U.S. patent application number 11/960311 was filed with the patent office on 2008-04-24 for multi-compartment reagent container having means to inhibit re-use thereof.
This patent application is currently assigned to DADE BEHRING INC.. Invention is credited to William J. Sr. Devlin, Timothy P. Evers, Peter L. Gebrian, Thai Q. Huynh-Ba.
Application Number | 20080095670 11/960311 |
Document ID | / |
Family ID | 25488638 |
Filed Date | 2008-04-24 |
United States Patent
Application |
20080095670 |
Kind Code |
A1 |
Gebrian; Peter L. ; et
al. |
April 24, 2008 |
MULTI-COMPARTMENT REAGENT CONTAINER HAVING MEANS TO INHIBIT RE-USE
THEREOF
Abstract
A method for automatically determining whether a reagent
container is new and unused or whether the reagent container has
been previously used whenever reagent containers are initially
placed onto an analyzer. Unused containers have a weakened member
that can be deformed by a moveable sensor probe when containers are
placed onto the analyzer.
Inventors: |
Gebrian; Peter L.;
(Townsend, DE) ; Devlin; William J. Sr.; (Lincoln
University, PA) ; Evers; Timothy P.; (Wilmington,
DE) ; Huynh-Ba; Thai Q.; (Newark, DE) |
Correspondence
Address: |
DADE BEHRING INC.;LEGAL DEPARTMENT
1717 DEERFIELD ROAD
DEERFIELD
IL
60015
US
|
Assignee: |
DADE BEHRING INC.
1717 Deerfield Road Legal Dept. - Patents
Deerfield
IL
60015
|
Family ID: |
25488638 |
Appl. No.: |
11/960311 |
Filed: |
December 19, 2007 |
Related U.S. Patent Documents
|
|
|
|
|
|
Application
Number |
Filing Date |
Patent Number |
|
|
10858156 |
Jun 1, 2004 |
|
|
|
11960311 |
Dec 19, 2007 |
|
|
|
09949132 |
Sep 7, 2001 |
6943030 |
|
|
10858156 |
Jun 1, 2004 |
|
|
|
Current U.S.
Class: |
422/400 |
Current CPC
Class: |
G01N 2035/0436 20130101;
B01L 99/00 20130101; G01N 2035/00772 20130101; B01L 3/5085
20130101; Y10T 436/12 20150115; G01N 35/1002 20130101 |
Class at
Publication: |
422/099 |
International
Class: |
B01L 11/00 20060101
B01L011/00 |
Claims
1. A mechanism for confirming that a reagent container has not
previously been used on a clinical analyzer, the mechanism
comprising: a probe; a weakened member on the reagent container;
and, a sensor providing a signal representative of interactions
between the probe and the lock-out member when the reagent
container is placed on the analyzer.
2. The mechanism of claim 1 wherein the probe is urged against the
weakened member when the reagent container is placed on the
analyzer.
3. The mechanism of claim 1 wherein the container comprises a
generally linear multi-well array having opposed edgewalls between
two sidewalls.
4. The mechanism of claim 3 wherein the weakened member is attached
to one of said edgewalls.
5. The mechanism of claim 4 wherein the weakened member is mounted
between pylons attached to the one edgewall.
6. The mechanism of claim 5 wherein the weakened member and the
pylons define an open region proximate said edgewall.
7. The mechanism of claim 5 wherein the weakened member comprises a
bridge weakened in its central region by a notch contiguous with
the open region.
8. The mechanism of claim 7 wherein the bridge is weakened by a
pair of cusps formed at the ends of the weakened bridge.
9. The mechanism of claim 8 wherein the cusps are formed on the
opposite side of the bridge from the notch.
10. The mechanism of claim 1 wherein the analyzer is equipped with
a computer-implemented control program that monitors the output
signal representative of interactions between the probe and the
weakened member to confirm that the reagent container is new and
unused.
11. The analyzer of claim 10 wherein the output signal reflects the
length of travel of the probe or the displacing force of the probe
or the resilience of the weakened member.
12. The mechanism of claim 10 wherein the computer-implemented
control program compares the output signals to a range of
predetermined signal values in order to determine whether the
reagent container is unused or previously used.
Description
REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS
[0001] This application is a Continuation of U.S. Ser. No.
10/858,156, filed Jun. 1, 2004, now pending, which is a Divisional
of U.S. Ser. No. 09/949,132, filed Sep. 7, 2001, now U.S. Pat. No.
6,943,030.
FIELD OF THE INVENTION
[0002] The present invention relates to a method and apparatus for
automatically processing a patient's biological fluids such as
urine, blood serum, plasma, cerebrospinal fluid and the like. In
particular, the present invention provides a method to prevent
accidental re-use of reagents contained within a previously used
reagent container.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
[0003] Various types of tests related to patient diagnosis and
therapy can be performed by analysis for an analyte within a sample
of a patient's infections, bodily fluids or abscesses. Patient
samples are combined with various assay reagents in reaction
vessels; the mixture is then incubated and analyzed using
interrogating radiation measurements to aid in treatment of the
patient. Automated clinical analyzers for chemical, immunochemical
and biological testing of such sample-reagent mixtures are well
known, typically adding one or two assay reagents to a liquid
sample, the reagents being obtained from reagent storage
compartments maintained on-board the analyzer.
[0004] For convenience and compactness within an automated chemical
analyzer, it is desirable to store all reagents needed to conduct a
single assay within contiguous compartments or vessels. Typical of
such vessels is the multi-compartment reagent container available
for use in an analyzer known as the Dimension.RTM. Chemical
Analyzer, sold by Dade Behring Inc., Deerfield, Ill. This
multi-compartmented container is in the form of a container strip
described in U.S. Pat. No. 4,720,374, entitled "Container Having a
Sonication Compartment", issued to Ramachandran, and includes a
rigid peripheral band formed of an inert plastic. The band is
formed integrally with each of several reagent containers so that
the container strip generally tapers in a substantially elongated
wedge-like manner from a first edge to a second edge. The
wedge-shaped plan profile for the container strip facilitates the
mounting of a plurality of such strips in a circumferentially
adjacent generally radially extending relationship across a
rotatable reagent carrying plate, like described in U.S. Pat. No.
4,863,693, entitled "Analysis Instrument Having A Blow Molded
Reaction Chamber", issued to Howell, and having a reagent supply
arrangement with an array of multi-compartment reagent containers
disposed in substantially radial directions from the vertical
center of rotation of rotatable plate. The reagent containers may
be refrigerated or cooled, if desired, as is discussed therein. The
reagent supply includes a reagent dispensing probe that is movable
in substantially radially inward or radially outward directions
with respect to the plate to aspirate a selected reagent from any
one of the segmented reagent compartments of the multi-compartment
reagent containers and to deposit a predetermined amount of reagent
into one or more of a number of reaction vessels disposed at
angular positions arranged around the periphery of the plate.
[0005] The tops of the multi-compartment reagent containers may be
sealed with a suitable laminate that prevents gas and vapor escape
and yet permits penetration by a probe for aspiration etc. The
plastic used for the receptacle is polyethylene and the laminate is
a three-ply laminate of a polyester film, a polyvinylidene chloride
coating on the polyester film, and finally a sheet of polyethylene
adhered to the coating. The laminate is heat sealed to the
peripheral surface of the polyethylene compartments with the lower
polyethylene sheet contacting the compartment rim. Variations of
such a multi-compartment reagent container are described in U.S.
Pat. Nos. 4,935,274 and 5,009,942 all of which are assigned to the
assignee of the present invention.
[0006] A persistent problem with the use of reagent containers as
employed on automated clinical analyzers is accidental attempts to
re-use reagent containers that have been previously used on such an
analyzer. When a container is used on an analyzer, partial amounts
of reagents are removed by reagent aspiration devices; if the
container is removed from the analyzer, it is possible that reagent
quantities remaining therein may become contaminated or stored in a
hostile environment so that their reactive characteristics become
altered. In such instances, erroneous analytical results may be
reported by the analyzer before the situation is noted and
corrected. Accordingly, it is desirable whenever a reagent
container is initially placed onto an analyzer, that an automated
method be provided to determine whether the container is new and
unused or whether the reagent container has been previously
used.
[0007] U.S. Pat. No. 5,976,469 discloses an analytical specimen cup
having a removable lid of a type for defining a test space with a
chemical strip mounted therein; the cup includes a
selectively-removable protective cover for selectively covering and
uncovering an outer surface of a transparent portion of an outer
partition forming the test space. The protective cover is formed as
one piece with an inner partition to be attached thereto by a dual
living hinge. The lid is rectangular in shape and includes an
elongated magnifying lens which has protrusions extending into
blind holes of the inner partition. The magnifying lens extends
across the transparent portion of the outer partition. When the
protective cover is in a closed position it impinges on the
magnifying lens.
[0008] U.S. Pat. No. 5,645,824 discloses a color changing reagent
composition for coating onto syringe needles and other needle
containing medical devices which upon contact with such bodily
fluids as blood, mucous, saliva, and semen will cause the
composition coated needle to change in color to signal a prior use
and contamination with a possibly infected bodily fluid.
[0009] U.S. Pat. No. 5,472,415 discloses an instrument for
evaluating the fit of a corresponding orthopedic implant. The
instrument is intended and designed to be a disposable, single use
provisional instrument component. The provisional instrument
component is made of a material which can be sterilized by gamma
irradiation, but which provides a visible indicator, such as
visible deformation, upon re-sterilization by exposure to a heated
environment, thereby discouraging or preventing re-use of the
component.
[0010] U.S. Pat. No. 5,403,551 discloses an assaying device for
both collecting and analyzing a sample which includes a container
and an opening for collecting the sample in a chamber for storing
the sample. A cap is provided for sealing the container opening and
at least one assay system is attached to the container for
chemically analyzing the sample. A channel is provided for enabling
a portion of the sample to enter the assay system upon a change of
orientation of the container. A tamper-proof device is provided
through the use of a releasable seal which permits the sample to
enter the assay system only when desired.
[0011] U.S. Pat. No. 5,255,804 discloses a tamper-proof closure for
a tube includes a neck projection on a neck of the tube, which neck
projection is riveted to an edge of a sleeve section provided in a
cap. After the neck projection has been broken off to use the tube,
the cap can be replaced on the tube, however, the connection is so
loose that when the tube is picked up again, the cap is immediately
detached from the neck, thus indicating prior use.
[0012] U.S. Pat. No. 4,591,062 discloses a tamper-evident closure
apparatus for internally pressurized containers includes a closure
provided with a mechanism for venting the internal pressurized gas
upon initial unsealing of the container and a tamper-indicating
device adapted to be acted upon by the vented gas to indicate that
an initial unsealing of the container has occurred. The
tamper-indicating device may be, for example, chemically activated
to change colors when acted upon by the vented gas or may be
mechanically activated so that venting of the pressurized gas
causes a visibly apparent disruption, distortion or the like to
indicate initial unsealing of the container.
[0013] U.S. Pat. No. 4,286,640 discloses a tamper-resistant cover
for the port of a container for medical liquids which when applied
to the port indicates that an additive material has been introduced
into the container. The port cover is molded from a resinous
plastic material and includes latch portions which fit into a latch
bar with the latch bar serving as a means to prevent access with
the latch portions so as to result in a tamper-resistant structure.
The latch portions are in the form of barbed sections and are
guided by means of an inclined ramp into latch openings in such a
manner that a compression fit is provided so that after the barbed
sections are forced through the latch openings the barbed sections
will expand to engage latch surfaces in the latching bar.
[0014] From this discussion of the state of art in automated
clinical analyzers, it may be seen that while there has been
progress toward introduction of tamper-evident containers, there
has been no progress made toward reducing the potential problems
caused by re-use of a clinical assay reagent container. Thus, there
remains an unmet need for a method and reagent container adapted to
disable an analyzer whenever a previously used reagent container is
presented to the analyzer, and/or to alert an operator that results
reported by the analyzer were obtained using a previously used
reagent container and that the assay results may therefore be
suspect.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
[0015] The principal object of the invention is to provide a method
for automatically determining whether a reagent container is new
and unused or whether the reagent container has been previously
used whenever a reagent container is initially placed onto an
analyzer. In a first exemplary embodiment of the present invention,
whenever a reagent container is placed onto a clinical analyzer, a
moveable sensor probe within the analyzer determines the presence
or absence of a lock-out member attached to the reagent container.
Analysis of the length of travel of the probe, taken with the
displacing force of the probe and the resilience of the lock-out
member, is undertaken to ensure that the reagent container is new
and unused. In addition, attempts to over-ride the lock-out member
may be detected if the length of travel of the probe and the
displacing force do not fall within previously predetermined
ranges. In this embodiment, the lock-out member may be dislodged
from the container by the probe.
[0016] In an alternate embodiment of the invention, the lock-out
member is of a "two-position snap" design in which a selectively
weakened bridge member is displaced or toggled from an original
"new" location to a "used" location whenever the container is
initially placed onto the analyzer. In this embodiment, the bridge
member is retained as a permanent but displaced portion of the
reagent container. In practicing either embodiment of the present
invention, the analyzer may be programmed to automatically eject a
previously used reagent container; alternately, the analyzer may
allow sample analysis to continue uninterrupted with reagents from
a previously used container but automatically noting such re-use in
the reported analytical results.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0017] The invention will be more fully understood from the
following detailed description thereof taken in connection with the
accompanying drawings which form a part of this application and in
which:
[0018] FIG. 1 is a schematic plan view of a reagent container
having features needed to practice an exemplary embodiment of
lock-out features of the present invention;
[0019] FIG. 2 is an isometric view of the reagent container of FIG.
1 illustrating an alternate lock-out embodiment of the present
invention;
[0020] FIG. 2A is an isometric view of the alternate lock-out
embodiment of FIG. 2 illustrating the use of a sensor probe in
breaking away a flag portion of the reagent container of FIG.
1;
[0021] FIG. 3 illustrates signals typically generated by the sensor
probe of FIG. 2A when practicing the present invention;
[0022] FIG. 4 is an enlarged view of an exemplary lock-out member
of the reagent container of FIG. 1 in an unused condition;
[0023] FIG. 5 is an isometric view of the lock-out member of FIG. 4
in an unused condition;
[0024] FIG. 6 is an enlarged view of an exemplary lock-out member
of the reagent container of FIG. 1 in a used condition;
[0025] FIG. 7 is a schematic elevation view of the reagent
container of FIG. 1 illustrating an exemplary embodiment of the
present invention employing the lock-out member of FIG. 4;
[0026] FIG. 8 is a schematic plan view illustrating the embodiment
of FIG. 7 employing the lock-out member of FIG. 4; and,
[0027] FIG. 9 is a plot of sensor signals generated when practicing
the embodiment of FIG. 7.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
[0028] FIG. 1, taken with FIG. 2, shows schematically the elements
of a multi-compartment reagent container 10 comprising a plurality
of compartments 14 arranged in an end-to-end relationship to form a
container strip generally enclosed between two sidewalls 12
depending downwardly from a top surface 15. The reagent container
10 may be fabricated in any convenient manner and formed of
suitable material such as an inert plastic. The top surface 15 is
joined to or is preferably formed integrally with each of the
compartments 14 such that reagent container 10 generally tapers in
a substantially elongated wedge-like manner from a first wider
edgewall 18 to a second less wide edgewall 16. This wedge-shaped
plan profile for the container 10 facilitates the mounting of a
plurality of such reagent containers 10 in a circumferentially
adjacent, generally radially extending relationship across a
rotatable reagent carrying plate (U.S. Pat. No. 4,863,693). It
should be appreciated however that the individual containers may
take any predetermined configuration and may be used alone or
arranged together in any convenient number and remain within the
contemplation of this invention.
[0029] As is described in the aforementioned U.S. Pat. No.
4,720,374, such reagent containers 10 are sold under the tradename
FLEX.TM. cartridge by Dade Behring Inc, Deerfield, Ill. and contain
reagents as necessary to perform a particular given assay. Each of
the compartments 14 generally have the form of a closed well
defined by generally opposed pairs of generally parallel and
integrally formed sidewalls and endwalls. The upper surfaces of the
sidewalls and the endwalls together with the upper surface 15 of
the reagent container 10 in the vicinity thereof register to define
a substantially planar sealing surface peripherally surrounding the
open upper end of the compartments 14. Each of the compartments 14
is closed by a downwardly sloping floor. The top surface 15 of the
multi-compartment reagent container 10 may be sealed with a
suitable laminate (not shown) that prevents gas and vapor escape
and yet permits penetration by a probe for aspiration, etc.
[0030] A principal object of the present invention is to provide a
method for automatically determining whether the reagent container
10 is new and unused or whether the reagent container 10 has been
previously used whenever reagent container 10 is initially placed
onto an analyzer. The terms "new" and "unused" are meant to convey
a condition of having not previously been placed into an analyzer,
irregardless of whether or not reagents have been extracted from
compartments 14. In a first embodiment of the present invention,
reagent container 10 is provided with a punch-out flag member 21
(FIGS. 2 and 2A) having the shape of a rectangular tab in a
lowermost portion of either sidewall 12. Flag member 21 is
preferably formed when container 10 is molded and is of the same
material as is container 10 but is attached to sidewall 12 only
along a weakened top flag edge 23 (shown in dotted lines) and is
unattached to sidewall 12 along two sidewall edges 25 of the flag
member 21. Obvious equivalents to flag member 21 include sidewall,
endwall, top or bottom flag-like portions having circular, oblong
and similar shapes and which are semi-attached to container 10.
When container 10 is placed onto the analyzer, a moveable sensor
probe 27 inside the analyzer is automatically extended by an
appropriate actuator into contact with flag member 21. Sensor probe
27 comprises a conventional pressure-reading sensor and
displacement transducer adapted to provide electronic signals
indicative of the resistive forces encountered by probe 27 as well
as of the length of travel of sensor probe 27. Such probes are well
known in the art, being supplied by companies like Schaevitz
Engineering, Hampton Va. Upon contact with flag member 21, sensor
probe 27 generates a non-zero resistive force signal like that
shown by letter "C" corresponding to a position #1 in FIG. 3 where
the probe 27 is initially brought into physical contact with
container 10. Continued movement of sensor probe 27 inwardly into
the body of container 10 corresponding to a position #2 in FIG. 3
causes a bending along weakened flag edge 23 of flag member 21
inwardly from sidewall 12, accompanied by increased resistive
forces as indicated by the letter "B" in FIG. 3. Even further
continued movement of sensor probe 27 inwardly into the body of
container 10 causes weakened flag edge 23 to rupture and snap flag
member 21 free from sidewall 12, as indicated by the letter "S" in
FIG. 3 corresponding to a position #3. It is well within the skill
of art to adjust the thrust forces of signal probe 27 in accord
with the connective strength of weakened flag edge 23 to obtain
such tensile and rupturing forces for relatively brittle materials
of construction. Alternately, in an embodiment in which container
10 is constructed of less brittle and more pliable materials, flag
member 21 may be bent inwardly and not dislodged from container 10.
Such situations permit that the flag member 21 may be re-bent
outwardly near its original location and the signals generated by
probe 27 may not be as reliable as desired.
[0031] It is well within the state of art for the analyzer to be
equipped with computer-implemented control programs that monitor
the shape of the signal curve generated by sensor probe 27 to
confirm from the length of travel of the probe 25, taken with the
displacing force of the probe 27 and the resilience of the flag
member 21, that reagent container 10 is new and unused. In
particular, if no resistive forces are indicated by probe 27 in
moving between probe positions #1 and #2, it may be concluded that
container 10 has been previously "used" since flag member 21 has
been previously displaced from its original location in a plane
coincident with sidewall 12 of the container. In such an instance,
container 10 is not being presented to the analyzer in a "new,
unused" condition and no guarantee may be presumed for the quality
of the reagents contained therein. A key feature of the present
invention is that whenever a container 10 is initially placed onto
an analyzer, if the length of travel of probe 27 and the displacing
force do not fall within previously predetermined ranges, for
example within a range indicated by a dashed lines R of about 15%
to 20% of the relative values indicated in FIG. 3, it may be
automatically determined that a reagent container has been
previously used. In such an instance, the analyzer may optionally
be caused to eject the previously used container, to enter a
stand-by condition and signal for operator attention, or to
complete the requested test assays and provide a warning signal
concerning the quality of assay results. Conversely, if the length
of travel of probe 27 and the displacing force do fall within
previously predetermined ranges, for example within a range
indicated by a dashed lines R of about 15% to 20% of the relative
values indicated in FIG. 3, it may be automatically determined that
a reagent container has not previously used. In such an instance,
the analyzer may optionally be caused to complete the requested
test assays and provide a signal or report that the assays were
completed with reagents from a new container 10.
[0032] In this first embodiment, flag member 21 is typically
dislodged from container 10 by sensor probe 27 and may therefore
interfere with automated operation of the analyzer. Flag member 21
may be constructed of materials like paper, thin plastic, or cloth
and attached to container 10 at all boundaries and may be easily
penetrated by moveable sensor probe 27. In such embodiments, flag
member 21 would be caused to stretch inwardly by sensor probe 27
before rupturing. Signals similar to those illustrated in FIG. 3
would still be obtained.
[0033] In another exemplary embodiment of the present invention,
lock-out member 17 is envisioned by the present invention to be of
a "two-position-snap" design in which a selectively weakened bridge
member 24 integral with reagent container 10 is snap-displaced or
toggled from an original "new" position to a "used" position. In
such an embodiment, bridge member 24 is retained on container 10 as
a permanent but displaced portion of the reagent container 10. FIG.
4 illustrates lock-out member 17 as comprising a weakened bridge
member 24 supported between two pylons 22 extending outwardly from
edgewall 18. Importantly, bridge member 24 is caused to be weakened
in its central region due to a notch 28 formed contiguous with open
region 30 and bridge member 24 is caused to be weakened at both of
its ends by narrowed cusps 26 where the bridge member 24 enjoins
pylons 22. Cusps 26 are formed on the opposite side of bridge
member 24 from notch 28 in order to facilitate a "collapsing" of
bridge member 24 from its "original, unused" position to an
inwardly displaced position indicative of a "previously used"
condition, seen in FIG. 6 and as explained hereinafter. The degree
of weakening of bridge member 24 separately and independently by
cusps 26 and by notch 28 may be adjusted so that the displacement
of bridge member 24 from the new, unused condition of FIG. 4 and
the used condition of FIG. 6 is a permanent displacement.
Consequently, bridge member 24 "toggles" from its unused condition
of FIG. 4 to its used condition of FIG. 6. An open region 30 is
also formed between bridge member 24, pylons 22 and edgewall 18 to
further accommodate such toggling of bridge member 24. FIG. 5 is a
perspective view of bridge member 24 in an original "new"
position.
[0034] As explained later, in practicing the method of the present
invention, in the embodiment illustrated by FIGS. 4 and 5, during
the installation of a "new, unused" container 10 onto an analyzer,
container 10 is automatically urged by a motorized transducer
against a displacement probe and bridge member 24 is caused to be
permanently displaced into a "collapsed" position as seen in FIG.
6. The method by which bridge member 24 is displaced into a
"collapsed" position may vary; generally however, either the
position and/or displacing force of the probe and/or the
displacement alone of a moveable probe may be monitored and are
required to be within certain predetermined ranges. FIG. 3
discussed earlier is an example of monitoring the displacing force
of a sensor as a function of relative displacement of the sensor in
order to determine the used-condition or new-condition of any
reagent container.
[0035] In this alternate exemplary method of practicing the present
invention, illustrated in FIG. 7 and using a container 10 having
the lock-out member 17 of FIGS. 4-6, whenever a container 10 is
initially inserted into an analyzer (stage A, upper portion of FIG.
7), the container is urged rightwards by a conventional transducer
(not shown) so that lock-out member 17 is moved in the direction
indicated by arrow 32 (left-to-right) into contact with a moveable
sensor probe 20 (stage B). In this embodiment, the sensor probe has
the form of a displacement probe 20 equipped with a conventional
displacement sensor 38 and is biased against a stop 37 to a
vertical orientation by a biasing spring 36. Container 10 is
continued to move rightwards (stage C) as shown until probe 20
engages a stationary stop 34 (stage D) and is forced against
lock-out member 17 proximate notch 28 (see stage D, FIG. 8).
Container 10 is further continued to move rightwards by the
transducer until stationary stop 34 (stage E) restricts further
movement of displacement probe 20 which causes the weakened bridge
member 24 of lock-out member 17 to snap into a collapsed state like
that shown in FIG. 6. As described before, cusps 26 and notch 28
are provided to facilitate the collapsing of bridge member 24 to a
permanent inwardly displaced position so that it becomes possible
to ascertain that container 10 has been previously placed onto an
analyzer and is therefore in a "previously used" condition.
[0036] At this point, an analysis like that shown in FIG. 9 of the
amount of displacement of displacement probe 20 relative to the
length of travel of container 10 may be made to determine whether
or not container 10 has been previously used. Such an analysis
evaluates the displacement of probe 20 at stage C--if container 10
has been previously used, bridge member 24 will be in a collapsed
state like that seen in FIG. 6 and probe 20 will be displaced a
predetermined distance less than the length of travel of probe 20
if the bridge member 24 is in the un-collapsed state like that seen
in FIG. 4, indicative of an unused container. Equivalently, if
container 10 is previously used and bridge member 24 is in a
collapsed state, then container 10 must be moved a greater distance
rightwards to achieve the same displacement of probe 20 as if the
bridge member 24 is in the un-collapsed state like that seen in
FIG. 4, indicative of an unused container.
[0037] In practice, for an unused container 10 at stage B,
container 10 has been moved into the analyzer a predetermined
distance and is brought into contact with displacement probe 20. As
soon as any movement of container 10 rightwards beyond stage B
occurs, like shown at stage C, sensor 38 of displacement probe 20
must begin to send a signal indicative of movement elsewise
container 10 may be determined to have been previously used and the
analyzer may be optionally programmed to reject such a used
container 10. The purpose of continuing movement of container 10
beyond stage B is to cause bridge member 28 to toggle into the
"used" position shown in FIG. 6 whenever such a container 10 is
initially placed onto an analyzer. It is desirable to also make a
complete analysis of the condition of container 10 in order to
detect any unwarranted attempts to over-ride the effectiveness of
lock-out member 17, for instance using tape to patch over the
collapsed bridge member 24 of a previously used container 10.
[0038] The lowermost portion of FIG. 7 shows the opposite
interactions occurring as container 10 is moved leftwards
(right-to-left) as indicated by arrow 33 into an operating position
within the analyzer after it has been determined whether container
10 is new and unused or previously used by employing the present
invention. Stage E is repeated for the sake of illustration only.
At stage F, container 10 has been moved to a location equivalent to
stage D sufficient for probe 20 to begin to break free of
stationary stop 34. Leftwards movement of container 10 continues,
stages G-H-J until container 10 is away from stop 34 and probe 20
is held in its original vertical orientation by biasing spring
36.
[0039] FIG. 8 is a schematic plan view corresponding to the stages
A-J in FIG. 7 (stage "I" is not used) and is presented for further
clarity in explaining this embodiment of the present invention.
Weakened bridge member 24 may be seen initially contacting probe 20
at stage B, continuing rightwards motion at stage C and probe 20
being moved against stationary stop 34 at stage D. Arrows 32 and 33
again indicate right-to-left and left-to-right motion,
respectively, only for purposes of illustration and explanation.
Obviously all that is required to practice the present inventive
method is relative movement of the container 10. Weakened bridge
member 24 is illustrated in stage E as collapsed from an unused
condition to a used condition by continued movement of container 10
further forcing lock-out member 17 against stop 34. As the
container 10 is moved leftwards into an operating position within
the analyzer, beginning with stage F in the lower portion of FIG.
8, the biasing action of spring 36 causes displacement probe 20 to
be pulled against the now collapsed bridge member 24. Consequently,
bridge member 24 will be in different displacements, indicated by
the dot-dashed vertical lines in FIG. 8, in stages G and C if, and
only if, a legitimate collapsing action has occurred to weakened
bridge member 24. A similar different displacement exists at stages
D and F. That is, when container 10 is in the same location at
stages C and G, or D and F, displacement probe 20 will have a
predetermined difference in vertical orientation, as denoted by the
letter "P".
[0040] FIG. 9 illustrates signals like those generate by sensor 38
in practicing this embodiment of the present invention. Solid line
"R" indicates signals received by sensor 38 during relative
rightwards movement of container 10 and the dashed line "L"
indicates signals received by sensor 38 during relative leftwards
movement of container 10. Initial contact between lock-out member
17 and probe 20 takes place at stage B in FIGS. 8 and 9; with
continued rightwards movement of container 10, probe 20 is
displaced rightwards, stage C of FIGS. 8 and 9, and sensor probe 38
generates an increasing displacement signal like that shown at
stages C and D in FIGS. 8 and 9. Continued movement of container
10, stage D, by a shuttle mechanism (not shown) rightwards causes
probe 20 to snap or toggle weakened bridge member 28 from its
original new condition to a used condition, stage E of FIG. 8, and
as indicated by the letter "S" prior to stage E in FIG. 9. As
described previously, a key feature of the present invention is
that whenever a container 10 is initially placed onto an analyzer,
if sensor 38 output signals, indicative of the displacement of
probe 20 as a function of the position of container 10, do not fall
within previously predetermined ranges, for example within a range
of about 15% to 20% of the relative displacement signal values
indicated in FIG. 9, it may be automatically determined whether a
reagent container is new and unused or whether the reagent
container has been previously used. Such a range is illustrated in
FIG. 9 by dot-dashed lines Ra. As a fail-safe, confirming
mechanism, the displacement signal of sensor 38 generated at
container locations corresponding to stages C and G, or D and F,
displacement probe 20 will have a predetermined difference
displacement as measured by sensor 38, again shown by the letter
"P" in FIG. 9, at stages C and G.
[0041] In practicing either embodiment of the present invention,
the analyzer may be programmed to automatically eject a previously
used reagent container, shut-down or the analyzer may allow sample
analysis to continue uninterrupted with reagents from a previously
used container but automatically noting such re-use in the reported
analytical results. The degree of skill required to cause an
analyzer to automatically perform such actions is well within the
range of routine computer programs.
[0042] Accommodating a myriad of different potential designs for
lock-out member 17 within a container is a task regularly
encountered within the art and need not be described herein. It is
sufficient that the inventive teaching presented herein that a
reagent container may be determined to have previously been used by
examining a physical feature of the container when it is initially
placed into an analyzer in order to ascertain the position of a
lock-out member, need only be presented to artisans for equivalent
variations to be rendered obvious. It is therefore to be understood
that the embodiments of the invention disclosed herein are
illustrative of the principles of the invention and that other
modifications may be employed which are still within the scope of
the invention. For instance, flag member 21 may be of a variety of
physical shapes, lock-out member 17 may be placed at a variety of
locations on container 10, bridge member 24 may be caused to snap
fully apart when in a collapsed stage, etc. For these reasons, the
present invention is not limited to those embodiments precisely
shown and described in the specification but only by the following
claims.
* * * * *