U.S. patent application number 14/761196 was filed with the patent office on 2016-01-28 for drive control method and drive system operating according to said method.
This patent application is currently assigned to SIEMENS AKTIENGESELLSCHAFT. The applicant listed for this patent is SIEMENS AKTIENGESELLSCHAFT. Invention is credited to ANDREAS KUBE.
Application Number | 20160023218 14/761196 |
Document ID | / |
Family ID | 48998582 |
Filed Date | 2016-01-28 |
United States Patent
Application |
20160023218 |
Kind Code |
A1 |
KUBE; ANDREAS |
January 28, 2016 |
DRIVE CONTROL METHOD AND DRIVE SYSTEM OPERATING ACCORDING TO SAID
METHOD
Abstract
In a drive control method for a vertical mill having a grinding
plate rotatable about the vertical axis and being drivable by a
drive train that includes an electric motor and a gearbox, a
rotational speed of the grinding plate is varied cyclically,
especially intermittently. A corresponding drive system operating
according to the method is also disclosed.
Inventors: |
KUBE; ANDREAS; (Aachen,
DE) |
|
Applicant: |
Name |
City |
State |
Country |
Type |
SIEMENS AKTIENGESELLSCHAFT |
Munchen |
|
DE |
|
|
Assignee: |
SIEMENS AKTIENGESELLSCHAFT
80333 Munchen
DE
|
Family ID: |
48998582 |
Appl. No.: |
14/761196 |
Filed: |
August 6, 2013 |
PCT Filed: |
August 6, 2013 |
PCT NO: |
PCT/EP2013/066477 |
371 Date: |
July 15, 2015 |
Current U.S.
Class: |
241/30 ;
241/117 |
Current CPC
Class: |
B02C 15/007 20130101;
B02C 2015/008 20130101; B02C 15/02 20130101; B02C 15/06 20130101;
B02C 25/00 20130101; H02P 31/00 20130101 |
International
Class: |
B02C 25/00 20060101
B02C025/00; B02C 15/00 20060101 B02C015/00 |
Foreign Application Data
Date |
Code |
Application Number |
Jan 16, 2013 |
DE |
10 2013 200 578.4 |
Claims
1.-13. (canceled)
14. A drive control method for a vertical roller mill having a
grinding table rotatable about a vertical axis, the method
comprising: driving the grinding table by way of a drive train
having an electric motor and a gearbox, and cyclically varying a
rotation speed of the grinding table.
15. The method of claim 14, wherein the cyclical variation of the
rotation speed of the grinding table is activated under time
control for a predefined period of time.
16. The method of claim 15, wherein the rotation speed is activated
at predefined points in time.
17. The method of claim 16, wherein the predefined points in time
are equidistant.
18. The method of claim 14, wherein the cyclical variation of the
rotation speed of the grinding table is activated in response to a
fluctuation of vibration-relevant measured values that exceeds a
predefined limit.
19. The method of claim 18, wherein the vibration-relevant measured
values comprise at least one of a rotation speed of a rotating
component of the vertical roller mill and a driving torque and
supporting torque operating in or on the gearbox.
20. The method of claim 14, wherein the rotation speed is
cyclically varied by periodically varying of the rotation speed,
and wherein at least one of an amplitude and a period duration of
the periodic variation of the rotation speed of the grinding table
is increased or reduced as a function of a fluctuation of
vibration-relevant measured values that exceeds a predefined
limit.
21. The method of claim 20, wherein the vibration-relevant measured
values comprise at least one of a rotation speed of a rotating
component of the vertical roller mill and a driving torque and
supporting torque operating in or on the gearbox.
22. The method of claim 14, wherein the rotation speed is
cyclically varied by periodically varying of the rotation speed
with a rotation speed profile selected from a sinusoidal profile, a
rectangular profile, a square-wave profile and a ramp-profile.
23. The method of claim 22, wherein a change in a signal waveform
with which the rotation speed of the grinding table is periodically
varied is initiated when a fluctuation of vibration-relevant
measured values exceeds a predefined limit.
24. The method of claim 23, wherein the vibration-relevant measured
values comprise at least one of a rotation speed of a rotating
component of the vertical roller mill and a driving torque and
supporting torque operating in or on the gearbox.
25. The method of claim 14, wherein the electric motor is fed by a
frequency converter, and wherein the rotation speed of the grinding
table is cyclically varied by appropriate control of the frequency
converter.
26. The method of claim 14, wherein vibration-relevant measured
values are obtained by measuring with a sensor system a rotation
speed of a rotating component of the drive train or at least one
driving torque or supporting torque, or both, operating in or on
the gearbox.
27. A computer program product embodied on a non-transitory storage
medium and comprising a computer program having program
instructions which, when loaded into a memory of a control device
controlling a drive for a vertical roller mill having a grinding
table driven by at least one electric motor and a drive train
comprising at least one gearbox for rotation about a vertical axis,
and executed by the control device, causes the control device to
cyclically vary a rotation speed of the grinding table.
28. A non-transitory digital storage medium comprising a computer
program having program instructions which, when loaded into a
memory of a programmable controller controlling a drive system for
a vertical roller mill having a grinding table driven by at least
one electric motor and a drive train comprising at least one
gearbox for rotation about a vertical axis, and executed by the
programmable controller, cause the programmable controller to
cyclically vary a rotation speed of the grinding table.
29. A drive system for a vertical roller mill having a grinding
table rotatable about a vertical axis, the drive system comprising:
an electric motor driving the grinding table, a frequency converter
feeding the electric motor, a gearbox arranged between the electric
motor and the grinding table, and a rotation speed varying device
configured to cyclically vary a rotation speed of the grinding
table.
30. The drive system of claim 29, further comprising a sensor
system for measuring vibration-relevant measured values.
31. The drive system of claim 30, wherein the vibration-relevant
measured values comprise at least one of a rotation speed of a
rotating component of the vertical roller mill and a driving torque
and supporting torque operating in or on the gearbox.
32. A controller of a drive system of a vertical roller mill having
a grinding table rotatable about a vertical axis, wherein the drive
system comprises an electric motor driving the grinding table, a
frequency converter feeding the electric motor, and a gearbox
arranged between the electric motor and the grinding table, the
controller comprising a processing unit and a memory into which a
computer program having program instructions which, when loaded
into the memory and executed by the processing unit, cause the
controller during operation of the controller to cyclically vary a
rotation speed of the grinding table.
Description
[0001] The present invention relates to a drive control method,
namely a method for controlling a heavy duty drive, in particular a
heavy duty drive for a vertical roller mill for comminuting brittle
materials such as cement raw material, and to a corresponding drive
system operating according to said method.
[0002] Vertical roller mills of the above mentioned type, having a
grinding table rotating about the vertical and grinding rollers
above the grinding table, are subject to severe mechanical
vibrations. The resulting forces and torques can be so powerful
that the grinding process has to be stopped in order to prevent
damage to the drive train, namely the electric motor and gearbox in
particular, or to the plant as a whole.
[0003] In order to minimize such vibrations, the mill operator has
hitherto had to design the process parameters, i.e. in particular
the contact pressure of the grinding rollers, composition of the
material to be ground and amounts of grinding additives such that
the vibrations excited remain below a critical level. However, this
means undesirable process design limitations which negatively
impact many areas. These include the range of products that can be
made from the respective ground material obtained, the
effectiveness of the mill, the energy input required and the
cost-efficiency. Nevertheless, such measures are unreliable, as
much experience is required for correct process control and the
properties of the natural materials before and after grinding are
necessarily always different. This makes it necessary to
continuously optimize the process and adjust it to the raw
material.
[0004] However, extreme vibration states--known in the industry as
"rumbling" of the mill, repeatedly occur, with the result that the
mill has to be stopped and then restarted. This is to the detriment
of the availability and productivity of the plant. There is also
the risk of gearbox and plant damage. To obviate this problem,
process control has hitherto been organized particularly
defensively in order to prevent these mill vibrations as far as
possible. However, the production rate, product quality and the
range of manufacturable products suffer as a result.
[0005] Against this background and because of the increasingly
exacting requirements in respect of availability, efficiency and
Total Cost of Ownership (TCO), the design and arrangement of the
electrical and mechanical components of a drive system and of the
respective drive train of a heavy duty drive, in particular of a
vertical roller mill, are becoming increasingly important.
[0006] For vertical roller mills, drive systems comprising a
gearbox and an electric motor in the form of an asynchronous motor,
preferably a wound rotor, and a frequency converter feeding the
electric motor constitute a preferred solution. Here the mill
gearboxes are in practice implemented as variants of bevel or spur
gear planetary mechanisms. The purpose of the gearing arrangement
is not only speed and torque conversion but also to absorb the
axial grinding forces and transfer them into the base.
[0007] Controlling such a drive system for a vertical roller mill
essentially presents the following problems in practice:
[0008] In order to be able to ensure optimum process control, the
first, apparently trivial task of the drive is to deliver the
predefined rotation speed of the grinding table. As the process
torque demand at the grinding table fluctuates, speed control is
required.
[0009] The load fluctuations and vibration excitations acting on
the drive mechanism are influenced by impulsive loads such as those
produced when the grinding rollers encounter coarse material,
stochastic loads of the grinding process, periodic excitations from
the gearbox and mill kinematics, and a varying contact pressure of
the grinding rollers. The interaction of these load influences
results in a complex load cycle which can even set off resonance
vibrations.
[0010] In addition to the drive train vibrations, an unstable, i.e.
fluidizing or undulating grinding bed, for example, can also cause
extreme vibrational states of the mill, in particular mill
rumbling.
[0011] Lastly the grinding of natural products makes it largely
unpredictable how the grinding process must be adjusted in order to
guarantee quiet running of the mill. It is therefore always a
challenge for the operator at the control desk to find the correct
process parameters. In the end, although the drive alone can
quieten a poorly adjusted process, it cannot correct it.
[0012] The approach proposed here deals with the effect of
undesirable rumbling of a mill as the result of a particular
surface structure of the grinding bed, and an object of the present
invention is accordingly to specify a means of efficiently
preventing or at least reducing such rumbling.
[0013] One reason for mill rumbling caused by the surface structure
of the grinding bed is that the mill, as a resonant system, reacts
to stochastic excitations from the grinding process e.g. with
regular relative movements between the grinding rollers and the
grinding bed. These regular relative movements result from the
particular natural frequency of the mechanics and kinematics of the
grinding rollers which are disposed in a movable, in particular
swiveling manner above the grinding table and the grinding bed
produced thereon during mill operation. The grinding rollers act on
the grinding bed on the one hand because of their own weight and
because of their movable, in particular swivel mounting. In
addition, the action of the grinding rollers on the grinding bed
can be intensified still further by an additionally applied contact
pressure.
[0014] The above mentioned object is achieved by a method for drive
control of a vertical roller mill having the features as claimed in
claim 1. The object is also achieved by a drive system having the
features of the parallel device claim. The vertical roller mill,
also referred to here and in the following sometimes merely as the
mill for short, comprises a grinding table rotating about the
vertical, wherein the grinding table can be driven by means of a
drive train comprising at least one electric motor and usually a
gearbox and is driven during operation of the mill. The method is
characterized in that the rotation speed of the grinding table is
cyclically varied.
[0015] In the case of a drive system designed to carry out such a
method and possibly one or more of the embodiments described below,
namely a drive system for a vertical roller mill comprising a
grinding table rotating about the vertical, the drive system
comprises at least one electric motor, optionally a frequency
converter feeding the electric motor, a gearbox between the at
least one electric motor and the grinding table and optionally a
sensor system for obtaining vibration-relevant measured values, in
particular vibration-relevant measured values in the form of torque
or speed measurements with respect to a rotation speed of a
rotating component of the vertical roller mill or to at least one
driving and/or supporting torque acting in or on the gearbox. The
drive system is characterized by a speed variation device with
which the rotation speed of the grinding table can be varied,
wherein the speed variation device is designed and set up to
operate according to the method outlined above and described in
greater detail below, and carries out such a method during
operation of the drive system.
[0016] In short, the invention is therefore a method and a device
for drive control of a heavy duty arrangement in the form of a
drive system in which the cyclical variation of the rotation speed
of the grinding table has the aim of creating no regular structure
in the grinding bed surface, i.e. no undulation of the grinding
bed. Accordingly, the purpose of the method and the device
operating according to said method is to prevent a possible cause
of mill rumbling at source.
[0017] The advantage of the invention is that by cyclically varying
the rotation speed of the grinding table, rumbling of the mill can
be prevented or eliminated or at least reduced without having to
stop the grinding process, and that this result is achieved by
comparatively simple intervention in the overall system, namely by
appropriately controlling the electric motor. The prevention,
elimination or reduction of the vibrations will hereinafter be
referred to as prevention for short.
[0018] Cyclically varying the rotation speed of the grinding table
is to be understood as meaning varying the rotation speed of the
grinding table using an, in particular, variable speed profile in
which the time-averaged speed profile corresponds to the setpoint
rotation speed of the grinding table. A special form of such
cyclical variation of the rotation speed of the grinding table is
periodic variation of the rotation speed of the grinding table,
e.g. sinusoidally varying the rotation speed of the grinding table
about a setpoint rotation speed of the grinding table.
[0019] Advantageous embodiments of the invention are set forth in
the sub-claims. References used indicate the further development of
the subject matter of the main claim by the features of the
respective sub-claim. They are not to be understood as a waiver of
the achievement of independent, concrete protection for the feature
combination of the sub-claims referred to. In addition, in respect
of interpretation of the claims in the case of a closer
concretization of a feature in a subordinate claim it is assumed
that such a limitation is not present in the respective preceding
claims. Lastly it is pointed out that the method specified here can
also be further developed according to the dependent device claims
and vice versa.
[0020] In an embodiment of the method, cyclical or periodic
variation of the rotation speed of the grinding table is activated
in a time-controlled manner at predefined or predefinable, in
particular equidistant points in time for a predetermined or
predeterminable time period, e.g. every five minutes for ten
seconds at a time. The cyclical or periodic variation of the
rotation speed of the grinding table is then not continuously
active. Outside of the activation of the cyclical or periodic speed
variation, "normal" rotation speed of the grinding table is
produced.
[0021] In an alternative embodiment of the method, the cyclical or
periodic variation of the rotation speed of the grinding table is
activated as a reaction to a vibration-relevant measured value
fluctuation exceeding a predefined or predefinable limit value.
[0022] Vibration-relevant measured values are all the measured
values obtained or obtainable in respect of the mill, the
evaluation of which indicates mechanical vibrations of the mill, in
particular such mechanical vibrations as are termed rumbling.
Possible means of obtaining such vibration-relevant measured values
include sensors in the form of vibration monitors, vibration
sensors or the like which are e.g. mounted on the mill framework or
other parts of the mill structure. Alternatively or additionally
possible are also sensors which are assigned to the drive train
where they acquire vibration-relevant measured values. For example,
it can be provided that the power draw of the electric motor is
measured by means of such a sensor and vibration-relevant data is
derived from an electric motor power draw correlated with varying
load situations so that in this respect measured values relating to
motor current drawn during operation of the mill in each case are
also an example of vibration-relevant measured values.
[0023] If such a measured value exceeds a predefined or
predefinable limit value or possibly repeatedly exceeds such a
limit value, in particular repeatedly exceeds it within a
predefined or predefinable period of time, this indicates existing
or impending mill rumbling. On the basis of such a detection or
prediction of mill rumbling, cyclical or periodic variation of the
rotation speed of the grinding table is activated in order to
eliminate or at least reduce mill rumbling or prevent it from
occurring in the first place.
[0024] In this variant of the method, the cyclical or periodic
varying of the rotation speed of the grinding table does not
therefore take place continuously but only as required, namely if
monitoring of the respective value obtained automatically indicates
the necessity of counteracting an existing, undesirable vibration
or risk of vibration in the form of mill rumbling in each case.
[0025] In an embodiment of the method, cyclically varying the
rotation speed of the grinding table takes the form of periodically
varying the speed, wherein a frequency and/or an amplitude of the
signal waveform underlying the periodic variation of the rotation
speed of the grinding table and, alternatively or additionally,
possibly also the signal waveform itself is increased or reduced,
i.e. changed, as a function of a vibration-relevant measured value
fluctuation exceeding a predefined or predefinable threshold value.
In this variant of the method, the periodic variation of the
rotation speed of the grinding table is therefore itself varied on
the basis of automatic evaluation of the above mentioned measured
value. The threshold value in question can be below or above the
limit value mentioned earlier. In the case of continuous variation
of the rotation speed of the grinding table, a threshold value
below a limit value indicating existing or impending rumbling is a
possibility. The attainment or exceeding of such a threshold value
then indicates that the already occurring periodic variation of the
rotation speed of the grinding table is insufficient to prevent or
eliminate mill rumbling. In the case of periodic variation of the
rotation speed of the grinding table solely as a function of a
monitored limit value, the threshold value additionally considered
in this embodiment of the method will be above such a limit value.
Exceeding of the threshold value is then an automatically evaluable
indication that periodically varying the rotation speed of the
grinding table is insufficient for preventing or eliminating mill
rumbling.
[0026] As a countermeasure, both in the case of grinding table
speed variation that is active continuously or only when required
or intermittently, the periodic variation is itself varied, e.g. by
increasing the period of the underlying signal waveform. This is
aimed at changing the undulation of the grinding bed and the aim of
the thereby achieved change in the undulation of the grinding bed
is in turn that no natural frequencies in the overall mill system
are excited by the resulting movements of the grinding rollers
because of grinding bed undulation and therefore mill rumbling is
prevented or eliminated, in any case at least reduced, namely e.g.
in its frequency and/or vibration intensity and/or echo speed.
[0027] A sinusoidal profile, a triangular profile, a rectangular
profile or a ramp profile, for example, can be used for
periodically varying the rotation speed of the grinding table. Such
profiles can easily be generated using a signal generator or the
like and, in the case of software implementation of the method, by
appropriate mathematical expressions or families of
characteristics.
[0028] In another or alternative embodiment of the method, a change
in a respective signal waveform with which the rotation speed of
the grinding table is periodically varied is initiated as a
function of a vibration-relevant measured value fluctuation
exceeding a predefined or predefinable threshold value. This
variant of the method is characterized by parallels with the
changing (frequency, amplitude or signal waveform) of the periodic
variation of the rotation speed of the grinding table already
described above. Here, however, it is not the period of the
periodic variation of the rotation speed of the grinding table that
is changed as a function of the exceeding of the threshold value,
but the signal waveform underlying said periodic variation. The
statements made above may be referred to regarding the position of
the threshold value and for the use of this variant of the method
either for continuous or merely as-required or intermittent
variation of the rotation speed of the grinding table. As a result,
this variant is designed to change the grinding table speed
variation according to the automatically detectable exceeding of
the threshold value which indicates that mill rumbling cannot be
prevented or eliminated using the existing periodic variation of
the rotation speed of the grinding table. This change is
accomplished by changing the signal waveform. This also produces a
change in the undulation of the grinding bed. As in the case of the
method variant described above, this is designed to ensure that no
natural frequencies are excited in the overall mill system due to
the resulting movements of the grinding rollers because of the
grinding bed undulation, so that in this way the mill rumbling is
prevented or eliminated, in any case at least reduced.
[0029] The two variants for changing the periodic variation of the
rotation speed of the grinding table, namely changing the period
and changing the signal waveform, in particular quantitative and/or
qualitative changing of the signal waveform, are self-evidently
also combinable.
[0030] Because it is particularly a matter of preventing a grinding
bed surface regularity that is conducive to resonances, another
possibility is to apply the individual methods in a quasi-random
manner. A software implementation of such a method provides all the
possible variants of the method as functional units or the changing
of the period and the changing of the signal waveform as
parameterizable functional units. Based on a random number
generator or the like, individual functional units and/or
parameters for the parameterization of the functional units or
combinations of possibly individually parameterized functional
units are then selected in order to counteract existing or
impending mill rumbling detected on the basis of the measured value
monitoring outlined above.
[0031] In a specific embodiment of individual method variants
described above, torque or rotation speed measurements are used as
vibration-relevant measured values and are acquired. The further
description of the approach proposed here will be based, without
loss of generality, on such torque or speed measurements. These
will now be subsumed under the term measured values. To obtain such
measured values, a sensor system, i.e. at least one sensor
incorporated in the sensor system or belonging to the sensor
system, is used to measure a rotation speed of a rotating component
of the drive train and/or at least one driving and/or supporting
torque acting on the gearbox.
[0032] A corresponding embodiment of the drive system outlined
above is characterized by such a sensor system for obtaining a
vibration-relevant measured value in the form of a torque or speed
measurement, wherein by means of the sensor system a rotation speed
of a rotating component of the vertical roller mill and/or at least
one driving and/or supporting torque acting in or on the gearbox
can be measured and is measured during operation.
[0033] In this connection it should be noted that the use of
sensors, e.g. sensors for acquiring torque or rotation speed
measurements in the drive train (drive sensor system) instead of
vibration sensors on the mill structure has apparently not been
taken into consideration hitherto. However, according to the
inventor's insight, mechanical vibration of the mill and therefore
also rumbling of the mill can also be detected using such
measurements. It is actually even the case that such measured
values replicate respective process events even more directly, as
the events in the grinding mechanism become much more clearly
apparent, according to the inventor's insight, in the degree of
rotational freedom of the drive than in the vibration level of the
mill structure as a whole. This is because the rumbling is a
periodic collapse of the supporting effect of the grinding bed on
the grinding rollers. Associated with the loss of this supporting
effect, e.g. because of undulation of the grinding bed or yielding
aside of a fluidized material to be ground, there also arises a
breakdown of the loading torque exerted by the grinding bed on the
grinding table therefore directly on the drive train. This torque
characteristic is directly detectable in said measured values,
namely even before the grinding rollers move so strongly that the
vibration also perceptibly spreads to the rest of the mill
structure. Undesirable states such as mill rumbling or incipient
mill rumbling can be detected earlier and more precisely in this
way. Comparative studies have shown that detection of mill rumbling
via vibration sensors usually takes place after a few seconds at
the earliest. In this time the drive is subject to just over a
hundred load cycles (at a rumble frequency of e.g. 15 Hz).
Evaluation of the drive sensor system allows rumbling to be
identified after just three to ten load cycles, i.e. in less than
one second. The advantage of using a sensor system of this kind and
of the thereby obtained measurements is therefore that, because
mill rumbling can be detected earlier, countermeasures, i.e. even
emergency shutdown of the drive ("emergency stop"), for example,
but self-evidently also the cyclical or periodic varying of the
rotation speed of the grinding table highlighted here, can be
initiated earlier and therefore the stressing of the drive, but
also of the mill as a whole, by mill rumbling can be reduced.
[0034] In one embodiment of the method, the electric motor is fed
by a frequency converter and the rotation speed of the grinding
table is cyclically or periodically varied by means of appropriate
control of the frequency converter. By means of a frequency
converter, the described cyclical or periodic varying of the
rotation speed of the grinding table by appropriate control of the
electric motor, but also the changing of the period or the changing
of the underlying signal waveform and combinations thereof, can be
comparatively easily achieved. An alternative to a frequency
converter is a superposition gear with which the above described
cyclical or periodic varying of the rotation speed of the grinding
table can be achieved in basically an equivalent manner.
[0035] The method and the drive system operating according to said
method are based on the cyclical or periodic variation of the
rotation speed of the grinding table and on a speed variation
device designed for that purpose. Individual aspects of the
functionality of the speed variation device have already been
described above. The functionality of the speed variation device,
the optional acquisition and processing of the measured values in
question functionally upstream of the cyclical or periodic
variation of the speed, and the resolution of the variation of the
rotation speed of the grinding table functionally downstream of the
speed variation device can be realized in hardware and/or software.
In the case of software realization, the invention is also a
computer program having program coding means for executing all the
steps of the method described here and in the following when the
computer program is run on a controller or the like for a drive
system for a vertical roller mill. Further, the invention is
therefore also a digital storage medium having electronically
readable control signals which can interact with a programmable
controller for a drive system for a vertical roller mill such that
such a method can be executed. Finally, the invention is also a
drive system of the above mentioned type which comprises a
processing unit and a memory, wherein such a computer program is
loaded into the memory and is executed during operation of the
drive system by the processing unit thereof.
[0036] An exemplary embodiment of the invention will now be
explained in greater detail with reference to the accompanying
drawings. Equivalent items or elements are provided with the same
reference characters in the figures.
[0037] It should also be pointed out that the approach described
here and individual and possibly combined embodiments can also be
combined with the approach proposed and specific embodiments
described in the same applicant's parallel application attributable
to the same inventor and having the applicant's internal reference
number 201312099 (official application number not yet known). In
this respect, the complete disclosure content of this parallel
application, especially having regard to the therein described
pattern recognition and the action on the basis of a detected
pattern, is implied in the description presented here.
[0038] The exemplary embodiment should not be interpreted as a
limitation of the invention. On the contrary, within the scope of
the present disclosure, changes and modifications are possible,
especially such modifications and combinations that, for example,
as a result of combinations or modifications of individual features
or elements or method steps contained in the general description,
in the descriptions of various embodiments, and in the claims, and
illustrated in the drawings, can be comprehended by persons skilled
in the art as far as the achievement of the object is concerned
and, as a result of combinable features, lead to a novel subject
matter or to novel method steps and/or sequences of method
steps.
[0039] FIG. 1 shows a greatly simplified schematic representation
of a vertical roller mill comprising a grinding table driven by
means of a heavy duty drive,
[0040] FIG. 2 shows a plan view onto the grinding table and
grinding bed,
[0041] FIG. 3 shows a periodically varied rotation speed of the
grinding table of the vertical roller mill, and
[0042] FIG. 4 shows a drive system of the vertical roller mill
incorporating a controller which causes the rotation speed of the
grinding table of the mill as shown in FIG. 3 to be cyclically and
periodically varied.
[0043] FIG. 1 shows a greatly simplified schematic representation
of a vertical roller mill 10 for comminuting brittle material, e.g.
cement raw material. The vertical roller mill 10 comprises a
grinding table 12 rotatable about the vertical. The grinding table
12 is driven by means of a heavy duty drive in the form of a motor,
in particular an electric motor 14, and, in the example shown here,
by means of a gearbox 16 located between electric motor 14 and
grinding table 12. The gearbox 16 is shown here, without loss of
further generality, as bevel-gear teeth with following planetary
gearing not shown in greater detail. The gearbox 16 can also
comprise spur-gear teeth or the like and/or a preceding or
following planetary gearing or the like.
[0044] The vertical roller mill 10 comprises at least one driven
shaft. In the illustration in FIG. 1, the vertical roller mill 10
comprises a motor shaft 18 and a grinding table shaft 20. All the
means for transmitting the driving force of the electric motor 14
to the grinding table 12 are termed the drive train. Here the drive
train comprises at least the electric motor 14, the motor shaft 18,
the gearbox and the grinding table shaft 20.
[0045] The vertical roller mill 10 as a whole is a resonant system.
During operation of the vertical roller mill 10, the electric motor
14 causes the grinding table 12 to rotate. On the grinding table 12
there is, as a result of the grinding process and as a result of
supplied material to be ground, a grinding bed 22, i.e. a mixture
of ground material and material to be ground. The grinding effect
is achieved by a grinding roller 24 or a plurality of grinding
rollers 24 pressing onto the grinding bed 22 and the rotating
grinding table 12 because of their weight on the one hand, but on
the other hand in some cases also because of additionally applied
forces which are applied e.g. by means of a hydraulic cylinder or
the like engaging with a swivel-mounted grinding roller 24.
[0046] FIG. 2 shows a simplified schematic plan view of the
grinding table 12 with the grinding bed 22 and the (here) two
grinding rollers 24. The radial dotted lines within the grinding
bed 22 are to indicate an undulation of the grinding bed 22 that
frequently arises during the grinding process. Such undulation of
the grinding bed 22 is a possible cause of the mill rumbling that
is to be prevented using the approach presented here. If the
grinding bed 22 is undulating, it is easy to see that the
swivel-mounted grinding rollers 24 follow the surface of the
grinding bed 22 and the thereby caused upward and downward movement
of the grinding rollers 24 is transmitted to the mill 10 in the
form of vibrations. If the natural frequency of the mill 10 is
excited in this way, resonance can even be set up.
[0047] Such vibrations have hitherto been detected by means of a
sensor system disposed on the mill framework (vibration sensor; not
shown). As soon as a vibration measurement acquired by the sensor
system exceeds a limit value, the electric motor 14 is stopped and
the mill 10 is subsequently restarted.
[0048] Here it is proposed that a rotation speed of the grinding
table 12 is cyclically, in particular periodically, varied. To
illustrate this, FIG. 3 shows a normally constant rotation speed 26
of the grinding table 12 apart from operational fluctuations, and a
rotation speed 28 that is periodically varied according to the
approach proposed here, namely a rotation speed 28 of the grinding
table 12 that is varied symmetrically about the original constant
rotation speed 26. The frequency underlying the periodic variation
of the rotation speed 28 of the grinding table 12 is in the 0.1 Hz
range, for example. The amplitude of the periodic variation is e.g.
in the range of 1% of the effective setpoint speed without the
variation. In the example shown, the periodic variation of the
rotation speed of the grinding table 12 has an underlying
triangular signal waveform. Other signal waveforms such as a
sinusoidal signal, a square-wave signal, a ramp-shaped signal, etc.
are also possible. The illustrated periodic variation of the speed
26 is a special form of a cyclical variation of the speed. The
feature of such a periodic variation of the speed 26, but also of
each more general cyclical variation of the speed 26 of the
grinding table 12, is that the average value over time of the
varied speed 26 results in the setpoint speed and that the varied
speed values continually assume or pass through the setpoint speed
value.
[0049] According to the inventor's insight, varying the rotation
speed of the grinding table 12 prevents mill rumbling from
occurring at all, because the cyclical or periodic variation of the
rotation speed of the grinding table 12 prevents the formation of a
regular undulation of the grinding bed 22 as shown in FIG. 2.
Varying the rotation speed of the grinding table, especially
periodically varying the rotation speed of the grinding table,
produces a local displacement of the wave contour in the surface of
the grinding bed 22 compared to a state arising in the case of an
unvaried rotation speed. This disrupts the regular excitation of
the grinding rollers 24, i.e. throws them out of their rhythm
somewhat, and no resonance is produced. According to the inventor's
insights, a slight variation (ranging from 1 to 5%) is sufficient
to achieve the desired effect. As a result, the mill 10 rumbles
less frequently, which advantageously impacts availability and the
operator's freedoms in terms of process design. In addition, the
mill and drive mechanics are subject to much less stress.
[0050] This is a method for drive control of the mill 10 in that,
in this way, a surface structure of the grinding bed 22 resulting
from the driving of the grinding table 12 is reacted to by
indirectly or directly varying the rotation speed of the grinding
table 12 in a cyclical or periodic manner.
[0051] The described cyclical or periodic varying of the rotation
speed of the grinding table 12 can be active continuously or in a
time-controlled manner. In the case of time-controlled activation
of the cyclical or periodic variation of the rotation speed of the
grinding table 12 it is possible for the speed variation to be
activated at equidistant points in time for a predefined or
predefinable time period and then deactivated again.
[0052] The described cyclical or periodic varying of the rotation
speed of the grinding table 12 can also be activated as a function
of a state detected in relation to the mill 10. This can be done
using a sensor system 30 (FIG. 1) assigned in particular to the
drive train, i.e. in particular the electric motor 14, motor shaft
18, gearbox 16 or grinding table shaft 20, or to the grinding table
12, to obtain vibration-relevant measured values 32, e.g. torque or
rotation speed measurements 32. Specifically vibration-relevant
measured values 32 in the form of torque measurements 32 are a
measure of the torque or gearbox torque transmitted by means of the
gearbox 16, i.e. a measure of a torque which is termed the
mechanically effective torque in the drive train, in particular in
the gearbox 16, to differentiate it from an electrical torque
acting on the electric motor 14. On the basis of such a measured
value 32 (or the pattern recognition described in the parallel
application having the internal reference number 201312099) the
cyclical or periodic speed variation can be activated as required,
e.g. whenever an acquired measured value 32 exceeds a predefined or
predefinable limit.
[0053] To cyclically or periodically vary the rotation speed of the
grinding table 12, a speed variation device 34 (FIG. 1) is
provided. This comprises, for example, a signal generator 36
realized in software or hardware and--if the method and its
embodiments are implemented in software--a computer program 38 and
a processing unit 40 in the form or in the manner of a
microprocessor provided for executing the computer program 38. The
computer program 38 is loaded into a memory 42 of the speed
variation device 34.
[0054] By generating an appropriate cyclical or periodic signal,
the signal generator 36 causes the rotation speed of the grinding
table 12 to be cyclically or periodically varied by e.g. combining
a resulting, cyclical or periodic output signal 44 of the speed
variation device 34 with a speed setpoint value 46 and feeding the
combination of the two signals 44, 46 (addition or subtraction) to
a frequency converter 48 connected upstream of the electric motor
14 in per se known manner which, on the basis of the input signal
50 thus obtained, produces a respective supply voltage, in
particular an AC voltage, for driving the electric motor 14. The
speed of the electric motor 14 therefore fluctuates with the
cyclicality or periodicity predefined by the speed variation device
34 and the resulting rotation speed of the grinding table 12 also
fluctuates accordingly.
[0055] Lastly FIG. 4 shows in schematically simplified form that
the speed variation device 34 is e.g. a sub-functionality of a
controller 52 or the like, i.e. an open-loop control device for
controlling the frequency converter 48. In addition to the speed
variation device 34 or a software implementation of the speed
variation device 34, the controller 52 can also comprise other
functional units such as a closed-loop control device 54 for
controlling the speed of the electric motor 14 or similar. The
controller 52, the frequency converter 48 and the electric motor 14
together constitute a drive system 56 for driving the mill 10.
Instead of the frequency converter 48 or in addition to a frequency
converter 48, it is also possible for a superposition gear to be
used.
[0056] In particular embodiments of the approach described here,
the signal waveform underlying the periodic speed variation and/or
a period 58 (FIG. 4) of the output signal 44 of the speed variation
device 34 underlying the periodic speed variation, for example, can
be selected by means of the speed variation device 34.
[0057] Although the invention has been illustrated and described in
detail by an exemplary embodiment, the invention is not limited by
the example(s) disclosed and other variations may be inferred
therefrom by the average person skilled in the art without
departing from the scope of protection sought to the invention.
[0058] Individual prominent aspects of the description submitted
here may be summarized as follows: specified are a method for drive
control of a vertical roller mill 10 having a grinding table 12
rotatable about the vertical, wherein the grinding table 12 can be
driven by a drive train comprising an electric motor 14 and a
gearbox 16, wherein a rotation speed of the grinding table 12 is
varied cyclically, in particular periodically, in order to prevent
rumbling of the mill 10, and a drive system 56 operating according
to the method with which a rotation speed of the grinding table 12
can be periodically varied.
* * * * *