U.S. patent number 3,705,500 [Application Number 04/871,797] was granted by the patent office on 1972-12-12 for nitrogen spray refrigeration system for perishables.
This patent grant is currently assigned to Union Carbide Corporation. Invention is credited to William Robert Jehle.
United States Patent |
3,705,500 |
Jehle |
December 12, 1972 |
**Please see images for:
( Certificate of Correction ) ** |
NITROGEN SPRAY REFRIGERATION SYSTEM FOR PERISHABLES
Abstract
A system for more efficient refrigeration of perishable products
in trucks and railcars is provided by spraying cold fluid into the
product chamber at effective flow rate resulting from maximum flow
rating between 30 and 110 lbs. per hour equivalent pure nitrogen
per 10 foot average length of storage chambers having
cross-sectional area between 40 and 110 ft.sup.2, and through
spaced small openings in a spray conduit of between 0.002 and 0.009
inch.sup.2 per 10 foot average length.
Inventors: |
Jehle; William Robert
(Williamsville, NY) |
Assignee: |
Union Carbide Corporation (New
York, NY)
|
Family
ID: |
25358166 |
Appl.
No.: |
04/871,797 |
Filed: |
October 22, 1969 |
Related U.S. Patent Documents
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Application
Number |
Filing Date |
Patent Number |
Issue Date |
|
|
776331 |
Nov 18, 1968 |
|
|
|
|
Current U.S.
Class: |
62/223; 62/51.1;
62/53.2 |
Current CPC
Class: |
F25D
3/105 (20130101) |
Current International
Class: |
F25D
3/10 (20060101); F25d 003/10 () |
Field of
Search: |
;62/514,64,45,373,223 |
References Cited
[Referenced By]
U.S. Patent Documents
Primary Examiner: Wayner; William E.
Parent Case Text
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
This is a divisional application of Ser. No. 776,331 filed Nov. 18,
1968 by W. R. Jehle, now abandoned.
Claims
What is claimed is:
1. Apparatus for refrigerating perishable products comprising in
combination:
a. a storage chamber for said perishable products having thermal
insulation sufficient to limit heat inlead rate below 0.10
Btu/hr-.degree.F-ft.sup.2 and cross-sectional area between 40 and
100 ft.sup.2 ;
b. a thermally insulated container associated with the storage
chamber for holding pressurized nitrogen-rich liquid;
c. spray conduit means positioned within the upper portion of said
storage chamber and extending substantially the entire length
thereof with openings of equivalent diameter less than 0.07 inch
spaced along the length for discharging a multiplicity of discrete
cold fluid streams into the storage chamber for refrigerating same,
said openings having total area of between 0.002 and 0.009 in.sup.2
per 10 ft average length of chamber;
d. fluid discharge conduit means communicating at one end with the
liquid container and at the other end with said spray conduit;
e. fluid flow control means comprising a temperature sensing
element positioned within said storage chamber, and a control valve
operably interposed in said fluid discharge conduit means being
connected to said temperature sensing element to be responsive to
the storage chamber gas temperature as sensed by such element.
2. Apparatus according to claim 1 in which thermal insulation is
provided around said spray conduit means.
3. Apparatus according to claim 1 in which the openings are of
about 0.038 inch diameter and circular.
4. Apparatus according to claim 1 in which the spray conduit means
comprises multiple sections of 1/4 -inch IPS pipe 57 inches long
each having four 0.038 inch diameter circular holes spaced
respectively 10, 21, 36 and 51 inches from one end.
5. Apparatus according to claim 1 in which the total area of said
openings is between 0.004 and 0.008 inch.sup.2 per 10 foot average
length of chamber.
6. Apparatus according to claim 1 in which a fan is positioned
within the storage chamber at one end thereof to circulate
environment gas.
Description
This invention relates to a method of and apparatus for highly
efficient nitrogen-rich liquefied gas intransit refrigeration of
perishable product wherein the refrigerant is sprayed into the
product chamber.
The intransit refrigeration of perishables by spraying cold
cryogenic liquid from a liquefied gas storage body into the
perishable product storage chamber is widely practiced as described
in Kane et al. U.S. Pat. No. 3,287,925. The conventional practice
has been to use sufficiently high maximum flow ratings of
refrigerant for rapid cooldown of the product storage chamber
following initial product loading or doop openings, i.e. greater
than 200 lbs. per hour liquid nitrogen per 10 foot average length
of chamber. In this manner the cryogenic liquid spray system could
minimize the period a perishable product, e.g. lettuce, is exposed
to high ambient temperatures at which deterioration is accelerated.
This was recognized as a significant advantage over mechanical
refrigeration systems where the cooldown rate is severely limited
by the need to mechanically circulate environment gas over cooling
coils and thereafter refrigerate the product with the cooled
gas.
Certain problems have developed in connection with the prior art
liquid nitrogen spray refrigeration system, including relatively
high liquid nitrogen consumption rates. This necessitated refilling
of the liquid nitrogen storage container at more frequent intervals
than was convenient or economically desirable. Another problem was
that the relatively high refrigerant flow rates made it more
difficult to maintain substantially uniform temperatures through
the entire length of the product chamber. The flow of refrigerant
is normally controlled in response to temperature sensing means,
e.g. a thermostat, positioned within the gas space of the product
storage chamber so that the refrigerant "on" cycles required to
reach the thermostat set point temperature were relatively short.
During these periods the chamber sections and product closest to
the openings in the overhead spray conduit tended to be overcooled
while the remote sections were undercooled.
It is an object of this invention to provide an improved method of
and apparatus for cold nitrogen-rich spray refrigeration of
perishables.
Another object is to provide such method and apparatus in which the
nitrogen-rich liquid consumption rate is lower than heretofore
realized.
Still another object is to provide such method and apparatus in
which more uniform refrigeration temperatures are realized
throughout all sections of the product chamber.
Other objects and advantages of this invention will be apparent
from the ensuing disclosure and appended claims.
SUMMARY
In the method aspect of this invention, pressurized nitrogen-rich
liquefied gas is provided in a thermally insulated storage
container associated with a product storage chamber having thermal
insulation sufficient to limit the heat inleak rate to below 0.10
Btu/hr.-.degree.F.-ft.sup.2 inside surface area.
The gas temperature within the storage chamber is monitored, as for
example by a temperature sensing bulb or thermocouple, and cold
fluid is dispensed from the storage container in response to the
monitored gas temperature. This cold fluid (either liquid or gas)
is sprayed as a multiplicity of discrete streams spaced from each
other along the length of the storage chamber for refrigerating the
perishable product therein. The effective rate of dispensing is
that provided by a spray header having maximum continuous flow
rating of between 30 and 110 lbs. per hour equivalent pure nitrogen
per 10 feet average length of chamber for chamber cross-sectional
area between 40 and 100 ft.sup.2 so as to maintain the monitored
gas temperature in a selected temperature range of -10.degree. to
60.degree.F. This flow rate is of course far below the
aforementioned 200 lbs. per hour nitrogen per 10 foot average
chamber length maximum flow rating characteristic of present
intransit spray nitrogen refrigeration systems. Tests have
indicated that under some operating conditions this invention
permits about 30 percent reduction in nitrogen refrigerant
consumption over sustained periods with no noticeable loss of
product refrigeration effectiveness.
In the apparatus of this invention, the aforedescribed liquid
nitrogen storage container and product chamber are provided along
with spray conduit means positioned within the upper portion of the
storage chamber and extending substantially the entire length
thereof. Openings of equivalent diameter less than 0.07 inch are
spaced along the spray conduit length for discharging a
multiplicity of discrete cold fluid streams into the storage
chamber. The openings have a total area of between 0.002 and 0.009
inch.sup.2 per 10 foot average length of chamber whereas the prior
art employed substantially higher opening total areas. At areas
below 0.002 inch/10 ft. average length, insufficient nitrogen
refrigerant flow would be provided into the storage chamber to
recover from heat inleak due to door openings within a reasonable
period of time.
In this apparatus, fluid discharge conduit means communicate at one
end with the liquid nitrogen container and at the other end with
the overhead spray conduit. Fluid control means are provided
comprising a temperature sensing element positioned within the
storage chamber and a control valve operably interposed in the
fluid discharge conduit means. The control valve is connected to
the temperature sensing element to be responsive to the storage
chamber temperature.
The term "average length" of chamber is used herein because a
particular 10 foot section of chamber length may not have the
nitrogen-rich flow rate or spray opening total area required to
practice the method and apparatus of this invention. The
aforementioned ranges are based on the total nitrogen-rich flow
rate or spray opening area divided by one-tenth of the chamber
length used to store product.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
FIG. 1 is a schematic view taken in cross-sectional elevation of a
truck or semi-trailer incorporating one embodiment of the
invention.
FIG. 2 is a schematic view taken in cross-sectional elevation of a
railroad car incorporating an alternative embodiment having gas
circulating means.
DESCRIPTION OF PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
Referring now to the drawings, FIG. 1 illustrates an embodiment in
which a mobile thermally insulated storage chamber 11 is provided
for holding perishable product 12. This chamber 11 may be of
standard construction for typical mobile refrigerated chambers,
e.g. reinforced aluminum siding outer walls, plywood panelled inner
walls and asbestos or plastic foam insulating material between the
two walls. The thermal insulation 13 must be sufficiently effective
to limit the atmospheric heat inleak rate below 0.10
Btu/hr.-.degree.F.-ft.sup.2 inside surface area, typical materials
providing overall heat conduction rates of about 0.05-0.07
Btu/hr.-.degree.F.-ft.sup.2. A higher quality thermal insulation is
not economically justified because the chamber is not airtight,
access means such as rear doors being required for insertion and
removal of the refrigerated perishable product.
A thermally insulated container 14 is associated with product
chamber 11 for storing pressurized liquid nitrogen or nitrogen-rich
liquid such as air. The term "equivalent pure nitrogen" as used
herein refers to refrigeration content, as compared to liquid
nitrogen. Because the thermodynamic properties of liquid air and
nitrogen are so similar, they are considered equivalent for
purposes of this invention.
The construction of container 14 is well-known and usually includes
an outer shell completely surrounding an innerstorage vessel to
form an evacuable insulation space therebetween, as for example
depicted in Loveday et al U.S. Pat. No. 2,951,348. This space is
preferably filled with an efficient solid insulating material, as
for example alternate layers of radiation-impervious barrier such
as aluminum foil separated by low conductive fibrous sheeting, as
for example glass fibers described in U.S. Pat. No. 3,007,596 to L.
C. Matsch. To remove gas accumulating in the evacuated insulating
space, an adsorbent material such as calcium zeolite A or a
gettering material such as powdered barium may be provided therein
to retain a high level of insulating quality.
The vessel within storage container 14 is filled with liquid
nitrogen by means well known to the prior art, such as for example
connecting a source of liquid nitrogen stored at above atmospheric
pressure to the container. If the liquid nitrogen is stored at a
pressure below the operating pressure of container 14, a suitable
pump would be employed and usually additional heat would be added
to the pressurized liquid before transferring it into container 14.
The liquid nitrogen is preferably charged into container 14 and
stored therein at saturated conditions and at temperatures
corresponding to a vapor pressure above 10 psig. with the entire
liquid and vapor substantially in equilibrium. If the
aforementioned highly efficient insulation is used, there is no
appreciable amount of heat inleak to the inner storage vessel of
container 14 and the stored liquid nitrogen is dispensed only by
this as-charged vapor pressure. Alternatively the liquid nitrogen
may be charged to container 14 under non-saturated conditions and
even in the subcooled state. Under these circumstances it would
probably be necessary to provide means for building sufficient
internal pressure on demand to discharge the liquid. Those skilled
in the art will appreciate that this heat may be introduced
externally, using the wellknown pressure building coil. The latter
includes a liquid discharge conduit, an atmospheric heat vaporizer
and a conduit for returning the resulting vapor to the container
gas space (not illustrated). As still another variation known to
the art, a less efficient heat insulating material may be used so
that sufficient atmospheric heat inleak is available to vaporize
sufficient stored liquid refrigerant to form gas pressure to insure
liquid discharge on demand.
It is preferred to store the liquid nitrogen refrigerant at
pressure below about 100 psig., because at higher pressures the
spray conduit openings would be impractically small, and also
inherent lag characteristics of presently known temperature sensing
elements would make adequate control of the liquid refrigerant
withdrawal more difficult. The storage pressure is preferably above
about 10 psig. to provide sufficient driving force for
substantially uniform distribution of cold fluid through the spray
orifices. Storage container internal pressures of 15-22 psig. are
commonly used.
Liquid discharge conduit 15 is joined at one end to storage
container 14 and has control valve 16 therein as part of a
liquefied gas flow control system. The latter includes temperature
sensing element 17, as for example a bulb positioned within the
storage chamber 11 gas space. This bulb is connected by signal
transmitting means 18 to temperature controller 19, and signal
transmitting means 20 provides communication between the controller
and control valve 16 in liquid discharge conduit 15. The flow
control means may be electrically or pneumatically operated.
The other end of liquid discharge conduit 15 is joined to overhead
spray conduit 21 having a series of spaced openings 22 therein.
Spray conduit 21 preferably extends substantially the end-to-end
length of product storage chamber 11 for discharge of cold fluid
into such chamber as a multiplicity of discrete streams. Openings
22 may be oriented either horizontally or slightly downwardly in
the conduit's circumference, and are distributed along the conduit
to provide total area of between 0.002 and 0.009 inch.sup.2 per 10
foot average length of chamber. Openings 22 may be of any shape,
although a circular configuration is preferred for uniform
symmetrical discharge of sprayed refrigerant. The openings should
have an equivalent diameter of less than 0.07 inch, i.e. an area
smaller than the area of a circle of this diameter. Holes of 0.07
inch equivalent diameter or larger would be so few in number and so
widely separated that the individual fluid spray streams would be
isolated. With such large holes the refrigerant could not be
introduced in a uniform pattern from one end to the other end of
the chamber over the product and thus provide uniform cooling and
temperature distribution.
In a preferred embodiment the total area of the spray openings is
between 0.004 and 0.008 inch.sup.2 per 10 foot average length of
the product chamber.
It should be understood that the flow rating of 30-110 lbs. per
hour equivalent pure nitrogen per 10 foot average length of
chamber, required by the method of this invention, is the maximum
rate which might be employed with the control valve continuously
open, and not the effective flow rate experienced while the control
valve is open during normal cycling operation. As used herein, the
term "effective flow-rate" is defined as the total refrigerant flow
divided by the control "valve open" time. This includes the
refrigerant used to initially cool the product to the desired low
temperature level and the refrigerant consumed to recool the
product to this level following warmup due to periodic opening of
the chamber doors. The reason why the maximum flow rating criteria
is used is that it eliminates variations such as cycle "on" time
due to the ambient temperature. The effective flow rate during
cycling operation is affected by the ambient temperature, i.e.
higher for relatively high ambient temperature and lower for
relatively low ambient. Tests have shown that for a particular
spray header and liquid nitrogen storage container discharge
pressure, the refrigerant flow rate increases with "on" time up to
a maximum continuous rate. When the control valve is first opened
and the spray header is warm, it initially discharges virtually 100
percent gas. As the spray header cools down with time, an
increasing percentage of liquid is discharged through the openings.
After continuous operation of 30-90 minutes (depending upon flow
rate and heat capacity of the spray header) the system reaches
substantially stable equilibrium condition and the spray header
discharges virtually 100 percent liquid. The flow rate under such
stable condition is the "maximum rating" as used herein. In a
preferred embodiment of the present method, the aforementioned
maximum flow rating is 40 to 90 lbs. per hour equivalent pure
nitrogen per 10 foot average length of product storage chamber.
In the normal cyclic operation the temperature controller usually
terminates refrigerant flow before the maximum rate is reached, and
it has been found that the effective flow rate of an uninsulated
spray header is on the order of 50-80 percent of its maximum
continuous rating. Accordingly, the total area of the openings
should be sufficient so that the desired refrigeration may be
obtained at the effective flow rate.
In a preferred embodiment the spray conduit with spaced openings is
provided in sections of standard length which can be joined
end-to-end, depending on the length of product storage chamber. The
latter may be relatively short, as for example the 8-10 foot truck
body section of an ice cream local delivery truck, or very long, as
for example a 40 foot semi-trailer or 50 foot long railway cars.
The preferred sections for uninsulated spray conduits are composed
of 1/4 inch IPS brass pipe 57 inches long with four 0.038 inch
diameter circular holes spaced 11 to 15 inches apart. In
particular, the four holes are located the following distances from
one end: 10, 21, 36, and 51 inches. Whereas the heretofore employed
nitrogen spray conduits had 1/16 inch diameter (0.0625 inch)
circular holes, it has been discovered that smaller size openings
discharge a more finely divided liquid spray which in turn affords
more uniform refrigeration distribution beneath the openings. Tests
have shown that with even very long spray conduits (40-45 feet),
the pressure drop is negligible so that each 0.038-inch opening
passes approximately equal quantity of cold nitrogen fluid during
operation.
The aforedescribed spray conduit sections have been connected
together for use according to this invention, in various size
trucks (about 56 ft.sup.2 cross-sectional area) and railroad cars
(about 95 ft.sup.2 cross-sectional area) as listed in Table A.
##SPC1##
It should be noted from the foregoing table that the total length
of the standard sections for any particular product chamber is not
necessarily equal to the length of the product chamber. In such
instances, portions of blank pipe (without openings) are used to
connect the standard sections of spray conduit. For example, a 2
foot long blank pipe may be placed between two standard 57 inch
long spray sections for a 17 foot chamber, and a 4 foot long blank
pipe may be positioned between two standard sections for a 20 foot
long chamber.
In operation, liquid nitrogen is discharged from storage container
14 through conduit 15 to overhead spray conduit 21 and thence
through openings 22 into chamber 11 for refrigerating perishable
product 12. Refrigerant flow is responsive to the chamber
temperature as sensed by element 17. The controller 19 is set to
maintain the chamber temperature within a predetermined range,
depending on the nature of the product. For frozen commodities, as
for example ice cream, the temperature should be about
0.degree.-10.degree.F. whereas with freeze-sensitive commodities
such as lettuce, the temperature should be 35.degree.-45.degree.F.
It should be understood that this invention may be employed to
refrigerate any type of temperature-sensitive product irrespective
of whether the product is to be maintained in the frozen or
unfrozen state.
The cold nitrogen fluid may be discharged through the spray
openings 22 as a liquid, liquid-vapor mixture or entirely vapor,
depending on the heat transfer characteristics of the particular
system. For example, in the FIG. 1 embodiment only a relatively
small portion of the liquid nitrogen discharged from container 14
is vaporized by heat from the environment gas upstream the
openings. In other systems contemplated by the invention, a heat
exchanger may be provided upstream of spray header 21 to vaporize
part or all of the liquid nitrogen. Such a heat exchanger may be
located within or outside the product chamber.
Another contemplated variation is a spray header with thermal
insulation. Whereas non-insulated spray headers are satisfactory
for systems refrigerating frozen products, it may be desirable to
position thermal insulation around the spray header for systems
refrigerating freeze-sensitive products, e.g. fruits and
vegetables. This is because high convective heat transfer to the
cold non-insulated spray header may cause freeze damage to the
nearby freeze-sensitive products. Also, dripping water from ice
frozen on the spray header during operation may damage product
cartons and is annoying to unloading personnel.
Although the spray header may be located anywhere within the upper
portion of the product storage chamber, it is preferably located
along the upper portions of a side wall near the ceiling. In this
location, all spray openings are placed along one side of the
header and preferably directed approximately horizontally across
the product, and if moisture forms it will drip down along the wall
of the storage chamber.
In certain types of cold nitrogen-rich spray intransit
refrigeration systems, usually those equipped with thermally
insulated spray conduits, means are provided to circulate the
product chamber environment gas for more uniform end-to-end
temperature distribution. The need for gas circulation means, e.g.
a fan, is greatest in long haul service (e.g. over 400 miles
between loading and unloading points or requiring transit time
greater than about 48 hours) and in particular in relatively long
chambers containing products to be refrigerated at above freezing
temperature to avoid deterioration. The fan may be electrically
driven from a truck battery or generator, or powered by energy from
the expansion of warmed pressurized nitrogen gas as described and
claimed in copending application Ser. No. 643,709 filed June 5,
1967.
FIG. 2 illustrates a railroad car embodiment in which elements
corresponding to those previously described and illustrated in FIG.
1 have been identified by the same numeral. Other elements which
differ from FIG. 1 are described hereinafter, along with their
functions.
Thermal insulation 21a is provided around overhead spray conduit 21
to avoid product freeze damage and moisture drippage. Second liquid
discharge conduit 23 having control valve 24 communicates at one
end with liquid nitrogen storage container 14 through first liquid
discharge conduit 15. Alternatively one end on conduit 23 may
extend directly into liquid storage container 14 as does first
conduit 15. In either event the other end of second liquid
discharge conduit 23 joins with heat exchanger means 25,
illustrated as a vaporizer extending the end-to-end length of
chamber 11 beneath floor 26 but in thermal association therewith.
Alternatively, heat exchange means 25 could be located above the
floor at one end of the storage chamber. Although illustrated as
one passageway, heat exchanger 25 preferably comprises two sections
positioned on either side of the longitudinal centerline of chamber
11, and provides sufficient heat transfer surface area to insure
vaporization of the cold liquid continuously flowing thereto. This
heat is supplied in large part by the warmer circulating chamber
environment gas contacting the outer surfaces of heat exchanger
25.
The discharge end of heat exchanger 25 joins external heat
exchanger 27 wherein the cold nitrogen fluid may be superheated by
atmospheric heat. The resulting warmed nitrogen gas is returned to
the product chamber 11 through conduit 28 communicating with gas
expander 29, which is preferably centrally positioned in the upper
portion of the chamber near the front end of storage chamber 11. As
illustrated the front end of chamber 11 is also the inlet end of
spray conduit 21, but the conduit might also be positioned with its
discharge end at the front of chamber 11 adjacent expander 29. The
latter is preferably a commercially available sliding vane-type air
motor with an inlet pressure of about 10-25 psig. operating at
200-1,500 rpm. or greater, but a turbine type expander may be used.
Expander 29 is joined by shaft coupling means 30 to fan 31 also
positioned near spray conduit 21, and preferably between the liquid
storage container 14 and the first spray opening 22a. If the
desired operating speed of fan 30 is not suitable for the driving
motor 29, speed change by belt drive or gears may be used.
The exhaust gas from expander 31 is preferably directed into
chamber 11 through the discharge port 32. Direct discharge through
expander port 32 at atmospheric pressure is preferred to obtain
maximum pressure drop across the expander. This in turn develops as
much shaft power as possible for driving fan 31.
Fan 31 circulates environment gas, including a portion of the cold
nitrogen intermittently sprayed from openings 22, across the upper
section of chamber 11 over product 12 to the rear end thereof and
downwardly to the bottom passages beneath floor 26. The floor
structures of commercially employed product storage chambers, e.g.
trucks, trailers or railcars, usually comprise wood slats or shaped
metal such as channels or corrugations which are spaced apart and
shaped to provide adequate structural strength and light weight.
These structures also provide spaces for adequate longitudinal gas
circulation under the product load. Cold fluid conduit 25 may be
supported within such depressions in the floor and thermally
insulated therefrom. The thermal insulation should be sealed from
the atmosphere to prevent moisture penetration and consequent loss
of efficiency. The fan circulates gas from end to end of the
chamber 11 floor in passageways formed by such channels or
corrugations to recover refrigeration from the liquid-vapor in
conduit 25. The thus warmed environment gas rises at the chamber
front end and is at least partially recirculated by fan 31 in the
aforedescribed manner. A part of this gas may be discharged to the
atmosphere through vent 32a to avoid overpressuring in chamber
11.
During the winter the temperature difference between the
surrounding atmosphere and the desired refrigeration level within
chamber 11 is smaller than in the summer. Accordingly the combined
heat exchange capacity of internal unit 25 and external unit 27 may
not be required during the winter. In this event passageways 25 may
be bypassed and the nitrogen liquid from second discharge conduit
23 diverted through conduit 33 and control valve 34 therein
directly to atmospheric heat exchanger 27. Under these
circumstances the nitrogen liquid is both vaporized and superheated
by atmospheric heat prior to flow through expander 29.
The unexpected advantages of this invention are illustrated in a
series of tests as follows.
TEST NO. 1
A 45 foot long stationary railcar having thermal insulation of
sufficient quality to limit the heat inleak rate to about 0.07
Btu/hr. .degree.F.-ft..sup.2 was provided with the components
illustrated in FIG. 2 and first tested with a 3/4-inch ID by 7/8
-inch OD copper spray header containing twenty-five 1/16 -inch
diameter openings longitudinally spaced end-to-end. The spray
header was insulated with 1 inch of urethane foam so that the fluid
discharged through the openings comprised mostly liquid. The set
point for bulb 17 was 0.degree.F. and the cross-sectional area of
the chamber was about 86 ft.sup.2. Nitrogen refrigerant was sprayed
into the product chamber at an effective flow rate of about 143
lbs./hr./10 ft. average length of chamber through the 25 openings,
having a total area of about 0.016. inch.sup.2 per 10 foot length
of chamber. The maximum flow rating was about 185 lbs/hr. N.sub.2
/10 ft. average length. After observing that the temperature
distribution within the chamber was undesirably uneven, all but
five of the spray openings were closed to provide total open area
of 0.003 inch.sup.2 /10 ft. average length of chamber. These
remaining five openings were located the following distances from
the spray conduit inlet end: 3.7, 13.6, 25.9, 36.1 and 44.2 feet.
The refrigerant flow rate was thereby reduced so that the
refrigerant "on" cycle was lengthened, the spray header cooldown
time became a smaller fraction of the "on" cycle, and the upset in
temperature distribution due to this cooldown was minimized.
Another advantage of the lower refrigerant effective flow rate was
lower pressure drop in the spray header which permitted maximum
pressure drop (to atmospheric pressure) across the spray openings.
This resulted in greater atomization of the liquid nitrogen on
discharge through the openings, and more uniform distribution of
refrigeration to the product. In addition to the runs with five
openings, other runs were made with six openings located the
following distances from the spray header inlet end: 7.4, 17.8,
27.7, 34.6, 39.4 and 44.2 feet; and eight openings located the
following distances from the spray header inlet end: 7.4, 13.6,
19.9, 25.9, 31.2, 36.1, 40.4 and 44.2 feet. These runs are
summarized in Table B and show that comparable or superior
temperature distribution was achieved at much lower maximum flow
ratings per 10 ft. average length of chamber. ##SPC2##
TEST NO. 2
Five railcars equipped with 1/4 inch-IPS brass pipe uninsulated
spray headers and forty-five 1/16-inch diameter holes were
converted to copper spray headers 1/2-inch ID X 5/8-inch OD
insulated with 1/2 inch thick elastomer foam and provided with ten
1/16-inch diameter openings to test this invention. These railcars
were provided with sufficient plastic foam thermal insulation in
the walls to limit the heat transfer inleak rate to about 0.07
Btu/hr.-.degree.F.-ft.sup.2, and used to transport and refrigerate
fresh produce such as lettuce, plums, cauliflower and avocados. The
operating data is summarized in Table C.
TABLE C
max. LN.sub.2 total area of flow rating average number holes -
effective per 10 ft. product spray in.sup.2 /10 ft. LN.sub.2 flow
lgth. avg. - temperature holes lgth. avg. rate - lb/hr. lbs/hr.
deviation .degree.F 45 0.040 1200 470 3-5 10 0.009 270 100 2-4
TEST NO. 3
A 37 foot long chamber of 55 ft.sup.2 cross-sectional area equipped
with apparatus similar to FIG. 2 but comprising a tractor-pulled
trailer was used to transport fresh lettuce from Blythe, California
to Tonawanda, New York over a seven-day period during the month of
December with a 35.degree.F. set point. The trailer was provided
with sufficient plastic foam thermal insulation to limit the heat
transfer inleak rate to about 0.06 Btu/hr.-.degree.F.-ft.sup.2. The
thermally insulated spray header had previously included thirty-two
1/16 -inch diameter holes (total area of about 0.025 inch.sup.2 /10
ft. length average) and freeze damage had been experienced on
similar trips in the uppermost layers of the lettuce product. In
this test the insulated spray header had ten 1/16 -inch diameter
openings (total area of about 0.008 inch/10 ft. length average).
The as-received product had virtually no freeze damage and the
nitrogen consumption was materially reduced, representing a
significant improvement over the conventional high flow rate
system. The data from these runs is summarized in Table D.
TABLE D
Max. LN.sub.2 Total Area of Flow Rating Average Number Holes -
Effective per 10 ft. product spray in.sup.2 /10 ft. LN.sub.2 Flow
lgth. avg. - Temperature Holes lgth. avg. Rate - lb/hr. lbs/hr.
Deviation .degree.F 32 0.026 850 330 5-10 10 0.008 270 100 3-4
TEST NO. 4
A series of runs were made using a product storage chamber in the
form of an insulated truck similar to FIG. 1, about 48 ft.sup.2
cross-sectional area and about 17.5 feet long. The truck was
insulated with nominal 3 inch polyurethane foam to provide a heat
inleak rate of about 0.05 Btu/hr-.degree.F-ft.sup.2. The product
was frozen food and the set points were +10.degree.F. and
-5.degree.F. Periodic stops were made to unload the frozen food,
first using a conventional uninsulated spray header having ten 1/16
-inch diameter openings (0.018 in.sup.2 /10 ft. length average) and
then with another spray header according to this invention with six
3/64 -inch diameter openings (0.006 in.sup.2 /10 ft. length
average). The latter spray header consisted of two 57 inch long
sections of 1/4-inch IPS brass pipe connected by a 24 inch blank
section. The spray header was side-mounted near the chamber ceiling
33 inches from the chamber front end, and the 3/64 -inch diameter
openings were located the following distances from the inlet
end:
Number Hole Distance (inches) 1 4 2 19 3 34 4 49 5 109 6 136
The data from these runs is summarized in Table E as follows:
##SPC3##
The frozen products refrigerated by each system were delivered in
substantially the same satisfactory condition. It is apparent from
Table E that the nitrogen spray refrigeration system of this
invention permitted a very significant reduction in refrigerant
consumption at no loss in performance, indicating that the
refrigerant was used more effectively.
TEST NO. 5
Another group of runs was made using the same product chamber as in
Test No. 4, but with a spray header having eight 0.038 inch
diameter holes (0.005 in.sup.2 /10 ft. length avg). These holes
were spaced the following distances from the header inlet end:
Number Hole Distance (inches) 1 6 2 21 3 36 4 47 5 88 6 103 7 118 8
129
The set point was again -5.degree.F. and the product was frozen
food, e.g. boxed vegetables, meat and canned fruit juices. The data
from these runs is summarized in Table F as follows: ##SPC4##
As before, the frozen products refrigerated by each system was
delivered to the customer in satisfactory condition with
substantially the same temperature pattern inside the storage
chamber. It is apparent from Table F that the nitrogen spray
refrigeration system of this invention permitted a very significant
reduction in refrigerant consumption at no loss in performance,
indicating again that the refrigerant was used more
effectively.
Although preferred embodiments of this invention have been
described in detail, it is contemplated that modifications of the
method and apparatus may be made and that some features may be
employed without others, all within the spirit and scope of the
invention. For example the invention may be used for stationary
refrigeration systems as well as in-transit systems.
* * * * *