U.S. patent number 3,883,877 [Application Number 05/444,147] was granted by the patent office on 1975-05-13 for optimized monopulse antenna feed.
This patent grant is currently assigned to Thomson-CSF. Invention is credited to Yves Campan, Maurice Chabah, Yves Commault.
United States Patent |
3,883,877 |
Chabah , et al. |
May 13, 1975 |
Optimized monopulse antenna feed
Abstract
The invention relates to a monopulse feed, contained in an
antenna, which supplies at three outputs sum and difference signals
which are a function of the angular difference between the line
along which an object in space lies and the axis of the antenna.
The feed is optimized, in one plane, by adding to the central horn,
two lateral horns which transmit only the difference signals, the
central horn being used solely for the sum signal, and in the other
plane, the feed is optimized by using high order modes.
Inventors: |
Chabah; Maurice (Paris,
FR), Commault; Yves (Paris, FR), Campan;
Yves (Paris, FR) |
Assignee: |
Thomson-CSF (Paris,
FR)
|
Family
ID: |
9115337 |
Appl.
No.: |
05/444,147 |
Filed: |
February 20, 1974 |
Foreign Application Priority Data
|
|
|
|
|
Feb 23, 1973 [FR] |
|
|
73.06564 |
|
Current U.S.
Class: |
343/778;
343/786 |
Current CPC
Class: |
H01Q
13/02 (20130101); H01Q 25/02 (20130101); H01Q
25/04 (20130101) |
Current International
Class: |
H01Q
25/04 (20060101); H01Q 25/00 (20060101); H01q
013/00 () |
Field of
Search: |
;343/776,777,778,789,786,853 |
References Cited
[Referenced By]
U.S. Patent Documents
Primary Examiner: Lieberman; Eli
Attorney, Agent or Firm: Greigg; Edwin E.
Claims
What is claimed is:
1. In an antenna system, an optimized monopulse feed for supplying
at three outputs a sum signal .SIGMA. and two difference signals
.DELTA.E and .DELTA.H respectively which are a function of the
angular deviation of an object in space with respect to the axis of
the antenna, comprising:
a rectangular main waveguide for propagating simultaneously at
least the fundamental mode and one odd mode, said main guide
terminating at one end in a radiating aperture;
a first coupling microwave circuit coupled to the other end of said
main guide for extracting said fundamental mode corresponding to
the sum signal, at a first output, and said odd mode corresponding
to a first difference signal, at a second output;
two lateral rectangular wave guides placed at each side of the main
guide respectively, for propagating the fundamental mode, each
lateral guide being terminated at one end in a radiating aperture,
and,
a second coupling microwave circuit having two inputs connected at
the other end of the two lateral guides for extracting the waves
which are in phase opposition in the lateral guides, corresponding
to the second difference signal, at an output thereof, and for
reflecting the waves which are in phase in said lateral guides.
2. A monopulse feed according to claim 1, wherein each lateral
guide has, at its aperture, a large side adjoining one large side
of the main guide.
3. A monopulse feed according to claim 1, wherein said second
coupling microwave circuit is a magic-T having two inputs, a first
output for extracting the waves which are in phase-opposition in
its two inputs, and a second output for extracting the waves which
are in phase in its two inputs, said second output being closed by
a short-circuit for reflecting said in-phase waves, wherein said
short-circuit is arranged at a distance from the respective
apertures of the lateral guides such that the reflected waves are
in phase at each aperture with the incident waves.
4. A monopulse feed according to claim 1, wherein said second
coupling microwave circuit is a magic-T having two inputs, a first
output for extracting the waves which are in phase-opposition in
its two inputs, and a second output for extracting the waves which
are in phase in its two inputs, said second output being closed by
a short-circuit for reflecting said in phase waves and wherein said
short-circuit is arranged at a distance from the respective
apertures of the lateral guides such that the reflected waves are
in phase-opposition with the incident waves.
5. A monopulse feed according to claim 1, wherein the second
coupling microwave circuit comprises a section of rectangular
waveguide, having one large side which is applied to a small side
of the two lateral guides respectively, means for coupling the
lateral guides and said section of waveguide, said means being
constituted by two slots which are provided in the common walls of
said guides and are oriented in a parallel direction with the axes
of symmetry of the lateral guides, in a symmetrical fashion with
respect to the plane of symmetry of said microwave circuit, and
three short-circuit means respectively located at the end of the
two lateral guides and one end of said section of waveguide, the
other end of said waveguide constituting the output of said second
microwave circuit.
6. A monopulse feed according to claim 5, wherein said slots and
said short-circuit means are arranged at respective distances from
the apertures of the lateral guides such that the reflected waves
in phase with the incident waves at each aperture.
7. A monopulse feed according to claim 5, wherein said slots and
said short-circuit means are arranged at respective distances from
the apertures of the lateral guides such that the reflected waves
are in phase opposition with the incident waves at each
aperture.
8. A monopulse feed according to claim 1, wherein the main guide 6
is widened to allow even TE modes of a higher order to exist at its
aperture in addition to the fundamental mode of propagation, for
optimizing said feed in H plane.
9. A monopulse feed according to claim 8, wherein individual
reflecting means for reflecting the said higher-order even modes
are positioned in the lateral guides and are arranged at a distance
from the apertures such that the reflected waves are then phased
with the incident waves at each apertures.
10. A monopulse feed according to claim 8, wherein individual
reflecting devices for reflecting the said even higher-order modes
are positioned in the lateral guides and are arranged at a distance
from the apertures such that the reflected waves are in phase
opposition with the incident waves at each aperture.
11. A monopulse feed according to claim 1, wherein the plane of the
aperture of the main guide is set back from the plane of the
apertures of the lateral guides.
12. A monopulse feed according to claim 1, wherein the plane of the
aperture of the main guide projects in front of the plane of the
apertures of the lateral guides.
Description
The present invention relates to an optimised monopulse antenna
feed of the amplitude-comparison type.
Monopulse systems are either active systems, that is to say radars
which emit and receive emitted energy after it has been reflected
from an object in space, or passive systems which receive the
energy radiated directly by the object. Whether it is active or
passive systems with which one is concerned, an indication of the
direction of the object as represented by two parameters, generally
elevation and azimuth, is obtained from a single received echo
pulse. A monopulse feed associated with a focussing device forms
the antenna of the system. Each echo received from the space is
focused to a "spot" or "image" having finite dimensions. This spot
generally is circular and has a cross section shape of the forme
sinX/X. The spot is centered in the focal plane when the target is
on the antenna axis and moves off center when the target moves off
axis. The antenna feed is located at the focal point to receive
maximum energy from an object on axis. An amplitude-comparison
monopulse feed is designed to sense any lateral displacement of the
spot from the center of the focal plane. The radar senses the
object displacement by comparing the amplitude of the echo signal
excited in each part of feed. The feed is so designed that each
received echo produces, at two separate outputs, two signals termed
"difference signals and referred as .DELTA. E and .DELTA. H. The
angular differences in elevation and azimuth, between the line
along which the object lies and the axis of the antenna, are
obtained by comparing each of the "difference" signals with a
reference signal termed the "sum" signal .SIGMA.. This signal is
generally obtained from another output.
A monopulse feed thus contains a sum output channel, an elevation
difference output channel and an azimuth difference output channel.
In the case of a radar system the feed also contains an input
channel which in general is identical with the sum output channel,
these various channels being connected to the radar by more or less
complex circuitry.
Externally of the monopulse feed, the three outputs are connected
to circuits for comparing the sum and difference signals. In the
case of a radar system the input channel is connected to the
transmitter; if the input channel is identical with the sum output
channel, a duplexer is inserted between this output on the one hand
and the transmitter and the comparison circuits on the other
hand.
There is a wide variety of possible configurations for monopulse
feeds. FIGS. 17, 18, 19, 20, 21 in chapter 21-4 of the Radar
Handbook by Merril Skolnick published by MacGraw-Hill show
monopulse feeds containing four or more radiating apertures, FIGS.
23, 25 and 26 show other feeds having a single aperture which use
high-order propagation modes for their waves in order to extract
the difference signals.
In all cases, optimum sum and difference signals, low side lobe
levels, minimum spill-over, omnipolarization capability and
simplicity cannot all be fully satisfied simultaneously. The more
important problem is to optimize simultaneously the sum and
difference signals. For this purpose the spill-over must be
reduced, since it causes high sidelobes which increase radar
susceptibility to interference from offaxis sources of radiation in
addition to loss of efficiency. For obtaining an optimized feed,
with optimum coupling of the feed to the antenna for each of the
three signals, the electrical field intensity in the aperture of
the feed should smoothly taper to the edges.
The usual aim is for the optimisation to exist in the two planes of
symmetry of the monopulse feed. In the following description, these
planes will be termed "E-plane" and "H-plane." The E plane is the
plane of symmetry which contains the electrical field vector E at
the centre of the sum source. The H plane is the plane of symmetry
at right angles to the E plane.
Monopulse feeds are basically formed from one or more sections of
wave guide, usually rectangular wave guide. The guides are open at
one end, and may or may not be flared into the shape of a horn, in
order to form radiating apertures. At the other end more or less
complex junction circuitry connects the guides to the sum and
difference outputs.
Four or five horn feeds are optimized by adding extra horns to
enlarge the apertures of the difference feeds. The consequence is
that the feed may comprise up to 12 horns but the microwave
circuitry is very complicated and hardly compatible with the size
and weight requirements in the case of airborne equipment.
A subsequent development in monopulse feed techniques provides the
monopulse sum and difference signals with a single feed aperture.
It makes use of hybrid modes of propagation in addition to the
conventional TE.sub.10 mode to separate the sum and difference
signals. Such a feed may be optimized by using high-order waveguide
modes. These modes are, however, difficult to use and require
complicated microwave circuitry.
The monopulse feed according to the invention does not have these
drawbacks. It enables the use of high-order propagation modes to be
avoided and employs very simple microwave circuitry.
In accordance with a feature of the invention, an optimized
monopulse feed for supplying at three outputs a sum signal .SIGMA.
and two difference signals .DELTA.E and .DELTA.H which are a
function of the angular deviation of an object in space with
respect to the axis of the antenna, the said feed comprising on the
one hand, a rectangular main wave-guide for propagating
simultaneously at least the fundamental mode for the sum signal and
at least one odd mode for a difference signal, the main guide
terminating at one end in a radiating aperture and at the other and
in a first coupling microwave circuit for separating said
fundamental mode and said odd mode and delivering respectively the
sum signal at a first output and the difference signal at a second
output, and, on the other hand, two lateral rectangular wave guides
each of which terminates at one end in a radiating aperture and
has, at the aperture, a large side adjoining one large side of the
main guide, the two lateral guides being connected at the other end
to a second coupling microwave circuit for extracting and
delivering the waves which are in phase opposition in the lateral
guides and correspond to the other difference signal, and for
reflecting the waves which are in phase in said lateral guides.
The coupling circuitry, which are completely separate, are thus
very much simplified. It is therefore easy to optimize the feed
independently in the E plane and the H plane.
Other features will appear in the following description which is
illustrated by the Figures, which show:
FIG. 1, a perspective view of a monopulse feed according to the
invention from which the output signal for the difference signal
.DELTA.H has been omitted;
FIGS. 2 and 3, views from above of the feed which shows the
direction of the electrical field in various sections of it;
FIGS. 4 and 5, schematic diagrams showing the distribution of the
electrical field in the aperture for the sum and difference
signals;
FIg. 6, a particular type of coupling circuitry between the lateral
horns and the output for the difference signal .DELTA.E;
FIG. 7, an embodiment of a complete feed;
FIGS. 8, 9 and 10, views showing the direction of the electrical
field in the three parts of the radiating aperture for the three
types of received signals.
FIG. 1 shows an example of a monopulse feed according to the
invention. It comprises a main rectangular wave guide 1 which
flares to form a horn and is contained between two lateral
rectangular guides 2 and 3 which are also flared. In the following
description reference will simply be made to the main horn 1 and
lateral horns 2 and 3. At the end at which their major opening is
situated the horns open into free space. These openings form the
radiating apertures of the monopulse feed. At the end at which
their minor openings are situated the horns are connected to a sum
output 4 and a difference output 5, by suitable microwave
circuits.
To simplify the description, the feed shown contains only the
output for the difference signal .DELTA.E and for which the
optimization is effected solely in the E plane. The second
difference output and the associated microwave coupling circuits
are not shown in FIG. 1. These circuits are independent of those
shown and they are described in the explanation below.
The invention is, of course, not restricted to monopulse feed
capable of determining an angular separation in only one plane.
The main horn 1 is directly connected to the sum output 4 by a
rectangular wave guide 6. A suitable coupling microwave circuit is
coupled to the output 4 for separating the sum signal and the
.DELTA.H difference signal which are carried respectively by the
fundamental mode and an odd mode. This microwave circuit is only
shown in FIG. 7 and will be described below. The lateral horns 2
and 3 are connected to the difference output 5 by means of a
coupling microwave circuit 7 such as a magic-T for example. Two
channels of the magic-T are coupled to the two horns 2 and 3 and
the other two channels are shown by sections of wave guide 5 and 8.
Guide 8 is closed by a short-circuit 9. Guide 5 forms the
difference output of the monopulse feed.
The operation of the feed will be better understood from FIGS. 2
and 3, which are views of the feed from above, and from FIGS. 4 and
5 which are schematic diagrams showing the distribution of the
electrical field in the aperture for the sum .SIGMA. signals and
difference .DELTA.E signals respectively.
Upon transmission, the energy to be transmitted is applied to the
sum input 4. Electrical field E, shown in the Figures by arrows, is
similarly oriented at any cross-sectional plane of the wave guides
6 and is propagated with the fundamental mode known internationally
as TE.sub.10 in technical literature.
Arriving at the mouth of horn 1, the energy is radiated into space
(after reflection on a reflector which is not shown). Because the
large side of the lateral horns are joined onto the large side of
main horn in the region of the respective aperture, part of the
energy radiated by the main horn is propagated into the lateral
horns as a result of coupling. The waves introduced into horn 2 and
those introduced into horn 3 are in phase. They combine in the
magic-T in a known way and are propagated solely in the section of
guide 8. Since these waves are in phase and are of equal amplitude,
no energy is propagated in guide 5 due to the characteristics of
such a junction. Guide 8 is closed off by a short-circuit 9 which
causes the waves to be reflected. The energy is then transmitted
back to the mouth of horns 2 and 3. The electrical length between
the respective apertures and the short circuit 9 should be such
that the waves are re-emitted in phase with those of the main
horn.
The overall illumination of the opening of the feed, i.e. the
amplitude distribution of the electrical field E in this aperture
is shown in FIG. 4. This distribution is a discontinuous equi-phase
function made up of a central step and two lower level lateral
steps. The electric field intensity is taperred to the edges of the
aperture resulting in a good optimization of the feed in the E
plane.
Distribution of the electrical field is thus related to the size of
the aperture. The shape of the radiation pattern of the feed is a
result of this distribution. Starting from the fact that the
pattern must correctly enclose the focusing device for the
optimization, the dimensions of the apertures and in particular
those of the main horn are calculated therefrom. It is also
possible for the waves re-emitted by the lateral horns to be in
phase opposition with respect to those from the main horn. In this
way the monopulse feed is better matched to the "spot" focused by
the associated antenna. This can be achieved, for example, by
altering the length of the section of wave guide 8.
Upon reception, if object in space is not situated on the axis of
the antenna, the focussing device forms spot in the plane of the
apertures which is not centred on the axis. This spot, which
contains almost all the received energy, may be broken down into
two components, one in which the electrical field distribution is
of even symmetry, whilst in the other it is of odd symmetry.
The distribution of energy in the field of even symmetry will
excite the three horns in phase. The energy collected by the main
horn passes to output 4. That collected by the lateral horns 2 and
3 is reflected by short circuit 9 and passes to output 4, partly as
a result of coupling to the main horn. The type of operation is the
reverse of that on transmission.
The component whose symmetry is odd excites horns 2 and 3 in phase
opposition. It is combined in the magic-T 7 and transmitted to
output 5. The direction of the electrical vector in this case in
the laternal horns and in the magic-T as far as output 5, is shown
in FIG. 3.
The main guide is excited by a hybrid mode TE.sub.11 + TM.sub.11.
This mode of propagation should not be allowed to exist. The
dimension of the horn are calculated to cut-off this mode. This
being so, the mode is reflected and causes only transversely
polarised waves to appear which can be suppressed by adding a
polarisation filter positioned in the aperture of the main horn.
The filter may be formed by a grid of wires parallel to H plane
i.e. parallel to the direction of polarisation to be
suppressed.
The field distribution as shown in FIg. 4 is that which gives rise
solely to the sum signal .SIGMA.. Curve A in FIG. 5 is that which
gives rise solely to the difference signal .DELTA.E. In particular,
in the case of the difference signal, the field is a nul at the
main horn and is a maximum at the lateral horns.
A radiation diagram equivalent to this field distribution is one
which should encompass the focussing device in order to optimise
the feed in E plane. As a first approximation, the directional
characteristic given by field distribution A is the same as the
first term of a Fourrier series development which is a sine-wave
arc, as shown by curve B of FIG. 5. This directional characteristic
is related to the overall dimensions of the feed, whereas the
directional characteristic of the sum signal may be adjusted by
altering the dimension of the main horn. The directional
characteristics may thus be adjusted independently.
Another parameter of adjustment consists in lengthening or
shortening the dividing walls between the main horn and the lateral
horns. In the second case, a cavity is formed at the front of the
main horn in which it is possible for upper-level hybrid modes to
exist. This process provides a further parameter which enables the
directional characteristic of the feed to be altered with a view to
achieving the desired optimization. This process is used, for
example, to make it easier to match the radiating aperture, i.e. to
reduce the effects of the discontinuity in the propagation of the
waves where they pass from the feed into free space and vice
versa.
FIG. 6 shows another type of junction circuit between the lateral
horns and the difference output.
The lateral horns 2 and 3, which are shown in broken lines, extend
into lateral rectangular sections of waveguide 20 and 30. The
difference output, which bears the same reference numeral 5, is
situated at an opening of a third rectangular section of waveguide
10 which is applied to the small side of the lateral guides 20 and
30 along one large side. The lateral guides are closed off by short
circuits 21 and 31. Guide 10 is also closed off by a short circuit
11. All the axes of symmetry of the guides are parallel to one
another.
The lateral guides and guide 10 are coupled to one another via two
slots 12 and 13 parallel to the axis of symmetry of the guides
which are pieced in the common walls of the guides in a symmetrical
fashion on either side of the axis of guide 10.
Guide 10 only operates in the fundamental mode TE.sub.10, which is
equivalent to slots 12 and 13 being excited in phase opposition.
For this, the waves propagated in lateral guides 20 and 30 must be
in phase opposition. This condition is satisfied when the line
along which a detected object lies does not coincide with the axis
of the antenna. A difference signal then appears at output 5.
The positions of short circuits 21 and 31 and 11 are calculated to
produce the best coupling between the lateral guides and guide
10.
When in-phase waves are propagated in the lateral guides, the
coupling slots excite mode TE.sub.20 in guide 10. Since this mode
is cut off, energy cannot be propagated in the guide and is
therefore reflected to the lateral guides, the length of which is
adjusted so that this energy is once again in phase with the
incident waves at the aperture. It is also possible to adjust the
length so that the reflected waves are in phase opposition at the
aperture.
For reasons of clarity, the feed which has just been described
contains only one difference channel. It is only capable of
detecting an angular divergence in a single plane, i.e. E plane. It
is however quite possible to use this feed to establish angular
divergences both in E plane and also in H plane at right angles to
it.
In this case, the TE.sub.10 mode is used, in a known way, in the
main horn for the sum signal and the TE.sub.20 mode for the
difference signal in plane H. An appropriate microwave circuit is
utilized for separating the TE.sub.10 and TE.sub.20 modes. This
circuit is shown on FIG. 7.
FIG. 7 shows an embodiment of a complete monopulse feed according
to the invention.
The horns 1, 2 and 3 and the central guide 6 are the same as in
FIG. 1. In contrast, the "magic-T" 7 used in FIG. 1 has been
replaced by the type of connection in FIG. 6 although all that
actually appears are the lateral guides 20 and 30 and the output
guide 10 from which the difference output for E plane (i.e. 5)
emerges.
The difference output for plane H is designated 18. It emerges from
a section of waveguide 17 the narrow sides of which are
perpendicular to the axis of guide 6. The plane of symmetry of
guide 17 is coincident with the horizontal plane of symmetry of
guide 6.
Guide 6 extends into a guide 16 after a constriction 15. At the end
of guide 16 is situated the sum output 4. It is assumed that all
the outputs 4, 5 and 18 are connected to external circuitry via
guides in which it is only possible for the TE.sub.10 mode to
exist.
The way in which the difference channel for E plane operates has
already been described. The displacement of the spot in the E plane
provide a .DELTA.E signal which appear at output 5, in addition
with a sum signal .SIGMA. at output 4. In H plane the displacement
of the "spot" excites the TE.sub.20 mode which is the unsymmetrical
waveguide mode used as the difference signal in the H plane.
TE.sub.20 and TE.sub.10 modes coexistent in the waveguide 6. Thus
the TE.sub.20 mode coupled from the feed has an amplitude
increasing with object displacement from the antenna axis and a
phase that differs by 180.degree., depending on the direction of
displacement, providing the direction sense used by the monopulse
receiver. TE.sub.10 mode is extracted by the microwave circuit 6-17
and appears at output 4. TE.sub.20 mode is extracted and
transmitted to guide 17 to output 18. The feed is optimized in H
plane in a very simple way by widening guide 6 at a suitable
distance from its mouth.
After passing through this widened portion a TE.sub.10 mode will
give rise to a combination of modes TE.sub.10 and TE.sub.30.
Optimation is thus achieved in H plane by using at least an
upper-level mode which alters the aperture field distribution
independently of E plane.
All these modes are excited in the lateral horns with the same
coefficient of coupling as the fundamental mode and are then
reflected by appropriate reflecting means, such as short circuits
judiciously positioned in the lateral guides 20 and 30 and are
again in phase at the aperture. The short circuits are individual
to each mode since propagation is different between one mode and
another. These reflecting means could also be positioned for
reflecting the higher-order mode waves in phase opposition at the
apertures.
The short circuits may be done away with if the TE modes utilised
are cut off in the lateral horns. Reflection then takes place
without phase-inversion at the aperture.
The dimensions of the central horn are calculated as a function of
the directional characteristic of the difference pattern in H
plane. The dimensions of the lateral horns may either be the same
or smaller, which prevents high-level modes from being excited.
When calculating the dimensions of the horn it is also necessary to
take into account the nature of the dielectric media which fill the
horns and the guides and also any ridges which might be placed
there in order to facilitate the propagation of upper-level modes
without increasing the dimensions of the guides to an excessive
degree.
FIGS. 8, 9 and 10 are front views of the three horns 1, 2 and 3 in
which are shown the directions of the electrical field vector E for
the three different types of operation, these being "sum,"
"difference in E plane," "difference in H plane," respectively.
In "sum" operation, the fields in the three horns are in phase.
In "difference in E plane" operation, there is no field in the
central horn 1 and the fields are in phaseopposition in the lateral
horns.
In "difference in H plane" operation, the fields are in phase
opposition between one end of a horn and the other in the case of
each horn.
* * * * *