U.S. patent application number 10/405165 was filed with the patent office on 2004-07-15 for protective sleeve for posts.
Invention is credited to Brown, Desmond.
Application Number | 20040134146 10/405165 |
Document ID | / |
Family ID | 32717125 |
Filed Date | 2004-07-15 |
United States Patent
Application |
20040134146 |
Kind Code |
A1 |
Brown, Desmond |
July 15, 2004 |
Protective sleeve for posts
Abstract
The invention of this application is a protective sleeve for
posts, such as fence posts, which are placed in the ground and
cemented in place. The use of the protective sleeve increases the
useful life of the post and makes it easy to replace a broken post
without removing the concrete.
Inventors: |
Brown, Desmond; (Fremont,
CA) |
Correspondence
Address: |
HOWARD E LEBOWITZ
19682 HESPERIAN BLVD
Suite 208
HAYWARD
CA
94541
US
|
Family ID: |
32717125 |
Appl. No.: |
10/405165 |
Filed: |
April 1, 2003 |
Related U.S. Patent Documents
|
|
|
|
|
|
Application
Number |
Filing Date |
Patent Number |
|
|
60440157 |
Jan 14, 2003 |
|
|
|
Current U.S.
Class: |
52/301 |
Current CPC
Class: |
E04H 12/2292
20130101 |
Class at
Publication: |
052/301 |
International
Class: |
E04H 012/00 |
Claims
What is claimed is:
1. A protective sleeve for a post, the post having a cross
sectional shape, comprising: a) an elongate body with a cross
sectional shape similar to the cross sectional shape of the post,
the elongate body having two substantially open ends, an outer
surface and an inner surface, and b) a plurality of axial
protrusions emanating into the elongate body from said inner
surface, such that said protective sleeve is capable of accepting
the post within the elongate body inside of the axial
protrusions.
2. The protective shield of claim 1 wherein the plurality of axial
protrusions define an inner volume bounded by the axial protrusions
and the protective sleeve is capable of accepting the post within a
tolerance of touching any axial protrusion.
3. The protective sleeve of claim 2 wherein the protective sleeve
has a height such that when a portion of the post is placed below
ground level, the protective sleeve is capable of accepting the
portion and extending above ground level.
4. The protective sleeve of claim 3 wherein the protrusions have a
triangular shape in a cross section drawn perpendicular to the
height of the elongate body.
5. The protective sleeve of claim 3 wherein the protrusions have a
"T" shape in a cross section drawn perpendicular to the height of
the elongate body.
6. The protective sleeve of claim 3 wherein the elongate body has a
generally rectangular cross-section having four corners, such that
a rectangular cross sectioned post having four corners will fit
within the elongate body without the corners of the post touching
the corners of the body.
7. The protective sleeve of claim 3 wherein the elongate body has a
generally circular cross-section.
8. The protective sleeve of claim 3 wherein the protective sleeve
comprises a durable plastic.
9. The protective sleeve of claim 8 wherein the elongate body and
plurality of axial protrusions are a single integral structure
formed by extruding plastic through at least one die.
10. The protective sleeve of claim 9 wherein the protective sleeve
has a generally rectangular shape and the plurality of protrusions
have a triangular shape in a cross section drawn perpendicular to
the height of the elongate body and wherein the durable plastic
comprises polyvinyl chloride.
11. The protective sleeve of claim 9 wherein the protective sleeve
has a generally circular shape and the plurality of protrusions
have a triangular shape in a cross section drawn perpendicular to
the height of the elongate body.
12. The protective sleeve of claim 10 further comprising a
rectangular post therein and at least one screw extending through
the protective sleeve into the post.
13. The protective sleeve of claim 11 further comprising a circular
post therein and at least one screw extending through the
protective sleeve into the post.
14. A method of placing a post in the ground, comprising the acts
of: a) providing a hole in the ground; b) placing an end of a post
in a protective sleeve, wherein the protective sleeve comprises an
elongate body with a cross sectional shape similar to the shape of
the cross sectional shape of the post having two open ends, an
outer surface and an inner surface, and a plurality of axial
protrusions emanating into the elongate body from said inner
surface, such that said protective sleeve is capable of accepting
the post within the body inside of the axial protrusions; c)
placing the protective sleeve into the ground, and d) filling the
hole around the protective sleeve.
15. The method of claim 14 wherein the act of filling the hole
comprises adding concrete to the hole.
16. The method of claim 15 wherein the act of providing a hole
further comprises the acts of adding gravel into the bottom of he
hole before adding concrete to the hole and placing at least one
screw through the protective sleeve into the post.
17. A post embedded in the ground according to claim 15.
18. A post embedded in the ground according to claim 16.
19. A method of building a removable fence section comprising the
acts of: a) providing three fence sections, the removable fence
section and two adjacent fence sections, each fence section being
between two fence posts, b) providing two holes in the ground each
hole being located to accept one fence post from the removable
fence section and one fence post from one of the adjacent fence
sections; c) placing a protective sleeve in each of the two holes,
wherein the protective sleeve comprises an elongate body with a
cross sectional shape suitable for holding two fence posts, having
two open ends, an outer surface and an inner surface, and a
plurality of axial protrusions emanating into the body from said
inner surface, such that said protective sleeve is capable of
accepting two fence posts within the body inside of the axial
protrusions, and wherein each protective sleeve extends above its
hole; d) filling the holes around each the two protective sleeves;
e) placing a pair of fence posts in each of the two protective
sleeves, where a pair of fence posts consists of one fence post
from the removable fence section and one fence post from one of the
adjacent fence posts in each of the protective sleeves; f) placing
at least one shim between each pair of fence posts in a protective
sleeve; and g) placing at least one screw into each fence post in a
protective sleeve, whereby the removable section may be removed by
removing the at least one screw though each of its fence post and
removing each of the at least one shims adjacent to each of its
fence posts.
20. A removable fence section constructed according to claim 19.
Description
[0001] This application claims the benefit of my Provisional
Application No. 60/440,157 dated Jan. 14, 2003, which is hereby
incorporated by reference herein.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
[0002] 1. Field of the Invention
[0003] The invention pertains to erecting fence posts, more
particularly to sleeves which are placed in the ground to accept
fence posts.
[0004] 2. Description of the Prior Art
[0005] The prior art for fence building involves erecting a fence
supported by fence posts. The fence posts are placed in holes in
the ground. The holes are filled around the pole, generally by
filling the hole with concrete for structural support. The problem
with the prior art is that the poles are attacked by rot in the wet
environment of the ground. When a fence post fails and needs to be
replaced, it is necessary to break away the concrete, replace the
post, and replace the concrete. This is a costly and inefficient
proposition. It would be desirable to extend the life of the posts
and/or provide a means for replacing the post without breaking up
the concrete base.
[0006] Several devices have been suggested for implanting tubes,
sleeves, or boots into the ground to protect a post and extend its
life. U.S. Pat. No. 5,315,796 to Gruhlke discloses an encapsulating
sleeve for underground portion of the posts providing a positive
barrier against deterioration by ground contact. The sleeve has an
open top to receive a post, sides and a closed bottom. The sleeve
is designed for a snug fit with the post and side vents for escape
of air when the post is inserted into the sleeve. U.S. Pat. No.
5,090,165 to Kenny discloses a sleeve or boot designed to encase a
preformed base configured diametrically smaller than the remainder
of the post or pole. U.S. Pat. No. 6,389,760 to McDonnell is
another wood post protective sleeve which has an open top and a
closed bottom and displacement resisting projections extending from
the external surface of the sleeve to resist compressive forces
which would tend to lift the post out of the sleeve.
[0007] U.S. Pat. No. 5,492,429 to Hodges is a device for erecting a
post which comprises a tubular body with a deformable, removable
internal collar for tightly retaining a post in place. Hodges'
device holds a post in place and allows replacement of the post
without removing the device from the concrete.
[0008] U.S. Pat. No. 5,315,796, U.S. Pat. No. 5,090,165, U.S. Pat.
No. 6,389,760, and U.S. Pat. No. 5,492,429 are hereby incorporated
by reference herein.
[0009] There is a need for an improved protective sleeve for posts
imbedded in concrete that increases the life of a post and also
allows easy replacement of a broken post without removal of the
concrete.
[0010] There is a need for an improved protective sleeve for posts
imbedded in concrete that increases the life of a post and also
allows easy replacement of a broken post without removal of the
concrete, wherein said improved protective sleeve is inexpensive
and easy to use.
[0011] There is a need for an improved protective sleeve for posts
imbedded in concrete that increases the life of a post and can be
used to make removable fence sections.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
[0012] It is an object of the invention to provide an improved
protective sleeve for posts to be placed in concrete that increases
the life of the post and allows a broken post to be easily
removed.
[0013] It is a further object of the invention to provide an
improved protective sleeve for posts to be placed in concrete that
increases the life of the post and allows a broken post to be
easily removed, wherein the improved protective sleeve is
inexpensive and easy to use compared to the prior art.
[0014] It is a further objective of the invention to provide a
method of using a protective sleeve to increase the life of a post
and replace the post without removing concrete used to anchor the
post.
[0015] It is a further objective of the invention to provide a
method for making a fence with a removable section using protective
sleeves.
[0016] One aspect of the invention is a protective sleeve for use
in placing a post in the ground secured with concrete. A typical
use is placing a fence post in the ground such as a wooden post or
a metal post. Another use is support poles for structures. These
examples are not limiting, and other uses will be obvious to those
skilled in the art.
[0017] A protective sleeve for a post, the post having a cross
sectional shape comprises:
[0018] (a) an elongate body with a cross sectional shape similar to
the shape of the cross sectional shape of the post, the elongate
body having two substantially open ends, an outer surface and an
inner surface, and
[0019] (b) a plurality of axial protrusions emanating into the
elongate body from said inner surface, such that said protective
sleeve is capable of accepting the post within the elongate body
inside of the axial protrusions.
[0020] Preferably the sleeve is designed such that the post fits
comfortably within the inner volume defined by the protrusions,
within a preferred tolerance. Tolerances preferably range from
about {fraction (1/64)} inch to about {fraction (1/16)} inch,
preferably about {fraction (1/32)} inch. The sleeve preferably has
a height that is sufficient for the sleeve to cover the portion of
the post that will be in the ground and in addition to extending
above the ground.
[0021] Preferred protrusions include ripples with a triangular
shape when viewed in a cross section drawn perpendicular to the
height of the elongate body. Other shapes are "T" shaped
protrusions or rectangular shaped channels.
[0022] A preferred sleeve is made with the elongate body and
protrusions being part of a single integral structure made by
extrusion through at least one die. A preferred material is a soft
and durable plastic, preferably polyvinyl chloride.
[0023] The sleeve is held in place with preferably at least one
screw and more preferably at least two screws that are screwed
through the sleeve and into the post. The screws are preferably
placed in the section of the sleeve which is above ground level,
preferably about four inches down from the top of the sleeve.
[0024] Another aspect of the invention is a method for using the
protective sleeves as described above, comprising the acts of:
[0025] a) providing a hole in the ground;
[0026] b) placing an end of a post in a protective sleeve,
[0027] c) placing at least one and preferably two screws through
the protective sleeve into the post;
[0028] d) placing the protective sleeve into the ground, and
[0029] e) filling the hole around the protective sleeve, preferably
with concrete.
[0030] It is preferred to put gravel into the bottom of the hole
before placing the protective sleeve and post into the hole. This
provides for improved drainage of water and also makes it possible
to adjust the vertical position of a post after it is set by
removing the screws, pulling out the post and adding more gravel to
the sleeve. The order of the above steps is not critical. For
instance, a post may be placed in a sleeve and the at least two
screws put in place before placing the post and sleeve into the
ground. Alternatively, the sleeve may be placed in the hole and
concreted in with a portion of the sleeve extending above ground
level. The pole is then placed in the sleeve, pushed into place,
and the screws applied.
[0031] Still another aspect of the invention is using protective
sleeves for making a removable fence section. In this aspect the
protective sleeves have a shape and size to accept two fence posts
side by side within the sleeve. The method comprises the following
acts:
[0032] a) providing three fence sections, the removable fence
section and two adjacent fence sections, each fence section being
between two fence posts,
[0033] b) providing two holes in the ground each hole being located
to accept one fence post from the removable fence section and one
fence post from one of the adjacent fence sections,
[0034] c) placing a protective sleeve in each of the two holes,
filling the holes around each the two protective sleeves;
[0035] d) placing a pair of fence posts in each of the two
protective sleeves, wherein each pair of fence posts consists of
one fence post from the removable fence section and one fence post
from one of the adjacent fence posts in each of the protective
sleeves;
[0036] e) placing at least one shim between each pair of fence
posts in a protective sleeve; and
[0037] f) placing at least one and preferably two screws into each
fence post in a protective sleeve, whereby the removable section
may be removed by removing the at least two screws though each of
its fence posts and removing each of the at least one shims
adjacent to each of its fence posts.
[0038] The invention provides a number of advantages compared to
the prior art, as follows:
[0039] 1. The invention provides a post sleeve that provides
extended life for the fence post and allows ready removal of the
fence post in the same device.
[0040] 2. The open bottom of the sleeve is a departure from the
prior art. Instead of trying to encase the post in an impervious
encasement as in the prior art, the instant invention allows water
to drain out through the open bottom. Drainage is promoted by a
gravel layer at the bottom of the hole.
[0041] 3. The axial protrusions of the invention provide protection
to the post without extensive contact with the walls of the sleeve.
When water inevitably moves into the post, snug contact with the
walls promotes mold growth and deterioration of the post. In the
instant invention sleeves, there is minimal contact due to the
protrusions and plenty of space for air circulation during dry
weather conditions to allow the post to dry out.
[0042] 4. The open bottom allows gravel to be added or removed to
adjust the height of a post after the cement has been set.
[0043] 5. The only attachment points between the sleeves and a post
within, are at least one and preferably two screws located above
ground level. This allows for easy removal of a post by simply
removing the screws.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0044] These and other features, aspects and advantages of the
present invention will become better understood with regard to the
following description, appended claims and accompanying drawings,
where:
[0045] FIG. 1A is a top view of the protective shield. FIG. 1B is a
front view of a protective shield.
[0046] FIG. 2 is a front view of a group of three fence posts
deployed in the ground with protective sleeves.
[0047] FIG. 3 is a front view of a removable fence section
according to the invention.
[0048] FIG. 4 is a top view of a protective shield with "T" shaped
protrusions.
[0049] FIG. 5 is a top view of a circular protective shield.
DESCRIPTION
[0050] The invention involves a protective sleeve for use in
installation of posts into the ground, generally posts that are
placed in a post hole and secured by concrete which fills the post
hole. One preferred embodiment of the invention is a protective
shield comprising an elongate body having a cross sectional shape
similar to the shape of a post, having two substantially open ends,
an inner surface and an outer surface. The elongate body has a
plurality of axial protrusions emanating into the elongate body
from the inner surface.
[0051] The cross sectional shape of the elongate body is said to be
similar to the post in that it has generally the same shape as the
post. Thus the elongate body for a circular cross sectioned post
will be generally circular and that for a rectangular cross
sectioned post will be generally rectangular with similar ratio of
length to width as the cross section of the post. In this context,
cross sectional refers to the cross section that is perpendicular
to the height of the elongate body. The cross sectional shape of
the elongate body is sufficiently larger than that of the post so
that the post will fit comfortably into the protective shield. It
is not necessary that the similarity be precise geometrical
similarity, for instance, the protective sleeve for a rectangular
post may have rounded corners.
[0052] When the sleeve is described as elongate, the term is used
to describe an object that has a height that is larger than its
diameter.
[0053] The height of the protective sleeve is such that it will
cover the portion of the post that will be placed in the ground and
will extend above the ground.
[0054] One preferred type of axial protrusion is a triangular cross
section ridge extending from end to end of the elongate body,
Another preferred type of protrusion is "T" shaped protrusion.
[0055] Once the bottom of the post is in the sleeve, the post is
held in place by driving at least one and preferably two screws
through the sleeve into the post. The screws are preferably placed
in the portion of the sleeve that will remain above ground when the
post is in place. The screws may be located on one side of the
sleeve or adjacent or opposing sides.
[0056] One of the principles of the invention is to provide a
protective sleeve that allows the post to dry out between wet
cycles. Prior art sleeves have focused on keeping all water out of
a sleeve by tightly encasing the post in a water impervious case.
However, water will inevitably get into the underground portion of
the post under wet conditions, at least by downward diffusion of
water from the upper portion of the post that is not protected from
rain. The instant design protects the post by minimizing contact
with wet surfaces since the post is in contact only with the
protrusions. Also, the open bottom promotes drainage from the
bottom of the sleeve. A layer of gravel is preferably placed at the
bottom of a hole to promote drainage.
[0057] Another principle of the sleeve design is that replacement
of a post should be easy to accomplish without removing the
protective sleeve from the ground. One of the big advantages of the
invention is that a protective sleeve allows a post to be replaced
without removing concrete that is used to secure the post in the
post hole. When a protective sleeve is used, a post within a
protective sleeve is placed in a post hole and then the hole is
filled with cement. If a pole rots or breaks off, the post can be
replaced by simply removing the screws which hold the post to the
sleeve and then removing the portion of the post remaining in the
ground from the sleeve (discussed in greater detail below under
section entitled "Method of Using a Protective Shield") and
inserting a new pole in the sleeve. This can be readily
accomplished without removing the sleeve from the concrete. Without
a sleeve it is necessary to break the concrete up and remove it to
replace a post. The design features which accomplish this are the
open bottom end of the sleeves, constructing the sleeve out of
plastic, leaving a clearance between the post and the wall of the
sleeve, and minimization of wall frictional contact by use of
protrusions rather than a flat wall.
[0058] FIG. 1 illustrates a first preferred embodiment of the
invention. FIG. 1A is a top view and FIG. 1B is a front view.
Referring to FIGS. 1A and 1B a protective sleeve 100 is shown with
a post 106 therein. The sleeve has an elongate body 102 having an
outer surface and an inner surface with axial protrusions 104
extending into the sleeve. The axial protrusions have a triangular
shape in a horizontal cross section (perpendicular to the length of
the sleeve) and extend from the top to the bottom of the sleeve.
There is a tolerance 108 between the post and the inner surface of
the protrusions. The post is held in the sleeve by screws 110. The
screws 110 may also be on opposing sides of the post. Note that in
FIG. 1B the hidden lines corresponding to the axial protrusions on
the front and back are not shown to prevent clutter.
[0059] The sleeve shown is a protective sleeve for a square cross
section wooden post such as a 4.times.4 post. A standard 4.times.4
post has an outside diameter of 31/2 inches. This is the distance B
on FIG. 1A. In one preferred embodiment of the invention the inside
distance on a horizontal plane (perpendicular to the length of the
sleeve) between opposing protrusions is about 3{fraction (9/16)}
inches. This is the distance C on FIG. 1A. In this embodiment the
tolerance between the post and the sleeve is {fraction (1/32)} inch
or half of (C-B). In general for a 4.times.4 post the preferred
tolerance is between a {fraction (1/64)}-inch and {fraction
(1/16)}-inch and is larger for larger post sizes. In this preferred
embodiment, the outside diameter of the protective sleeve is 37/8
inches (distance A on FIG. 1A). The wall thickness (including the
protrusions) is about {fraction (5/32)} inch with the protrusions
being about {fraction (1/16)}-inch peak to valley. In this
embodiment the axial protrusions are preferably spaced about
{fraction (1/8)} inch tip to tip. In this preferred embodiment the
body of the sleeve and the axial protrusions are a single integral
piece of polyvinyl chloride which has been made by extrusion
through a die. This method of construction is generally preferred
and is well known to those skilled in the art. The polyvinyl
chloride is preferably of the type that is treated for ultraviolet
light resistance.
[0060] In this preferred embodiment the height of the sleeve is 30
inches corresponding to about a buried depth of 24 inches and 6
inches extending above the soil line. The post is held in place by
two #10.times.1/4 inch stainless steel screws placed through the
sleeve and into the post.
[0061] Posts may be made with various shapes and sizes as well as
various types of axial protrusions. FIG. 4 illustrates a square
sleeve 400 with "T" shaped axial protrusions 401 with a post 402
therein. The post is held to the sleeve by screws 404. A circular
protective sleeve 501 for a circular post 502 is shown in FIG. 5.
The protective sleeve has axial protrusions 504 having a triangular
cross section. The post is held in the sleeve by screws 506.
[0062] Protective sleeves are preferably made to fit standard post
sizes such as 4.times.4 in the previous example. It should be
understood that the detailed dimensions will vary and the values
given in the first preferred embodiment are for examples of one
preferred embodiment and are not limiting.
[0063] Larger diameter posts will be buried deeper into the ground
and the height of a protective sleeve will be longer.
[0064] Method of Using a Protective Shield
[0065] The protective shield as previously described is used by
taking the following acts:
[0066] a) providing a hole in the ground,
[0067] b) placing an end of a post in a protective sleeve,
[0068] c) placing at least one screw and preferably two screws
through the protective sleeve into the post;
[0069] d) placing the protective sleeve into the ground, and
[0070] e) filling the hole around the protective sleeve, preferably
with concrete.
[0071] It is important to note that there is not a particular order
necessary for carrying out the acts. In one order, a protective
sleeve is placed over an end of the post and the screws placed
through the sleeve into the post before the sleeve (with included
post) is placed in the hole. In a second order, the sleeve is
placed in the hole first, then the hole is filled, and the post is
then placed into the sleeve and the screws set.
[0072] It is preferred that gravel is placed in the bottom of the
hole before the sleeve and post are set. The gravel allows for
improved water drainage. Preferably one inch to two inches of
gravel are used. FIG. 2 shows three posts 200 concreted in the
ground with post concrete 204. A protective sleeve 202 has been
placed over the portion of the post below ground level and extends
above ground level where it is held on the post by screws 206 (a
second screw is on the opposite side and is not shown). Gravel 205
has been placed under the posts. FIG. 2 illustrates one advantage
of using protective shields. If a post needs to be raised after the
posts are set in concrete, the post can be readily removed by
removing the two screws and pulling the post out of the sleeve. The
level can be raised by adding additional gravel into the sleeve and
then returning the post to the sleeve and replacing the screws.
[0073] Another advantage to using the protective sleeves is when a
post that was installed with a protective sleeve needs to be
replaced for any reason the use of a protective sleeve makes it
possible to replace the post without digging up the whole or
removing the concrete. For instance if a post breaks off due to
rot, leaving a portion of the post in the sleeve, the post can be
removed from the sleeve by removing the screws if necessary and
pulling it out, A fragment of post left below ground level can be
removed with a needle nose pliers.
[0074] If it is desired to replace the protective sleeve as well as
the post, once the post is removed the sleeve can often be pulled
out of the concrete. If this can not be readily done, a sleeve can
be removed by flling it with ice to shrink it and then pulling it
out. A new sleeve and post can then be placed in the concrete.
[0075] Removable Fence Section
[0076] Another method of using a protective sleeve is in making a
removable fence section. In this case the cross section of the
protective shield is sized so that two posts will fit inside of it.
The protective sleeve is otherwise the same as described above for
a single post. The use of protective sleeves in this manner is
illustrated on FIG. 3. The method comprises the following acts:
[0077] a) providing three fence sections (306,308, and 310), the
removable fence section 306 and two adjacent fence sections 308 and
310, each fence section being between two fence posts,
[0078] b) providing two holes in the ground each hole being located
to accept one fence post from the removable fence section and one
fence post from one of the adjacent fence sections,
[0079] c) placing a protective sleeve (300 and 302) in each of the
two holes, filling the holes around each the two protective sleeves
with concrete (310 and 304);
[0080] d) placing a pair of fence posts in each of the two
protective sleeves, wherein each pair of fence posts consists of
one fence post from the removable fence section (314 or 316) and
one fence post from one of the adjacent fence posts in each of the
protective sleeves (318 or 320);
[0081] e) placing at least one shim 304 between each pair of fence
posts in a protective sleeve, the at least one shim held in place
by screws (305); and
[0082] f) placing at least one screw and preferably two screws
(312) into each fence post in a protective sleeve, whereby the
removable section may be removed by removing the at least one screw
though each of its fence post and removing each of the at least one
shims adjacent to each of its fence posts.
[0083] Gravel 303 is preferably placed at the bottom of each hole
beneath the post and protective sleeve. An example of a preferred
set of components for a removable fence section comprises 2.times.4
pressure treated lumber for the fence posts 314,316, 318, and 320,
and 1.times.4.times.3/8 inch redwood bender boards for shims 304
between each pair of fence posts. If these components are chosen
then a preferred protective sleeve is the same sleeve that was
previously described as being suitable for a single 4.times.4 fence
post.
[0084] Although the present invention has been described in
considerable detail with reference to certain preferred versions
thereof, other versions are possible. Therefore the spirit and
scope of the appended claims should not be limited to the preferred
versions herein.
* * * * *