U.S. patent application number 11/985865 was filed with the patent office on 2008-06-12 for communications throughput with unicast packet transmission alternative.
Invention is credited to John Chanak, Charles Andrew Gram, William S. Kish.
Application Number | 20080137681 11/985865 |
Document ID | / |
Family ID | 36316222 |
Filed Date | 2008-06-12 |
United States Patent
Application |
20080137681 |
Kind Code |
A1 |
Kish; William S. ; et
al. |
June 12, 2008 |
Communications throughput with unicast packet transmission
alternative
Abstract
An access point of a communications network is configured to
receive a multicast or broadcast packet from a source. The access
point converts the multicast or broadcast packet into a unicast
packet addressed to a station associated with the access point. The
access point then transmits the unicast packet over the
communications network from the access point to the station. The
access point further may determine a minimum data rate by which the
access point may transmit the multicast or broadcast packet to the
station and determines an effective unicast rate for transmitting
the unicast packet to the station. If the effective unicast rate
does not exceed the minimum data rate, the access point does not
transmit the unicast packet to the station and transmits the
multicast or broadcast packet.
Inventors: |
Kish; William S.; (Saratoga,
CA) ; Chanak; John; (Saratoga, CA) ; Gram;
Charles Andrew; (Santa Clara, CA) |
Correspondence
Address: |
CARR & FERRELL LLP
2200 GENG ROAD
PALO ALTO
CA
94303
US
|
Family ID: |
36316222 |
Appl. No.: |
11/985865 |
Filed: |
November 16, 2007 |
Related U.S. Patent Documents
|
|
|
|
|
|
Application
Number |
Filing Date |
Patent Number |
|
|
11232196 |
Sep 20, 2005 |
|
|
|
11985865 |
|
|
|
|
60625331 |
Nov 5, 2004 |
|
|
|
Current U.S.
Class: |
370/432 |
Current CPC
Class: |
H04N 21/6405 20130101;
H04N 21/6408 20130101; H04W 4/06 20130101; H04W 28/06 20130101;
H04W 28/22 20130101; H04W 88/08 20130101; H04W 72/005 20130101 |
Class at
Publication: |
370/432 |
International
Class: |
H04J 3/26 20060101
H04J003/26 |
Claims
1. A method for improving throughput in a communications network,
the method comprising: receiving into an access point of the
communications network a multicast or broadcast packet from a
source; converting the multicast or broadcast packet into a unicast
packet at the access point, the conversion taking place at the
media access control layer, the multicast or broadcast packet
addressed to a station associated with the access point;
determining a minimum physical data rate by which the access point
may transmit the multicast or broadcast packet to the station;
determining an effective unicast rate for transmitting the unicast
packet to the station; and not transmitting the unicast packet to
the station and instead transmitting the multicast or broadcast
packet to the station if the effective unicast rate does not exceed
the minimum physical data rate.
2. A method for improving throughput in a communications network,
the method comprising: receiving into an access point of the
communications network a multicast or broadcast packet from a
source; converting the multicast or broadcast packet into a unicast
packet at the access point, the conversion taking place at the
media access control layer, the multicast or broadcast packet
addressed to a station associated with the access point; and
determining that the station acts as the source and not
transmitting the unicast packet to the station.
3. An access point for improving throughput in a communications
network, the access point configured to: receive a multicast or
broadcast packet from a source; convert the multicast or broadcast
packet into a unicast packet addressed to a station associated with
the access point, the conversion taking place at the media access
control layer; determine a minimum physical data rate by which the
access point may transmit the multicast or broadcast packet to the
station; determine an effective unicast rate for transmitting the
unicast packet to the station; and not transmit the unicast packet
to the station and transmit the multicast or broadcast packet to
the station if the effective unicast rate does not exceed the
minimum data rate.
4. An access point for improving throughput in a communications
network, the access point configured to: receive a multicast or
broadcast packet from a source; convert the multicast or broadcast
packet into a unicast packet addressed to a station associated with
the access point, the conversion taking place at the media access
control layer; and determine that the station acts as the source
and not transmit the unicast packet to the station.
5. A system for improving throughput in a communications network,
the system comprising: a first node and a second node, the first
node configured to: transmit to the second node of the
communication network; determine a first physical data rate for
transmitting to the second node a multicast or broadcast packet;
determine a second physical data rate for transmitting to the
second node one or more unicast packets resulting from conversion
of the multicast or broadcast packet into the one or more unicast
packets; and transmit the one or more unicast packets to the second
node if the second physical data rate exceeds the first physical
data rate and otherwise transmit the multicast or broadcast packet
to the second node.
6. The system of claim 5, wherein the communications network is a
wireless local area network.
7. The system of claim 5, wherein the multicast or broadcast packet
comprises a user datagram protocol networking message.
8. The system of claim 5, wherein the multicast or broadcast packet
comprises a multicast control protocol packet.
9. The system of claim 5, wherein the first node comprises a
multicast-enabled access point.
10. The system of claim 5, wherein the first node is further
configured to: determine an antenna configuration on which to
transmit to the second node; determine a physical data rate at
which to transmit to the second node; and transmit the one or more
unicast packets and the multicast or broadcast packet on the
antenna configuration and at the physical data rate to the second
node.
11. The system of claim 5, wherein the first node is further
configured to: determine a third physical data rate by which the
first node may transit the multicast or broadcast packet to a third
node of the communications network; and transmit over the
communications network the multicast or broadcast packet to the
second node and the third node at the lower of the first physical
data rate and the third physical data rate.
Description
CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATION
[0001] This application is a divisional and claims the priority of
U.S. patent application Ser. No. 11/232,196, entitled "Systems and
Methods for Improved Data Throughput in Communications Networks,"
filed on Sep. 20, 2005, which claims the benefit of U.S.
Provisional Patent Application No. 60/625,331 entitled "Systems and
Methods for Improved Data Throughput in Wireless Local Area
Networks," filed on Nov. 5, 2004, the subject matter of which are
hereby incorporated by reference.
[0002] This application is related to co-pending U.S. patent
application Ser. No. 11/010,076 entitled "System and Method for an
Omnidirectional Planar Antenna Apparatus with Selectable Elements,"
filed on Dec. 9, 2004, U.S. patent application Ser. No. 11/022,080
"Circuit Board Having a Peripheral Antenna Apparatus with
Selectable Antenna Elements," filed on Dec. 23, 2004, and U.S.
patent application Ser. No. 11/041,145 entitled "System and Method
for a Minimized Antenna Apparatus with Selectable Elements," filed
on Jan. 21, 2005, the subject matter of which are hereby
incorporated by reference.
[0003] This application is also related to co-pending U.S. patent
application Ser. No. ______, "Improved Communications Throughput
With Multiple Physical Data Rate Transmission Determinations,"
filed on Nov. 16, 2007, which is itself a divisional of U.S. patent
application Ser No. 11/232,196, "Systems and Methods for Improved
Data Throughput in Communications Networks," filed on Sep. 20,
2005.
[0004] The disclosures of the aforementioned applications are
incorporated herein by reference.
BACKGROUND
[0005] 1. Field of the Invention
[0006] The present invention relates generally to communications
networks and more particularly to systems and methods for increased
data throughput in communications networks.
[0007] 2. Description of the Prior Art
[0008] Demand for multimedia applications, including audio and
video data, is rapidly increasing. Some of the more popular uses of
multimedia are real-time interactive applications, such as video
and audio streaming, Internet Protocol TV (IPTV), transmission of
lectures or speeches to a remote audience, and animated
simulations. Even when data compression is used, multimedia
applications require large amounts of bandwidth.
[0009] In an IEEE 802.11 wireless local area network (LAN),
broadcast, or multicast packet transmission enables
bandwidth-intensive multimedia applications to simultaneously
transmit audio and video data packets to each receiving node
associated with a group of the wireless LAN. Broadcast packets are
transmitted to all receiving nodes of the wireless LAN, whereas
multicast packets are transmitted to two or more, but fewer than
all, of the receiving nodes of the wireless LAN.
[0010] In the wireless LAN, a source node may transmit (e.g., via
Ethernet) multicast packets to a multicast-enabled access point,
and the access point sends the multicast packets via wireless
transmission to destination receiving nodes that have identified
themselves as part of the multicast group.
[0011] The access point of the wireless LAN may also support
unicast packet transmission. For unicast transmission in the
wireless LAN, the access point transmits one or more unicast
packets to the receiving node identified by an intended destination
address included in the unicast packets. After receiving the
unicast packet, the receiving node transmits (approximately 9 .mu.s
later) an 802.11 acknowledgement (ACK) packet back to the access
point. The 802.11 ACK mechanism provides reliable data transmission
in the typically highly interfered 802.11 wireless network by
confirming to the access point that the unicast packet was
received.
[0012] A limitation with transmitting multicast packets in the
wireless LAN is that the 802.11 ACK does not provide a reliable
mechanism for ensuring that the receiving nodes actually received
the multicast packets. For example, if the 802.11 access point were
to transmit one or more multicast packets to a number of receiving
nodes, and each of the receiving nodes were to respond essentially
simultaneously with 802.11 ACK packets, the multiple ACK packets
received by the access point would comprise "noise" during the
period of the multiple simultaneous 802.11 ACKs. To the access
point, these multiple simultaneous 802.11 ACKs are undecipherable.
This condition may be referred to as a "multiple ACK problem."
[0013] Another limitation with transmitting multicast packets is
that the wireless LAN may be limited in the bandwidth used for
multicast packets. Because of the multiple ACK problem, the IEEE
802.11 specification for multicast dictates that transmission of
multicast packets occur at a minimum allowable physical data rate.
Because the receiving nodes may be at various distances from the
source of the transmission, and may experience various interference
levels, transmitting at the minimum allowable physical data rate
improves the probability of reception of the multicast packets by
each receiving node. For example, an 802.11 access point transmits
multicast packets at a minimum allowable physical data rate of 1
Mbps for 802.11b and 6 Mbps for 802.11a. The receiving nodes do not
transmit 802.11 ACK packets to verify reception of the multicast
packets. Thus, without the 802.11 ACK mechanism, there is no
verification of reception of the multicast packets.
[0014] further, transmitting at the minimum allowable physical data
rate under-utilizes available bandwidth in the wireless LAN, which
otherwise is capable of supporting much higher data rates. In
addition, transmitting at the minimum allowable physical data rate
may make the wireless LAN unsuitable for applications that require
high rate communication, such as multimedia applications.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
[0015] The invention addresses the above problems by providing
systems and methods for improved data throughput in communications
networks. An access point of a communications network of one
embodiment receives a multicast or broadcast packet from a source.
The access point converts the multicast or broadcast packet into a
unicast packet addressed to a station associated with the access
point. The access point then transmits the unicast packet over the
communications network from the access point to the station. By
converting the multicast or broadcast packet into one or more
unicast packets, the access point achieves improved data throughput
in the communications network by sending the unicast packet at
higher data rate than would otherwise be possible by transmitting
the multicast or broadcast packet to the station. Additionally, the
unicast packet provides for reliable delivery of data in the
multicast or broadcast packet in communications networks where the
unicast packet is acknowledged.
[0016] In some embodiments, the communication network comprises an
802.11 wireless network. The access point may determine the station
from a list of one or more stations associated with the access
point. The access point may determine a minimum data rate by which
the access point may transmit the multicast or broadcast packet to
the station and determine an effective unicast rate for
transmitting the unicast packet to the station. The access point
then may not transmit the unicast packet to the station and may
transmit the multicast or broadcast packet to the station if the
effective unicast rate does not exceed the minimum data rate.
[0017] The access point may also determine an antenna configuration
on which to transmit to the station and determine a physical data
rate at which to transmit to the station. The access point then may
transmit the unicast packet on the antenna configuration and at the
physical data rate over a wireless network from the access point to
the station. In still further embodiments, the access point
determines that the station acts as the source and does not
transmit the unicast packet to the station. The access point may
query the station to determine an address for the station and may
map an address of the multicast or broadcast packet to the address
of the station. The access point may also associate the station to
an address of the multicast or broadcast packet based on a join
request transmitted from the station to the source.
[0018] A method is provided comprising receiving into an access
point a multicast or broadcast packet from a source and converting
the multicast or broadcast packet into a unicast packet addressed
to station associated with the access point. The method also
includes transmitting the unicast packet over the communications
network from the access point to the station. The multicast or
broadcast packet may comprise a User Datagram Protocol (UDP)
networking message. The multicast or broadcast packet may also
comprise a multicast control packet.
[0019] An alternative method comprises receiving into an access
point of a communications network a multicast or broadcast packet
from a source, determining a first rate by which the access point
may transmit the multicast or broadcast packet to a first station
associated with the access point, determining a second rate by
which the access point may transit the multicast or broadcast
packet to a second station associated with the access point, and
transmitting the multicast or broadcast packet to the first station
and the second station at the lower of the first rate and the
second rate. Advantageously, the access point may determine a
higher data rate than a minimum physical data rate specified for
the communications network at which the access point may transmit
the multicast or broadcast packet to the first station and the
second station.
[0020] A first node of a communication network, in one embodiment,
for transmitting to a second node of the communication network is
configured to determine a first rate for transmitting a multicast
or broadcast packet. The first node also determines a second rate
for transmitting to the second node one or more unicast packets
resulting from conversion of the multicast or broadcast packet into
the one or more unicast packets. The first node then transmits the
one or more unicast packets to the second node if the second data
rate exceeds the first data rate and otherwise transmits the
multicast or broadcast packet to the second node.
[0021] Advantageously, the first node converts the multicast or
broadcast packet, when appropriate, to one or more unicast packets
and transmits the one or more unicast packets sequentially to the
second node at a higher data rate than the minimum physical data
rate specified for multicast or broadcast transmission. The first
node may comprise a multicast-enabled access point. In some
embodiments, the first node determines a third rate by which the
first node may transmit the multicast or broadcast packet to a
third node of the communications network and transmits over the
communications network the multicast or broadcast packet to the
second node and the third node at the lower of the first rate and
the third rate.
[0022] Therefore, the systems and methods may provide reliable
transmission of the multicast or broadcast packet over the wireless
LAN by converting the multicast or broadcast packet to the one or
more unicast packets and servicing corresponding acknowledgement
packets from the station. A further advantage is that the systems
and methods may determine not to convert the multicast or broadcast
packet, and may transmit the multicast or broadcast packet over the
wireless LAN at a higher data rate than the minimum physical data
rate that the station may reliably receive.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF the Drawings
[0023] FIG. 1 illustrates a block diagram of a system for multicast
transmission in a wireless local area network, in accordance with
one embodiment of the present invention;
[0024] FIG. 2 illustrates an exemplary method for multicast or
unicast transmission in the wireless local area network of FIG. 1,
in accordance with one embodiment of the invention; and
[0025] FIG. 3 illustrates an exemplary timing diagram illustrating
conversion of multicast packets into unicast packets as described
with respect to FIGS. 1-2, in accordance with one embodiment of the
present invention.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0026] The systems and methods disclosed herein enable data
throughput in communication networks greater than that which is
provided in the prior art. For example, the system and method
disclosed herein support bandwidth-intensive multimedia
applications over wireless LANs. In the disclosure, nodes of a
communication network may be referred to as a host, a source, a
destination, a node, a receiving node, an access point, and a
station. The references should not be considered in a limiting
sense, as it is understood that the present invention is in no way
limited to only the embodiments illustrated. For example, a
"receiving node" is in no way limited to the function of receiving
only. Additionally, the term group packet includes a multicast
packet, a broadcast packet, and any packet whose destination
address indicates one or more addresses and/or nodes of the
communications network.
[0027] According to one embodiment, a wireless local area network
(LAN) comprises an access point configured to receive a multicast
or broadcast packet from a source. The multicast or broadcast
packet is addressed to a group comprising one or more nodes of a
communications network (e.g., stations associated with the access
point of the wireless LAN). The access point determines whether to
convert the multicast or broadcast packet into one or more unicast
packets for sequential transmission to the one or more nodes or
whether to transmit the multicast or broadcast packet to the group.
If the access point transmits the multicast or broadcast packet
without conversion, the access point may determine a lowest common
denominator data rate based on data rates for transmitting
multicast or broadcast packets to the one or more nodes and
transmits the multicast or broadcast packet to the group at the
lowest common denominator rate.
[0028] FIG. 1 illustrates a block diagram of a system 100 for
multicast packet transmission in a wireless local area network, in
accordance with one embodiment of the present invention. The system
100 comprises a source node 110, a network link 115, an access
point 120, receiving nodes 130, 140, and 150, wireless links 135,
145, and 155, and a group 160 comprising two or more of the
receiving nodes (e.g., the receiving nodes 130 and 140). The source
node, 110 is configured to communicate with the access point 120
over the network link 115. The access point 120 is configured to
communicate with the receiving nodes 130-150 over the wireless
links 135-155 that form the wireless LAN.
[0029] The source node 110 is any device capable of network
communication including unicast or multicast packet transmission
with the access point 120 over the network link 115. The source
node 110 may comprise, for example, a personal computer, a server,
a network attached storage device, or a network video distribution
device. The source node 110 may support networking protocols such
as Transmission Control Protocol/Internet Protocol (TCP/IP), User
Datagram Protocol (UDP/IP), and/or Internet Group Management
Protocol (IGMP), and may support unicast, multicast, and/or
broadcast packet transmission of network data.
[0030] The source node 110 is configured to transmit one or more
group packets addressed to the group 160 (e.g., one or more
multicast or broadcast packets) over the network link 115. The
network link 115 may be a wired or wireless network link. In one
embodiment, the network link 115 comprises a UDP/IP connection. In
one example, the source node 110 comprises an IPTV video server
(not shown) that transmits the multicast packets, providing a
remote video stream to the group 160 through the access point 120.
Although discussed in regard to multicast transmission, the group
packets may comprise a packet whose destination address specifies
all (i.e., broadcast), or less than all (i.e., multicast) of the
receiving nodes 130-150.
[0031] The receiving nodes 130-150 each comprise any device capable
of receiving network communication from the source node 110 through
the access point 120 over the wireless links 135-155. The receiving
nodes 130-150 may comprise devices such as personal computers,
PDAs, cell phones, and/or internet enabled televisions. In one
example, the receiving nodes 130-140 of the group 160 may comprise
TV set-top boxes configured to receive a video stream provided by
the IPTV server at the source node 110 to the group 160. Although
described as the source node 110 and the receiving nodes 130-150,
it should be noted that the source node 110 may also be the
destination node of a data packet as well as the receiving nodes
130-150 may also be the source node of a data packet.
[0032] As described further herein, the access point 120 is
configured to transmit the video stream to the receiving node 130
and the receiving node 140 either simultaneously as a multicast
packet, or sequentially as one or more unicast packets to each of
the receiving nodes 130 and 140. The access point 120 is virtually
any device capable of acting as a bridge in a peer-to-peer
connection in the wireless LAN or as a bridge between the network
link 115 and the wireless links 135-155. The access point 120 may
be configured to convert the multicast packet into one or more
unicast packets, as discussed further with respect to FIG. 2. The
access point 120 may include a processor, a memory, and additional
circuitry that provides or assists in providing the bridge and/or
the multicast packet conversion. The access point 120 may use the
IEEE 802.11 protocol, such as 802.11a or 802.11b, to communicate
with the receiving nodes 130-150. It will be appreciated that the
access point 120 may incorporate other wireless protocols, such as
802.11g, 802.16, or Bluetooth.
[0033] The access point 120 may support multicast control
protocols, such as IGMP, and may be configured as a
multicast-enabled router. A multicast control protocol enables the
access point 120 to determine from the receiving nodes (e.g., the
receiving nodes 130-150) which group(s) (e.g., the group 160) the
receiving nodes 130-150 are associated with. Some examples of
multicast control protocols are IGMP, Protocol-Independent
Multicast (PIM), Real-Time Streaming Protocol (RTSP), Multiprotocol
Border Gateway Protocol (MBGP), Multicast Source Discovery Protocol
(MSDP), Simple Service Discovery Protocol (SSDP), and Source
Specific Multicast (SSM). For example, the receiving node 130 may
send a multicast control protocol packet to the access point 120 to
change the channel for an IPTV multicast stream received from the
source node 110. The multicast control protocol packet informs the
access point 120 that the receiving node 130 is interested in
receiving group packets for the selected channel.
[0034] The access point 120 of some embodiments is further
configured to maintain information about "associated nodes."
Associated nodes are devices that have negotiated a wireless
communication link (e.g., the wireless link 135) with the access
point 120. For example, when the receiving node 130 initially
associates with the access point 120 to negotiate the wireless link
135, the receiving node 130 provides a Media Access Control (MAC)
or hardware address that uniquely identifies the receiving node
130. The receiving node 130 may also provide a list of allowable
physical data rates (e.g., 1 Mbps-54 Mbps) at which it may
communicate with the access point 120. The access point 120 may
store such information about the associated nodes in memory, for
example.
[0035] As described further herein, the system 100 improves
multicast data throughput in the wireless LAN because the access
point 120 of one embodiment is configured to convert the multicast
packet addressed to the group 160 into one or more unicast packets
addressed to the receiving nodes 130-140. The access point 120 may
transmit the one or more unicast packets sequentially to the
receiving nodes 130-140 at a higher data rate than the minimum data
rate used for 802.11 multicast transmission. Further, the access
point 120 of this embodiment would ensure reliable transmission of
the converted multicast packet because the access point 120 would
be able to service 802.11 ACK packets generated by the receiving
nodes 130-140. In some embodiments, the access point 120 may
determine not to convert the multicast packet into one or more
unicast packets, but instead may transmit the multicast packet to
the receiving nodes of the group 160 at a relatively higher data
rate than the minimum allowable physical data rate used for 802.11
multicast packet transmission.
[0036] FIG. 2 illustrates an exemplary method for multicast or
unicast transmission in the wireless local area network of FIG. 1,
in accordance with one embodiment of the present invention. The
steps of the exemplary method are described as occurring in
particular order, but it will be appreciated that certain steps may
be rearranged to provide a similar result. The method determines
whether to convert a multicast packet into one or more unicast
packets or whether to transmit the multicast packet. The method
also determines at what rate to transmit the multicast packet and
the one or more unicast packets. The method begins with the access
point 120 already associated with receiving nodes 130-150.
[0037] In step 205, the access point 120 receives a first join
request (e.g., a multicast control protocol packet such as an IGMP
join request) from the first receiving node (e.g., the receiving
node 130) containing a first address for the receiving node 130.
The access point 120 uses the join request to correlate the
receiving node 130 with the address of the group 160. In IGMP, a
multicast client (e.g., the receiving node 130) joins a multicast
group (e.g., the group 160) to enable group reception of a
multicast traffic stream. When the access point 120 receives the
IGMP join request from the receiving node 130, the access point 120
inspects the IGMP packet and determines the required join
information.
[0038] In this embodiment, the access point 120 does not itself use
the IGMP protocol. Regardless, the system 100 takes advantage of
the fact that the IGMP join requests from the receiving nodes
130-140 to the source node 110 pass through the access point 120.
The access point 120 "sniffs" or samples the IGMP join requests to
map the hardware (MAC) address of the receiving nodes 130 and 140
with the address of the group 160. In some embodiments, the access
point 120 "speaks" the IGMP protocol. The access point 120 may map
the IP addresses (instead of the MAC addresses) of the receiving
nodes 130 and 140 to the address of the group 160.
[0039] In the alternative to sniffing or speaking IGMP or other
control protocols from the receiving nodes 130-150, the access
point 120 may maintain a map that contains the hardware addresses
of all or a subset of the receiving nodes 130-150 that are
associated with the access point 120. The access point 120 may use
the map to query the receiving nodes 130-150 to determine which of
the receiving nodes 130-150 are interested in receiving multicast
traffic addressed to the group 160. These maps of MAC addresses or
IP addresses allow the access point 120 to convert the multicast
packet received from the source node 110 and addressed to the group
160 into one or more unicast packets addressed to the receiving
nodes 130-140 of the group 160.
[0040] In step 210, the access point 120 maps the first address of
the receiving node 130 from the IGMP packet to the address of the
group 160. In step 215, the access point 120 receives a second join
request (e.g., a second IGMP join request) from a second receiving
node (e.g., the receiving node 140). In step 220, the access point
120 maps a second address of the receiving node 140 to the address
of the group 160.
[0041] In step 225, the access point 120 receives the multicast
packet addressed to the group 160. In step 230, the access point
120 determines a first data rate (e.g., 54 Mbps) by which the
access point 120 may reliably transmit (e.g., including the 802.11
ACK mechanism) one or more unicast packets to the receiving node
130. In step 235, the access point 120 determines a second data
rate (e.g., 24 Mbps) by which the access point 120 may reliably
transmit one or more unicast packets to the receiving node 140.
Although not depicted, in some embodiments the access point 120 may
determine additional (e.g., a third or more) data rates by which
the access point 120 may reliably transmit one or more unicast
packets to a third receiving node (e.g., the receiving node 150
which would be part of the group 160).
[0042] In step 240, the access point 120 determines an effective
unicast rate. As discussed further with respect to FIG. 3, the
effective unicast rate corresponds to a combined rate for
converting the multicast packet into one or more unicast packets
and sending the one or more unicast packets to the receiving nodes
130 and 140 of the group 160 at the first and second (and third . .
. ) data rates. The effective unicast rate depends on the total
number of bits included in the unicast packets, including
additional data packet overhead (e.g., additional bits in the
unicast packet as compared to the multicast packet). The effective
unicast rate also depends on computational time associated with
converting the multicast packet into one or more unicast packets.
The effective unicast rate is further based on the duration for
reception and processing of ACK packets from the receiving nodes of
the group 160. Further, the effective unicast rate is based on the
number of receiving nodes in the group 160, because each additional
receiving node in the group 160 proportionally lowers the effective
unicast rate. One method for determining the effective unicast rate
is presented in co-pending U.S. patent application entitled "System
and Method for Transmission Parameter Control for an Antenna
Apparatus with Selectable Elements," the subject matter of which is
hereby incorporated by reference.
[0043] As described further, rather than converting the multicast
packet to unicast packets, the access point may transmit at a
"lowest common denominator rate" to the group 160. For example, the
lowest common denominator rate may be higher than the effective
unicast rate, particularly with a large number of receiving nodes
in the group 160 each receiving at a relatively high rate. For
example, the group 160 may comprise the receiving nodes 130, 140,
and 150. The receiving node 130 may receive packets at a physical
data rate of 54 Mbps, the receiving node 140 may receive packets at
a physical data rate of 54 Mbps, and the receiving node 150 may
receive packets at a physical data rate of 54 Mbps. The lowest
common denominator rate for this example is 54 Mbps, which may be
higher than the effective unicast rate. In step 245, the access
point 120 determines the lowest common denominator rate (LCDR) for
transmitting the multicast packet simultaneously to the receiving
nodes of the group 160.
[0044] In steps 250-295, the access point 120 determines whether to
transmit unicast or multicast packets, and at what rate to transmit
the unicast or multicast packets. Specifically, in steps 250-275,
the access point 120 may determine to convert the multicast packet
into one or more first unicast packets addressed to the receiving
node 130 and one or more second unicast packet addressed to the
receiving node 140 for transmission. Alternatively, in steps
285-295, the access point 120 may determine to transmit the
multicast packet simultaneously to the receiving nodes 130-140 of
the group 160 and not convert the multicast packet into unicast
packets. Further, in steps 285-295 the access point 120 determines
whether to transmit at the lowest common denominator rate if the
lowest common denominator rate is higher than the minimum allowable
physical data rate.
[0045] In step 250, the access point 120 determines if the
effective unicast rate exceeds the lowest common denominator rate.
For example, in an 802.11a wireless LAN with the receiving nodes
130, 140, and 150 in the group 160, the first data rate may be 54
Mbps, the second data rate may be 6 Mbps, and the third data rate
may be 54 Mbps. The effective unicast rate, given the number of
data bits in the unicast packets, packet overhead, conversion
processing time, and the like may be 11.5 Mbps, for example.
Accordingly, the effective unicast rate of 11.5 Mbps exceeds the
lowest common denominator rate of 6 Mbps (i.e., the minimum
allowable physical data rate for 802.11a), so the access point 120
will convert the multicast packet into one or more unicast packets
in steps 255-275.
[0046] In step 255, the access point 120 converts the multicast
packet to a first unicast packet addressed to the receiving node
130. In step 260, the access point 120 transmits the first unicast
packet to the receiving node 130 at the first data rate. After
transmission of the first unicast packet, in step 265 the access
point 120 may delay for a predetermined delay period before
converting the multicast packet into a second unicast packet and
transmitting the second unicast packet to the receiving node 140 in
steps 270-275. The delay period is computed to allow the receiving
node 130 sufficient time to generate an 802.11 ACK that the access
point 120 may receive to verify reliable transmission and reception
of the first unicast packet. The access point 120 may compute the
delay period based on several factors. For example, the access
point 120 may compute the delay based on computational time needed
by the access point 120 to convert the multicast packet into the
first unicast packet. The delay may include data packet overhead
(e.g., additional bits in the first unicast packet that reduce the
first data rate to a relatively lower "user" data rate). Further,
the access point 120 may retransmit the first unicast packet to the
receiving node 130 if the access point 120 does not receive the
802.11 ACK from the receiving node 130 for the first unicast
packet, adding to the delay.
[0047] In step 270, the access point 120 converts the multicast
packet from the source node 110 into a second unicast packet
addressed to the receiving node 140. In step 275, the access point
120 transmits the second unicast packet at the second data rate to
the receiving node 140. In similar fashion to the method described
above with respect to steps 260-265 for the first unicast packet,
the access point 120 awaits an 802.11 ACK from the receiving node
140 to ensure reliable transmission and reception of the second
unicast packet. The access point 120 may retransmit the second
unicast packet to the receiving node 140 if the access point 120
does not receive the 802.11 ACK from the receiving node 140.
Although not depicted, the steps 265 to 275 may be repeated for
additional (e.g., third . . . ) receiving nodes in the group
160.
[0048] Optionally, the access point 120 may determine in step 260
and step 275 whether one of the receiving nodes of the group 160
comprises a multicast data transmitter. For example, if the
receiving node 130 acts as the source node 110 for sending the
multicast packet through the access point 120 to the receiving
nodes 140 and 150 of the group 160, the access point 120 need not
retransmit the converted unicast packet back to the receiving node
130. Although sending the unicast packet back to the receiving node
130 is legitimate practice in 802.11, doing so wastes network
bandwidth.
[0049] At step 250, if the effective unicast rate does not exceed
the lowest common denominator rate, the access point 120 may
determine not to convert the multicast packet into one or more
unicast packets for sequential transmission to each receiving node
in the group 160. Accordingly, in step 285, the access point 120
determines whether the LCDR exceeds the minimum allowable data
rate. For example, if the receiving node 130 is capable of
receiving at 54 Mbps and the receiving node 140 is capable of
receiving at 24 Mbps, the LCDR of 24 Mbps exceeds the minimum
allowable data rate of 6 Mbps. Accordingly, in step 290 the access
point 120 will transmit the multicast packet to the group 160 at
the LCDR of 24 Mbps. Alternatively, at step 285 if the receiving
node 130 is capable of receiving at 54 Mbps and the receiving node
140 is capable of receiving at only 6 Mbps, for example, the LCDR
does not exceed the minimum allowable data rate of 6 Mbps.
Accordingly, in step 295, the access point 120 will transmit the
multicast packet to the group 160 at the minimum allowable data
rate of 6 Mbps.
[0050] The methods described with respect to FIG. 2 advantageously
achieve higher data throughput than traditional multicast
transmission, by converting multicast packets in the access point
120 into one or more unicast packets that may be transmitted
sequentially to each receiving node of the group 160 at a
relatively higher data rate. Further, converting the multicast
packet into unicast packets affords higher data transmission
reliability because the unicast packets are verified by ACK
responses from each receiving node of the group 160. Additionally,
if the access point 120 determines not to convert multicast packets
into unicast packets, the access point 120 may transmit the
multicast packet at the lowest common denominator rate, which is a
higher physical data rate than the minimum allowable physical data
rate defined in the IEEE 802.11 standard.
[0051] Although FIGS. 1 and 2 generally describe multicast data
flow from the source node 110 to the group 160 (i.e., left to right
in FIG. 1), the methods described with respect to FIG. 2 are
applicable to multicast control protocol packets that flow in the
opposite direction (e.g., from right to left in FIG. 1). For
example, the system 100 may include a source node (e.g., the
receiving node 130) configured to transmit a group packet to a
destination node (e.g., the access point 120). The receiving node
130 sends a multicast control protocol packet, such as an IGMP join
request, over the wireless link 135 to the access point 120 to join
a group (e.g., group 160) receiving an IPTV multimedia multicast
stream. To provide more effective use of the available bandwidth of
the wireless link 135, and to provide reliable transmission of the
multicast control protocol packet, the receiving node 135 may
convert the multicast control protocol packet to one or more
unicast packets for transmission to and acknowledgement by the
access point 120.
[0052] In one example, the receiving node 130 determines a first
data rate for transmitting the group packet and determines a second
data rate based upon converting the group packet to a unicast
packet addressed to the access point 120. The receiving node 130
transmits the unicast packet at the second data rate through the
wireless link 135 to the access point 120 if the first data rate
for transmitting the group packet is less than the second data rate
for transmitting the unicast packet. As discussed herein, the
receiving node 130 transmits the unicast packet at a higher
physical data rate than specified for multicast transmission. Upon
receipt of the unicast packet, the access point 120 sends an ACK to
acknowledge receipt of the unicast packet.
[0053] If the first data rate for transmitting the group packet is
greater than the second data rate for transmitting the unicast
packet, the receiving node 130 may transmit the group packet
through the wireless link 135. As previously discussed, the
receiving node 130 may transmit the group packet at the lowest
common denominator rate. The access point 120 then receives the
group packet and processes the multicast control protocol packet.
Therefore, in these embodiments, the receiving node 130 and the
access point 120 individually determine whether transmitting the
group packet or converting the group packet to one or more unicast
packets allows more effective use of the available bandwidth and
reliable transmission.
[0054] FIG. 3 illustrates an exemplary timing diagram comparing the
conversion of the multicast packet into one or more unicast
packets, as described in FIGS. 1-2, as compared to multicast packet
transmission, in accordance with one embodiment of the present
invention. A first time interval 310 indicates the time needed for
the access point 120 to convert the multicast packet received from
the source node 110 into the first unicast packet and transmit the
first unicast packet to the receiving node 130, for example, at 54
Mbps. It will be appreciated that the time interval 310 may vary
depending upon at least the first data rate, the number of data
bits in the first unicast packet, and the conversion time needed by
the access point 120 to convert the multicast packet into the first
unicast packet. After the first unicast packet is transmitted to
the receiving node 130, an ACK time interval 320 indicates the time
needed for the receiving node 130 to return the 802.11 ACK
corresponding to the first unicast packet and for the access point
120 to process the 802.11 ACK packet.
[0055] Similarly, a second time interval 330 indicates the time
needed for the access point 120 to convert the multicast packet
received from the source node 110 into the second unicast packet
and transmit the second unicast packet to the receiving node 140 at
the second data rate, for example, 18 Mbps. A second ACK time
interval 340 indicates the time needed for the receiving node 140
to return an 802.11 ACK corresponding to the second unicast packet
and for the access point 120 to process the 802.11 ACK packet. In
comparison, a multicast time interval 350 indicates the duration
for the access point 120 to receive and transmit the multicast
packet simultaneously to the receiving nodes 130 and 140 at either
the lowest common denominator rate or the minimum allowable
physical data rate.
[0056] Because the duration of the combined time intervals 310,
320, 330, and 340 is shorter than the duration of the multicast
time interval 350, the system and method described herein
advantageously achieve a higher data throughput by converting the
multicast packet to sequential unicast packets. Further, as the
duration of the time intervals 310 and 320 increases because of
interference in the wireless links 135 and 145 (FIG. 1) leading to
lower first and second data rates, for example, the combined
duration of the time intervals 310, 320, 330, and 340 may exceed
the multicast time interval 350. In such case, the lowest common
denominator rate may provide a higher data rate than the minimum
allowable data rate. Another advantage, therefore, is graceful
degradation of the overall data transmission rate with changes in
the wireless LAN.
[0057] The embodiments discussed herein are illustrative of one
example of the present invention. As these embodiments of the
present invention are described with reference to illustrations,
various modifications or adaptations of the methods and/or specific
structures described may become apparent to those skilled in the
art. All such modifications, adaptations, or variations that rely
upon the teachings of the present invention, and through which
these teachings have advanced the art, are considered to be within
the scope of the present invention. Hence, these descriptions and
drawings should not be considered in a limiting sense, as it is
understood that the present invention is in no way limited to only
the embodiments illustrated. The scope of the invention should,
therefore, be determined not with reference to the above
description, but instead should be determined with reference to the
appended claims along with their full scope of equivalents.
* * * * *