U.S. patent application number 10/110831 was filed with the patent office on 2003-07-10 for hydrogen purification apparatus.
Invention is credited to Fujiwara, Seiji, Taguchi, Kiyoshi, Tomizawa, Takeshi, Ukai, Kunihiro.
Application Number | 20030129100 10/110831 |
Document ID | / |
Family ID | 26598076 |
Filed Date | 2003-07-10 |
United States Patent
Application |
20030129100 |
Kind Code |
A1 |
Ukai, Kunihiro ; et
al. |
July 10, 2003 |
Hydrogen purification apparatus
Abstract
It was difficult to acquire a good CO cleanup efficiency in a
hydrogen refining apparatus, for instance, when the start-up and
stop operations are frequently repeated. A hydrogen refining
apparatus, including a shifter 3 having a shifting catalyst body 3a
containing noble metals and metal oxides, and a reforming section 1
for supplying hydrogen gas containing carbon monoxide to the
shifter 3, (1) the temperature of an upstream side of the shifting
catalyst body 3a relative to the hydrogen gas flow being
substantially between 300.degree. C. and 500.degree. C. and (2) the
temperature of a downstream side of the shifting catalyst body 3a
relative to the hydrogen gas flow being substantially at
300.degree. C. or less.
Inventors: |
Ukai, Kunihiro; (Nara,
JP) ; Taguchi, Kiyoshi; (Osaka, JP) ;
Tomizawa, Takeshi; (Osaka, JP) ; Fujiwara, Seiji;
(Osaka, JP) |
Correspondence
Address: |
Allan Ratner
Ratner & Prestia
One Westlakes Berwyn Suite 301
PO Box 980
Valley Forge
PA
19482-0980
US
|
Family ID: |
26598076 |
Appl. No.: |
10/110831 |
Filed: |
August 26, 2002 |
PCT Filed: |
August 10, 2001 |
PCT NO: |
PCT/JP01/06890 |
Current U.S.
Class: |
422/177 ;
422/172; 422/173; 422/198; 422/600 |
Current CPC
Class: |
B01J 8/001 20130101;
C01B 2203/1619 20130101; B01J 8/0496 20130101; B01J 2219/00087
20130101; B01J 23/63 20130101; B01J 2219/00198 20130101; B01J
2208/0053 20130101; B01J 2208/00495 20130101; B01J 2208/00132
20130101; B01J 2208/00176 20130101; B01J 2208/00168 20130101; C01B
2203/1623 20130101; C01B 2203/1076 20130101; C01B 2203/0233
20130101; C01B 2203/066 20130101; B01J 2219/00159 20130101; B01J
2219/00155 20130101; H01M 8/0612 20130101; B01J 2208/00504
20130101; B01J 8/0453 20130101; Y02E 60/50 20130101; B01J 23/40
20130101; B01J 2219/00081 20130101; H01M 8/0662 20130101; B01J
19/0013 20130101; C01B 2203/0288 20130101; C01B 2203/1614 20130101;
C01B 2203/1082 20130101; B01J 8/0457 20130101; B01J 2208/00061
20130101; C01B 3/48 20130101; B01J 19/2485 20130101; B01J
2219/00063 20130101; C01B 2203/1064 20130101; B01J 2219/00202
20130101; B01J 2219/00157 20130101; B01J 8/0085 20130101 |
Class at
Publication: |
422/177 ;
422/172; 422/190; 422/173; 422/198 |
International
Class: |
B01D 053/62; B01J
008/02 |
Foreign Application Data
Date |
Code |
Application Number |
Aug 18, 2000 |
JP |
2000-248363 |
Oct 23, 2000 |
JP |
2000-323062 |
Claims
1. A hydrogen refining apparatus comprising: a shifter having a
shifting catalyst body containing noble metals and metal oxides for
converting carbon monoxide; and a hydrogen gas supplying section
for supplying hydrogen gas containing carbon monoxide to said
shifter, wherein (1) the temperature of an upstream side of said
shifting catalyst body relative to said hydrogen gas flow is
substantially between 300.degree. C. and 500.degree. C. and (2) the
temperature of a downstream side of said shifting catalyst body
relative to said hydrogen gas flow is substantially at 300.degree.
C. or less.
2. The hydrogen refining apparatus according to claim 1, wherein
said shifter having a cooling section for keeping the temperature
of said downstream side between 150.degree. C. and 300.degree.
C.
3. The hydrogen refining apparatus according to claim 1, wherein
the amount of said noble metals per volume of said shifting
catalyst body is smaller in said upstream side than in said
downstream side.
4. The hydrogen refining apparatus according to claim 1, wherein
the flow rate of said hydrogen gas is larger in said upstream side
than in said downstream side.
5. The hydrogen refining apparatus according to claim 1, wherein
the cross-sectional area of said shifting catalyst body
perpendicular to said hydrogen gas flow is smaller in said upstream
side than in said downstream side.
6. A hydrogen refining apparatus comprising: a plurality of stages
of a shifter having a shifting catalyst body containing both noble
metals and metal oxides for converting carbon monoxide; and a
hydrogen gas supplying section for supplying hydrogen gas
containing carbon monoxide to said plurality of stages of said
shifter, wherein the temperature of a stage of said shifter having
said plurality of stages is higher in a more upstream side relative
to said hydrogen gas flow.
7. The hydrogen refining apparatus according to claim 1 or 6,
wherein said noble metals are all or a part of Pt, Pd, Rh and Ru,
and said metal oxides are composite oxides made by compounding Zr
and/or Al with Ce.
8. The hydrogen refining apparatus according to claim 7, wherein
said composite oxides are, excluding oxygen, composed of 5 to 90
atomic percent of Ce, the balance being Zr and/or Al.
9. The hydrogen refining apparatus according to claim 8, wherein
the composite oxides are in the form of a solid solution.
10. The hydrogen refining apparatus according to claim 9, wherein
the composition proportion of Ce in a stage of said shifting
catalyst body is larger in a more upstream side relative to said
hydrogen gas flow.
11. The hydrogen refining apparatus according to claim 1 or 6,
wherein (1) between said hydrogen gas supplying section and said
shifter, or (2) between said shifting catalyst bodies in respective
stages is installed a cooling section used for cooling said
hydrogen gas.
Description
[0001] The present invention relates to a hydrogen refining
apparatus for reducing carbon monoxide generated when hydrocarbon
components and water are reformed.
BACKGROUND ART
[0002] A cogeneration system using fuel cells of a high power
generation efficiency receives attention as a decentralized
generating set that can effectively utilize energy, and most fuel
cells such as a commercialized phosphoric acid type fuel cell and a
polymer type fuel cell under development generate electricity using
hydrogen as fuel.
[0003] Currently, fuel infrastructures for hydrogen are not
established, and so hydrogen needs to be generated at the
installation sites. Accordingly, the steam reforming process or
autothermal process, wherein hydrocarbon components such as natural
gas and LPG, alcohols including methanol, or naphtha components,
etc. as raw materials are allowed to react with water to generate
hydrogen at a reforming section with are forming catalyst, is
utilized as a hydrogen generating method.
[0004] In such a reforming reaction of water with the raw
materials, carbon monoxide is formed as a by product. For a polymer
type fuel cell, which operates at low temperature, carbon monoxide
acts as a poisoning component for the electrode catalyst of the
fuel cell, and therefore a shifter for accomplishing shift reaction
of water and carbon monoxide to hydrogen and carbon dioxide is
employed along with a cleanup section for oxidizing or carbon
monoxide converting it into methane.
[0005] Normally, the shifter uses both a Fe--Cr based catalyst and
a Cu--Zn based catalyst. Since the Fe--Cr based catalyst is used at
a comparatively high temperature (300.degree. C. to 500.degree. C.)
carbon monoxide cannot be decreased to a large extent. On the other
hand, the Cu--Zn based catalyst can decrease carbon monoxide to a
considerably low concentration because it is used at a relatively
low temperature (200.degree. C. to 300.degree. C.).
[0006] Thus, the shifter lowers the concentration of carbon
monoxide to about 0.5% using a Cu--Zn based catalyst; the cleanup
section uses a catalyst based on Pt or Ru, a platinum series noble
metal to selectively oxidize carbon monoxide or convert it into
methane and finally lowers the concentration of carbon monoxide to
about 20 ppm (Certainly, the shifter should stably reduce the
amount of carbon monoxide in order to reduce its quantity
effectively in the cleanup section).
[0007] Nevertheless, the shifting catalyst of the Cu--Zn system is
active in the shift reaction in a reduced state, and during the
continuous operation of the equipment, the catalyst always remains
in a reduced state, resulting in almost no degradation of the
catalyst activity. However, in an intermittent operation, start-up
and stop are repeated, so the shifter comes to contain air, which
oxidizes the catalyst leading to an extensive reduction in the
catalyst activity.
[0008] Hence, for applications wherein the start-up and stop
operation are repeated frequently, when a hydrogen generating
device with a Cu--Zn based catalyst is used in the shifter, carbon
monoxide cannot be decreased sufficiently due to the oxidation of
the shifting catalyst. When, for instance, the catalyst is used at
an elevated temperature of 300.degree. C. or more the catalyst
activity is also degraduated (Accordingly, the CO cleanup
efficiency is also decreased).
[0009] In addition, in Japanese Patent Application No. 11-115101, a
catalyst prepared by incorporating a metal of the platinum series
noble metals into a metal oxide is used as a shifting catalyst in
order to improve both oxidation resistance and heat resistance. The
catalyst prepared by incorporating the metal of the platinum series
noble metals into a metal oxide exhibits excellent features; the
catalyst scarcely causes aggregation due to sintering of the
catalyst species or does not change its activity in the oxidized
state even if it is used at a temperature of about 500.degree. C.
However, the catalyst slightly declines in shift reactivity at low
temperature as compared with the Cu--Zn based catalyst, which leads
to an increase in the concentration of the carbon monoxide at the
outlet of the shifter.
DISCLOSURE OF THE INVENTION
[0010] The present invention is made in view of the above described
previous problems, and it is an object of the invention to provide
a hydrogen refining apparatus of a good CO cleanup efficiency even
when the start-up and stop operations are repeated frequently, for
instance.
[0011] The 1st invention of the present invention (corresponding to
claim 1) is a hydrogen refining apparatus comprising:
[0012] a shifter having a shifting catalyst body containing noble
metals and metal oxides for converting carbon monoxide; and
[0013] a hydrogen gas supplying section for supplying hydrogen gas
containing carbon monoxide to said shifter,
[0014] wherein (1) the temperature of an upstream side of said
shifting catalyst body relative to said hydrogen gas flow is
substantially between 300.degree. C. and 500.degree. C. and (2) the
temperature of a downstream side of said shifting catalyst body
relative to said hydrogen gas flow is substantially at 300.degree.
C. or less.
[0015] The 2nd invention of the present invention (corresponding to
claim 2) is the hydrogen refining apparatus according to the 1st
inveniton, wherein said shifter having a cooling section for
keeping the temperature of said downstream side between 150.degree.
C. and 300.degree. C.
[0016] The 3rd invention of the present invention (corresponding to
claim 3) is the hydrogen refining apparatus according to the 1st
invention, wherein the amount of said noble metals per volume of
said shifting catalyst body is smaller in said upstream side than
in said downstream side.
[0017] The 4th invention of the present invention (corresponding to
claim 4) is the hydrogen refining apparatus according to claim 1,
wherein the flow rate of said hydrogen gas is larger in said
upstream side than in said downstream side.
[0018] The 5th invention of the present invention (corresponding to
claim 5) is the hydrogen refining apparatus according to the 1st
invention, wherein
[0019] the cross-sectional area of said shifting catalyst body
perpendicular to said hydrogen gas flow is smaller in said upstream
side than in said downstream side.
[0020] The 6th invention of the present invention (corresponding to
claim 6) is a hydrogen refining apparatus comprising:
[0021] a plurality of stages of a shifter having a shifting
catalyst body containing both noble metals and metal oxides for
converting carbon monoxide; and
[0022] a hydrogen gas supplying section for supplying hydrogen gas
containing carbon monoxide to said plurality of stages of said
shifter,
[0023] wherein the temperature of a stage of said shifter having
said plurality of stages is higher in a more upstream side relative
to said hydrogen gas flow.
[0024] The 7th invention of the present invention (corresponding to
claim 7) is the hydrogen refining apparatus according to the 1st or
6th invention, wherein said noble metals are all or a part of Pt,
Pd, Rh and Ru, and
[0025] said metal oxides are composite oxides made by compounding
Zr and/or Al with Ce.
[0026] The 8th invention of the present invention (corresponding to
claim 8) is the hydrogen refining apparatus according to the 7th
invention, wherein said composite oxides are, excluding oxygen,
composed of 5 to 90 atomic percent of Ce, the balance being Zr
and/or Al.
[0027] The 9th invention of the present invention (corresponding to
claim 9) is the hydrogen refining apparatus according to the 8th
invention, wherein the composite oxides are in the form of a solid
solution.
[0028] The 10th invention of the present invention (corresponding
to claim 10) is the hydrogen refining apparatus according to the
9th invention, wherein the composition proportion of Ce in a stage
of said shifting catalyst body is larger in a more upstream side
relative to said hydrogen gas flow.
[0029] The 11th invention of the present invention (corresponding
to claim 11) is the hydrogen refining apparatus according to the
1st or 6th invention, wherein (1) between said hydrogen gas
supplying section and said shifter, or (2) between said converting
catalyst bodies in respective stages is installed a cooling section
used for cooling said hydrogen gas.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0030] FIG. 1 is a longitudinal section of the principal positions
of a hydrogen refining apparatus in an Embodiment 1 of the present
invention;
[0031] FIG. 2(a) shows the catalyst temperature vs. the carbon
monoxide concentration, when a gas composed of 10% of carbon
monoxide, 10% of carbon dioxide and 80% of hydrogen, and adjusted
to the dew point of 65.degree. C., is passed through the catalyst.
FIG. 2(b) shows the catalyst temperature vs. the carbon monoxide
concentration, when a gas composed of 2% of carbon monoxide, 18% of
carbon dioxide and 80% of hydrogen, and adjusted to the dew point
of 65.degree. C., is passed through the catalyst;
[0032] FIG. 3 is a longitudinal section of the principal portions
of a hydrogen refining apparatus in an Embodiment 2 of the present
invention;
[0033] FIG. 4 is a longitudinal section of the principal portions
of a hydrogen refining apparatus in an Embodiment 3 of the present
invention;
[0034] FIG. 5 is a longitudinal section of the principal portions
of a hydrogen refining apparatus in an Embodiment 4 of the present
invention;
[0035] FIG. 6 is a longitudinal section of the principal portions
of a hydrogen refining apparatus in an Embodiment 5 of the present
invention; and
[0036] FIG. 7 is a longitudinal section of the principal portions
of a hydrogen refining apparatus in an Embodiment 6 of the present
invention.
[0037] Description of Symbols
[0038] 1 Reforming section
[0039] 1a Reforming catalyst body
[0040] 2 Heating section
[0041] 3 Shifter
[0042] 3a Shifting catalyst body
[0043] 4 Cleanup section
[0044] 4a Cleanup catalyst body
[0045] 5 Raw material supplying section
[0046] 6 Water supplying section
[0047] 7 Gas passage pathway
[0048] 8 Air supplying section
[0049] 9 Conversion No. 1 temperature measurement section
[0050] 10 Conversion No. 2 temperature measurement section
[0051] 11 Cleanup No. 1 temperature measurement section
[0052] 12 Cleanup No. 2 temperature measurement section
[0053] 13 Conversion cooling section
[0054] 14 Conversion No. 3 temperature measurement section
[0055] 15 Conversion cooling fan
[0056] 101 Catalyst body
[0057] 102 Reaction chamber
[0058] 103, 115 Reformed gas inlet
[0059] 104, 116 Reformed gas outlet
[0060] 105, 117 Diffusing plate
[0061] 106, 118 Insulating material
[0062] 111 No. 1 catalyst body
[0063] 112 No. 1 reaction chamber
[0064] 113 No. 2 catalyst body
[0065] 114 No. 2 reaction chamber
[0066] 119 Cooling fan
BEST MODE FOR CARRYING OUT THE INVENTION
[0067] Now, embodiments according to the present invention will be
described with reference to drawings.
Embodiment 1
[0068] Firstly, referring to FIG. 1 illustrating in longitudinal
section the principal portions of a hydrogen refining apparatus in
the Embodiment 1 of the present invention, the arrangement of the
hydrogen refining apparatus in this embodiment will be
described.
[0069] In FIG. 1, a reforming section 1 is means (hydrogen gas
supplying section) of supplying hydrogen (gas), equipped with a
reforming catalyst body 1a used for the steam reforming reaction (a
material made by the incorporation of a noble metal into an alumina
base (Ru/alumina, N.E. CHEMCAT CORPORATION) was used for the
reforming catalyst body 1a).
[0070] A heating section 2 is means of heating the reforming
section 1 (flame burner in this embodiment).
[0071] A shifter 3, which contains a (CO) shifting catalyst body
3a, is means of converting the carbon monoxide (a material made by
incorporating a catalyst including Pt and an oxide of Ce in an
alumina pellet was used for the shifting catalyst body 3a).
[0072] A cleanup section 4, which contains a cleanup catalyst body
4a, is means of cleaning up the carbon monoxide (a material made by
incorporating a Pt catalyst as a member in a cordierite honeycomb
was used for the cleanup catalyst body 4a).
[0073] A raw material supplying section 5 is means of supplying a
raw material mainly containing hydrocarbons for the steam reforming
reaction to the reforming section 1; a water supplying section 6 is
means of supplying water for the steam reforming reaction to the
reforming section 1. A gas passage pathway 7 is means of flowing
the gas to the reforming section 1, the shifter 3 and the cleanup
section 4 in that order and the cleanup section 4 has an
outlet.
[0074] An air supplying section 8 is means of supplying air as an
oxidizing gas to the gas passage pathway 7 between a shifter 2 and
a cleanup section 3.
[0075] A shift No. 1 temperature measurement section 9 is means of
detecting the temperature of the gas before the gas passes through
a shifting catalyst body 3a and a shift No. 2 temperature
measurement section 10 is means of detecting the temperature of the
gas after the gas passes through the shifting catalyst body 3a;
these sections are both installed in the shifter 3. In addition, as
will be described later, the temperature of the shifter 2 is
controlled (set) on the basis of the results of the gas temperature
measurements at both the shift No. 1 temperature measurement
section 9 and the shift No. 2 temperature measurement section
10.
[0076] A cleanup No. 1 temperature measurement section 11 is means
of detecting the temperature of the gas before the gas passes
through a cleanup catalyst body 4a and a cleanup No. 2 temperature
measurement section 12 is means of detecting the temperature of the
gas after the gas passes through the cleanup catalyst body 4a;
these sections are both installed in the cleanup section 4.
[0077] Next, the operation of the hydrogen refining apparatus in
this embodiment will be depicted.
[0078] At first, a reforming heating section 2 is operated and then
the reforming catalyst body 1a of the reforming section 1 is heated
to a temperature of 700 to 750.degree. C. (Although a flame burner
was used as the reforming heating section 2, but any heating means
that can provide a target heating temperature may be used).
[0079] Next, the steam reforming reaction is allowed to proceed by
supplying the raw material of hydrocarbon components from a raw
material supplying section 5 and water from a water supplying
section 6, to a reforming catalyst body 1a that is being heated.
The gas after the reforming section passes through the gas passage
pathway 7 to the shifter 3.
[0080] While the Fe--Cr based catalyst or Cu--Zn based catalyst is
frequently used in the shifter, in order to improve the oxidation
resistance and heat resistance of the part, in this embodiment, a
catalyst prepared from a noble metal and a metal oxide,
specifically Pt and an oxide of Ce, was used in the shifter.
[0081] In particular, this catalyst shows a high heat resistance
temperature compared to the Cu--Zn based catalyst and does not
decrease in its catalyst activity as well even when the catalyst is
in oxidation state during a stop of the operation. However, the
catalyst slightly decreases in shift reactivity at low temperature
compared to the Cu--Zn based catalyst. Thus, the concentration of
the carbon monoxide at the outlet of the shifter tends to
increase.
[0082] In this embodiment, the apparatus was operated with the part
located upstream to the hydrogen gas flow of the shifting catalyst
body being set in the temperature range of 300.degree. C. to
500.degree. C. and with the part positioned downstream from the
hydrogen gas flow set in the temperature range of 150.degree. C. to
300.degree. C.
[0083] FIG. 2(a) and FIG. 2(b) show the catalyst property of a
catalyst made by preparing Pt and an oxide of Ce. In addition, FIG.
2(a) is a view (graph) illustrating the relationship between the
catalyst temperature and the carbon monoxide concentration when a
gas of 10% of carbon monoxide, 10% of carbon dioxide and 80% of
hydrogen, which is adjusted to the dew point of 65.degree. C., is
supplied to the catalyst. Furthermore, FIG. 2(b) is a view (graph)
illustrating the relationship between the catalyst temperature and
the carbon monoxide concentration when a gas of 2% of carbon
monoxide, 18% of carbon dioxide and 80% of hydrogen, which is
adjusted to the dew point of 65.degree. C., is supplied to the
catalyst.
[0084] As is shown in FIG. 2(a), when the catalyst temperature is
between 300.degree. C. and 500.degree. C., the concentration of the
carbon monoxide is 2% or less. In the case where the concentration
of the carbon monoxide is high, as the catalyst temperature is
decreased, the reaction rate decreases, and so the amount of the
carbon monoxide cannot be sufficiently reduced. In addition, when
the catalyst temperature is increased, the concentration of the
carbon monoxide increases because of the reaction equilibrium.
Therefore, in this embodiment, taking 2% of the concentration of
the carbon monoxide as a guide, the part located upstream to the
hydrogen gas flow of the shifting catalyst body was operated in the
temperature range of 300.degree. C. to 500.degree. C. However, it
is also shown that under these conditions the amount of the carbon
monoxide cannot be sufficiently reduced compared to the widely
used, traditional Cu--Zn based catalyst.
[0085] As is presented in FIG. 2(b), when the catalyst temperature
is low, the temperature equilibrium can reduce the amount of the
carbon monoxide. However, a decrease in temperature to some extent
decreases the reaction rate, resulting in an increase in the
concentration of the carbon monoxide.
[0086] Hence, when 0.5% or less of the carbon monoxide, wherein the
characteristic is almost the same as that of the widely used,
traditional Cu--Zn based catalyst, being taken as a guide, it is
shown that setting the catalyst temperature to be between
150.degree. C. and 300.degree. C. can achieve the target level of
the CO cleanup efficiency.
[0087] As a result, in this embodiment, the apparatus is operated
with the part located upstream to the hydrogen gas flow of the
shifting catalyst body being set in the temperature range of
300.degree. C. to 500.degree. C. and with the part positioned
downstream from the hydrogen gas flow set in the temperature range
of 150.degree. C. to 300.degree. C. Therefore, the amount of the
carbon monoxide is reduced by decreasing the amount of the carbon
monoxide in advance in the upstream side of the shifting catalyst
body, and setting the downstream side at a temperature of
300.degree. C. or less can further reduce the amount of the carbon
monoxide.
[0088] Further, use of the Cu--Zn based catalyst is generally
avoided at a temperature of 300.degree. C. or more from the view
point of catalyst degradation at high temperature. Thus, a large
volume is required to ensure the reactivity of the shifting
catalyst. The catalyst used in this example can be employed at a
temperature (between 300.degree. C. and 500.degree. C.) higher than
the Cu--Zn based catalyst and thus can reduce the catalyst volume
as compared to the Cu--Zn based catalyst due to superiority in the
reaction rate.
[0089] In addition, in this embodiment, the operation of the
shifter was confirmed in the above described temperature range by
measuring the temperature of the gas before the gas passed through
the shifting catalyst body 3a at the shift No. 1 temperature
measurement section 9 and by measuring the temperature of the gas
after the gas passed through the shifting catalyst body 3a at the
shift No. 2 temperature measurement section 10 during the hydrogen
gas supply.
[0090] Surely, when a hydrocarbon raw material including methane
was reformed, the hydrogen gas temperature after the reforming
catalyst is about 700.degree. C. Hence, the temperature in the side
upstream to the gas flow in the shifting catalyst body can be also
controlled by installing means of cooling the hydrogen gas such as
air cooling or water cooling, etc. in the gas passage pathway
between the reforming section and the shifter.
[0091] Next, the gas after the passage of the shifter 3 flows
through the gas passage pathway 7 to the cleanup section 4. The gas
after the passage of the cleanup section 4 is supplied through the
gas passage pathway 7 to the outside. In this time, the gas passes
from the air supplying section 8 through the gas passage pathway 7
between the shifter 3 and the cleanup section 4 to the shifter 3
and then to the gas is supplied air. As a result, the concentration
of the carbon monoxide in the hydrogen gas is reduced to about 20
ppm.
[0092] Furthermore, when the apparatus is used as hydrogen
supplying equipment for a solid polymer type fuel cell, the
concentration of the carbon monoxide in the hydrogen needs to be
reduced to about 20 ppm. However, when the concentration of the
carbon monoxide needs not be reduced to such an extent of
concentration, an additional reduction structure for such as
selectively oxidizing the carbon monoxide is not necessary.
Embodiment 2
[0093] Next, referring to FIG. 3 which illustrates a longitudinal
section of the primary part of a hydrogen refining apparatus in the
Embodiment 2 of the present invention, the arrangement of the
hydrogen refining apparatus in this embodiment will be
described.
[0094] The arrangement of the hydrogen refining apparatus of this
embodiment is almost the same as that of the hydrogen refining
apparatus (see FIG. 1) of the previously described Embodiment 1,
and so the explanation of the same parts will be omitted and only
differences will be explained.
[0095] The differences are as follows: (1) the shifting catalyst
body of the shifter 3 includes a first shifting catalyst body 3c
and a second shifting catalyst body 3e, and a shift No. 3
temperature measurement section is installed after the first
shifting catalyst body 3c, and (2) the cross-sectional area of the
first shifting catalyst body 3c at the plane perpendicular to the
hydrogen gas flow is set to be smaller than that of the second
shifting catalyst body 3e at the plane perpendicular to the
hydrogen gas flow.
[0096] The hydrogen refining apparatus of this embodiment is
operated in much the same way as in the case of the previously
described Embodiment 1 of the hydrogen refining apparatus to reduce
the amount of the carbon monoxide in the shifter 3.
[0097] In addition, in this embodiment, the cross-sectional area of
the upstream surface of the shifting catalyst body at the plane
perpendicular to the hydrogen gas flow was set as small as about
1/4 that of the downstream surface of the shifting catalyst body at
the plane perpendicular to the hydrogen gas flow. In other words,
the apparatus is characterized in that the flow rate of the
hydrogen gas in the part located upstream to the hydrogen gas flow
is set to be about four times faster than that in the downstream
side. This means that the first shifting catalyst body 3c of the
shifting catalyst body, placed upstream to the hydrogen gas flow,
is operated at a temperature between 300.degree. C. and 500.degree.
C., the temperature of which is higher than that of the second
shifting catalyst body 3e. This is because when the catalyst
temperature is high, a sufficient reaction occurs even though the
flow rate of the hydrogen gas is made fast due to an increased
reaction rate by the catalyst.
[0098] In addition, when the cross-sectional area at the plane
perpendicular to the hydrogen gas flow is made small, in terms of
apparatus arrangement, the distribution of the hydrogen gas flow at
the cross section of the shifting catalyst body is improved and the
catalyst is effectively used, and therefore an effect of
stabilizing the reduction of the amount of the carbon monoxide at
the first shifting catalyst body is produced. Consequently, the
shifter can stably reduce the amount of the carbon monoxide.
[0099] Furthermore, since the traditionally used Cu--Zn based
catalyst is difficult to operate at a catalyst temperature between
300.degree. C. and 500.degree. C. due to a decrease in catalyst
activity, and so the reduction of the amount of the carbon monoxide
in such an arrangement appears to have a small effect.
Embodiment 3
[0100] Next, referring to FIG. 4 which illustrates a longitudinal
section of the primary part of a hydrogen refining apparatus in the
Embodiment 3 of the present invention, the arrangement of the
hydrogen refining apparatus in this embodiment will be
described.
[0101] The arrangement of the hydrogen refining apparatus of this
embodiment is almost the same as that of the hydrogen refining
apparatus (see FIG. 1) of the previously described Embodiment 1,
and so the explanation of the same parts will be omitted and only
differences will be explained.
[0102] The differences are that a shift cooling section 13 was
installed in the shifting catalyst body of the shifter 3. The shift
cooling section 13 used water as cooling medium and had a cooling
arrangement by heat exchange with hydrogen gas.
[0103] The hydrogen refining apparatus of this embodiment is
operated in much the same way as in the case of the previously
described Embodiment 1 of the hydrogen refining apparatus to reduce
the amount of the carbon monoxide in the shifter 3.
[0104] However, in the hydrogen refining apparatus of this
embodiment, the shifting catalyst body located downstream from the
hydrogen gas flow is operated at a temperature between 150.degree.
C. and 300.degree. C., with the shift cooling section 13 being
operated. Surely, while the arrangement for carrying out cooling
was a water cooling structure in this embodiment, any arrangement
that cools the hydrogen gas may be employed.
[0105] As was explained in the previously described embodiment 1,
the upstream section of the shifting catalyst body is operated at a
temperature between 300.degree. C. and 500.degree. C., and
therefore the sensible heat of the hydrogen gas above 300.degree.
C. becomes redundant in the downstream side. In addition, the shift
reaction of carbon monoxide with steam is an exothermal reaction
(about 41.2 kJ/CO mol)
[0106] When the amount of the sensible heat and shift reaction heat
exceeds the amount of heat released from the shifter 3, the
downstream side of the shifting catalyst body cannot be operated at
a temperature between 150.degree. C. and 300.degree. C., leading to
an increase in the concentration of the carbon monoxide at the
outlet of the shifter (see FIG. 2(b)).
[0107] Hence, the shifting catalyst body positioned downstream from
the hydrogen gas flow is controlled so that the temperature of the
catalyst body is between 150.degree. C. and 300.degree. C., by
running the shift cooling section 13 to remove the redundant amount
of heat in the shifter. In such a way, the concentration of the
carbon monoxide can be stably reduced to 0.5% or less. In
particular, even when the amount of hydrogen gas is increased
resulting in an increase in the amount of the sensible heat and
shift reaction heat, the concentration of the carbon monoxide can
be stably reduced.
Embodiment 4
[0108] Next, referring to FIG. 5 which illustrates a longitudinal
section of the primary part of a hydrogen refining apparatus in the
Embodiment 4 of the present invention, the arrangement of the
hydrogen refining apparatus in this embodiment will be
described.
[0109] The arrangement of the hydrogen refining apparatus of this
embodiment is almost the same as that of the hydrogen refining
apparatus (see FIG. 1) of the previously described Embodiment 1,
and so the explanation of the same parts will be omitted and only
differences will be explained.
[0110] The differences are as follows: (1) the shifter 3 was
altered to a first shifter 3b equipped with the first shifting
catalyst body 3c and to a second shifter 3d equipped with the
second shifting catalyst body 3e; (2) the first shifter was
equipped with the shift No. 1 temperature measurement section 9,
and the second shifter was equipped with the shift No. 2
temperature measurement section 10; and (3) a shift cooling fan 15,
cooling means of dissipating the heat of the hydrogen gas, was
installed between the first shifter 3b and the second shifter 3d.
In addition, a honeycomb form, not a pellet form, was used as the
shifting catalyst.
[0111] The hydrogen refining apparatus of this embodiment is
operated in much the same way as in the case of the previously
described Embodiment 1 of the hydrogen refining apparatus to reduce
the amount of the carbon monoxide in the shifter 3.
[0112] However, in the hydrogen refining apparatus of this
embodiment, the upstream side of the first shifting catalyst body
of the first shifter is operated at a temperature between
300.degree. C. and 500.degree. C.; the downstream side of the
second shifting catalyst body of the second shifter is operated at
a temperature between 150.degree. C. and 300.degree. C.
[0113] Furthermore, the temperature of the downstream side of the
second shifting catalyst body of the second shifter is controlled
by cooling the hydrogen gas by use of the shift cooling fan 15.
Since the temperature of the shifting catalyst body depends on the
flow rate of the hydrogen gas, the temperature of the shifting
catalyst body changes extensively as the flow rate of the hydrogen
gas greatly varies. However, in this embodiment, the temperatures
of the upstream and downstream sides of the shifting catalyst body
come to be mutually little dependent, by dividing the shifter into
two parts, the first shifter and the second shifter, resulting in
ease of the temperature control of the shifting catalyst body.
[0114] Surely, although the temperature of the second shifting
catalyst body was controlled based on the temperature of the
downstream side of the second shifting catalyst body, the
temperature of the second shifting catalyst body may be controlled
by installing a temperature measurement section in the upstream
side of the second shifting catalyst body to operate the shift
cooling fan on the basis of the temperature.
[0115] More specifically, a structure for reducing the amount of
carbon monoxide through the use of two stages or two layers of the
shifter like this embodiment, utilizing the Fe--Cr based catalyst
at a relatively high temperature (300.degree. C. to 500.degree. C.)
and the Cu--Zn based catalyst at a comparatively low temperature
(200.degree. C. to 300.degree. C.) in combination in the shifter,
is being used (the Fe--Cr based catalyst as the high temperature
section reduces the amount of the carbon monoxide of high
concentration; the Cu--Zn based catalyst as the low temperature
section reduces the amount of the carbon monoxide to a low
concentration). However, in such a structure, the Fe--Cr based
catalyst is low in catalyst activity for the carbon monoxide shift
reaction, resulting in a larger scale of the shifter. In addition,
since the function of both the catalysts is decreased due to
oxidation, continuous operation is desirable.
[0116] Thus, in this embodiment, a catalyst made by preparing Pt
and an oxide of Ce as a noble metal and a metal oxide was used.
Because of this, the catalyst offers an excellent oxidation
resistance and can cope with the frequent start-up and stop action.
In addition, the catalyst is high in catalyst activity for the
carbon monoxide shift reaction as compared to the Fe--Cr based
catalyst, and so the former provides an effect of the first stage
of the shifter being made a smaller scale. Further, controlling the
temperature within the shifter, through the use of one shifter, can
give an effect of reducing the amount of the carbon monoxide
equivalent to the case of the conventional two-stage shifter
arrangement (In other words, the simplification of the arrangement
can be achieved). Additionally, because the same catalyst body can
be used in the shifter, the recovery of the catalyst is simplified,
and so the arrangement, which cannot be easily devised in a
conventional way, has excellent effects of such as further
facilitating catalyst recycling.
[0117] Furthermore, the present invention constructed the shifting
catalyst body by incorporating a catalyst including Pt and an oxide
of Ce in an alumina pellet, but similar results were also provided
when any of Pt, Pd, Ru or Rh was used as the noble metal in the
shifting catalyst body and any of Ce, Zr or Zn as the metal
oxide.
Embodiment 5
[0118] At first, referring to FIG. 6, the arrangement of a hydrogen
refining apparatus in this embodiment will be explained. In
addition, FIG. 6 is a longitudinal section of the primary part of
the hydrogen refining apparatus in the Embodiment 5 of the present
invention.
[0119] In FIG. 6, a CO shifting catalyst body (also called simply
(shifting) catalyst body) 101 is installed inside a reaction
chamber 102 and a reformed gas is introduced at a reformed gas
inlet 103. The reformed gas that was allowed to react in the CO
shifting catalyst body 101 is discharged out of a reformed gas
outlet.
[0120] In addition, in the upstream side of the catalyst body 101,
a diffusing plate 105 is installed so that the reformed gas flows
uniformly. Further, in order to keep the reaction vessel at a
constant temperature, the outsides of the necessary portions were
covered with an insulating material 106 made from ceramics
wool.
[0121] Here, for the catalyst body 101 was used a material made by
coating a cordierite honeycomb with a catalyst prepared by the
incorporation of Pt into a composite oxide of cerium (hereinafter
referred to as Ce) and zirconia (hereinafter referred to as
Zr).
[0122] Next, the operation of the hydrogen refining apparatus in
this embodiment will be explained.
[0123] Fuels used for generating reformed gases supplied to a
hydrogen refining apparatus include natural gas, methanol and
gasoline; reforming processes include steam reforming by the
addition of steam and partial reforming by adding air. Here, the
case wherein a reformed gas is obtained by steam reforming natural
gas will be depicted.
[0124] While the composition of a reformed gas where natural gas is
steam reformed slightly varies depending on the temperature of the
reforming catalyst body, the reformed gas includes, as average
values excluding steam, about 80% of hydrogen, about 10% of carbon
dioxide and about 10% of carbon monoxide.
[0125] The reforming reaction of natural gas is conducted in a
temperature range of about 500 to 800.degree. C., while the shift
reaction wherein CO reacts with steam proceeds at about 150 to
350.degree. C., and so the reformed gas is supplied after the gas
is cooled before the reformed gas inlet 103. The CO concentration
after the passage of the CO shifting catalyst body 101 is reduced
to about 0.5% and then discharged out of a reformed gas outlet
104.
[0126] Next, the operation principle of the hydrogen refining
apparatus of this embodiment will be explained.
[0127] The water-gas shift reaction is an equilibrium reaction that
depends on the temperature and the CO concentration can be reduced
as the temperature of the reaction is decreased. On the other hand,
as the temperature is lowered, the reaction rate associated with
catalyst activity is decreased. Therefore, a temperature at which
the CO concentration takes a minimal value exists.
[0128] Copper base shifting catalysts such as a copper/zinc
catalyst and copper/chromium catalyst that are used as CO shifting
catalysts in the conventional hydrogen refining apparatus can be
used for the water-gas shift reaction at a low temperature of 150
to 250.degree. C. Under certain conditions, the CO concentration
can be reduced to about a few hundred to a thousand ppm.
[0129] However, copper based catalysts need to be activated by
passing a reducing gas such as hydrogen or reformed gas after
filled in a reaction vessel and the catalysts heat resistance is as
low as about 300.degree. C. Thus, the reducing gas needs to be
diluted by use of an inert gas or the like and then supplied so as
not to exceed the heat resistance temperature by reaction heat
during the activation, or the reaction needs to be made to occur
gradually in a small flow rate and thus needs a long time. In
addition, at the time of the start-up of the equipment as well, the
catalyst needs to be heated slowly by taking much time to avoid
exceeding the heat resistance temperature as a result of an
excessive temperature rise. Thus, the catalyst has many problems in
applications such as a frequent, repeated start-up and stop
operation.
[0130] On the other hand, in (the shifter of) the hydrogen refining
apparatus of this embodiment, the noble metal catalyst Pt is used
as the catalyst body 101 and has a very high heat resistance
compared with the copper based catalyst, and therefore no extensive
deterioration in the catalyst occurs even when the temperature
rises to about 500.degree. C. at the time of the start-up of the
equipment. In addition, a long-hour reduction treatment is
unnecessary in contrast to the copper based catalyst. Furthermore,
even though air is mixed when the equipment is stopped, the
degradation of the catalyst is less than that of the copper based
catalyst.
[0131] Further, since noble metal catalysts with active components
such as Pt, Pd, Rh and Ru have high activities, their reaction
selectivity is comparatively low. Hence, under certain conditions,
the methanation of the CO or the carbon dioxide may proceed as a
secondary reaction of the water-gas shift reaction, and so concerns
rise that the consumption of the hydrogen arising from the progress
of the methanation decreases the efficiency of the whole
equipment.
[0132] However, normally, in the temperature range of 150 to
500.degree. C., wherein the water-gas shift reaction is conducted,
as the temperature increases, the methanation becomes conspicuous,
but the yield of methane varies depending on the kinds of noble
metals. This is because the adsorption mechanism of CO varies with
the kinds of noble metals. Pd, Rd and Ru, which exhibit an
adsorption mechanism of CO that makes the methanation liable to
proceed, generate methane at relatively low temperature, leading to
a narrow temperature range wherein the water-gas shift reaction can
be carried out. To the contrary, the Pt catalyst used in this
embodiment resists causing the methanation and thus can conduct the
water-gas shift reaction in a wide temperature range. Thus, the
progress of the methanation does not consume a great amount of
hydrogen, and so the hydrogen refining apparatus of this embodiment
can be operated effectively.
[0133] Furthermore, the addition of Ce as a promoter can enhance
the activity of the Pt catalyst for the water-gas shift reaction as
well as retard the methanation. The more the proportion of Ce
contained in the support, the more the methanation can be
restricted. Cerium oxide, when used as a support, offers the
highest low temperature activity to the shift reaction and can also
retard the methanation.
[0134] However, because cerium oxide exhibits a low heat resistance
compared to supports such as alumina and zirconia, when it is used
in conditions such as at a temperature above 600.degree. C. or when
water condensation occurs at the time of start-up or stop of the
equipment, it raises the possibility of its catalyst activity being
decreased. This is due to the fact that sintering by heat decreases
the specific surface area of the cerium oxide, or the cerium oxide,
which shows basicity, reacts with the carbon dioxide in the
reformed gas.
[0135] On the other hand, the hydrogen refining apparatus of the
present invention uses a composite oxide prepared by compounding Zr
with Ce as the catalyst support, which enhances the stability of
the catalyst support resulting in a resistance to the activity
decline of the catalyst. Normally, zirconia is relatively stable
and offers resistance to a decrease in the specific surface area by
heat or to the occurrence of the reaction with the carbon dioxide
in the reformed gas. However, zirconia shows a low catalyst
activity in a shift reaction at low temperature compared with
cerium oxide and also facilitates the methanation at high
temperature. Thus, as in the present invention, the composite oxide
made by compounding Zr with Ce is used as the catalyst support. For
a composite oxide prepared under the coexistence of cerium oxide
and zirconia, the exchange of electrons between the cerium oxide
and the zirconia is facilitated, so that the catalyst activity in
the shift reaction leads to an effect comparable to the case of
cerium oxide alone. However, when zirconia and cerium oxide coexist
simply without making a composite, no electron exchange occurs, and
so this effect is not greatly exerted. In addition, as for the
ratio of the Ce to the Zr, as the amount of the Ce is smaller (that
is, the amount of the Zr is larger), the heat resistance is
increased resulting in a good stability, but with decreasing
content of the Ce, the methanation at high temperature is enhanced.
Accordingly, the content of the Ce is preferably 5 atomic percent
or more. Note that when the content of the Ce is higher than 90
atomic percent, a level of performance only comparable to the case
of cerium oxide is obtainable. Further, a process for compounding
Zr with Ce is not specified. For instance, the coprecipitation
method, the sol-gel process, the alcoxide method or the like can be
used.
[0136] In addition, as will be described in detail later referring
to Tables 1 and 2, a process for forming a solid solution of cerium
oxide and zirconia is available as a process for compounding Zr
with Ce to give a composite. When a composite is uniformly formed
as a solid solution, the stability of the support is further
enhanced and also the progress of the methanation is retarded. When
cerium oxide and zirconia exist with neither forming a composite
nor forming a solid solution, characteristics of the heat
resistance and methanation of respective materials alone are likely
to come out. On the other hand, when a solid solution is formed,
cerium oxide is integrated into zirconia crystal to restrict the
heat deterioration of the cerium oxide, resulting in a heat
resistance almost equivalent to that of zirconia alone.
Furthermore, since the electron exchange between the cerium oxide
and the zirconia is further facilitated, the ability of oxygen
supply from the cerium oxide can be maintained. As a result, the
stability of the support is promoted and a special effect of
retarding the progress of the methanation as well is produced. In
addition, the formation of a solid solution can be confirmed via
powder X-ray diffraction measurement. The smaller the intensity of
the diffraction line of the single phase of the cerium oxide or the
zirconia is, the more homogeneous the formation of the solid
solution is made.
[0137] Incidentally, making the Pt particles small and producing
many activity points are required to obtain a sufficient catalyst
activity. To this end, Pt is preferably incorporated into a metal
oxide of which BET specific surface area is 10 square meters per
unit or more. Here, the BET specific surface area refers to the
specific surface area evaluated from a well-known measurement
method, wherein measurement is carried out by adsorbing nitrogen on
powder.
[0138] The upper limit of the BET specific surface area is not
particularly restrained, and even when the value is 100 to 200
squaremeters per gram, a similar, high activity is acquired.
However, when it reaches 100 square meters per gram or more, the
effect arising from an increase in the specific surface area is
decreased. When BET specific surface areas of the metal oxide and
composite metal oxide are less than 10 square meters per gram, the
degree of dispersion of the Pt is reduced without sufficient
adsorption of Pt, resulting in an insufficient catalysis activity.
Additionally, when the amount of Pt incorporation is decreased in
order to reduce the particle size of the Pt, the number of activity
points is decreased, leading to an insufficient activity.
[0139] Furthermore, in this embodiment, although a composite oxide
made by compounding Zr with Ce was used, a further addition of Al
reduces the decrease in the specific surface area in a high
temperature range, which results in an enhancement of the heat
resistance. Also, instead of Zr, compounding only Al gives rise to
a similar effect. In summary, the composite oxide of the present
invention is simply a composite oxide made by compounding Zr and/or
Al with Ce.
[0140] In addition, in this embodiment, while a form made by
coating a cordierite honeycomb with a catalyst was used as the form
of a catalyst body, a procedure, wherein the form of a support is
made a pellet form and then a salt of Pt is impregnated to prepare
a CO shifting catalyst body, also provides a shifting catalyst body
of a similar performance.
Embodiment 6
[0141] Next, referring to FIG. 7, the arrangement and operation of
a hydrogen refining apparatus in this embodiment will be explained.
In addition, FIG. 7 is a longitudinal section of the primary part
of the hydrogen refining apparatus in the Embodiment 6 of the
present invention.
[0142] The hydrogen refining apparatus in this embodiment, as shown
in FIG. 7, is made by dividing the catalyst body into two stages
and installing a cooling section in a midway of the catalyst body.
Most of the effect of action is similar to the case of the
Embodiment 5. Therefore, this embodiment will be explained focusing
on primarily the differences.
[0143] The catalyst body is divided into a No. 1 catalyst body 111
and a No. 2 catalyst body 113, with a cooling section being
installed in between, and a cooling fan 119 (hydrogen gas
temperature adjustment section) cools the reformed gas. The CO
concentration can be reduced using a small amount of catalyst. This
is because reaction heat produced in the upstream section of the
catalyst body is transported to the downstream section via the
reformed gas due to the fact that the water-gas shift reaction is
an exothermal reaction. As a result, the temperature of the
catalyst body tends to be higher in the downstream section, and so
even though the CO concentration is sufficiently reduced in the
upstream section, the CO concentration is again increased in the
downstream section of high temperature because of the reverse
reaction. Therefore, the reverse reaction can be restrained by
lowering the temperature of the No. 2 catalyst body 113 in the
downstream side relative to that of the No. 1 catalyst body
111.
[0144] In addition, a composite oxide with a large content of Ce is
desirably used for the catalyst body 111 in the upstream side, the
temperature of which tends to be high. This is because the use of a
composite oxide with a large content of Ce in the upstream side,
the temperature of which tends to be high, can extend the operation
temperature range that can promote the water-gas shift reaction
leading to easier control of the apparatus, even in the high
temperature region where the operation of the apparatus is
restricted by the methanation.
[0145] Further, the methanation is reduced to proceed by use of a
composite oxide with a small content of Ce in the downstream
section where the condensation of water is likely to occur at the
time of start-up, so that such a decline of the characteristic
caused by water as previously described can be constrained, leading
to an elongation of the endurance life.
[0146] Additionally, while, in the above described embodiment, the
catalyst body was divided into the two stages: the No. 1 catalyst
body 111 and the No. 2 catalyst body 113, the number of stages is
not particularly specified, and if a structure wherein the
temperature in each stage of the catalyst body is optimally
controlled, a high characteristic can be achieved (For example, the
same goes for the previously described Embodiment 4).
EXAMPLE 1
[0147] A shifting catalyst used in this example was prepared by
dispersively incorporating Pt into CeO.sub.2 and then sintering, by
use of both CeO.sub.2 and a salt solution of Pt (a nitrate of a
dinitrodiamine platinum complex). The catalyst body was made by
coating an alumina pellet (3 mm in diameter, 3 mm in length) with
this CeO.sub.2 into which Pt was incorporated (the amount of Pt
incorporated is 3% by weight). A shifting catalyst body was also
prepared by coating a cordierite honeycomb 100 mm in diameter and
50 mm in length. Further, a honeycomb form has a merit of being
more easily able to be adjusted the surface area per volume with
the number of cells per area compared with a pellet form.
[0148] A shifting catalyst body was also made by a similar method
using Zr or Zn, or Ce and their mixture or their solid solution as
the metal oxide. In addition, for comparison, a conventional Rh--Ce
based catalyst was prepared as well in the same way described
above.
[0149] As a result, the shifting catalyst of this example has been
shown to offer a better CO cleanup efficiency than the conventional
Rh--Ce based catalyst.
EXAMPLE 2
[0150] The decline of catalyst activity of the Pt--Ce based
catalyst of the present invention was compared with that of the
conventional Cu--Zn based catalyst.
[0151] When a Pt--Ce based catalyst was used, even though the
action of start-up and stop was repeated 10 times or more, almost
no deterioration of catalyst activity of the catalyst body in the
shifter was observed. This is because the Pt--Ce based catalyst is
rarely affected by the decline of the catalyst activity caused by
oxidation.
[0152] For the use of a Cu--Zn based catalyst, in the case of the
equipment for which the action of the start-up and stop was
conducted 10 times or more, the concentration of the carbon
monoxide at a site after the shifter was about twice that of the
case where the start-up was conducted once, indicating that the
catalyst activity was reduced. This is because the catalyst is
oxidized resulting in the decline of its activity during the
start-up and stop operation.
[0153] Therefore, the Pt--Ce based catalyst of this example
exhibits a resistance to the decline of its catalyst activity as
compared with the conventional Cu--Zn based catalyst.
EXAMPLE 3
[0154] Comparison was made between the characteristics of a Pt--Ce
based catalyst and a Rh--Ce based catalyst as shifting catalysts in
this example, using the arrangement of the hydrogen refining
apparatus shown in FIG. 1.
[0155] Since the fundamental characteristics as a shifting catalyst
were rarely affected by the deterioration of catalyst activity
caused by oxidation, the Rh--Ce based catalyst showed
characteristics almost equivalent to those of the Pt--Ce base
shifting catalyst. However, because the Rh--Ce based catalyst was
better than Pt in the activity for the methanation of the carbon
dioxide or the carbon monoxide with the hydrogen, the concentration
of the methane in the gas after the shifter was slightly increased.
In comparison at a catalyst temperature of 300.degree. C., the
concentration of the methane for the Pt--Ce base shifting catalyst
was 0.1% (on a dry basis), while that of the Rh--Ce base shifting
catalyst was 0.2% (on a dry basis), but the concentrations of the
carbon monoxide at the outlets were a constant value.
[0156] Surely, the extent of such an increase in the methane
concentration does not influence practical uses, and so the Rh--Ce
based catalyst can be used as a shifting catalyst as well.
[0157] In addition, not only the combinations of Pt and the Rh
catalyst indicated here showed the activity of catalyst, but also
other noble metals were confirmed to exhibit similar shift
reactivities, although their characteristics slightly vary
depending on respective noble metals.
EXAMPLE 4
[0158] The shift reactivities of the various shifting catalysts
indicated in the Example 1 were confirmed in each example.
[0159] As a result, catalysts prepared using Zr or Zn, or Ce and
their mixture or their solid solution as the metal oxide were
confirmed to serve as shifting catalyst bodies excellent in the
oxidation resistance the Cu--Zn base shifting catalyst does not
offer. However, shift reactivities slightly varied depending on
respective metal oxides.
[0160] For example, when Zr was used, the methanation of the carbon
dioxide or the carbon monoxide with the hydrogen was likely to
proceed and the methane concentration at the outlet of the shifter
tended to increase slightly. Although depending on the catalyst
conditions, in comparison at a catalyst temperature of 300.degree.
C., the concentration of the methane for a Pt--Ce base shifting
catalyst was 0.1% (on a dry basis), while that of a Pt--Zr base
shifting catalyst was 0.15% (on a dry basis).
[0161] In addition, when Zn was used, because its ability of oxygen
donation is superior to that of Ce at low temperature, the shift
reactivity at low temperature tended to be enhanced, but when used
at high temperature (for example, 500.degree. C. or more), the
tendency of reduction of an oxide of Zn was increased, leading to
the tendency of a decrease in the catalyst activity. However, it
was confirmed that not only a combination with an oxide of Ce shows
catalyst activity, but also other metal oxides exhibit equivalent
shift reactivities.
EXAMPLE 5
[0162] An example of the operation of the hydrogen refining
apparatus in the previously described Embodiment 1 will be
presented.
[0163] At first, the hydrogen gas supplying section was operated.
By the use of methane gas as raw material, a steam reforming was
conducted by adding three moles of water to one mole of methane gas
to generate hydrogen gas containing about 10% of carbon monoxide
and about 10% of carbon dioxide. This hydrogen gas was supplied to
the shifter to promote the shift reaction, leading to the reduction
of the carbon monoxide. During this time, the part located upstream
to the hydrogen gas flow of the shifting catalyst body was operated
in the temperature range of 300.degree. C. to 500.degree. C. and
the part positioned downstream from the hydrogen gas flow was
operated in the temperature range of 150.degree. C. to 300.degree.
C.
[0164] In addition, the amount of noble metal per volume of the
shifting catalyst body in the upstream section was the same as that
of the shifting catalyst body in the downstream section. When the
apparatus was operated at the above described temperatures, the
carbon monoxide was sufficiently subjected to shift reaction in the
shifter, leading to a reduction to about 0.5%.
[0165] Here, two Comparative Examples that were not operated at the
above described catalyst temperatures will be shown. When the
upstream temperature of a catalyst was set at 250.degree. C., the
shift reaction in the catalyst in the upstream section rarely
proceeded and the concentration of the carbon monoxide after the
shift was reduced to only about 2%. In addition, when the upstream
temperature of the catalyst was set at a temperature above
500.degree. C., the amount of the carbon monoxide was not
sufficiently reduced because of the equilibrium reaction, with the
concentration of the carbon monoxide at the shift outlet being not
more than 0.5%.
[0166] Further, when the temperature of a catalyst is high, the
carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide react with the hydrogen to yield
methane. As the amount of the noble metal of a catalyst is
increased, the tendency is increased. The methanation is not
desirable because of its consumption of the hydrogen.
[0167] In this example, the apparatus was operated, with the amount
of noble metal in a half of the shifting catalyst body located
upstream to the hydrogen gas flow being set equal to about 1/4 of
the amount of noble metal in a half of the downstream side, to see
the tendency. As compared with the case where the amounts of noble
metals were the same, the amount of the methane was confirmed to be
reduced to about 1/2. On the other hand, the concentrations of the
carbon monoxide at the outlets were almost the same value, not more
than 0.5%.
[0168] As can be seen from this example, the amount of noble metal
in the part located upstream to the flow of the hydrogen gas used
at a relatively high temperature can be reduced compared with that
in the part located downstream from the hydrogen gas flow.
EXAMPLE 6
[0169] An example of the operation of the hydrogen refining
apparatus in the previously described Embodiment 2 will be
presented.
[0170] While the operation was carried out under almost the same
conditions and equipment arrangement as shown in the above
described Example 5, the cross-sectional area of the shifting
catalyst body in the upstream side, at a plane perpendicular to the
hydrogen gas flow, was reduced to about 1/4 of the cross-sectional
area of the shifting catalyst body in the downstream side, at a
plane perpendicular to the hydrogen gas flow. As a result, the flow
rate of the hydrogen gas of the part located upstream to the
hydrogen gas flow becomes about four times larger than that of the
part located in the downstream side. However, the concentration of
the carbon monoxide at the shift outlet could be reduced to about
0.5%. This is because, when the catalyst temperature is high, the
reaction rate at the catalyst is increased, and so the reaction
occurs sufficiently even though the flow rate of the hydrogen gas
is increased.
[0171] Next, a comparison with the Example 5 will be conducted. In
the Example 5, the cross-sectional area of the shifting catalyst
body in the upstream side is the same as that of the shifting
catalyst body in the downstream side. Accordingly, as compared with
the Example 5, the flow rate of the shifting catalyst body at the
upstream side is about four times. In addition, the height of the
catalyst load in the shifter was taken almost equal to the height
of the catalyst in the upstream side. In other words, the amount of
catalyst loaded is reduced compared with the case of the Example 5.
When the amount of catalyst loaded in the Example 5 case is taken
as 1, the amount of loading in this example is about 3/4.
[0172] However, it became possible to reduce the concentration of
the carbon monoxide to the concentration equivalent to that in the
case of the Example 5. This is due to the fact that, when the
cross-sectional area at a plane perpendicular to the hydrogen gas
flow is reduced, the apparatus arrangement enhances the flow
distribution of the hydrogen gas at the cross section and so the
catalyst can be used effectively, and therefore the effect of
stabilizing the reduction of the amount of the carbon monoxide in
the first shifting catalyst body is produced. As a result, even
though the amount of shifting catalyst loaded is reduced, it is
possible to stably reduce the amount of the carbon monoxide.
EXAMPLE 7
[0173] An example of the operation of the hydrogen refining
apparatus in the previously described Embodiment 3 will be
presented. In this example, the shift cooling section 3 uses water
as a cooling medium and its arrangement is characterized by
conducting cooling through the gas/liquid heat exchange with the
hydrogen gas.
[0174] When the operation was carried out under almost the same
conditions and equipment arrangement as shown in the above
described Example 5, no large problems were caused. However, when
the amount of hydrogen gas supplied to the shifter was increased,
the sensible heat of the hydrogen gas became redundant in the
downstream side. In addition, the shift reaction of the carbon
monoxide with the steam is exothermic. When this amount of sensible
heat and shift reaction heat exceeds the amount of heat released
out of the shifter 3, the downstream side of the shifting catalyst
body cannot sometimes work at a temperature between 150.degree. C.
and 300.degree. C. For example, under the conditions shown in the
Example 5, when the amount of hydrogen gas to be supplied was made
twice, the downstream side of the shifting catalyst body could not
be operated at 300.degree. C. or less, resulting in an increase in
the concentration of the carbon monoxide at the outlet.
[0175] Thus, in this example, with the operation of the shift
cooling section being conducted, the downstream side of the
shifting catalyst body was operated at a temperature between
150.degree. C. and 300.degree. C. As a result, the amount of the
carbon monoxide at the outlet of the shifter was reduced to not
more than 0.5%.
EXAMPLE 8
[0176] An example of the operation of the hydrogen refining
apparatus in the previously described Embodiment 4 will be
presented.
[0177] The operation was carried out under almost the same
conditions and equipment arrangement as shown in the above
described Example 7. That is, the concentration of the carbon
monoxide at the outlet of the shifter was confirmed by varying the
amount of hydrogen gas supplied to the shifter. Since the
temperature of the shifting catalyst body depends on the hydrogen
gas flow rate, when the hydrogen gas flow rate varies extensively,
the temperature of the shifting catalyst body changes greatly as
well.
[0178] However, the shifter is divided into the two sections of the
first shifter and the second shifter as demonstrated in this
example to reduce the mutual dependence of the temperatures of the
upstream and downstream sides of the shifting catalyst body on
their temperatures, leading to an easy temperature control of the
shifting catalyst bodies. As a result, it is possible to stably
reduce the concentration of the carbon monoxide at the outlet of
the shifter. In addition, the apparatus was confirmed to be able to
stably operate when the amount of hydrogen gas reaches about four
times that of the case in the Example 5.
EXAMPLE 9
[0179] One percent by weight of Pt was incorporated into the metal
oxides or composite oxides 1 to 15 of which compositions are given
in Table 1. Cordierite honeycombs were coated with these oxides and
then were installed in a reaction chamber 112 (see FIG. 6).
[0180] A reformed gas consisting of 8% carbon monoxide, 8% carbon
dioxide, 20% steam and hydrogen (the rest) was introduced at a flow
rate of 10 liters per minute at a reformed gas inlet 113 (see FIG.
6). After the temperature of the reformed gas was controlled to
react in the catalyst body 111 (see FIG. 6), the composition of the
gas discharged out of a reformed gas outlet 114 (see FIG. 6) was
determined by gas chromatography.
[0181] The lowest values of the CO concentrations and the
concentrations of the methane in the gas after the reaction at a
catalyst temperature of 400.degree. C. were measured. Further, the
action of stopping the equipment and then re-starting it was
repeated 10 times and then the CO concentrations were measured to
evaluate the changes in activities of the catalysts. These results
are summarized in Table 1.
1TABLE 1 CO concentrations after 10 time CO repetitions of Sample
Metal oxides or concentrations start-up and Concentrations of No.
composite oxides (%) stop action (%) methane at 400.degree. C. (%)
1 Cerium oxide 0.13 0.65 0.01 2 Alumina 1.25 1.25 2.25 3 Zirconia
0.62 0.63 1.52 4 Ce0.95Zr0.05Ox 0.13 0.64 0.03 5 Ce0.9Zr0.1Ox 0.13
0.15 0.05 6 Ce0.5Zr0.5Ox 0.13 0.14 0.10 7 Ce0.05Zr0.95Ox 0.14 0.14
0.30 8 Ce0.03Zr0.97Ox 0.50 0.51 1.02 9 Ce0.01Zr0.99Ox 0.55 0.56
1.25 10 Ce0.95Al0.5Ox 0.13 0.64 0.02 11 Ce0.9Al0.1Ox 0.13 0.14 0.05
12 Ce0.5Al0.5Ox 0.13 0.13 0.12 13 Ce0.05Al0.95Ox 0.15 0.15 0.33 14
Ce0.03Al0.97Ox 0.66 0.67 0.81 15 Ce0.01Al0.99Ox 0.89 0.90 1.20
[0182] The experimental results shown in Table 1 attest the
previously described following facts. For instance, cerium oxide
(ceria) exhibits an extremely high activity for the shift reaction
and can restrain the methanation, but it tends to show a decline in
catalyst activity as a result of the repetition of the start-up and
stop action of the equipment, as compared with alumina, zirconia or
the like. Additionally, when a composite oxide prepared by
compounding Zr with Ce is used as a catalyst support, as the
proportion of the Ce decreases, (1) the decline in the activity of
the catalyst is hard to occur, but (2) the methanation is likely to
proceed in the high temperature region, for instance.
[0183] Incidentally, for the samples in the experiment of which
results are shown in Table 1, the intensity of the diffraction peak
measured by the X-ray diffraction measurement is about 20%, and so
the ceria, zirconia or alumina remains as a single phase; that is,
a solid solution is not formed sufficiently. Thus, samples of solid
solutions whose sufficient formation was confirmed by the
disappearance of the diffraction peak assigned to the single phase
of ceria, zirconia or alumina were used and the experimental
results are listed in Table 2.
2TABLE 2 CO concentrations after 10 time CO repetitions of Sample
Metal oxides or concentrations start-up and Concentrations of No.
composite oxides (%) stop action (%) methane at 400.degree. C. (%)
16 Ce0.95Zr0.05Ox 0.13 0.55 0.02 17 Ce0.9Zr0.1Ox 0.13 0.14 0.04 18
Ce0.5Zr0.5Ox 0.13 0.14 0.06 19 Ce0.05Zr0.95Ox 0.14 0.14 0.20 20
Ce0.03Zr0.97Ox 0.50 0.51 0.80 21 Ce0.01Zr0.99Ox 0.55 0.56 1.10 22
Ce0.95Al0.5Ox 0.13 0.54 0.02 23 Ce0.9Al0.1Ox 0.13 0.14 0.03 24
Ce0.5Al0.5Ox 0.13 0.13 0.07 25 Ce0.05Al0.95x 0.15 0.15 0.25 26
Ce0.03Al0.97Ox 0.65 0.65 0.50 27 Ce0.01Al0.99Ox 0.89 0.90 1.05
[0184] From the experimental results given in Tables 1 and 2, (a) a
degradation in a catalyst that is likely to occur when the
proportion of ceria is high and (b) the methanation that tends to
occur when the proportion of zirconia or alumina is high are shown
to be considerably retarded by sufficiently forming a solid
solution. In addition, the coprecipitation method, the sol-gel
process, the alcoxide method, etc. can be utilized as methods for
forming a homogeneous solid solution.
[0185] Furthermore, when the atomic percent of Ce is 90 or more
like in the sample 4 in Table 1 and in the sample 16 in Table 2,
and when the atomic percent of Ce is 5 or less like in the samples
13 to 15 in Table 1 and the samples 25 to 27 in Table 2, the
results are not so good in both the CO concentration (after 10 time
start-up and stop actions) and the concentration of the methane at
400.degree. C. However, as described above, (1) at a temperature
between 300.degree. C. and 500.degree. C. in the upstream side, and
(2) at a temperature of 300.degree. C. or less in the downstream
side, of the (carbon monoxide) shifting catalyst body, results more
desirable than in the cases of the previously described
conventional example can be acquired.
[0186] In addition, Al, like Zr, is inclined to form a composite
oxide with Ce and is also stable as a simple substance of
Al.sub.2O.sub.3. Therefore, though concrete data are omitted, also
when a composite oxide made by compounding (a) Al, or (b) Zr and
Al, with Ce, was used, results were obtained similar to those when
a composite oxide made by compounding Zr with Ce was used.
EXAMPLE 10
[0187] Into a composite oxide having a 1-to-1 Zr-to-Ce ratio, in
atomic number, with the Zr and Ce being indicated in the sample 6
in Table 1, used in the Example 9, was incorporated 1% by weight of
Pt. As cordierite honeycombs coated with this oxide, the No. 1
catalyst body 111 (see FIG. 7) and the No. 2 catalyst body 113 (see
FIG. 7), the total volume of which was made equal to that in the
Example 1, were installed, respectively, in the No. 1 reaction
chamber 112 (see FIG. 7) and in a No. 2 reaction chamber 114 (see
FIG. 7).
[0188] A reformed gas consisting of 8% carbon monoxide, 8% carbon
dioxide, 20% steam and hydrogen (the rest) was introduced at a flow
rate of 10 liters per minute at a reformed gas inlet 115 (see FIG.
7). The lowest value of the CO concentration and the concentration
of the methane in the gas after a reaction in the No. 1 catalyst
body 111 at a temperature of 400.degree. C. were 0.09% and 0.06%,
respectively. Further, the action of stopping the equipment and
then re-starting it was repeated 10 times and then the CO
concentration was measured to confirm the change in activity of the
catalyst; the CO concentration was 0.11%.
[0189] In this way, when the catalyst in this example was used,
both of the CO concentration and the methane concentration were
lower than in the case where the catalyst body utilizing the sample
6 in the Example 1 was used. Therefore, it has been at tested that
the cooling section explained in the Embodiment 2 facilitates the
progress of the reaction directed toward the reduction of the CO
concentration and contributes to a high efficiency operation of the
hydrogen refining apparatus.
EXAMPLE 11
[0190] In the Example 10, the ratios of Ce to Zr of 9 to 1 and 1 to
9 in the composite oxides used in the No. 1 catalyst body 111 (see
FIG. 7) and the No. 2 catalyst body 113 (see FIG. 7), respectively,
were set and the content of Ce in the catalyst body of the upstream
side was made larger. Similarly to the Example 2, the lowest value
of the CO concentration and the concentration of the methane in the
gas after a reaction in the No. 1 catalyst body 111 at a
temperature of 400.degree. C. were determined to be 0.09% and
0.01%, respectively. Further, the action of stopping the equipment
and then re-starting it was repeated 10 times and then the CO
concentration was measured to confirm the change in activity of the
catalyst; the CO concentration was 0.09%.
[0191] In this way, when the catalyst in this example was used,
both of the CO concentration and the methane concentration have a
tendency to be lower than in the case where the catalyst body in
the Example 10 was used. In particular, this tendency is remarkable
for the methane concentration. Thus, as described above, it has
been attested that the use of a composite oxide of a large content
of Ce in the upstream side, of which temperature is likely to be
high, restrains the progress of the methanation to promote a high
efficiency operation of the hydrogen refining apparatus.
COMPARATIVE EXAMPLE 1
[0192] Instead of a composite oxide, wherein Pt is incorporated, of
the present invention, in this comparative example, a conventional
copper zinc catalyst was used as a catalyst body 101 (see FIG. 6),
and like the Example 9, the catalyst was installed in the reaction
chamber 102 (see FIG. 6). A reformed gas consisting of 8% carbon
monoxide, 8% carbon dioxide, 20% steam and hydrogen (the rest) was
introduced at a flow rate of 10 liters per minute at a reformed gas
inlet 103 (see FIG. 6). After the temperature of the reformed gas
was controlled to react in the catalyst body 101, the composition
of the gas discharged out of a reformed gas outlet 104 (see FIG. 6)
was determined by gas chromatography; the lowest value of the CO
concentration was 0.08%. Further, the action of stopping the
equipment and then re-starting it was repeated 10 times and then
the CO concentration was measured to confirm the change in activity
of the catalyst; the lowest value of the CO concentration was
4%.
[0193] Like this, when the catalyst body in this comparative
example was used, the CO concentration after 10-time start-up and
stop actions is remarkably high as compared with the case by use of
the catalyst body in the previously described example. Hence, as
described previously, it has been attested that the hydrogen
refining apparatus of the present invention, even when the action
of stopping the equipment and then re-starting it was repeated, is
rarely affected by mixing of oxygen, for example and works stably
for a long while.
[0194] To sum up, the present invention relates to a hydrogen
refining apparatus that comprises a shifter having a shifting
catalyst body containing noble metals and metal oxides, and a
hydrogen gas supplying section that supplies hydrogen gas
containing carbon monoxide to the shifter, with (1) the temperature
of the shifting catalyst body upstream to the hydrogen gas flow
being set to be substantially between 300.degree. C. and
500.degree. C. and (2) the temperature of the shifting catalyst
body downstream from the hydrogen gas flow being set to be
substantially at 300.degree. C. or less (Surely, the present
invention also includes a hydrogen refining apparatus that
comprises a shifting (reaction) section with a plurality of stages
having a shifting catalyst body containing noble metals and metal
oxides, and a hydrogen gas supplying section that supplies hydrogen
gas containing carbon monoxide to the shifter with a plurality of
stages, the temperature of a stage of the shifter with a plurality
of stages being higher in a more upstream side relative to the
hydrogen gas flow).
[0195] In addition, (1) between the hydrogen gas supplying section
and the shifter, or (2) between stages of the shifting catalyst
body (the whole or part), may be installed cooling sections used
for cooling the hydrogen gas.
[0196] As is obvious from the descriptions thus far, a hydrogen
refining apparatus of the present invention is characterized in
that the apparatus includes, for example, a shifter having a
shifting catalyst body containing noble metals and metal oxides as
component materials, and a hydrogen gas supplying section that
supplies hydrogen gas containing at least carbon monoxide and steam
as minor components to the shifter, with the shifter being a shift
reaction section having a plurality of shifting catalyst bodies,
and with the temperature of a shifting catalyst body of the shift
reaction section, located downstream from the hydrogen gas flow,
being set lower than that of the shift reaction section positioned
in the upstream side.
[0197] Further, this apparatus includes a first shifter and a
second shifter, the temperature of the shifting catalyst body of
the first shifter is maintained in the range of 300.degree. C. to
500.degree. C., and the temperature of the shifting catalyst body
of the second shifter is set between 150.degree. C. and 300.degree.
C.; the amount of noble metals per volume of the catalyst body of
the first shifter is set to be smaller than that of the catalyst
body of the second shifter; and in the above described means, a
cooling section for cooling the hydrogen gas may be provided
between the first shifter and the second shifter.
[0198] Still further, the above described apparatus includes a
hydrogen gas temperature adjusting section is installed between the
hydrogen gas supplying section and the shifter to control the
upstream temperature of the shifting catalyst body of the shifter
in the range of 300.degree. C. and 500.degree. C., the noble metal
of the shifting catalyst body contains at least one species of Pt,
Pd, Ru and Rh, and the metal of the metal oxide of the shifting
catalyst body contains at least one species of Ce and Zr.
[0199] With the above described measures, the present invention
provides a stably hydrogen-supplying, hydrogen refining apparatus
of a simple arrangement that can stably reduce the carbon monoxide
in the shifter so as to be able to effectively reduce the carbon
monoxide in the clean up section.
[0200] Therefore, the present invention could easily provide an
apparatus which realizes a stable supply of hydrogen, which, for
example, allows the shifter to perform the stable carbon monoxide
reduction characteristic in the shifting catalyst having Pt and
metal oxides as component materials in the shifter of the hydrogen
refining apparatus that supplies hydrogen by steam reforming
hydrocarbon components.
[0201] In addition, the present invention, for example, relates to
a hydrogen refining apparatus having a reformed gas supplying
section that supplies a reformed gas containing at least hydrogen
gas, carbon monoxide and steam, and having a reaction chamber that
contains a carbon monoxide shifting catalyst body and is located
downstream from the above described reformed gas supplying section,
with the above described carbon monoxide shifting catalyst body
being made by incorporating at least Pt into a composite oxide made
by compounding Ce with at least Zr and/or Al.
[0202] In this case, the composite oxide is preferably composed of
5 to 90 atomic % Ce and Zr and/or Al (the rest). Further, the
composite oxides are in the form of a solid solution. In addition,
preferably, the carbon monoxide shifting catalyst body is divided
into a plurality of stages, and heat releasing sections or cooling
sections are installed between catalyst bodies. Furthermore, in the
composite oxide, the Ce content is preferably lower in the side
downstream relative to the direction of the reformed gas flow than
in the upstream side.
[0203] Further, although Pt was incorporated into the composite
oxide in the above described embodiment of the present invention,
this is not limited; that is, at least one of Pt, Pd, Rh and Ru may
be selected. However, a noble metal catalyst having Pd, Rh, Ru,
etc. as an active component may make the methanation proceed as
described previously, and so Pt is most preferably utilized. Thus,
even when Pd, Rh, Ru, etc. are used, at least Pt is incorporated
into the above described composite oxides; Pt is desirably added to
these oxides as a requisite.
[0204] In this manner, hydrogen refining equipment of the present
invention improves the durability of the CO shifting catalyst body
and can work stably when the start-up and stop action of the
equipment was repeated.
[0205] In addition, the entire disclosure of the above descriptions
are incorporated herein by reference in its entirety.
Industrial Applicability
[0206] As is clear from the descriptions thus far, the present
invention has the advantage that a hydrogen refining apparatus
having a good CO cleanup efficiency can be provided, for instance,
even when the start-up and stop operations are frequently
repeated.
* * * * *