein to the A-position and to
automatically begin the cycle sequencing of the switching control
unit 56a, in a manner similar to that described before.
From the foregoing it will be apparent to those skilled in the art,
that in particular cathodic protection systems, the programmer 70
could be adapted to sense any particular controlling parameter or
parameters in that system and to control the switching cycle of the
switching control unit 56a in response to such a sensing signal. It
will also be apparent to those skilled in the art, that although
the C-position of the switches 26a, 36a, and 44a, as shown in FIG.
2, is essentially an "off" position, that in a particular cathodic
protection system, the C-position of the switching control unit 56a
could represent a switch position wherein the central power supply
24 was providing polarizing current to both anodes 16 and 18.
OPERATION OF FIG. 2
The cathodic protection apparatus 10a, shown in FIG. 2, will
operate substantially similar to the cathodic protection apparatus
10, described before. One of the salient differences in the
operation of the cathodic protection apparatus 10a, is that the
switching period of the switching control unit 56a is controllingly
varied in response to the control signal 74 from the programmer 70.
Since the programmer 70 is adapted to receive a sensing signal 72
which is responsive to various parameters of the cathodic
protection system 10a, it is apparent that the cathodic protection
apparatus 10a provides a more complete automatic control, which may
be more effective or desirable in some applications.
It will be apparent from the foregoing, that the cathodic
protection apparatus 10a retains all of the advantages of the
cathodic protection apparatus 10, described before, and yet
provides an additional control feature which may operate in an
overall cathodic protection system to still further reduce the
total power consumption and yet maintain the predetermined
polarization.
As mentioned before, the two anodes 16 and 18 have been shown
merely for illustrative purposes and, in a particular cathodic
protection system, as contemplated by the present invention, more
anodes may be utilized. The precise number of additional anodes and
the placement of such additional anodes with respect to the
protected surface will be apparent to those skilled in the art from
the above detailed description.
Changes may be made in the construction and arrangement of the
parts or the elements of the various embodiments as disclosed
herein without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention
as defined in the following claims.
* * * * *